Methylphosphonyl Thiocholines Research Articles

Mutation of acetylcholinesterase to enhance oxime-assisted catalytic turnover of methylphosphonates

Selected mutagenesis of acetylcholinesterase (AChE; EC 3.1.1.7) may enable one to develop more effective scavenging agents in which AChE itself, in combination with an oxime, will complete a catalytic cycle of hydrolysis of the organophosphate by rapid conjugation followed by enhanced nucleophile-mediated hydrolysis of the phosphonyl enzyme conjugate. Through enlargement of the active site gorge of mouse AChE by mutations Y337A, F295L and F297I, we studied continuous enzymatic degradation of S P-cycloheptyl methylphosphonyl thiocholine ( S P-CHMPTCh) in the presence of HI-6. Continuous hydrolysis of S P-CHMPTCh was measured spectrophotometrically from thiocholine released during hydrolysis with DTNB as the thiol reagent. The rates of hydrolysis expressed as moles of formed thiocholine per mole of enzyme per minute were 3.3, 0.69, 0.34 and 0.15 min −1 for F295L/Y337A, Y337A, F297I/Y337A and AChE wild-type, respectively. These rates did not depend on the initial S P-CHMPTCh concentration range employed. However, by increasing HI-6 concentrations, the rates approached a limiting value, indicating that oxime reactivation is the rate-limiting step in S P-CHMPTCh hydrolysis. Our results confirm that a mixture of a mutant enzyme and an oxime might serve as an in vivo catalytic scavenger of organophosphates.

(24) Acetylcholinesterase mutants—oxime-assisted catalytic scavengers of organophosphonates

instead abstract, part of the Introduction: Reaction of organophosphonates with acetylcholinesterase (AChE ; EC 3.1.1.7) is characterized by the formation of serine-conjugated adducts that are only slowly reversible. Since oximes are the only known antidote to nerve agent poisoning that restore the activity of AChE, mutagenesis of AChE should enable one to develop more effective scavenging agents in which AChE mutants in combination with an oxime would complete a catalytic cycle of hydrolysis of the organophosphate by rapid inhibition followed by rapid nucleophile-mediated hydrolysis of the phosphonyl enzyme conjugate. We enlarged the active site gorge of mouse AChE with mutations Y337A, F295L and F297I. Based on rapid inhibition of mutants with SP-cycloheptyl methylphosphonyl thiocholine (SP-CHMPTCh) and enhancement of their HI-6 reactivation rates up to 130-fold as compared to the AChE wild-type, we studied the continuous enzymatic decomposition of the SP-CHMPTCh by AChE mutants in the presence of HI-6.

Mutant cholinesterases possessing enhanced capacity for reactivation of their phosphonylated conjugates.

Selective mutants of mouse acetylcholinesterase (AChE; EC 3.1.1.7) phosphonylated with chiral S(P)- and R(P)-cycloheptyl, -3,3-dimethylbutyl, and -isopropyl methylphosphonyl thiocholines were subjected to reactivation by the oximes HI-6 and 2-PAM and their reactivation kinetics compared with wild-type AChE and butyrylcholinesterase (EC 3.1.1.8). Mutations in the choline binding site (Y337A, Y337A/F338A) or combined with acyl pocket mutations (F295L/Y337A, F297I/Y337A, F295L/F297I/Y337A) were employed to enlarge active center gorge dimensions. HI-6 was more efficient than 2-PAM (up to 29000 times) as a reactivator of S(P)-phosphonates (k(r) ranged from 50 to 13000 min(-1) M(-1)), while R(P) conjugates were reactivated by both oximes at similar, but far slower, rates (k(r) < 10 min(-1) M(-1)). The Y337A substitution accelerated all reactivation rates over the wild-type AChE and enabled reactivation even of R(P)-cycloheptyl and R(P)-3,3-dimethylbutyl conjugates that when formed in wild-type AChE are resistant to reactivation. When combined with the F295L or F297I mutations in the acyl pocket, the Y337A mutation showed substantial enhancements of reactivation rates of the S(P) conjugates. The greatest enhancement of 120-fold was achieved with HI-6 for the F295L/Y337A phosphonylated with the most bulky alkoxy moiety, S(P)-cycloheptyl methylphosphonate. This significant enhancement is likely a direct consequence of simultaneously increasing the dimensions of both the choline binding site and the acyl pocket. The increase in dimensions allows for optimizing the angle of oxime attack in the spatially impacted gorge as suggested from molecular modeling. Rates of reactivation reach values sufficient for consideration of mixtures of a mutant enzyme and an oxime as a scavenging strategy in protection and treatment of organophosphate exposure.

