The mechanical behavior of polymeric parts manufactured by fused filament fabrication is often characterized as orthotropic because of the layer-wise extrusion of the material. To perform reliable simulations of the mechanical response of these parts subjected to certain loads, the material parameters have to be known. This leads to the task of material parameter identification from suitable experimental data. In this work, the identification of the material parameters for orthotropic material behavior is studied in detail with a focus on the specific characteristics of additively manufactured parts. This comprises working out the differences that arise compared to the parameter identification for classical orthotropic composite materials. Moreover, the material parameters are identified from tensile and shear test information together with full-field displacement data from digital image correlation measurements. Then, the obtained parameters are compared for analytical and numerical approaches, where a non-linear least-squares method with finite elements is drawn on. The parameters are not only identified, but also an uncertainty analysis is carried out and, subsequently, the different methods are validated. Further, a clear derivation of commonly applied analytical equations is provided with a special focus on the underlying assumptions. It turns out that the analytical parameter identification procedures cannot be easily transferred to numerical procedures, especially when using full-field data, because of correlations between the parameters. Moreover, the identified parameters are employed to prove the reasonability of orthotropic material behavior for specimens manufactured by fused filament fabrication. Finally, during validation it turns out that all parameter identification methods provide a good agreement with experimental data, showing only small differences between the results of the different calibration strategies.