Merger Shocks Research Articles

Morphology of radio relics – II. Properties of polarized emission

ABSTRACTRadio relics are diffuse radio sources in galaxy clusters that are associated with merger shock waves. Detailed observations of radio relics in total intensity and in polarization show complex structures on kiloparsec scales. The relation between the observed features and the underlying morphology of the magnetic field is not clear. Using 3D magneto-hydrodynamical simulations, we study the polarized emission produced by a shock wave that propagates through a turbulent medium that resembles the intracluster medium. We model the polarized synchrotron emission on the basis of diffusive shock acceleration of cosmic ray electrons. We find that the synchrotron emission produced in a shocked turbulent medium can reproduce some of the observed features in radio relics. Shock compression can give rise to a high polarization fraction at the shock front and a partial alignment of the polarization E-vectors with the shock normal. Our work confirms that radio relics can also be formed in an environment with a tangled magnetic field. We also discuss the effect of Faraday rotation intrinsic to the source, and how our results depend on the angular resolution of observations.

Tempestuous life beyond R500: X-ray view on the Coma cluster with SRG/eROSITA

This is the first paper in a series of studies of the Coma cluster using the SRG/eROSITA X-ray data obtained in the course of the calibration and performance verification observations. The data cover a ~3° × 3° area around the cluster with a typical exposure time of more than 20 ks. The stability of the instrumental background and operation of the SRG observatory in the scanning mode provided us with an excellent data set for studies of the diffuse emission up to a distance of ~1.5R200 from the Coma center. In this study, we discuss the rich morphology revealed by the X-ray observations (also in combination with the SZ data) and argue that the most salient features can be naturally explained by a recent (ongoing) merger with the NGC 4839 group. In particular, we identify a faint X-ray bridge connecting the group with the cluster, which is convincing proof that NGC 4839 has already crossed the main cluster. The gas in the Coma core went through two shocks, first through the shock driven by NGC 4839 during its first passage through the cluster some gigayear ago and, more recently, through the “mini-accretion shock” associated with the gas settling back to quasi-hydrostatic equilibrium in the core. After passing through the primary shock, the gas should spend much of the time in a rarefaction region, where radiative losses of electrons are small, until the gas is compressed again by the mini-accretion shock. Unlike “runway” merger shocks, the mini-accretion shock does not feature a rarefaction region downstream and, therefore, the radio emission can survive longer. Such a two-stage process might explain the formation of the radio halo in the Coma cluster.

How Merger-driven Gas Motions in Galaxy Clusters Can Turn AGN Bubbles into Radio Relics

Abstract Radio relics in galaxy clusters are extended synchrotron sources produced by cosmic-ray electrons in the microgauss magnetic field. Many relics are found in the cluster periphery and have a cluster-centric, narrow arc-like shape, which suggests that the electrons are accelerated or reaccelerated by merger shock fronts propagating outward in the intracluster plasma. In the X-ray, some relics do exhibit such shocks at the location of the relic, but many do not. We explore the possibility that radio relics trace not the shock fronts but the shape of the underlying distribution of seed relativistic electrons, lit up by a recent shock passage. We use magnetohydrodynamic simulations of cluster mergers and include bubbles of relativistic electrons injected by jets from the central active galactic nucleus or from an off-center radio galaxy. We show that the merger-driven gas motions (a) can advect the bubble cosmic rays to very large radii and (b) spread the relativistic seed electrons preferentially in the tangential direction—along the gravitational equipotential surfaces—producing extended, filamentary, or sheet-like regions of intracluster plasma enriched with aged cosmic rays, which resemble radio relics. Once a shock front passes across such a region, the sharp radio emission edges would trace the sharp boundaries of these enriched regions rather than the front. We also show that these elongated cosmic-ray features are naturally associated with magnetic fields stretched tangentially along their long axis, which could help explain the high polarization of relics.

