This study focused on the effect of potassium salt type on the physicochemical properties of carrageenan (Car) films and rehydrated hydrogels, with the aim of developing a new method for the preparation of Car hydrogels. The addition of potassium salt decreased the tensile strength (TS) of Car films, especially those containing KI. After rehydration, the weight and thickness change ratios of the Car films decreased with salt addition, and the sequence was as follows: K2CO3 < KH2PO4 < CH3COOK < KCl < K2SO4 < KSCN < KI < C6H5K3O7. The effect of potassium salt type on the TS and thermal transition temperature of rehydrated hydrogels was opposite that on weight and thickness change ratios. The hydrogels with K2CO3, KH2PO4, CH3COOK, KCl, and K2SO4 exhibited lower transverse relaxation time (T2) and smaller pore size compared with the other hydrogels. On the other hand, the effect of potassium salt type on hydrogels prepared using Car films soaked in potassium salt solution (S-Car) was similar to that observed on hydrogels prepared using Car films with potassium salt soaked in ultrapure water (U-Car). Compared with U-Car hydrogels, the S-Car hydrogels had higher TS and thermal transition temperature and lower elongation at break, T2, pore size, and hydrogen bond intensity. In conclusion, the potassium salt type and soaking method can be used to regulate the properties of Car hydrogels and provide a theoretical basis for the design of Car hydrogels.