Systematic Literature Review Method Research Articles

Peluang dan Tantangan Pengembangan Usaha Mikro Kecil Menengah (UMKM) dari Berbagai Aspek Ekonomi

Micro, Small, and Medium Enterprises (MSMEs) are productive economic entities owned by individuals or private business entities that meet the criteria for micro, small, or medium enterprises. In practice, MSME actors face various challenges and issues frequently encountered in the development of MSMEs. This study aims to identify the opportunities and challenges in the development of Micro, Small, and Medium Enterprises (MSMEs) from various economic aspects. The study is interested in examining the conditions of MSMEs that manage to survive under pressure, delving deeper into and providing an analysis of the challenges faced by MSMEs as well as the opportunities that can be leveraged to improve their performance, using a systematic literature review method. It is hoped that this study will provide further policy recommendations to enhance MSME strength as an opportunity and empower MSMEs in facing various challenges. The research findings indicate that Digital Marketing, Human Resources (HR), and Financial Literacy play crucial roles in creating markets and integrating into global supply chains. However, to ensure that the digital economy benefits MSME growth in Indonesia optimally, challenges such as limited access and technology infrastructure, as well as deficiencies in financial literacy, digital marketing, and human resources, need to be effectively addressed. MSMEs that can adapt to technological advancements and innovate their products will be able to compete with their rivals in the increasingly advanced digital economy.

Improving The Competitiveness Of SMEs through the Capital Market: Literature Review and Discourse Network Analysis

This article examines the prevailing conditions of Small, and Medium Enterprises (SMEs) in Indonesia, assessing their potential access to the capital market as an alternative financing for SMEs. It also investigates the required criteria for SMEs to fulfill, the potential benefits of their participation in the capital market, the challenges for them to enter the capital market, and what strategies are available for SMEs to access the capital market. The methodology in this research involves secondary data, specifically a compilation of Scopus indexed journal articles and news sourced from various sources on online platforms. Using specific keywords related to SMEs accessing the capital market during 2010-2024. The data analysis process uses the Systematic Literature Review (SLR) method and Discourse Network Analysis (DNA) software. DNA analysis to produce a visual representation of a discourse network, with a focus on interactions between actors, concepts (such as agreement or disagreement regarding SMEs entering the capital market), and their interconnections. From the results of the analysis, it is known that there are SMEs in Indonesia that have entered the stock exchange, but their numbers are decreasing. By entering the stock exchange, SMEs are expected to increase capital, performance, business scale, competition and public trust. However, there are obstacles and prerequisites for SMEs to enter the stock exchange. Capital market conditions in other countries are similar to conditions in Indonesia. This can be overcome with several strategies and synergy between all stakeholders related to creating and protecting an investment ecosystem that is friendly for SMEs.

Development of a breastfeeding co-parenting intervention program for couples with primiparas: a program development process study

BackgroundThe exclusive breastfeeding rates is low in some countries. Low breastfeeding rates results in higher healthcare expenses and adverse health outcomes for individuals and society. Co-parenting is effective in promoting breastfeeding as it involves shared responsibility and collaboration between parents in raising children. However, the current breastfeeding co-parenting intervention programs exhibits significant variations in components, timing, and duration across studies. An evidence-based breastfeeding co-parenting intervention program is essential for enhancing breastfeeding-related outcomes.ObjectiveTo develop an evidence-based breastfeeding co-parenting intervention program for healthcare providers to guide parents with primiparas on breastfeeding.MethodTo form an initial version of the intervention program, a systematic literature review was conducted to consolidate information on current intervention programs. Two rounds of Delphi method were followed to gather expert comments for the program modification to establish the formal version.ResultsFourteen articles published between 1995 and 2022 were screened. Details of these researches, including starting and ending time, duration and specific contents, were integrated to developed the initial program. Then, six experts completed the two rounds consultation with a positive coefficient of 85.71%, coefficient judgment basis of 0.93, familiarity coefficient of 0.87, authority coefficient of 0.90 and the Kendall’s W of 0.62. Finally, an evidence-based breastfeeding co-parenting intervention program was constructed in this study, consisting of breastfeeding co-parenting courses, individual counselling and a father’s support group.ConclusionThis research developed a breastfeeding co-parenting intervention program for healthcare providers to guide primiparous parents to improve breastfeeding rates. Through a systematic literature review and Delphi method with good reliability, the program integrates breastfeeding courses, individual counseling, and a father’s support group. Future research will focus on evaluating its impact and scalability to benefit maternal and infant health globally.Trial registrationChiCTR.org.cn (ChiCTR2300069648). Registration date: 2023-03-22.

