Metalloenzyme Inhibitors Research Articles

Metalloenzyme Inhibitors against Zoonotic Infections: Focus on Leishmania and Schistosoma.

The term "zoonosis" denotes diseases transmissible among vertebrate animals and humans. These diseases constitute a significant public health challenge, comprising 61% of human pathogens and causing an estimated 2.7 million deaths annually. Zoonoses not only affect human health but also impact animal welfare and economic stability, particularly in low- and middle-income nations. Leishmaniasis and schistosomiasis are two important neglected tropical diseases with a high prevalence in tropical and subtropical areas, imposing significant burdens on affected regions. Schistosomiasis, particularly rampant in sub-Saharan Africa, lacks alternative treatments to praziquantel, prompting concerns regarding parasite resistance. Similarly, leishmaniasis poses challenges with unsatisfactory treatments, urging the development of novel therapeutic strategies. Effective prevention demands a One Health approach, integrating diverse disciplines to enhance diagnostics and develop safer drugs. Metalloenzymes, involved in parasite biology and critical in different biological pathways, emerged in the last few years as useful drug targets for the treatment of human diseases. Herein we have reviewed recent reports on the discovery of inhibitors of metalloenzymes associated with zoonotic diseases like histone deacetylases (HDACs), carbonic anhydrase (CA), arginase, and heme-dependent enzymes.

Discovery of Novel Metalloenzyme Inhibitors Based on Property Characterization: Strategy and Application for HDAC1 Inhibitors.

Metalloenzymes are ubiquitously present in the human body and are relevant to a variety of diseases. However, the development of metalloenzyme inhibitors is limited by low specificity and poor drug-likeness associated with metal-binding fragments (MBFs). A generalized drug discovery strategy was established, which is characterized by the property characterization of zinc-dependent metalloenzyme inhibitors (ZnMIs). Fifteen potential Zn2+-binding fragments (ZnBFs) were identified, and a customized pharmacophore feature was defined based on these ZnBFs. The customized feature was set as a required feature and applied to a search for novel inhibitors for histone deacetylase 1 (HDAC1). Ten potential HDAC1 inhibitors were recognized, and one of them (compound 9) was a known potent HDAC1 inhibitor. The results demonstrated the effectiveness of our strategy to identify novel inhibitors for zinc-dependent metalloenzymes.

On the hunt for metalloenzyme inhibitors: Investigating the presence of metal-coordinating compounds in screening libraries and chemical spaces.

Metalloenzymes play vital roles in various biological processes, requiring the search for inhibitors to develop treatment options for diverse diseases. While compound library screening is a conventional approach, the exploration of virtual chemical spaces housing trillions of compounds has emerged as an alternative strategy. In this study, we investigated the suitability of selected screening libraries and chemical spaces for discovering inhibitors of metalloenzymes featuring common ions (Mg2+, Mn2+, and Zn2+). First, metal-coordinating groups from ligands interacting with ions in the Protein Data Bank were extracted. Subsequently, the prevalence of these groups in two focused screening libraries (Life Chemicals' chelator library, comprising 6,428 compounds, and Otava's chelator fragment library, with 1,784 fragments) as well as two chemical spaces (GalaXi and REAL space, containing billions of virtual products) was investigated. In total, 1,223 metal-coordinating groups were identified, with about a quarter of these groups found within the examined libraries and spaces. Our results indicate that these can serve as valuable starting points for drug discovery targeting metalloenzymes. In addition, this study suggests ways to improve libraries and spaces for better success in finding potential inhibitors for metalloenzymes.

Structural, Biochemical, and Computational Characterization of Sulfamides as Bimetallic Peptidase Inhibitors.