Peripheral site ligands accelerate inhibition of acetylcholinesterase by neutral organophosphates.

The rates of inhibition of mouse acetylcholinesterase (AChE; EC 3.1.1.7) by paraoxon, haloxon, DDVP and enantiomers of neutral alkyl methylphosphonyl thioates and cationic alkyl methylphosphonyl thiocholines were measured in the presence and absence of AChE peripheral site inhibitors: gallamine, d-tubocurarine, propidium, atropine and derivatives of coumarin. All ligands, except the coumarins, at submillimolar concentrations enhanced the rates of inhibition by neutral organophosphates, whereas inhibition rates by cationic organophosphates were decreased. When peripheral site ligand concentrations extended to millimolar concentrations the extent of the enhancement decreased, creating a well-shaped activation profile. Analysis of inhibition by DDVP revealed that peripheral site inhibitors increase the second-order reaction rates by increasing maximal rates of phosphorylation. These observations suggest that peripheral site ligands are capable of allosterically affecting the conformation of residues in the choline binding site of AChE, thus optimizing the position of the leaving group of uncharged organophosphates during the inhibition reaction.

The influence of peripheral site ligands on the reaction of symmetric and chiral organophosphates with wildtype and mutant acetylcholinesterases

The rates of inhibition of mouse acetylcholinesterase (AChE) (EC 3.1.1.7) by paraoxon, haloxon, DDVP, and enantiomers of neutral alkyl methylphosphonyl thioates and cationic alkyl methylphosphonyl thiocholines were measured in the presence and absence of AChE peripheral site inhibitors: gallamine, d-tubocurarine, propidium, atropine and derivatives of coumarin. All ligands, except the coumarins, at submillimolar concentrations enhanced the rates of inhibition by neutral organophosphorus compounds (OPs) while inhibition rates by cationic OPs were slowed down. When peripheral site ligand concentrations extended to millimolar, the extent of the enhancement decreased creating a bell shaped activation profile. Analysis of inhibition by DDVP and haloxon revealed that peripheral site inhibitors increased the second order reaction rates by increasing maximal rates of phosphylation.

Aspartate 74 as a primary determinant in acetylcholinesterase governing specificity to cationic organophosphonates.

Through site-specific mutagenesis, we examined the determinants on acetylcholinesterase which govern the specificity and reactivity of three classes of substrates: enantiomeric alkyl phosphonates, trifluoromethyl acetophenones, and carboxyl esters. By employing cationic and uncharged pairs of enantiomeric alkyl methylphosphonyl thioates of known absolute stereochemistry, we find that an aspartate residue near the gorge entrance (D74) is responsible for the enhanced reactivity of the cationic organophosphonates. Removal of the charge with the mutation D74N causes a near equal reduction in the reaction rate constants for the Rp and Sp enantiomers and exerts a greater influence on the cationic organophosphonates than on the charged trimethylammonio trifluoromethyl acetophenone and acetylthiocholine. This pattern of reactivity suggests that the orientation of the leaving group for both enantiomers is directed toward the gorge exit and in apposition to Asp 74. Replacement of tryptophan 86 with alanine in the choline subsite also diminishes the reaction rates for cationic organophosphonates, although to a lesser extent than with the D74N mutation, while not affecting the reactions with the uncharged compounds. Hence, reaction with cationic OPs depends to a lesser degree on Trp 86 than on Asp 74. Docking of Sp and Rp cycloheptyl methylphosphonyl thiocholines and thioethylates in AChE as models of the reversible complex and transition state using molecular dynamics affords structural insight into the spatial arrangement of the substituents surrounding phosphorus prior to and during reaction. The leaving group of the Rp and Sp enantiomers, regardless of charge, is directed to the gorge exit and toward Asp 74, an orientation unique to tetrahedral ligands.

