The formation of shear band in metallic lattice structures under compression prompts an unstable stress–strain curve, resulting in a significant reduction in the energy absorption capacity. The development and formation of shear band need to be clarified, and versatile approaches to suppress the shear band are required. In this study, we explored the formation mechanism of shear band using a representative Al–12Si alloy lattice structure, consisting of a simple body-centered cubic (BCC) unit cell manufactured by laser powder bed fusion. The X-ray computed tomography observations of an interruptedly compressed lattice specimen and finite element analyses revealed that the crack initiations in the bent struts under the localized tensile stress trigger the formation of shear band. Accordingly, an attempt was made to fabricate various lattice structures consisting of BCC unit cells with different strut diameter ratios to suppress shear band formation. Finite element analyses revealed relaxed tensile stress inside the struts with the controlled diameter ratios, suggesting the suppressed formation of shear bands; this was demonstrated by compression tests. The present results provide new insights for achieving a stable compressive deformation and high energy absorption capacity of lattice structures.