The sulfonamide function is used extensively as a general building block in various inhibitory scaffolds and, more specifically, as a zinc-binding group (ZBG) of metalloenzyme inhibitors. Here, we provide biochemical, structural, and computational characterization of a metallopeptidase in complex with inhibitors, where the mono- and bisubstituted sulfamide functions are designed to directly engage zinc ions of a bimetallic enzyme site. Structural data showed that while monosubstituted sulfamides coordinate active-site zinc ions via the free negatively charged amino group in a canonical manner, their bisubstituted counterparts adopt an atypical binding pattern divergent from expected positioning of corresponding tetrahedral reaction intermediates. Accompanying quantum mechanics calculations revealed that electroneutrality of the sulfamide function is a major factor contributing to the markedly lower potency of bisubstituted compounds by considerably lowering their interaction energy with the enzyme. Overall, while bisubstituted uncharged sulfamide functions can bolster favorable pharmacological properties of a given inhibitor, their use as ZBGs in metalloenzyme inhibitors might be less advantageous due to their suboptimal metal-ligand properties.

Bacterial Zinc Metalloenzyme Inhibitors: Recent Advances and Future Perspectives.

Human deaths caused by Gram-negative bacteria keep rising due to the multidrug resistance (MDR) phenomenon. Therefore, it is a priority to develop novel antibiotics with different mechanisms of action. Several bacterial zinc metalloenzymes are becoming attractive targets since they do not show any similarities with the human endogenous zinc-metalloproteinases. In the last decades, there has been an increasing interest from both industry and academia in developing new inhibitors against those enzymes involved in lipid A biosynthesis, and bacteria nutrition and sporulation, e.g., UDP-[3-O-(R)-3-hydroxymyristoyl]-N-acetylglucosamine deacetylase (LpxC), thermolysin (TLN), and pseudolysin (PLN). Nevertheless, targeting these bacterial enzymes is harder than expected and the lack of good clinical candidates suggests that more effort is needed. This review gives an overview of bacterial zinc metalloenzyme inhibitors that have been synthesized so far, highlighting the structural features essential for inhibitory activity and the structure-activity relationships. Our discussion may stimulate and help further studies on bacterial zinc metalloenzyme inhibitors as possible novel antibacterial drugs.

Masking thiol reactivity with thioamide, thiourea, and thiocarbamate-based MBPs.

Thioamides, thioureas, and thiocarbamates are introduced as stable, sulfur-based metal-binding pharmacophores (MBPs) for use in metalloenzyme fragment-based drug discovery (mFBDD). MBP reactivity, bioactivity, and structural studies show that these molecules can act as ligands for Zn(II)-dependent metalloenzymes including human carbonic anhydrase II (hCAII) and matrix metalloproteinase-2 (MMP-2).

Hydroxypyrone derivatives in drug discovery: from chelation therapy to rational design of metalloenzyme inhibitors.

The versatile structural motif of hydroxypyrone is found in natural products and can be easily converted into hydroxypyridone and hydroxythiopyridone analogues. The favourable toxicity profile and ease of functionalization to access a vast library of compounds make them an ideal structural scaffold for drug design and discovery. This versatile scaffold possesses excellent metal chelating properties that can be exploited for chelation therapy in clinics. Deferiprone [1,2-dimethyl-3-hydroxy-4(1H)-one] was the first orally active chelator to treat iron overload in thalassemia major. Metal complexes of hydroxy-(thio)pyr(id)ones have been investigated as magnetic resonance imaging contrast agents, and anticancer and antidiabetic agents. In recent years, this compound class has demonstrated potential in discovering and developing metalloenzyme inhibitors. This review article summarizes recent literature on hydroxy-(thio)pyr(id)ones as inhibitors for metalloenzymes such as histone deacetylases, tyrosinase and metallo-β-lactamase. Different approaches to the design of hydroxy-(thio)pyr(id)ones and their biological properties against selected metalloenzymes are discussed.

Salicylate metal-binding isosteres as fragments for metalloenzyme inhibition.

