Midcarpal Arthrodesis Research Articles

Midcarpal Arthrodesis with or without Excision of Triquetrum: A Systematic Review

Abstract Purpose The purpose of this systematic review is to compare the clinical outcomes of midcarpal arthrodesis with triquetrum excision against midcarpal fusion without the excision of triquetrum performed using modern osteosynthesis technology. Methods A systematic review of publications in PubMed, Medline, EMBASE, and Cochrane Database of Systematic Review was conducted. The studies that utilized osteosynthesis techniques other than Kirshner wire, with at least 10 patients, and had a minimum one-year follow-up period in English language were included. The quality of studies were evaluated using validated tools for assessing observational studies. Union rate, functional outcomes and revision/complication rates were collected and analyzed. Results A meta-analysis was not possible. Based on pooled data the flexion-extension arc improved by 6 degrees for midcarpal arthrodesis group with triquetrum excision, but decreased by 11 degrees in the group without. The radial-ulnar arc improved by 5 degrees in the triquetrum excision group, but decreased by 3 degrees in the triquetrum preserving group. Improvement in grip strength appears to be better in the triquetrum preserving group (10 kg as opposed to 1 kg), while there were no observable difference in pain score. Conclusions The literature lacked good comparison studies to examine the role of triquetrum excision in midcarpal fusion. While midcarpal fusion with triquetrum excision appeared to yield better ROM in the pooled data, studies with direct comparison of the two techniques are required to fill in the gap. Type of Study/Level of Evidence Therapeutic IV.

Lunate Shift Index (LSI): A New Parameter for the Evaluation of Residual Ulnar Side Wrist Pain in Patients with Wrist Osteoarthritis Undergoing Three-Corners Arthrodesis vs. Four-Corners Arthrodesis-A Retrospective Comparative Study with Minimum 2Years of Follow-up.

Both scaphoid non-union advanced collapse wrist (SNAC) and scapho-lunate advanced collapse wrist (SLAC) at stage II-III are common indications for limited wrist fusions including four-corners fusion (4CF) and three-corners fusion (3CF). The aim of this study was to assess the clinical and radiological outcomes in patients undergoing 3CF vs. 4CF. A new radiological index called Lunate Shift Index (LSI) was devised to evaluate the importance of the lunate displacement relative to the radiolunate joint. Twenty-eight patients undergoing 3CF and 40 patients undergoing 4CF were clinically evaluated. The radiolunate angle, the carpal height, and the LSI were recorded radiographically. The LSI corresponds to the ratio between the distance from the lunate centre to the middle of the intermediate column and the length of the intermediate column of the distal radius. A statistically significant correlation was observed between LSI and clinical outcomes. The lunate displacement was associated with an increased incidence of wrist ulnar pain.No statistically significant differences were observed between 3 and 4CF in all parameters compared. The osteoarthritis of piso-triquetral joint has been identified as the cause of wrist ulnar pain in patients undergoing 4CF. The lunate correct positioning allows to maintain the carpal height and to increase the contact area at the level of the radiolunate joint. A good reduction of the lunate could be obtained with the 3CF compared to 4CF. This study showed how proper realignment of the lunate following midcarpal arthrodesis correlates with a better clinical outcome. Level III, Retrospective comparative study.

Mid-carpal Arthrodesis Using Staples

Limited carpal fusion offers patients with degenerative wrist conditions reliable pain relief without the complication profile of total wrist arthroplasty and preserves motion compared to total wrist fusion. The authors of this study present the technique of limited carpal fusion with nitinol memory compression staples, which offer a reliable and consistent, alternative to classic methods of intercarpal fusion. Multiple studies have demonstrated outcomes equivalent to traditional fusion alternatives.

Comment on "Is bio absorbable screw really reliable for midcarpal arthrodesis? A literature review illustrated by a case report"

Comment on "Is bio absorbable screw really reliable for midcarpal arthrodesis? A literature review illustrated by a case report"

Is bio absorbable screw really reliable for midcarpal arthrodesis? A literature review through a case report

Bio absorbable materials have been used for a long time in human surgery. Application in various surgical fields as hand, foot, knee and spine surgery were developed. Among the numerous uses in hand surgery, wrist arthrodesis with those materials has rarely been studied. Should we use bio absorbable screw for midcarpal arthrodesis? We reviewed the literature about wrist arthrodesis with absorbable devices and shared our experience with a case of a midcarpal arthrodesis failure with magnesium and zinc alloy screws. From our review, we found that very few articles about that particular subject were published and amongst them very few had good results regarding wrist arthrodesis. Complications were construct failure and led to reintervention. Thus, this subject should be investigated biomechanically and clinically. According to our research and experience, bio absorbable screws should be avoided for midcarpal arthrodesis.

