A series of monodisperse cyclic and linear poly(d,l-lactide)s (c-PLA and l-PLA, respectively) were prepared with various degrees of polymerization (DP) using an iterative convergent synthesis approach. The absence of a molecular weight distribution provided us a chance to study their mechanochemical reactivity without obstructions arising from the size distribution. Additionally, we prepared l- and c-PLAs with identical DPs, which enabled us to attribute differences in scission rates to the cyclic polymer architecture alone. The polymers were subjected to ultrasonication (US) and ball-mill grinding (BMG), and their degradation kinetics were explored. Up to 9.0 times larger scission rates were observed for l-PLA (compared to c-PLA) with US, but the difference was less than 1.9 times with BMG. Fragmentation requires two backbone scission events for c-PLA, and we were able to observe linear intermediates (formed after a single scission) for the first time. We also developed a new method of studying the dynamic memory effect in US by characterizing and comparing the daughter fragment molecular weight distributions of l- and c-PLAs. These results provide new insights into the influence of the cyclic polymer architecture on mechanochemical reactions as well as differences in reactivity observed with US and BMG.