Metalloenzyme inhibitors typically share a common need to possess a metal-binding pharmacophore (MBP) for binding the active site metal ions. However, MBPs can suffer from physicochemical liabilities, impeding the pharmacological properties and drug-likeliness of inhibitors. To circumvent this, problematic features of the MBP can be identified and exchanged with isosteric replacements. Herein, the carboxylic and hydroxyl group of the salicylic acid MBP were replaced and a total of 27 salicylate metal-binding isosteres (MBIs) synthesized. Of these 27 MBIs, at least 12 represent previously unreported compounds, and the metal-binding abilities of >20 of the MBIs have not been previously reported. These salicylate MBIs were examined for their metal-binding features in model complexes, physicochemical properties, and biological activity. It was observed that salicylate MBIs can demonstrate a range of attractive physicochemical properties and bind to the metal in a variety of expected and unexpected binding modes. The biological activity of these novel MBIs was evaluated by measuring inhibition against two Zn2+-dependent metalloenzymes, human glyoxalase 1 (GLO1) and matrix metalloproteinase 3 (MMP-3), as well as a dinuclear Mn2+-dependent metalloenzyme, influenza H1N1 N-terminal endonuclease (PAN). It was observed that salicylate MBIs could maintain or improve enzyme inhibition and selectivity. To probe salicylate MBIs as fragments for fragment-based drug discovery (FBDD), an MBI that showed good inhibitory activity against GLO1 was derivatized and a rudimentary structure–activity relationship was developed. The resulting elaborated fragments showed GLO1 inhibition with low micromolar activity.

Evaluating Metal-Ligand Interactions of Metal-Binding Isosteres Using Model Complexes.

Bioisosteres are a useful approach to address pharmacokinetic liabilities and improve drug-like properties. Specific to developing metalloenzyme inhibitors, metal-binding pharmacophores (MBPs) have been combined with bioisosteres, to produce metal-binding isosteres (MBIs) as alternative scaffolds for use in fragment-based drug discovery (FBDD). Picolinic acid MBIs have been reported and evaluated for their metal-binding ability, pharmacokinetic properties, and enzyme inhibitory activity. However, their structural, electronic, and spectroscopic properties with metal ions other than Zn(II) have not been reported, which might reveal similarities and differences between MBIs and the parent MBPs. To this end, [M(TPA)(MBI)]+ (M = Ni(II) and Co(II), TPA = tris(2-pyridylmethyl)amine) is presented as a bioinorganic model system for investigating picolinic acid, four heterocyclic MBIs, and 2,2'-bipyridine. These complexes were characterized by X-ray crystallography as well as NMR, IR, and UV-vis spectroscopies, and their magnetic moments were accessed. In addition, [(TpPh,Me)Co(MBI)] (TpPh,Me = hydrotris(3,5-phenylmethylpyrazolyl)borate) was used as a second model compound, and the limitations and attributes of the two model systems are discussed. These results demonstrate that bioinorganic model complexes are versatile tools for metalloenzyme inhibitor design and can provide insights into the broader use of MBIs.

Development of a Hybrid Neural Network/Molecular Mechanics Approach for Metalloprotein Simulations

Metalloproteins are surprisingly common, the inclusion of metal ion cofactors results in amazingly diverse proteins that are involved in virtually all biological processes. Investigation of metal-ligand interactions is particularly important for drug design of metalloenzyme inhibitors and metallodrugs. Molecular dynamics (MD) simulations of metalloproteins based on molecular mechanics (MM) force fields are challenging due to the intricate nature of transition metals. Despite improvement of force fields, electronic effects demand a full quantum mechanical (QM) description.

Immobilized Metal Affinity Chromatography as a Drug Discovery Platform for Metalloenzyme Inhibitors.

Immobilized metal-ion affinity chromatography (IMAC) used to purify recombinant proteins features a resin-bound 1:1 Ni(II)-iminodiacetic acid (IDA) complex. This hemi-saturated Ni(II)-IDA system containing exchangeable sites at the metal ion is re-cast as a surrogate of a coordinatively-unsaturated metalloenzyme active site, with utility for selecting compounds with metal-binding groups from mixtures as potential metalloenzyme inhibitors. Exchanging Ni(II) for other metal ions could broaden the scope of metalloenzyme target. This work examined the performance of Cu(II)-, Fe(III)-, Ga(III)-, Ni(II)-, or Zn(II)-IMAC resins to reversibly bind experimental or clinical metalloenzyme inhibitors of Zn(II)-ACE1, Zn(II)-HDAC, Fe(II)/(III)-5-LO or Cu(II)-tyrosinase from a curated mixture (1-17). Each IMAC system gave a distinct selection profile. The Zn(II)-IMAC system selectively bound the thiol-containing Zn(II)-ACE1 inhibitors captopril and omapatrilat, and the Fe(III)-IMAC system selectively bound the Fe(II)/(III)-5-LO inhibitor licofelone, demonstrating a remarkable IMAC-metalloenzyme metal ion match. IMAC provides a simple, water-compatible platform, which could accelerate metalloenzyme inhibitor discovery.

