Tidal marshes are important for the ecosystem of the Chesapeake Bay, east coast USA. They have the capacity to sequester large amounts of carbon as they accrete with sea-level rise. The purpose of this study was to evaluate carbon distributions in a marsh restored using coarse mineral and organic sediments in 2003 and a natural reference marsh. Soil cores were collected across transects in each marsh to a depth of 1 m. Samples were divided by horizon and analyzed for bulk density and carbon concentration. The restored marsh had wider ranges of bulk density and C concentrations due to the presence of both organic and mineral soil materials. Horizons from the restored marsh had a mean bulk density of 0.50 g cm−3 while the reference marsh averaged 0.09 g cm−3. Carbon concentrations were greater in the reference marsh (30%) than the restored marsh (13%). The average carbon content in the restored marsh was 35 kg m−2 while the reference marsh has only 24 kg m−2 due to a greater bulk density. New organic material deposited over the dredge material represents surface carbon accumulation of 1.8 Mg C ha−1 yr−1. Evaluating restoration and carbon dynamics are difficult without knowledge of site characteristics prior to restoration.