Evolution of splashback boundaries and gaseous outskirts: insights from mergers of self-similar galaxy clusters

ABSTRACT A self-similar spherical collapse model predicts a dark matter (DM) splashback and accretion shock in the outskirts of galaxy clusters while missing a key ingredient of structure formation – processes associated with mergers. To fill this gap, we perform simulations of merging self-similar clusters and investigate their DM and gas evolution in an idealized cosmological context. Our simulations show that the cluster rapidly contracts during the major merger and the splashback radius rsp decreases, approaching the virial radius rvir. While in the self-similar model rsp depends on a smooth mass accretion rate parameter Γs, our simulations show that in the presence of mergers, rsp responds to the changes in the total mass accretion rate Γvir, which accounts for both mergers and smooth accretion. The scatter of the Γvir − rsp/rvir relation indicates a generally low Γs ∼ 1 in clusters in cosmological simulations. In contrast to the DM, the hot gaseous atmospheres significantly expand by the merger-accelerated (MA-) shocks formed when the runaway merger shocks overtake the outer accretion shock. After a major merger, the MA-shock radius is larger than rsp by a factor of up to ∼1.7 for Γs ≲ 1 and is ∼rsp for Γs ≳ 3. This implies that (1) mergers could easily generate the MA-shock-splashback offset measured in cosmological simulations, and (2) the smooth mass accretion rate is small in regions away from filaments where MA-shocks reside. We further discuss the shapes of the DM haloes, various shocks, and contact discontinuities formed at different epochs of the merger, and the ram-pressure stripping in cluster outskirts.

Radio relics in PSZ2 G096.88+24.18: a connection with pre-existing plasma

ABSTRACT Giant radio relics are arc-like structures of diffuse, non-thermal synchrotron radiation that trace shock waves induced by galaxy cluster mergers. The particle (re-)acceleration mechanism producing such radio relics is unclear. One major open question is whether relics can be formed directly from a population of thermal seed electrons, or if pre-existing relativistic seed electrons are required. In some cases, active galactic nuclei (AGNs) can provide such a population of sub-GeV electrons. However, it is unclear how common this connection is. In this paper, we present LOFAR 140 MHz and Very Large Array L-band radio observations, as well as Chandra data of PSZ2 G096.88+24.18, a merging galaxy cluster system hosting a pair of radio relics. A large patch of diffuse emission connects a bright radio galaxy with one of the relics, likely affecting the properties of the relic. We find that the most plausible explanation for the connection is that the merger shock wave has passed over an AGN lobe. The shock passing over this seed population of electrons has led to an increased brightness in the relic only in the region filled with seed electrons.

Troubled cosmic flows: turbulence, enstrophy, and helicity from the assembly history of the intracluster medium

ABSTRACT Both simulations and observations have shown that turbulence is a pervasive phenomenon in cosmic scenarios, yet it is particularly difficult to model numerically due to its intrinsically multiscale character which demands high resolutions. Additionally, turbulence is tightly connected to the dynamical state and the formation history of galaxies and galaxy clusters, producing a diverse phenomenology which requires large samples of such structures to attain robust conclusions. In this work, we use an adaptive mesh refinement (AMR) cosmological simulation to explore the generation and dissipation of turbulence in galaxy clusters, in connection to its assembly history. We find that major mergers, and more generally accretion of gas, is the main process driving turbulence in the intracluster medium. We have especially focused on solenoidal turbulence, which can be quantified through enstrophy. Our results seem to confirm a scenario for its generation which involves baroclinicity and compression at the external (accretion) and internal (merger) shocks, followed by vortex stretching downstream of them. We have also looked at the infall of mass to the cluster beyond its virial boundary, finding that gas follows trajectories with some degree of helicity, as it has already developed some vorticity in the external shocks.

The First Integral Field Unit Spectroscopic View of Shocked Cluster Galaxies

Abstract Galaxy clusters grow by merging with other clusters, giving rise to Mpc-wide shock waves that travel at 1000–2500 km s−1 through the intracluster medium. To study the effects of merger shocks on the properties of cluster galaxies, we present the first spatially resolved spectroscopic view of five Hα-emitting galaxies located in the wake of shock fronts in the low redshift (z ∼ 0.2), massive (∼2 × 1015 M ⊙), post-core passage merging cluster, CIZA J2242.8+5301 (nicknamed the “Sausage”). Our Gemini/Gemini Multi-Object Spectrograph-North integral field unit (IFU) observations, designed to capture Hα and [N ii] emission, reveal the nebular gas distribution, kinematics, and metallicities in the galaxies over >16 kpc scales. While the galaxies show evidence for rotational support, the flux and velocity maps have complex features like tails and gas outflows aligned with the merger axis of the cluster. With gradients that are incompatible with inside-out disk growth, the metallicity maps are consistent with sustained star formation (SF) throughout and outside of the galactic disks. In combination with previous results, these pilot observations provide further evidence of a likely connection between cluster mergers and SF triggering in cluster galaxies, a potentially fundamental discovery revealing the interaction of galaxies with their environment.