Effect of heterocycle content on metal binding isostere coordination.

Bioisostere replacement is a core concept in modern medicinal chemistry and has proven an invaluable strategy to address pharmacodynamic and pharmacokinetic limitations of therapeutics. The success of bioisostere replacement is often dependent on the scaffold that is being modified (i.e., "context dependence"). The application of bioisostere replacement to a picolinic acid fragment was recently demonstrated as a means to expand a library of metal-binding pharmacophores (MBPs) to modulate their physicochemical properties, while retaining their metal binding and metalloenzyme inhibitory activity. Here, metal binding isosteres (MBIs) with different nitrogen-containing heteroarenes is explored. This resulted in a number of new MBIs that were evaluated for their physicochemical properties and metal binding features. It was observed that the coordination behavior of an MBI is dependent on the identity and arrangement of the heteroatoms within each heteroarene. To further understand the observed coordination chemistry trends, density functional theory (DFT) calculations were performed. Theory indicates that preferences in coordination geometry are largely determined by the electronic character of the heteroarene scaffold. These results provide important insights into the development of novel MBI scaffolds that can serve to broaden the scope of scaffolds for metalloenzyme inhibitor development.

Structure–Activity Relationships in Metal-Binding Pharmacophores for Influenza Endonuclease

Metalloenzymes represent an important target space for drug discovery. A limitation to the early development of metalloenzyme inhibitors has been the lack of established structure-activity relationships (SARs) for molecules that bind the metal ion cofactor(s) of a metalloenzyme. Herein, we employed a bioinorganic perspective to develop an SAR for inhibition of the metalloenzyme influenza RNA polymerase PAN endonuclease. The identified trends highlight the importance of the electronics of the metal-binding pharmacophore (MBP), in addition to MBP sterics, for achieving improved inhibition and selectivity. By optimization of the MBPs for PAN endonuclease, a class of highly active and selective fragments was developed that displays IC50 values <50 nM. This SAR led to structurally distinct molecules that also displayed IC50 values of ∼10 nM, illustrating the utility of a metal-centric development campaign in generating highly active and selective metalloenzyme inhibitors.

Metal-Binding Isosteres as New Scaffolds for Metalloenzyme Inhibitors.

The principle of isosteres or bioisosteres in medicinal chemistry is a central and essential concept in modern drug discovery. For example, carboxylic acids are often replaced by bioisosteres to mitigate issues related to lipophilicity or acidity while retaining acidic characteristics in addition to hydrogen bond donor/acceptor abilities. Separately, the development of metal-binding pharmacophores (MBPs) for binding to the active site metal ion in metalloenzymes of therapeutic interest is an emerging area in the realm of fragment-based drug discovery (FBDD). The direct application of the bioisostere concept to MBPs has not been well-described or systematically investigated. Herein, the picolinic acid MBP is used as a case study for the development of MBP isosteres (so-called MBIs). Many of these isosteres are novel compounds, and data on their physicochemical properties, metal binding capacity, and metalloenzyme inhibition characteristics are presented. The results show that MBIs of picolinic acid generally retain metal coordinating properties and exhibit predictable metalloenzyme inhibitory activity while possessing a broad range of physicochemical properties (e.g., p Ka, log P). These findings demonstrate the use of bioisosteres results in an untapped source of metal binding functional groups suitable for metalloenzyme FBDD. These MBIs provide a previously unexplored route for modulating the physicochemical properties of metalloenzyme inhibitors and improving their drug-likeness.

Isosteres of hydroxypyridinethione as drug-like pharmacophores for metalloenzyme inhibition.

