Melt Pool Surface Research Articles

Effect of energy density on down surface characteristics of AlSi10Mg alloy fabricated via selective laser melting

The correlation between surface roughness and energy density in the down surface area of AlSi10Mg alloy manufactured by selective laser melting was analyzed. This study investigated the relationship between the contour melt pool shape and surface roughness in the down surface area across an energy density range of 10–150 J/mm³. As the energy density increased, the contour melt pool in the down surface area became more stable, which significantly influenced surface roughness. Low energy density resulted in the unstable formation of the contour melt pool, leading to a deterioration in surface quality, whereas high energy density promoted the stable formation of the melt pool. Sufficient energy density is essential for the complete formation of the contour melt pool on the down surface, which plays a crucial role in reducing surface roughness. However, within the energy density range where the contour melt pool is fully formed, keyhole defects may occur, and it can be anticipated that these defects may worsen at energy densities exceeding the critical threshold.

Interaction of contour and hatch parameters on vertical surface roughness in laser powder bed fusion

In Laser Powder Bed Fusion (L-PBF), surface roughness is pivotal for controlling the mechanical and functional performances, as well as the geometrical accuracy of the final product. This study extensively investigated the interactions of hatch and contour processing parameters, along with contour offset distance, on vertical surface roughness for 316L stainless steel in L-PBF. Melt pool morphology and surface arithmetic average roughness (Sa) were quantified using confocal microscopy, while scanning electron microscopy was employed to interpret the detailed microstructure of surface features. Under low volumetric energy density (VED) hatch conditions (e.g., 66.7 J/mm3), varying the contour offset distance has a negatable effect on the surface roughness when the contour VED is lower than 121.6 J/mm3, remaining relatively smooth surfaces dominated by bare melt tracks with sparely attached partially melted particles. Increasing the hatch or contour VED (e.g., 166.7 J/mm3), dross formation, identified by the microstructural differences and explained by the melt pool instability and migration, is inevitable, which dictates the surface roughness with higher Sa values. The larger contour offset distance further promotes the dross occurrence with irregularity and increases Sa. Employing a low contour VED with an appropriate offset distance and adopting the contour-first scan strategy was demonstrated as an effective solution to reduce the dross formation. Through the analysis of melt pool behavior, surface topography, and microstructure, this study elucidates the mechanisms governing dominant surface characteristics under the combined influence of hatch and contour parameters. It lays the foundation for precise control of surface roughness without altering hatching parameters, enabling the tailored manipulation of performance in additively manufactured structures.

Improved accuracy of continuum surface flux models for metal additive manufacturing melt pool simulations

Computational modeling of the melt pool dynamics in laser-based powder bed fusion metal additive manufacturing (PBF-LB/M) promises to shed light on fundamental mechanisms of defect generation. These processes are accompanied by rapid evaporation so that the evaporation-induced recoil pressure and cooling arise as major driving forces for fluid dynamics and temperature evolution. The magnitude of these interface fluxes depends exponentially on the melt pool surface temperature, which, therefore, has to be predicted with high accuracy. The present work utilizes a diffuse interface finite element model based on a continuum surface flux (CSF) description of interface fluxes to study dimensionally reduced thermal two-phase problems representative for PBF-LB/M in a finite element framework. It is demonstrated that the extreme temperature gradients combined with the high ratios of material properties between metal and ambient gas lead to significant errors in the interface temperatures and fluxes when classical CSF approaches, along with typical interface thicknesses and discretizations, are applied. It is expected that this finding is also relevant for other types of diffuse interface PBF-LB/M melt pool models. A novel parameter-scaled CSF approach is proposed, which is constructed to yield a smoother temperature field in the diffuse interface region, significantly increasing the solution accuracy. The interface thickness required to predict the temperature field with a given level of accuracy is less restrictive by at least one order of magnitude for the proposed parameter-scaled approach compared to classical CSF, drastically reducing computational costs. Finally, we showcase the general applicability of the parameter-scaled CSF to a 3D simulation of stationary laser melting of PBF-LB/M considering the fully coupled thermo-hydrodynamic multi-phase problem, including phase change.