Reviewing Social Forestry in Indonesia through an Integrative Framework for Collaborative Governance

Collaboration is a major problem affecting implementation of Social Forestry Policy in Indonesia. This paper aimed at synthesising the results of previous studies to identify challenges and knowledge gaps using an Integrative Framework for Collaborative Governance (IFCG) model. A systematic literature review method was used to search the Scopus database, and a total of 47 studies on Social Forestry Policy in Indonesia from 2019‐2022 were reviewed. The results suggested three main challenges: 1) limited community capacity, namely in initiating and making forest management effective; 2) burdensome administrative-bureaucratic fulfilment; and 3) lack of attention to multi-level (vertical-horizontal) collaborative processes from policy making to implementation at the member level. The review found that the IFCG model, though important, does not emphasise actor complexity related to leadership, which has different levels and scopes. Additionally, economic benefits are essential to sustain collaboration between parties. Furthermore, the internal conditions of the community contribute to effective collective action, and economic benefits are essential in sustaining the collaborative process. The paper recommends further research into social forestry to examine the impact of Social Forestry Policy, which have been under-examined by previous studies.

OPTIMIZING FINANCIAL MANAGEMENT IN SMALL AND FAMILY-OWNED ENTERPRISES: A LITERATURE REVIEW ON SIGNALING AND AGENCY THEORIES

This research explores the role of ownership structure, agency relationship dynamics, and the implementation of financial signals in the context of small and family firm financial management. Employing the Systematic Literature Review method, a literature review was conducted to gather, filter, and analyze relevant literature on the topic. The research findings indicate that a deep understanding of ownership structure enables firms to design more efficient risk management policies and decision-making. Additionally, an understanding of agency relationship dynamics allows firms to manage conflicts of interest more effectively through the development of appropriate oversight mechanisms and incentives. The proper use of financial signals was also found to enhance transparency and external stakeholders' trust in the firm, thereby opening doors to better access to external capital. The conclusion drawn from this research is that effective financial management practices are crucial for the long-term success of small and family firms. The implications of these findings emphasize the need for firms to continuously update their knowledge and skills in financial management and actively apply proven principles in their own context. Thus, they can remain competitive in an ever-changing business environment and meet their long-term objectives.

DYNAMICS IN HARMONIOUS HUMAN-NATURE URBAN ECOSYSTEM MODEL FOR ENVIRONMENT SUSTAINABILITY: A REVIEW

In the face of growing urbanization, conflicts between human activities and the natural environment have resulted in increasingly evident problems, such as ecological degradation, excessive resource depletion, loss of biodiversity, and pollution. These issues pose a growing threat to the achievement of global sustainable development goals. This study is part of a larger study to create a liveable and sustainable urban environment. It aims to develop an urban ecosystem model for promoting harmony with nature by analyzing the latest literature research from 2019 to 2023 using the Systematic Literature Review method. This paper elucidates the newest research developments in urban design, urban ecosystems, and the pursuit of enhanced synergy harmonious humans with nature. Subsequently, from the cross-analysis method it presents a synthesized model proposing a harmonious human-nature ecosystem for urban design. This model advocates the cultivation of human natural identity, providing a framework to adapt, modify, and preserve the urban environment in harmony with nature. Such an approach is expected to enhance urban vitality, which is harmonious between humans and nature while maintaining ecological functions and biodiversity and ensuring efficiency, equity, socio-cultural, and aesthetic values. This study contributes to identifying, understanding, and resolving ecological imbalances arising from urbanization. The results are expected to benefit authorities in maintaining a healthy standard of living in rapidly urbanizing areas. Future research will combine methods such as field investigations and design practices to further refine this urban design proposal, providing support and guidance for a more comprehensive sustainable urban environmental development.

Karakteristik limbah pertanian dan dampaknya: Mengapa pengelolaan ramah lingkungan penting?