Combined synovectomy and extensor carpi radialis longus transfer to realign and stabilise the rheumatoid wrist

BackgroundIn patients with rheumatoid arthritis, the surgical treatment of wrist lesions relies on synovectomy combined with stabilisation and realignment of the carpal bones. The objective of this study was to evaluate the outcomes and define the indications of extensor carpi radialis longus (ECRL) transfer to the extensor carpi ulnaris (ECU) as described by Clayton and Ferlic. HypothesisECRL-to-ECU transfer combined with synovectomy can prevent the development and/or progression of rheumatoid deformities at the wrist. Material and methodsA retrospective observational study was performed in 16 wrists. The following data were collected before and after surgery: pain, synovitis, range of motion, carpal height, ulnar translocation and radial deviation of the carpal bones, and Larsen's grade of the radio-carpal and mid-carpal joints. ResultsAfter a mean follow-up of 42.5 months after surgery, pain relief was noted in 14 cases and synovitis resolution in 10 cases. Mean mobility gains were 19.7° in extension and 5.7° in flexion. The radiographs showed a decrease in carpal height, whereas radial deviation and ulnar translocation were unchanged. No change was seen in the radio-carpal and mid-carpal joint lines. In the 3 wrists that required mid-carpal arthrodesis due to advanced disease before surgery, the radio-carpal joint line was unchanged and outcomes were the same as in the overall population. DiscussionECRL-to-ECU transfer combined with synovectomy provides pain relief and prevents radio-carpal destabilisation. The main indication of ECRL transfer is reducible radial deviation and ulnar translocation. ECRL is also indicated in combination with mid-carpal arthrodesis in the small minority of patients who have predominant mid-carpal involvement with a Larsen grade greater than 2. Level of evidenceIV, retrospective observational study.

Classifications in Brief: Watson and Ballet Classification of Scapholunate Advanced Collapse Wrist Arthritis.

Classifications in Brief: Watson and Ballet Classification of Scapholunate Advanced Collapse Wrist Arthritis.

Proximal row carpectomy, scaphoidectomy with midcarpal arthrodesis or midcarpal tenodesis: when and how to use.

I report my personal experience over three decades in the treatment of carpal collapse due to scapholunate collapse and scaphoid nonunion. I have used the proximal carpal row resection performed through palmar approach, the scaphoidectomy and double-column midcarpal arthrodesis, and scaphoidectomy with midcarpal tenodesis. Diagnostic arthroscopy is essential for staging and surgical decision making regarding the type of treatment. The details of the surgical techniques, tips, results and possible complications are described for each method. The advantage of the proximal row carpectomy by palmar approach is the early permitted rehabilitation with better recovery of wrist motility in comparison with the traditional technique. The advantage of the double-column midcarpal arthrodesis lies in its ease of execution. The midcarpal tenodesis is an excellent intervention from the conceptual point of view even if over time there is a progressive carpal collapse even in absence of symptoms.

Denervation of the wrist with two surgical incisions. Is it effective? A review of 33 patients with an average of 41 months’ follow-up

The goal of wrist denervation is to decrease pain at the wrist, whether caused by an intra- or extra-articular problem or even when the reason for the pain is unknown. It is an alternative to partial or total arthrodesis and proximal row carpectomy. Our hypothesis was that wrist denervation with a two-incision technique was a reliable and efficient way to treat painful degenerative wrists. Thirty-three patients, 48years old on average, were included in this study. Indications were scapholunate advanced collapse (SLAC) in 18 cases, scaphoid nonunion advanced collapse (SNAC) in 10, distal radius fracture sequelae with advanced radiocarpal osteoarthritis in 4, and post-traumatic ulnocarpal impingement in 1 case. At 41 months’ follow-up (12–161), there was a 75% reduction in pain levels, decreasing from 7.1 to 1.8 on a visual analog scale (VAS). There were no modifications related to wrist range of motion or grip strength. The QuickDASH averaged 23 points (5 to 70). Radiographic evaluation showed progression of intracarpal degeneration in 6 patients. All but 2 patients returned to their previous work. Persistent dysesthesia was observed in 7 patients; it resolved in 3 cases and persisted in 4. One patient developed complex regional pain syndrome (CRPS). A midcarpal arthrodesis with scaphoidectomy was performed in one patient because of disabling pain 5months after surgery. Wrist denervation with a two-incision technique for post-traumatic osteoarthritis led to satisfactory results in 75% of cases with reduction in pain, preservation of range of motion and grip strength. However, this technique does not stop the progression of osteoarthritis. It can be discussed as a therapeutic alternative to proximal row carpectomy or intracarpal arthrodesis to treat degenerative painful wrists. Type of study/level of evidenceTherapeutic IV.