High-speed synchrotron X-ray imaging of melt pool dynamics during ultrasonic melt processing of Al6061

Ultrasonic processing of solidifying metals in additive manufacturing can provide grain refinement and advantageous mechanical properties. However, the specific physical mechanisms of microstructural refinement relevant to laser-based additive manufacturing have not been directly observed because of sub-millimeter length scales and rapid solidification rates associated with melt pools. Here, high-speed synchrotron X-ray imaging is used to observe the effect of ultrasonic vibration directly on melt pool dynamics and solidification of Al6061 alloy. The high temporal and spatial resolution enabled direct observation of cavitation effects driven by a 20.2 kHz ultrasonic source. We utilized multiphysics simulations to validate the postulated connection between ultrasonic treatment and solidification. The X-ray results show a decrease in melt pool and keyhole depth fluctuations during melting and promotion of pore migration toward the melt pool surface with applied sonication. Additionally, the simulation results reveal increased localized melt pool flow velocity, cooling rates, and thermal gradients with applied sonication. This work shows how ultrasonic treatment can impact melt pools and its potential for improving part quality.

Beam-shaping in laser-based powder bed fusion of metals: A computational analysis of point-ring intensity profiles

Laser-based powder bed fusion has the potential to enable manufacturing of local material properties and locally varying alloys. One promising approach under research is shaping of the applied laser beam. The current commercial standard using a Gaussian laser beam profile is associated with a high energy intensity peak and strong gradients. A potential alternative beam shape is the point-ring profile where laser energy is distributed between a central spot and an outer ring. We conduct a numerical study of beam shape impact on melt-pool shapes, surface temperatures, evaporation and flow dynamics of single-melt-tracks. To that end, we apply a Weakly Compressible Smoothed Particle Hydrodynamics solver coupled with a ray-tracing laser scheme. A point-ring profile is compared to a standard Gaussian profile. The profiles are studied at two different beam sizes to find the influence of beam size on the shape effect. We find good agreement between numerical results and experimental data for both narrow and deep, as well as wide and shallow melt-tracks. The simulation results show that beam size and thus energy density influence the effect beam-shaping has on the melt-pool dynamics. Both the distribution of evaporation and surface tension forces over the melt-pool surface are found to depend on the used beam shape. The study highlights the importance of distinguishing between size and shape effects when investigating laser beam shapes. Both energy density and its distribution need to be tuned for the desired melt-pool behavior.

Dynamics of pore formation and evolution during multi-layer directed energy deposition additive manufacturing via in-situ synchrotron X-ray imaging: A case study on high-entropy Cantor alloy

Blown-powder directed energy deposition (DED) additive manufacturing is impeded for novel alloys processing by perceivable and detrimental porosity. During multi-layer depositions, however, mechanisms of pore formation and evolution remain elusive for developing pore mitigation strategies. Here, conduction-mode multi-layer DED process of an exemplary high-entropy Cantor alloy have been investigated in-situ by high-energy high-speed synchrotron X-ray imaging. Three new pore formation mechanisms are unveiled when depositing first layer and successive layers: gas pore induced by high-velocity powder injection into melt pool, pore generated from swirl shear of turbulent melt flow, and pore trapped by surface wave. Three pore formation mechanisms are reconfirmed: pore inheritance from feedstock powder, pore generation when laser remelting defect-sensitive locations of existing pore from previous layer or unmelted powder attached on the melt pool surface, and pore formation as cooling of melt pool. A unique mechanism for pore elimination is proposed: a counter-Marangoni melt flow is experimentally found in the stable melt pool and contributes to the prolonged pore lifetime at tens of milliseconds scale; pores are prone to coalesce into larger sizes in laser interaction zone and the adjacent location with circulation zone; coalesced larger pores driven by combined effect of Marangoni and buoyant forces easily get eliminated from melt pool. The results of pore formation and evolution dynamics revealed in Cantor alloy provide quantified experimental data for high-fidelity computational modeling and in-depth insights of porosity control for high-entropy alloy printing down to melt pool scale.