Background: Agricultural waste is a significant by-product of the agrarian sector, with the potential for substantial environmental and economic impacts. This study aims to examine the characteristics of organic agricultural waste and analyze its effects on the environment, both in terms of threats and its potential utilization. Method: This study employs a systematic literature review method. The literature search focuses on articles discussing agricultural waste, its characteristics, and its environmental impacts. Findings: The results show that agricultural waste has diverse characteristics based on fiber composition, physical form, and protein content. The main threats from agricultural waste include water pollution due to nutrient runoff and greenhouse gas emissions, especially methane. However, this waste also holds significant potential as a source of organic mulch, animal feed, and raw material for bioenergy. Utilizing agricultural waste as mulch can improve soil quality and crop yields, while its use as animal feed supports the integration of agricultural and livestock systems. In the context of energy, converting waste into biogas and biofuel offers an effective solution. Conclusion: This study emphasizes the importance of integrated and sustainable agricultural waste management to minimize negative impacts and optimize its economic potential. Novelty/Originality of this article: By providing a comprehensive analysis of the characteristics and impacts of agricultural waste, this study offers insights into the importance of a holistic approach to agricultural waste management to support sustainable agriculture.

Systematic Literature Reviews of Architectural Soundscapes Study

Sound is an inseparable part of human activity, exhibiting various phenomena related to its source, duration, timing, and interpretation. In residential environments, sound contributes uniquely to each building's character, shaped by its spatial dimensions. This auditory phenomenon is subject to interpretation by both residents and the surrounding environment, though these interpretations may differ. This study aims to explore the boundaries of recent research in soundscape studies, particularly within the field of architecture. Utilizing a Systematic Literature Review (SLR) method, this study analyzes journals from the past 20 years using the Publish or Perish (PoP) application and the keywords "Soundscape" and "Architecture" in the Scopus Index. The objective is to present a research map of the past 5 years, identifying patterns and trends in Soundscape Architecture. The findings reveal distinct concentrations in the object of study and scale within the architectural scope, contributing to a deeper understanding of the complexities and nuances of Soundscape Architecture research. Furthermore, this study highlights areas for future investigation and development, emphasizing the evolving nature of this interdisciplinary field.

Impact of Government Subsidies on Green Innovation in Polluting Enterprises: A Review

To address the increasingly severe environmental challenges and achieve the "dual carbon" goals, the Chinese government has implemented a series of subsidy policies to promote green innovation and transformation of heavily polluting enterprises. However, against the backdrop of fierce market competition and tightening resource constraints, many companies still lack sufficient inherent motivation for green innovation. This study employs a systematic literature review method, analyzing relevant research from databases such as Web of Science, Scopus, and CNKI, aiming to systematically elucidate the research trajectory of government subsidies' impact on the green innovation performance of heavily polluting enterprises, thereby providing a theoretical perspective for improving relevant policy designs. The paper first posits that the logical starting point for government subsidies in green innovation lies in correcting environmental externalities, laying the foundation for subsequent discussions. It then examines the "incentive effect" and "crowding-out effect" of government subsidies on enterprises' green innovation performance, analyzes the non-linear relationship between government subsidies and corporate green innovation performance, and discusses the limitations of existing research from three aspects: relationship complexity, classification mechanisms, and influencing factors. Building on this, the paper integrates institutional theory with principal-agent theory to construct a multi-level analytical framework. This framework emphasizes the regulatory role of external institutional pressures, such as environmental regulations, on the effectiveness of subsidy implementation, while also focusing on how internal agency problems within enterprises may lead to inefficient utilization of subsidies, and how environmental information disclosure can help mitigate this issue. The study finds that there exists a non-linear relationship between subsidy intensity and green innovation performance, exhibiting "incentive effects" and "crowding-out effects" at different subsidy levels. Concurrently, factors such as environmental regulations, enterprise characteristics, and information disclosure practices play a moderating role in the effectiveness of subsidies. These findings have significant implications for policy-making, including designing subsidy schemes that avoid potential crowding-out effects at high subsidy levels, strengthening environmental regulations to enhance the effectiveness of R&D subsidies, implementing robust environmental information disclosure mechanisms, and formulating differentiated subsidy policies based on enterprise characteristics.

Improve Accounting Laws in the Public Sector to Prevent Fraud and Corruption in Vietnam

Corruption in the field of accounting and finance is new topic that is of interest to many researchers because of the increase in the number and scale of fraud, corruption and similar acts. This article analyzes the nature of fraud and corruption in the field of public accounting, thereby identifying structural factors that contribute to fraud and corruption in the application of accounting laws in the public sector. Finally, there are recommendations to improve the accounting laws in the public sector to prevent fraud and corruption in Vietnam. The article uses bibliometric analysis and systematic literature review (SLR) methods to analyze fraud and corruption in the field of public accounting. The main result of this study is to identify structural factors that lead to fraud and corruption in the field of public accounting