Morphology of radio relics – I. What causes the substructure of synchrotron emission?

ABSTRACT High-resolution radio observations of cluster radio relics often show complex spatial and spectral features. However, it is not clear what these features reveal about the underlying magnetic field properties. We performed three-dimensional magnetohydrodynamical simulations of merger shock waves propagating through a magnetized, turbulent intracluster medium. Our model includes the diffusive shock acceleration (DSA) of cosmic ray electrons, their spatial advection and energy losses at run-time. With this set-up we can investigate the relation between radio substructure and pre-shock plasma conditions in the host cluster. We find that upstream turbulence plays a major role in shaping the properties of radio relics produced downstream. Within the assumption of DSA, we can reproduce the observed discrepancy between the X-ray derived Mach number of shocks, and the Mach number inferred from radio spectra. Our simulated spectral index maps and profiles across the radio relic also suggest that the standard deviation of the upstream magnetic field must be relatively small ($\sigma _B\le 1 \, \mu$G) in order to reproduce observations and therefore radio relics can potentially constrain the distribution of magnetic fields in galaxy clusters outskirts.

The application of the adiabatic compression scenario to the radio relic in the galaxy cluster Abell 3411−3412

ABSTRACT Although radio relics are understood to originate in intracluster shock waves resulting from merger shocks, the most widely used model for describing this (re-)acceleration process at shock fronts, the diffusive shock acceleration (DSA) model, has several challenges, including the fact that it is inefficient at low shock Mach numbers. In light of these challenges, it is worthwhile to consider alternative mechanisms. One possibility is the adiabatic compression by a shock wave of a residual fossil electron population which has been left over from a radio galaxy jet. This paper applies this model to the relic hosted in the merging galaxy cluster Abell 3411−3412, where a radio bridge between the relic and a radio galaxy has been observed, with the aim to reproduce the spatial structure of the spectral index of the relic. Four scenarios are presented, in which different effects are investigated, such as effects behind the shock front and different shock strengths. The results show that the adiabatic compression model can reproduce the observed spectral indices across the relic for a shock Mach number that is lower than the value required by the DSA-type modelling of this relic and is in accordance with the values derived from X-ray observations, if other mechanisms, such as an expansion phase or post-shock turbulence, are effective behind the shock front.

Collision of merger and accretion shocks: formation of Mpc-scale contact discontinuity in the Perseus cluster

ABSTRACT Two Mpc-size contact discontinuities have recently been identified in the XMM–Newton and Suzaku X-ray observations in the outskirts of the Perseus cluster (Walker et al.). These structures have been tentatively interpreted as ‘sloshing cold fronts’, which are customarily associated with differential motions of the cluster gas, perturbed by a merger. In this study, we consider an alternative scenario, namely, that the most prominent discontinuity, near the cluster virial radius, is the result of the collision between the accretion shock and a ‘runaway’ merger shock. We also discuss the possible origin of the second discontinuity at ${\sim}1.2{\rm \, Mpc}$.

Passive spirals and shock influenced star formation in the merging cluster A3376

ABSTRACT We present a detailed analysis of star formation properties of galaxies in a nearby (z ∼ 0.046) young (∼0.6 Gyr) post-merger cluster system A3376, with a moderate merger shock front (vs ∼1630 km s−1; $\mathcal {M}$ ∼ 2) observed as symmetric radio relics. Exploiting the spectroscopic data from the wide-field OmegaWINGS survey and the associated photometric information, our investigations reveal the plausible effects of the dynamic post-merger environment differing from the high-density cluster environment experienced prior to the merging activity. The remnants of the pre-merger relaxed cluster environment are realized through the existence of passive spiral galaxies located in the central regions of the cluster between the two brightest cluster galaxies. We discover A3376 to contain a population of massive (log (M*/M⊙) > 10) blue regular star-forming spirals in regions of maximum merger shock influence but exhibiting star formation rates similar to those in relaxed clusters at similar epoch. We further discover low-mass (log (M*/M⊙) ≤ 10) late-type blue post-starburst galaxies which could either be formed as a result of rapid quenching of low-mass spirals following the shock-induced star formation or due to the intense surge in the intracluster medium pressures at the beginning of the merger. With the possibility of the merger shock affecting high- and low-mass spirals differently, our results bridge the seemingly contradictory results observed in known merging cluster systems so far and establish that different environmental effects are at play right from pre- to post-merger stages.