Complications With the Use of BMP-2 in Scaphoid Nonunion Surgery

In an effort to improve fracture healing and decrease the need for autologous bone graft, products such as recombinant human bone morphogenetic protein (rhBMP-2) have been developed and used in both spine and nonspine surgery. There is a paucity of literature regarding the use of rhBMP-2 in scaphoid nonunion surgery with very little reporting on the complications associated with its use. The objective of this study was to retrospectively review the complications documented for a case series of patients treated with revision fixation, bone graft, and rhBMP-2 in revision scaphoid nonunion surgery. We retrospectively reviewed 6 cases of scaphoid nonunion revision surgery comprising open reduction and internal fixation (ORIF). All cases were performed for persistent nonunion after a previous scaphoid ORIF. All patients were treated with revision screw fixation, bone graft, and rhBMP-2. Union was determined by computed tomography in all cases. Complications of nonunion, heterotopic bone formation, delayed wound healing, functional loss of motion, and need for revision surgery are reported. Between 2011 and 2014, 6 cases in which rhBMP-2 was used in revision scaphoid nonunion surgery were identified. All patients had failed an initial attempt at ORIF after delayed union or nonunion. The time from injury to index ORIF ranged from 3 months to 4 years (mean, 24 months). Revision surgery with rhBMP-2 was performed at an average of 6 months from the index ORIF. Of the 6 cases, 2 had resultant persistent nonunion. Both underwent scaphoid excision and midcarpal arthrodesis. Four cases developed notable heterotopic ossification (one of which required revision surgery). One patient had a loss of functional motion after the revision surgery. There were no cases of delayed wound healing. Only one of the 6 patients healed without complications. In this case series, the use of rhBMP-2 in scaphoid nonunions was associated with a higher complication rate than reported in previous studies. Surgeons performing off-label use of rhBMP-2 should be aware of the potential for complications including heterotopic ossification. Therapeutic IV.

The effect of wrist surgery on the kinematic consistency of joint axis reconstruction in a static posture.

Three-dimensional analysis of wrist motion is a growing focus in orthopedic research, however, our understanding of its validity (accuracy and reliability) remains limited. Nine human cadavers were tested to estimate wrist joint axes alignment in a postural static pose. The objective was to investigate a rater's ability to reliably align three skin- tracked wrist joint coordinate system (WJCS) definitions across baseline and reconstructive wrist states (intact, mid-carpal arthrodesis, and proximal-row carpectomy). Two WJCSs (legacy, anatomic) were based on palpated bony landmarks and the third (functional) was based on both landmarks and passive flexion-extension motion. A coordinate frame based on the anatomic definition was tracked with bone pins and served as a reference. Each WJCS was tested in each wrist state and in three forearm position (45° pronation, neutral, 45° supination). The angular offset about each axis of the WJCS frames were calculated with respect to the reference in flexion-extension, radial-ulnar deviation, and pronation-supination for every iteration. Reliability and root mean square deviation values were analyzed across wrist states. Our data suggest that no WJCS is uniformly more reliable than another. The functional WJCS definition was most consistent across intact and post-operative states for pronation-supination offset, but this was dependent on rater interpretation. It still however offers the practical benefit of requiring fewer landmarks.

Scaphoidectomy and Double Column Midcarpal Arthrodesis for SLAC and SNAC Stage III°

Introduction One surgical option for the treatment for SLAC and SNAC stage III° is the midcarpal arthrodesis with scaphoidectomy. Various methods of synthesis for arthrodesis are used from simple K-wires to headless screws and intercarpal plates.

Limited intercarpal fusion as a salvage procedure for advanced Kienbock disease.