Problem Solving Learning in Science Education: A Systematic Literature Review

This study aims to describe the application of problem solving in the learning process and describes the technique of forming groups that are carried out in learning. This study uses the Systematic Literature Review method, which focuses on reviewing and analyzing broadly and thoroughly some of the literature that is relevant to the research topic. The stages carried out in this research are clarification and approach; search, filter, and select; analysis and interpretation; draft articles; and dissemination. Literature data used as the main source in this study were 15 articles from Scopus-indexed Springer within a period of 6 years (2018-2023). The articles analyzed examined problem solving skills ranging from junior high school to university. The results showed problem solving research was carried out individually and in groups, and most research was done through groups. The technique of forming groups is carried out by paying attention to the background, results of initial ability tests in individual rounds, pretest, and educational strata. The steps taken in learning problem solving are: orientation of students to problems; group formation; carrying out investigative activities to solve problems; discussing and reviewing problem solving strategies in groups; making presentations; and the teacher providing feedback.

Systematic Literature Review Related to Learning Obstacles of Junior High School Students in Understanding Algebra Concepts

Learning obstacles faced when solving math problems have become an exciting topic to research. This is due to the importance of developing mathematical concepts and understanding skills, especially algebraic concepts. This study aims to describe the research results related to junior high school students learning obstacles in understanding algebraic concepts. This research uses the Systematic Literature Review (SLR) method, comprising 22 studies. This study concludes that research related to junior high school students learning obstacles in understanding algebra concepts is found most in Sinta publications, then continued with Scopus, EBSCO, Proceeding, and DOAJ. These studies include a variety of methods used, with the Didactical Design Research approach dominating. Epistemological, didactical, and ontogenic barriers were the main concerns, with didactical obstacles being the most common in this study. These obstacles include the lack of direct interaction and active learning between teachers and students and the lack of optimal use of varied learning methods and teaching aids, causing students to have difficulty in planning problem-solving strategies, solving story problems, and understanding mathematical concepts thoroughly. Concrete efforts that can be made to overcome the identified obstacles include utilizing active, collaborative, and exploratory learning approaches.

The Impact Of The Blockade And Politics On Health And Social Welfare In Palestine

The political conflict between Israel and Palestine has created a difficult situation for the Palestinian population, with a blockade imposed by Israel and persistent political tensions. The impact of the blockade and politics on the health and social well-being of the Palestinian population requires in-depth research to fully understand its implications. This research aims to analyze the impact of the blockade and politics on physical and mental health, access to health services, and the social welfare of Palestinian society. This research uses the Systematic Literature Review (SLR) method to collect and analyze data from various related literature sources. Data was analyzed comprehensively to understand the impact of the blockade and politics on health and social well-being in Palestine. The results show that the blockade imposed by Israel has caused a severe health crisis, with increased risks of infectious diseases, shortages of medical equipment, and limited access to health services. In addition, political conflict has also caused an increase in mental disorders among the Palestinian population, as well as disturbing social instability.

Metode dan Algoritma Dalam Sentimen Analisis: Systematic Literature Review

This study highlights the advantages of sentiment analysis using algorithms in understanding public opinion, especially in the context of the increasing complexity of digital content. To investigate and present the latest developments in sentiment analysis, this study uses the Systematic Literature Review (SLR) method to identify and evaluate previously developed sentiment analysis methods. The research steps involve identifying significant sentiment analysis methods, assessing advantages and disadvantages, and critically reviewing recent advances. By applying algorithms in this process, it is expected to be able to analyze and describe the development of sentiment analysis research comprehensively. Through the application of the SLR method, this study is expected to provide in-depth insights into trends, challenges, and opportunities for future research in sentiment analysis, create a better understanding of effective sentiment analysis methods, and detail the expected results that can be expected in the development of sentiment analysis.

Identifikasi Teknik Data Mining Metode Asosiasi: Systematic Literature Review

Data mining is a process of collecting important information from large data. Data mining has many functions, one of which is the description function. In this case, the description function is that later data mining can find certain patterns hidden in data. This research aims to identify which association methods in data mining are most often used, identify the most dominant dataset models in association methods, identify the most relevant journal years in association methods, identify what fields most often use association methods, and find out the objectives of researchers using association methods such as FP-Growth and Apriori in various related journals. Using a Systematic Literature Review (SLR) approach, to answer the research questions that have been prepared from the analysis with a total of 33 related journals. So as a result, this study shows that the application of the SLR method can provide answers to the research questions that have been prepared.