Interface characteristics of selective laser melted stainless steel 316L and Inconel 718

Additive manufactured dissimilar metal constructs of alternating Inconel 718 and Stainless Steel 316L layers were fabricated by using selective laser melting. The solidified interfaces between two materials were examined to understand the interface characteristics. No distinct horizontal layers have been observed and undulating dissimilar interfaces at meso-scale. The undulations of the interfacing are understood a result of the melt pool surface oscillations driven by forces such as surface tension. The shape of the interface and the chemical distribution across the interface implied that the mass transport by the flow can significantly influence the interface morphology.

A Review on Laser Beam Shaping Application in Laser Powder Bed Fusion

Laser powder bed fusion (L‐PBF) is extensively adopted in the aerospace and automobile industries for producing metallic components. The L‐PBF process involves rapid melting and solidification of metallic powders using a laser source to produce dense parts. Most industrial L‐PBF systems use a fiber‐based laser source that emits a Gaussian beam distribution. However, the conventional Gaussian beam used in L‐PBF processes presents inherent limitations that can impact the quality and properties of the final products. This review aims to provide a theoretical background of laser beam shaping techniques and explores the application of alternative beam shapes in L‐PBF. It investigates how different beam profiles affect the melt pool geometry, process stability, productivity, mechanical properties, microstructure, and surface roughness of fabricated parts. Additionally, it discusses different types of beam‐shaping techniques and elements utilized to generate distinct beam shapes. Furthermore, different constraints and limitations that hinder the full exploitation of beam shaping are critically discussed. By analyzing the impact of beam shaping in L‐PBF, this review provides insight into optimizing the AM process, enhancing part quality, and improving processing performance. It will also help readers to overview the research gaps, challenges, and promising future directions in laser beam shaping applications in L‐PBF.This review comprehensively covers and presents the current research trend of laser beam shaping applications in L‐PBF. It delves into the opportunities, challenges, limitations, and futures prospects of beam shaping applications. Furthermore, presents the methods and techniques used to modulate the laser beam profile, including spatial and temporal.This article is protected by copyright. All rights reserved.

Gas-particle-heat dynamic coupling simulation in directed energy deposition

Powder flow can affect the temperature variations in directed energy deposition (DED). However, the direct coupling mechanism remains unknown. To solve this problem, the heat and mass transfer in additive manufacturing was simulated using dynamic coupling. The interactions between the multiphase flow and heat transfer were established. A comparison with experiment shows that the accuracy of the predictions of the numerical simulation regarding powder size distributions and temperature increases is higher than 95 %. The average temperature increase of the metal powders with different weight functions was highly consistent in the simulation process. As the powder size increases, the average temperature of the powder on the printing plane decreases. This was the reason for the formation of a deeper melt pool in the case of smaller particles in the experiment. The different curvatures between the particle surface and melt pool surface lead to a decreased energy absorption efficiency in DED. The relationship between the powder features and the melt pool size was studied. A decrease in the powder flow rate increased the temperature, leading to a larger melt depth.

Understanding Melt Pool Behavior of 316L Stainless Steel in Laser Powder Bed Fusion Additive Manufacturing.

In the laser powder bed fusion additive manufacturing process, the quality of fabrications is intricately tied to the laser-matter interaction, specifically the formation of the melt pool. This study experimentally examined the intricacies of melt pool characteristics and surface topography across diverse laser powers and speeds via single-track laser scanning on a bare plate and powder bed for 316L stainless steel. The results reveal that the presence of a powder layer amplifies melt pool instability and worsens irregularities due to increased laser absorption and the introduction of uneven mass from the powder. To provide a comprehensive understanding of melt pool dynamics, a high-fidelity computational model encompassing fluid dynamics, heat transfer, vaporization, and solidification was developed. It was validated against the measured melt pool dimensions and morphology, effectively predicting conduction and keyholing modes with irregular surface features. Particularly, the model explained the forming mechanisms of a defective morphology, termed swell-undercut, at high power and speed conditions, detailing the roles of recoil pressure and liquid refilling. As an application, multiple-track simulations replicate the surface features on cubic samples under two distinct process conditions, showcasing the potential of the laser-matter interaction model for process optimization.