With progressive lunate collapse, salvage procedures in advanced Kienbock disease attempt to provide pain relief and maintain motion. Scaphocapitate arthrodesis may provide a durable option with comparable outcomes to proximal row carpectomy in the well-selected patient. We performed a retrospective chart review of all consecutive patients with Lichtman stage IIIA or IIIB Kienbock's disease who underwent either scaphocapitate or scaphotrapeziotrapezoid-capitate arthrodesis from January 2004 to December 2013. Twelve patients were included with a mean age of 41.6years. Ten patients underwent scaphocapitate arthrodesis, while two patients underwent scaphotrapezio-trapezoid-capitate arthrodesis with an average clinical follow-up of 13.1months. All patients achieved fusion. The average postoperative flexion-extension arc was 53° (range 20-110°). The average ulnar deviation was 9° (range 5-15°), and the average radial deviation was 13° (range 5-25°). Postoperative pain scores were significantly improved, having changed from an average of 6.6 preoperatively to 2.8 on a 10-point scale (W = 18, P < 0.05). Despite a mean flexion-extension arc that is reduced from that of a normal individual, the postoperative range of motion following a midcarpal arthrodesis was not significantly different than that reported in a recent systematic review of proximal row carpectomy (73.5° compared with 53°, respectively) (P = 0.05). Additionally, given the significant postoperative reduction in associated pain symptoms at the time of follow-up, scaphocapitate arthrodesis should be considered as a treatment option for wrist salvage in the patient with advanced Kienbock's disease.

Klinisch-funktionelle Nachuntersuchung verschiedener handchirurgischer Versteifungsmethoden

Total and partial arthrodesis of the wrist are currently sophisticated treatment options for many advanced pathological changes of the wrist. This retrospective study analyzed the subjective and objective outcome of different wrist arthrodesis techniques, e.g. total wrist arthrodesis, scaphotrapeziotrapezoid (STT) bone fusion and midcarpal arthrodesis. Subjective physical and mental quality of life of 98 patients (total wrist arthrodesis n = 43, STT fusion n = 30 and midcarpal arthrodesis n = 25) was measured using the DASH questionnaire. The range of motion and grip strength were analyzed in 48 patients (total wrist arthrodesis n = 21, STT fusion n = 17 and midcarpal arthrodesis n = 10). Patients with partial wrist arthrodesis achieved a significantly better DASH score than patients with total wrist arthrodesis. Grip strength did not show any statistically significant differences between the two groups. Patients with STT fusion showed the best range of motion of the wrist. Partial arthrodesis seems to be superior to total wrist arthrodesis. Patients profit from a higher physical and mental quality of life.

Long-Term Results after Midcarpal Arthrodesis

Background and Purpose Midcarpal arthrodesis is a well-accepted treatment option for advanced carpal collapse. In this study, we retrospectively assessed survival, analyzed complications and reviewed the long-term follow-up after midcarpal fusion. Materials and Methods The computerized medical records of 572 patients who had undergone 594 four-corner fusions between 1992 and 2001 were explored. Furthermore 56 patients with 60 midcarpal fusions were randomized for clinical and radiological follow-up at a mean of 14.7 years. Results Forty midcarpal fusions (6.7%) had to be converted into complete wrist arthrodesis. The reasons were ongoing pain in spite of a well-healed midcarpal fusion (31) or nonunion (9). Sixty-three patients (11%) required revision surgery because of nonunion (22), hematoma (8), wound infection (3) or persisting pain (31). In clinical follow-up the mean Disabilities of the Arm, Shoulder, and Hand (DASH) score was 20.4. Pain at rest was infrequent, a mild increase with daily activity was complained of (mean visual analog scale [VAS] 3.3). The mean active range of wrist motion for extension and flexion, ulnar and radial deviation and supination and pronation reached 62.5%, 68.4%, 94.7%, and mean grip strength 84.9% of the unaffected side. All patients had radiographic abnormalities, with frequent evidence of osteoarthritis of the lunate fossa. Patients with preserved carpal height appeared to have less pain, better DASH scores and a better range of motion. Conclusions The midcarpal arthrodesis is a long-lasting treatment option for advanced carpal collapse and has good long-term results. Level of Evidence Level IV, Therapeutic study.