Chiral nature of covalent methylphosphonyl conjugates of acetylcholinesterase

This paper examines the chiral nature of the covalent conjugates formed upon reaction of acetylcholinesterase (AchE) with enantiomeric cycloheptyl, isopropyl, and 3,3-dimethylbutyl methylphosphonyl thiocholines. With the exception of the conjugate formed from reaction of AchE with RP-cycloheptyl methylphosphonyl thiocholine, all enantiomeric conjugates underwent oxime reactivation at rates that were within 2-3-fold of each other. Oxime reactivation was, therefore, independent of both initial configuration about phosphorus and the alkyl phosphonyl ester (-OR) moiety. Aging of the enantiomeric cyclopheptyl and isopropyl methylphosphonyl conjugates occurred exclusively for the conjugate formed from the SP-enantiomer and therefore displayed an absolute dependence on the initial configuration of the methylphosphonyl group. Equilibrium titrations with decidium, a fluorescent bisquaternary competitive inhibitor of AchE, provided an index of aging and enantiomeric configuration of the conjugates independent of enzyme activity. Decidium association with the enantiomeric conjugates (prior to aging) showed no marked dependence on the initial configuration about phosphorus but was measurably dependent on nature of the -OR moiety. These results are interpreted with respect to symmetry and nonrigidity of the organophosphonyl conjugates and are consistent with formation of final methylphosphonyl conjugates that are enantiomerically pure and of opposite configuration. These studies indicate that the active center of AchE comprises at least two kinetically distinct environments separate from the esteratic region but located within 5 A of the nucleophilic serine and differing in dipolar characteristics that promote charge separation and general acid catalysis.

Chiral reactions of acetylcholinesterase probed with enantiomeric methylphosphonothioates: Noncovalent determinants of enzyme chirality

Abstract Enantiomeric cycloheptyl- and isopropyl methylphosphonothioates containing uncharged and cationic leaving groups, and 3,3-dimethylbutyl methylphosphonyl thiocholines were synthesized, and their inhibition of acetylcholinesterase from Torpedo examined. Bimolecular inhibition constants spanned 10(1)-10(9) M-1.min-1, equilibrium dissociation constants 10(-3)-10(-7) M, and phosphonylation constants 1-300 min-1. A general but not absolute preference for the SP-enantiomer, in the range 170-4600 for cycloheptyl-, 0.6-150 for isopropyl-, and 30 for 3,3-dimethylbutyl methylphosphonothioates, varied with nature of the alkyl ester (-OR) and thioic leaving groups (-SR') surrounding phosphorus. While the overall bimolecular reaction constant showed no marked dependence on ionic strength of the medium, the microscopic kp and KD for the RP- but not SP-cycloheptyl methylphosphonyl thiocholine underwent marked reduction with decreases in ionic strength. This result unmasks the interplay between occupation of the active center and productivity of that occupation. These studies reveal that chiral reactions with acetylcholinesterase are dependent more on the nature of the groups surrounding the tetrahedral phosphorus than on the absolute configuration about the phosphorus atom and indicate that the active center comprises partially overlapping subsites that can accommodate the -OR and -SR' groups. The presence of neighboring subsites characterized by different steric, electrostatic, and hydrophobic properties permits a multiplicity of binding orientations, independent of chiral configuration, and which account for the large variation in chiral preference seen among organophosphonates containing different substituents.