Manajemen Strategi Dalam Upaya Peningkatan Kinerja Guru Melalui Supervisi Akademik

The existence of an educational institution lies in the quality of human resources created by the institution. This study focuses on the strategic management role of school principals to improve the quality of Human Resources (HR) management in an effort to improve teacher performance through academic supervision. This research uses the Systematic Literature Review (SLR) method where researchers review and identify journals in a structured and analyzable manner which is carried out in depth from scientific literature according to the research topic with the aim of increasing understanding regarding the research topic used. As for the literature used to strengthen the results of the analysis, researchers succeeded in identifying 30 articles or journals indexed by Sinta and several others found on Google Scholar related to strategic management in efforts to improve teacher performance through academic supervision carried out by school principals. Thus, from the 30 articles it could be filtered and 8 articles were found that were suitable, and the other 22 articles were excluded. Because this research focuses on strategic management in an effort to improve teacher performance through academic supervision. The results obtained are able to determine the role of the school principal in improving teacher performance through academic supervision.

Establishing Company Direction: A Literature Review of Management Strategy

This research examines the literature on key concepts that drive strategy analysis, formulation, and implementation based on values, vision, and mission as guiding principles for determining a company's direction. This article utilizes a systematic literature review method to consolidate the findings of various studies and scientific literature. The process involves accessing and analyzing literature through digital search engines using keywords related to management strategies. The research uncovers a shortage of scientific literature containing important theoretical concepts that strategists can use as a roadmap for analyzing, formulating, and implementing strategies. This review adds to the existing literature by employing a management strategy approach to determine the company's direction.

Hospital Preparedness Analysis in Disaster Management : Literature Review

Under Act No. 44 of 2009, hospitals have a responsibility to actively engage in disaster situations, provide services to victims as they can, and have an accident prevention and disaster management system. This research aims to find out how prepared some hospitals are in disaster management based on some library studies. The preparation of this article uses a method of systematic literature review using 10 articles from 2019 to 2024 from search databases, namely Google Scholar, Garuda, Sage Journals, and ScienceDirect. Although hospitals have policies and standard operational procedures to cope with disasters, the findings suggest that their implementation by health personnel is not optimal. Although disaster response teams, K3RS teams, and abuse teams have been formed, education and training efforts are still not at their maximum. Hospitals are important in disaster management, but many still need improvements such as special guidelines, infrastructure, and intensive training. Preparedness includes planning, organization, movement, control, and recovery. Ready hospitals have emergency response teams, training programs, and early warning systems.

Literature Review: Analysis of The Presentation of Humanity Conditions: A Case Study of Inherent Houses in Indonesia

This study aims to analyze fire emergency preparedness in Indonesian hospitals through a systematic review of previous studies. Using a systematic literature review method, this study identified and synthesized key findings from related studies. The results showed that fire emergency preparedness in hospitals in Indonesia still needs improvement, especially in terms of emergency response systems, human resource capacity, availability of facilities and infrastructure, and coordination with related parties. Efforts to improve preparedness need to be carried out comprehensively, involving collaboration between hospitals, government, fire department and the community.

Systematic Literature Review (SLR): Explorations flood systems theory and appropriate modeling

Urban flood risk assessment conducts a comprehensive evaluation of hazard formative factors, hazard formative environment, hazard-affected bodies, and capabilities for disaster prevention and reduction in order to obtain an accurate assessment of flood risk levels. The current study aimed to conduct a systematic review of the existing literature on engagement outcomes, focusing on high-quality studies Each step of the SLR method and their results are explained in detail in the following subsections using SLR performed. Using the SLR method can help answer the objectives of this research in the form of: What type of modeling to overcome flooding This research uses the SLR method which aims to recognize, review, and evaluate Using bibliometric analysis.To achieve the goal of SLR, the variables of interest are organized based on the general characteristics of the article and the specific parameters used general information about the article includes year of publication, type of analysis (quantitative, qualitative, cartographic or mixed), type and scale of research, and the country or region where the research was conducted. The model consists of three components, including rainfall runoff, river channels, and flooding The flow in the channel was generated with a 1D diffusion wave model, and the outflow on the slope was generated with a 2D model.This article showed the basic steps that need to be followed to conduct SLR This method generates topic-specific existing knowledge, trends, and observed gaps and helps to draw relevant conclusions for policy makers and the scientific community. and the appropriate modeling is Press RRI refers to 2D grid-based fluid dynamics and is a model that combines a hydrological model and a flood model.