Hydroxypyridinethiones (HOPTOs) are strong ligands for metal ions and potentially useful pharmacophores for inhibiting metalloenzymes relevant to human disease. However, HOPTOs have been sparingly used in drug discovery efforts due, in part, to concerns that this scaffold will act as apromiscuous, non-selective metalloenzyme inhibitor, as well as possesspoor pharmacokinetics (PK), which may undermine drug candidates containing this functional group. To advance HOPTOs as a useful pharmacophore for metalloenzyme inhibitors, a library of 22 HOPTO isostere compounds has been synthesized and investigated. This library demonstrates that it is possible to maintain the core metal-binding pharmacophore (MBP) while generating diversity in structure, electronics, and PK properties. This HOPTO library has been screened against a set of four different metalloenzymes, demonstrating that while the same metal-binding donor atoms are maintained, there is a wide range of activity between metalloenzyme targets. Overall, this work shows that HOPTO isosteres are useful MBPs and valuable scaffolds for metalloenzyme inhibitors.

Metal–ligand interactions in drug design

The fast-growing body of experimental data on metalloenzymes and organometallic compounds is fostering the exploitation of metal–ligand interactions for the design of new drugs. Atomistic understanding of the metal–ligand interactions will help us identify potent metalloenzyme inhibitors and metallodrugs. Static docking calculations have proved effective in identifying hit compounds that target metalloproteins. However, the flexibility, dynamics and electronic structure of metal-centred complexes pose difficult challenges for shaping metal–ligand interactions in structure-based drug design. In this respect, once-prohibitive quantum mechanics-based strategies and extensive molecular simulations are rapidly becoming practical approaches for fast-paced drug discovery. These methods account for ligand exchange and structural flexibility at metal-centred complexes and provide good estimates of the thermodynamics and kinetics of metal-aided drug binding. This Perspective examines the successes, limitations and new avenues for modelling metalloenzyme inhibitors and metallodrugs to further explore and expand the unconventional chemical space of these distinctive drugs.

Structures of the Peptidoglycan N-Acetylglucosamine Deacetylase Bc1974 and Its Complexes with Zinc Metalloenzyme Inhibitors.

The cell wall peptidoglycan is recognized as a primary target of the innate immune system, and usually its disintegration results in bacterial lysis. Bacillus cereus, a close relative of the highly virulent Bacillus anthracis, contains 10 polysaccharide deacetylases. Among these, the peptidoglycan N-acetylglucosamine deacetylase Bc1974 is the highest homologue to the Bacillus anthracis Ba1977 that is required for full virulence and is involved in resistance to the host's lysozyme. These metalloenzymes belong to the carbohydrate esterase family 4 (CE4) and are attractive targets for the development of new anti-infective agents. Herein we report the first X-ray crystal structures of the NodB domain of Bc1974, the conserved catalytic core of CE4s, in the unliganded form and in complex with four known metalloenzyme inhibitors and two amino acid hydroxamates that target the active site metal. These structures revealed the presence of two conformational states of a catalytic loop known as motif-4 (MT4), which were not observed previously for peptidoglycan deacetylases, but were recently shown in the structure of a Vibrio clolerae chitin deacetylase. By employing molecular docking of a substrate model, we describe a catalytic mechanism that probably involves initial binding of the substrate in a receptive, more open state of MT4 and optimal catalytic activity in the closed state of MT4, consistent with the previous observations. The ligand-bound structures presented here, in addition to the five Bc1974 inhibitors identified, provide a valuable basis for the design of antibacterial agents that target the peptidoglycan deacetylase Ba1977.

Controlling Plasma Stability of Hydroxamic Acids: A MedChem Toolbox.

Hydroxamic acids are outstanding zinc chelating groups that can be used to design potent and selective metalloenzyme inhibitors in various therapeutic areas. Some hydroxamic acids display a high plasma clearance resulting in poor in vivo activity, though they may be very potent compounds in vitro. We designed a 57-member library of hydroxamic acids to explore the structure-plasma stability relationships in these series and to identify which enzyme(s) and which pharmacophores are critical for plasma stability. Arylesterases and carboxylesterases were identified as the main metabolic enzymes for hydroxamic acids. Finally, we suggest structural features to be introduced or removed to improve stability. This work thus provides the first medicinal chemistry toolbox (experimental procedures and structural guidance) to assess and control the plasma stability of hydroxamic acids and realize their full potential as in vivo pharmacological probes and therapeutic agents. This study is particularly relevant to preclinical development as it allows obtaining compounds equally stable in human and rodent models.