Scaphoid Excision and Midcarpal Arthrodesis: The Effect of Triquetral Excision—A Biomechanical Study

To evaluate the biomechanical alterations that occur after traditional scaphoid excision and midcarpal arthrodesis with and without excision of the triquetrum. The hypothesis of this study was that removal of the triquetrum increases the radiolunate contact pressure. We cyclically moved 10 fresh cadaver wrists using a wrist joint motion simulator while measuring the contact pressures between the proximal carpal row and the distal radius and ulna using a dynamic pressure sensor. We acquired data in the intact wrist, after a midcarpal arthrodesis with the scaphoid excised, and then again with the triquetrum removed, which is also known as a capitolunate arthrodesis. The peak pressures in the radiolunate fossa significantly increased with either of the midcarpal arthrodeses compared with the intact wrist during each of the 3 dynamic wrist motions. In comparing the 2 midcarpal arthrodeses, the peak pressure in the ulnocarpal fossa significantly decreased after the triquetrum was removed during wrist radioulnar deviation and in the static ulnarly deviated position. After arthrodesis, we could identify no differences during any motion or static wrist position in the peak radiolunate pressures with or without the triquetrum. We found that scaphoid excision and 4-corner arthrodesis shifts loads to the radiolunate joint. Isolated capitolunate arthrodesis with excision of the scaphoid and triquetrum further alters carpal kinematics and loading patterns. These findings raise concern about routine excision of the triquetrum when performing a midcarpal arthrodesis.

Radiolunate and Radioscapholunate Arthrodeses as Treatments for Rheumatoid and Psoriatic Arthritis: Long-Term Follow-Up

We evaluated long-term results for radiolunate and radioscapholunate arthrodeses for patients with rheumatoid or psoriatic arthritis to determine the durability and efficacy of the procedures. The results are described and compared with those in the literature. We carried out arthrodesis of the radiolunate joint (33 wrists) and the radioscapholunate joint (13 wrists) to achieve pain reduction and ulnar translation of the carpus in patients with rheumatoid (42 wrists) or psoriatic arthritis (4 wrists). At follow-up, 11 patients (13 wrists) had died, 2 patients (4 wrists) were lost to follow-up, and in 6 wrists an additional midcarpal arthrodesis had been performed. We evaluated the remaining 23 wrists (19 radiolunate and 4 radioscapholunate, and 1 psoriatic arthritic wrist) after a mean of 11 years. Clinical outcome was good, with a mean visual analog score of 2 out of 10 for pain, mean grip strength of 13 kg, and mean range of flexion-extension of 60°. Outcomes as measured by questionnaires were good. Radiographs demonstrated deterioration of all intracarpal joints as noted by an increased Larsen score and evidence of carpal translation. We noted no significant change in carpal height. Despite radiographic progression, radiolunate and radioscapholunate arthrodeses yield good clinical results at long-term follow-up. Therapeutic IV.

Comparison of Wrist Kinematics and Functional Performance After Midcarpal Arthrodesis and Proximal Row Carpectomy

To compare wrist coupling, angular excursion, and functional performance between: healthy subjects, subject's status post midcarpal arthrodesis (MA) and proximal row carpectomy (PRC) during hammering and dart throwing.

A new plate for partial wrist fusions: results in midcarpal arthrodesis

Partial wrist fusions are commonly performed for various degenerative conditions. In this series 30 wrists had a scaphoidectomy and midcarpal arthrodesis performed with a new plate. The most common indications were SLAC and SNAC wrists. In 24 cases a four-corner arthrodesis was done and in the other six the triquetrum was not included. Mean follow-up was 3 years. Mean flexion was 31° and extension 35°. Union was achieved in all wrists despite movement being commenced early. The plates proved straightforward to use, allowing some latitude in placement. This series confirms that scaphoidectomy and midcarpal arthrodesis is a useful salvage procedure and that these plates are suitable for that purpose.

Three-Corner Midcarpal Arthrodesis and Scaphoidectomy

Midcarpal arthrodesis has been a treatment of choice in the last decade for scapholunate advanced collapse and related conditions of the wrist. In this study, we present a new uncomplicated technique in which a 3-corner intercarpal fusion is done with screw fixation from a volar approach. The advantages of this technique include simplified excision of the scaphoid, radial styloidectomy, and straightforward placement of 2 screws from the lunate into the capitate and hamate, respectively, to maintain a readily achievable correction of the dorsal intercalated segment instability. With adequate debridement and compression of the midcarpal joint, fusion is readily achieved.