Vogel & Motulsky is an unusual book. The four editions span 40 years, the first in 1970, the second in 1976, the third in 1997 and now in 2010 the fourth. Planning of this latest version stalled with the death of Friedrich Vogel in 2006. Eventually, Stylianos Antonarakis and Michael Speicher joined Arno Motulsky, and this substantial volume is the result, just short of 1,000 pages and weighing in at 2.6 kg. Maybe I should declare an interest, as co-author of the recently published fourth edition of Strachan & Read’s Human Molecular Genetics. But actually, the two books are very different. S&R is a course textbook for advanced undergraduates, and an overview of the principles for people coming into the area from another discipline who want to hit the ground running. V&M is a series of highlevel reviews, produced with the help of 76 co-authors. However, it is not the usual sort of multi-author tome that always gives me a sinking feeling, those dinosaurs of the information era, large, blundering compilations out-performed by their nimbler Internet competitors and surely overdue for extinction. The editors have done a lot more than just assemble a suitable list of authors and sit back waiting for the chapters to come in. Antonarakis and Speicher have both contributed substantial amounts of the content, at least a quarter of the total length of the book is authored or co-authored by one or other of them. It must have been a huge amount of work. From Motulsky, there are chapters on the history of human genetics and on the formal genetics of humans, both revised from the third edition, and a co-authored chapter on linkage. All three have obviously been involved in signing up a very distinguished panel of co-authors, the list is almost a Who’s Who of current human genetics. A downside (from the point of view of booksellers) of having such an A-list set of authors is that many will have written reviews on their subject that those of us with access to an academic library can read free of charge. The content is broad, but generally covers methods and applications rather than specific diseases. There is a welcome emphasis on formal genetics, which sets this book apart from most others. Chapters on monogenic, oligogenic and multifactorial inheritance go into considerable mathematical detail. This is a valuable feature, and one that will not date. It is not easy to find treatments of these topics that go beyond the basics, yet are comprehensible to nonmathematicians. Population genetics, epidemiology and aspects of evolution also get solid chapters. Another strong point of previous editions was the detailed treatment of behavioural genetics, and again this is carried through in seven chapters covering personality, mental retardation, Alzheimer disease, autism, addiction, psychoses and behavioural aspects of chromosomal variants. Inevitably, these will date, but with their extensive reference lists they will provide useful starting points for following the current literature. A new feature is a set of chapters on each of the main model organisms. Processes of mutation, on the other hand, get less attention than in the previous edition. One always wonders whether the shelf life of a book like this would justify its cost. A big book like this is not the place to try to keep up with the furious pace of technical and scientific progress. The combination of in-depth reviews of principles and a notable interest in the history of the various topics should mean it will still be worth reading in five years’ time. Most of the chapters I checked were well A. Read (&) Genetic Medicine, St Mary’s Hospital, Manchester M13 0JH, UK e-mail: Andrew.Read@man.ac.uk