A Bioinorganic Approach to Fragment-Based Drug Discovery Targeting Metalloenzymes.

Metal-dependent enzymes (i.e., metalloenzymes) make up a large fraction of all enzymes and are critically important in a wide range of biological processes, including DNA modification, protein homeostasis, antibiotic resistance, and many others. Consequently, metalloenzymes represent a vast and largely untapped space for drug development. The discovery of effective therapeutics that target metalloenzymes lies squarely at the interface of bioinorganic and medicinal chemistry and requires expertise, methods, and strategies from both fields to mount an effective campaign. In this Account, our research program that brings together the principles and methods of bioinorganic and medicinal chemistry are described, in an effort to bridge the gap between these fields and address an important class of medicinal targets. Fragment-based drug discovery (FBDD) is an important drug discovery approach that is particularly well suited for metalloenzyme inhibitor development. FBDD uses relatively small but diverse chemical structures that allow for the assembly of privileged molecular collections that focus on a specific feature of the target enzyme. For metalloenzyme inhibition, the specific feature is rather obvious, namely, a metal-dependent active site. Surprisingly, prior to our work, the exploration of diverse molecular fragments for binding the metal active sites of metalloenzymes was largely unexplored. By assembling a modest library of metal-binding pharmacophores (MBPs), we have been able to find lead hits for many metalloenzymes and, from these hits, develop inhibitors that act via novel mechanisms of action. A specific case study on the use of this strategy to identify a first-in-class inhibitor of zinc-dependent Rpn11 (a component of the proteasome) is highlighted. The application of FBDD for the development of metalloenzyme inhibitors has raised several other compelling questions, such as how the metalloenzyme active site influences the coordination chemistry of bound fragments, how one can identify the best fragments for a given metalloenzyme, and many others. Among the most significant, and concerning, questions for metalloenzyme inhibition are those that reside around issues of specificity and whether metalloenzyme inhibitors can be as selective and specific as other small molecule inhibitors (i.e., compounds that inhibit enzymes that do not utilize a metal at their active site). This also leads to the question of whether metalloenzyme inhibitors might interfere more broadly with the metallome. Efforts to address these and related questions are discussed, with the expectation that our findings will illuminate some of these topics, alleviate some of these concerns, and encourage greater interest in this important, undervalued class of drug targets.

Effect of donor atom identity on metal-binding pharmacophore coordination.

The inhibition and binding of three metal-binding pharmacophores (MBPs), 2-hydroxycyclohepta-2,4,6-trien-1-one (tropolone), 2-mercaptopyridine-N-oxide (1,2-HOPTO), and 2-hydroxycyclohepta-2,4,6-triene-1-thione (thiotropolone) to human carbonic anhydrase II (hCAII) and a mutant protein hCAII L198G were investigated. These MBPs displayed bidentate coordination to the active site Zn(II) metal ion, but the MBPs respond to the mutation of L198G differently, as characterized by inhibition activity assays and X-ray crystallography. The L198G mutation increases the active site volume thereby decreasing the steric pressure exerted on MBPs upon binding, allowing changes in MBP coordination to be observed. When comparing the binding mode of tropolone to thiotropolone or 1,2-HOPTO (O,O versus O,S donor sets), structural modifications of the hCAII active site were shown to have a stronger effect on MBPs with an O,O versus O,S donor set. These findings were corroborated with density functional theory (DFT) calculations of model coordination complexes. These results suggest that the MBP binding geometry is a malleable interaction, particularly for certain ligands, and that the identity of the donor atoms influences the response of the ligand to changes in the protein active site environment. Understanding underlying interactions between a MBP and a metalloenzyme active site may aid in the design and development of potent metalloenzyme inhibitors.