Discovering the most elusive radio relic in the sky: diffuse shock acceleration caught in the act?

ABSTRACT The origin of radio relics is usually explained via diffusive shock acceleration (DSA) or re-acceleration of electrons at/from merger shocks in galaxy clusters. The case of acceleration is challenged by the low predicted efficiency of low Mach number merger shocks, unable to explain the power observed in most radio relics. In this letter, we present the discovery of a new giant radio relic around the galaxy cluster Abell 2249 ($z$ = 0.0838) using Low-Frequency Array (LOFAR). It is special since it has the lowest surface brightness of all known radio relics. We study its radio and X-ray properties combining LOFAR data with uGMRT, JVLA, and XMM. This object has a total power of $L_{1.4\rm\, GHz}=4.1\pm 0.8 \times 10^{23}$ W Hz−1 and integrated spectral index α = 1.15 ± 0.23. We infer for this radio relic a lower bound on the magnetization of $B\ge 0.4\, \mu$G, a shock Mach number of $\mathcal {M}\approx 3.79$, and a low acceleration efficiency consistent with DSA. This result suggests that a missing population of relics may become visible, thanks to the unprecedented sensitivity of the new generation of radio telescopes.

Dynamical heating of the X-ray emitting intracluster medium: the roles of merger shocks and turbulence dissipation

ABSTRACT The diffuse plasma inside clusters of galaxies has X-ray emitting temperatures of a few keV. The physical mechanisms that heat this intracluster medium (ICM) to such temperatures include the accretion shock at the periphery of a galaxy cluster, the shocks driven by merger events, as well as a somewhat overlooked mechanism – the dissipation of intracluster turbulent motions. We study the relative role of these heating mechanisms using galaxy clusters in Lagrangian tracer particle re-simulations of the Omega500 cosmological simulation. We adopt a novel analysis method of decomposing the temperature increase at each time-step into the contribution from dissipative heating and that from adiabatic heating. In the high-resolution spatial–temporal map of these heating rates, merger tracks are clearly visible, demonstrating the dominant role of merger events in heating the ICM. The dissipative heating contributed by each merger event is extended in time and also occurs in the rarefaction regions, suggesting the importance of heating by the dissipation of merger-induced turbulence. Quantitative analysis shows that turbulence heating, rather than direct heating at merger shocks, dominates the temperature increase of the ICM especially at inner radii r < r500c. In addition, we find that many merger shocks can propagate with almost constant velocity to very large radii r ≫ r500c, some even reach and join with the accretion shock and becoming the outer boundary of the ICM. Altogether, these results suggest that the ICM is heated more in an ‘inside–out’ fashion rather than ‘outside–in’ as depicted in the classical smooth accretion picture.

Encounters of merger and accretion shocks in galaxy clusters and their effects on intracluster medium

ABSTRACT Several types/classes of shocks naturally arise during formation and evolution of galaxy clusters. One such class is represented by accretion shocks, associated with deceleration of infalling baryons. Such shocks, characterized by a very high Mach number, are present even in 1D models of cluster evolution. Another class is composed of ‘runaway merger shocks’, which appear when a merger shock, driven by a sufficiently massive infalling subcluster, propagates away from the main-cluster centre. We argue that, when the merger shock overtakes the accretion shock, a new long-living shock is formed that propagates to large distances from the main cluster (well beyond its virial radius), affecting the cold gas around the cluster. We refer to these structures as Merger-accelerated Accretion shocks (MA-shocks) in this paper. We show examples of such MA-shocks in one-dimensioanal (1D) and three-dimensional (3D) simulations and discuss their characteristic properties. In particular, (1) MA-shocks shape the boundary separating the hot intracluster medium (ICM) from the unshocked gas, giving this boundary a ‘flower-like’ morphology. In 3D, MA-shocks occupy space between the dense accreting filaments. (2) Evolution of MA-shocks highly depends on the Mach number of the runaway merger shock and the mass accretion rate parameter of the cluster. (3) MA-shocks may lead to the misalignment of the ICM boundary and the splashback radius.

