Hepatocellular carcinoma (HCC) is one of the most common human malignancies. The majority of HCCs occur in a background of cirrhosis related to hepatitis B virus, hepatitis C virus, or alcoholism. The presence of cirrhosis has significant impact on the management of the cancer. The impairment of liver function as a result of cirrhosis restricts the treatment options, and cirrhosis is also known to predispose to multicentric hepatocarcinogenesis and increase the risk of recurrence after resection of HCC. The advent of liver transplantation and radiofrequency ablation have provided better chances of curative treatment for patients with small HCC detected by screening in recent years; however, hepatic resection remains the mainstay of curative treatment for HCC associated with Child-Pugh class A cirrhosis. While the perioperative safety and long-term survival of liver resection in cirrhotic liver have improved in recent years, the rate of postoperative recurrence of HCC remains high. In more than 80% of the cases of postoperative recurrence after resection of HCC, the recurrent tumors occur in the liver remnant. The mechanisms of intrahepatic recurrence can be either intrahepatic metastasis from the initial tumor or a de novo multicentric tumor. Differentiation of the two has potential implications on surveillance, prevention, and management strategies for recurrence. Clinically, it is impossible to distinguish the two based on imaging appearances. The only definitive way of differentiation is by genetic or molecular studies of the clonal origin of the tumors, which are technically complicated and cannot be used in clinical practice. Hence, several groups of authors have attempted to differentiate intrahepatic metastasis and multicentric recurrence based on the interval of development of recurrence from the time of resection and risk factors associated with the recurrence. These studies have consistently demonstrated that early recurrence within the first 2 years after resection of HCC is likely to be associated with aggressive tumor pathological factors such as high tumor grade, microvascular invasion, and microsatellite lesions, whereas late recurrence is more likely related to underlying liver conditions such as the presence of cirrhosis and hepatitis activity. Such results suggested that early recurrence is most likely the consequence of occult metastasis from the initial tumor, whereas late recurrence more likely represents multicentric tumors. Cucchetti et al. conducted a study on the risk factors associated with early and late recurrence in 204 patients with cirrhosis who had undergone resection of HCC. The authors identified high alpha-fetoprotein level, poorly differentiated tumor, and microvascular invasion as the risk factors for early recurrence within 2 years after resection, and male gender, older age, high transaminase levels, multiple primary tumors, and high alpha-fetoprotein level as risk factors for late recurrence beyond 2 years. These findings are generally in line with those of previous studies. To demonstrate that late recurrence is most likely related to new multicentric tumor development in the cirrhotic liver, the authors further compared the incidence and risk factors of late recurrence in resected patients with the those of development of HCC in a cohort of 150 cirrhotic patients undergoing regular surveillance of HCC. Such data are not available in previous studies and provide a better insight into the risk of late recurrence after resection of HCC in cirrhotic patients. The authors showed that the risk factors for development of HCC in a group of cirrhotic patients undergoing surveillance were similar to the risk Society of Surgical Oncology 2009
Read full abstract