Analytical model for cluster radio relics

ABSTRACT Radio relics are vast synchrotron sources that sit on the outskirts of merging galaxy clusters. In this work we model their formation using a Press–Schechter formalism to simulate merger rates, analytical models for the intracluster medium and the shock dynamics, as well as a simple model for the cosmic ray electrons at the merger shocks. We show that the statistical properties of the population of radio relics are strongly dependent on key physical parameters, such as the acceleration efficiency, the magnetic field strength at the relic, the geometry of the relic and the duration of the electron acceleration at merger shocks. It turns out that the flux distribution as well as the power–mass relation can constrain key parameters of the intracluster medium. With the advent of new large-area radio surveys, statistical analyses of radio relics will complement what we have learned from observations of individual objects.

Shock acceleration efficiency in radio relics

Context. Radio relics in galaxy clusters are giant diffuse synchrotron sources powered in cluster outskirts by merger shocks. Although the relic–shock connection has been consolidated in recent years by a number of observations, the details of the mechanisms leading to the formation of relativistic particles in this environment are still not well understood. Aims. The diffusive shock acceleration (DSA) theory is a commonly adopted scenario to explain the origin of cosmic rays at astrophysical shocks, including those in radio relics in galaxy clusters. However, in a few specific cases it has been shown that the energy dissipated by cluster shocks is not enough to reproduce the luminosity of the relics via DSA of thermal particles. Studies based on samples of radio relics are required to further address this limitation of the mechanism. Methods. In this paper, we focus on ten well-studied radio relics with underlying shocks observed in the X-rays and calculate the electron acceleration efficiency of these shocks that is necessary to reproduce the observed radio luminosity of the relics. Results. We find that in general the standard DSA cannot explain the origin of the relics if electrons are accelerated from the thermal pool with an efficiency significantly smaller than 10%. Our results show that other mechanisms, such as shock re-acceleration of supra-thermal seed electrons or a modification of standard DSA, are required to explain the formation of radio relics.

LoCuSS: exploring the connection between local environment, star formation, and dust mass in Abell 1758

ABSTRACT We explore the connection between dust and star formation, in the context of environmental effects on galaxy evolution. In particular, we exploit the susceptibility of dust to external processes to assess the influence of dense environment on star-forming galaxies. We have selected cluster Abell 1758 from the Local Cluster Substructure Survey (LoCuSS). Its complex dynamical state is an ideal test-bench to track dust removal and destruction in galaxies due to merger and accretion shocks. We present a systematic panchromatic study (from $0.15\, \mu$m with GALEX to $\rm 500\, \mu$m with Herschel) of spectroscopically confirmed star-forming cluster galaxies at intermediate redshift. We observe that the main subclusters (A1758N and A1758S) belong to two separate large-scale structures, with no overlapping galaxy members. Star-forming cluster members are found preferentially outside cluster central regions, and are not isotropically distributed. Rather, these galaxies appear being funneled towards the main subclusters along separate accretion paths. Additionally, we present the first study of dust-to-stellar (DTS) mass ratio used as an indicator for local environmental influence on galaxy evolution. Star-forming cluster members show lower mean values (32$\rm {{\ \rm per\ cent}}$ at $\rm 2.4\sigma$) of DTS mass ratio and lower levels of infrared emission from birth clouds with respect to coeval star-forming field galaxies. This picture is consistent with the majority of star-forming cluster members infalling in isolation. Upon accretion, star formation is observed to decrease and warm dust is destroyed due to heating from the intracluster medium radiation, ram-pressure stripping, and merger shocks.

Radio relic and the diffuse emission trail discovered in low-mass galaxy cluster Abell 1697

We report the discovery of a putative radio relic, 830 kpc in length, and found towards the outskirts of galaxy cluster Abell 1697 (z = 0.181), using the LOFAR Two Meter Sky Survey at 144 MHz. An X-ray-inferred mass of M500X-ray = 2.9−0.7+0.8 × 1014 M⊙ places Abell 1697 among the least massive relic hosts. The relic is also detected at 325 MHz in the Westerbork Northern Sky Survey and at 1.4 GHz in the NRAO VLA Sky Survey, with an average spectral index of α(144, 325, 1400 MHz) = − 0.98 ± 0.01, and magnetic field of Beq ∼ 0.6 μG. This relic, located in the north-east periphery of the cluster, is 300 kpc wide, exhibits a gradual spectral steepening across the width (α144 MHz1.4 GHz(inj) = −0.70 ± 0.11 to α144 MHz1.4 GHz(edge) = −1.19 ± 0.15), as well as indications of a co-spatial X-ray (ROSAT) shock and the radio relic emission. The radio power of the relic is P1.4 GHz = 8.5 ± 1.1 × 1023 W Hz−1, which is found to be in good agreement with the expected empirical correlation between the radio power and largest linear size of relics. The relic is trailed by extended (790 × 550 kpc) diffuse radio emission towards the cluster centre, which is likely an ultra-steep spectrum (α144 MHz1.4 GHz < −1.84) radio source. This structure is also found to be older by at least 190 Myr, has a very low surface brightness of 0.3 μJy arcsec−2 and magnetic field Beq ∼ 0.8 μG, similar to that of a radio phoenix. Finally, we discuss the possible mechanisms responsible for the relic and the trailing diffuse radio emission, invoking re-acceleration due to wake turbulence, as well as the revival of fossil electrons in the remnant radio lobes of active galactic nuclei by the cluster merger shocks.

Low-frequency radio study of MACS clusters at 610 and 235 MHz using the GMRT

Abstract Studies have shown that mergers of massive galaxy clusters produce shocks and turbulence in the intracluster medium, these events possibly creating radio relics, as well as radio haloes. Here we present Giant Metrewave Radio Telescope (GMRT) dual-band (235- and 610-MHz) radio observations of four such clusters from the MAssive Cluster Survey (MACS) catalogue. We report the discovery of a very faint, diffuse, elongated radio source with a projected size of about 0.5 Mpc in cluster MACSJ0152.5−2852. We also confirm the presence of a radio-relic-like source (about 0.4 Mpc, previously reported at 325 MHz) in cluster MACSJ0025.4−1222. Proposed relics in both these clusters are found apparently inside the virial radius, instead of at their usual peripheral location, while no radio haloes are detected. These high-redshift clusters (z = 0.584 and 0.413) are among the earliest merging systems detected from cluster radio emission. In cluster MACSJ1931.8-2635, we found a radio mini-halo and an interesting highly bent pair of radio jets. Also, we present here a maiden study of low-frequency (GMRT 235- and 610-MHz) spectral and morphological signatures of the previously known radio cluster MACSJ0014.3−3022 (Abell 2744). This cluster hosts a relatively flat spectrum ($\alpha ^{610}_{235}\sim -1.15$), giant (∼1.6 Mpc each) halo–relic structure and a nearby high-speed ($1769\pm ^{148}_{359}$ km s−1) merger shock ($\mathcal {M}=2.02\pm ^{0.17}_{0.41}$) originating from a possible second merger in the cluster.

Runaway merger shocks in galaxy cluster outskirts and radio relics

ABSTRACT Moderately strong shocks arise naturally when two subclusters merge. For instance, when a smaller subcluster falls into the gravitational potential of a more massive cluster, a bow shock is formed and moves together with the subcluster. After pericentre passage, however, the subcluster is decelerated by the gravity of the main cluster, while the shock continues moving away from the cluster centre. These shocks are considered as promising candidates for powering radio relics found in many clusters. The aim of this paper is to explore the fate of such shocks when they travel to the cluster outskirts, far from the place where the shocks were initiated. In a uniform medium, such a ‘runaway’ shock should weaken with distance. However, as shocks move to large radii in galaxy clusters, the shock is moving down a steep density gradient that helps the shock to maintain its strength over a large distance. Observations and numerical simulations show that, beyond R500, gas density profiles are as steep as, or steeper than, ∼r−3, suggesting that there exists a ‘habitable zone’ for moderately strong shocks in cluster outskirts where the shock strength can be maintained or even amplified. A characteristic feature of runaway shocks is that the strong compression, relative to the initial state, is confined to a narrow region just behind the shock. Therefore, if such a shock runs over a region with a pre-existing population of relativistic particles, then the boost in radio emissivity, due to pure adiabatic compression, will also be confined to a narrow radial shell.