Preliminary Parametric Investigations into Macro-Laser Polishing of Laser-Directed Energy Deposition of SS 304L Bulk Structures

The higher surface roughness of laser-directed energy deposition (LDED)-built components necessitates advanced and sustainable surface quality enhancement techniques like laser polishing. In the present work, a parametric study involving experimental investigation and numerical analysis is conducted to determine the effect of macro-laser polishing on LDED-built SS 304L structures. A thermophysical model is developed to simulate the effect of laser power and scan speed on the melt pool depth of the LDED-built samples. The simulated melt pool depth is compared with experimental results and is found to be in good agreement. Further, the correlation between the melt pool depth and surface behaviour is studied based on shallow surface melting and shallow over-melting mechanisms. A maximum reduction in surface roughness from 21.3 µm to 9 µm (~57%) is achieved with laser polishing, and process parameters’ effect on the surface roughness is investigated. Scanning electron microscopy (SEM), energy-dispersive spectroscopy (EDS) mapping, and X-ray diffraction (XRD) are used to further characterize the laser-polished surface. SEM-EDS analysis shows that the segregation is more evident in laser-polished samples, while the XRD results indicate the absence of phase change during the process. This study paves the way to a greater understanding of the effect of macro-laser polishing on LDED-built SS 304L structures.

In situ observation of melt pool evolution in ultrasonic vibration-assisted directed energy deposition

The presence of defects, such as pores, in materials processed using additive manufacturing represents a challenge during the manufacturing of many engineering components. Recently, ultrasonic vibration-assisted (UV-A) directed energy deposition (DED) has been shown to reduce porosity, promote grain refinement, and enhance mechanical performance in metal components. Whereas it is evident that the formation of such microstructural features is affected by the melt pool behavior, the specific mechanisms by which ultrasonic vibration (UV) influences the melt pool remain elusive. In the present investigation, UV was applied in situ to DED of 316L stainless steel single tracks and bulk parts. For the first time, high-speed video imaging and thermal imaging were implemented in situ to quantitatively correlate the application of UV to melt pool evolution in DED. Extensive imaging data were coupled with in-depth microstructural characterization to develop a statistically robust dataset describing the observed phenomena. Our findings show that UV increases the melt pool peak temperature and dimensions, while improving the wettability of injected particles with the melt pool surface and reducing particle residence time. Near the substrate, we observe that UV results in a 92% decrease in porosity, and a 54% decrease in dendritic arm spacing. The effect of UV on the melt pool is caused by the combined mechanisms of acoustic cavitation, ultrasound absorption, and acoustic streaming. Through in situ imaging we demonstrate quantitatively that these phenomena, acting simultaneously, effectively diminish with increasing build height and size due to acoustic attenuation, consequently decreasing the positive effect of implementing UV-A DED. Thus, this research provides valuable insight into the value of in situ imaging, as well as the effects of UV on DED melt pool dynamics, the stochastic interactions between the melt pool and incoming powder particles, and the limitations of build geometry on the UV-A DED technique.

Ultrasonic effects with different vibration positions on gas tungsten arc wire additive manufactured aluminum nanocomposite

Ultrasonically assisted gas tungsten arc based wire additive manufacturing (UA-GTAAM) of TiB2 nanoparticle-reinforced AA7075 aluminum metal matrix nanocomposite (MMNC) was conducted with the UA probe directly immersed in the molten pool. This work focuses on the UA effects with different probe positions on the UA-melt interactions and the resulting microstructure. In situ high-speed imaging reveals melt pool surface ripples induced by UA. More refined surface ripples, corresponding to a faster melt flow, are observed with the UA probe immersed deeper into the melt. This condition also leads to a lighter etched color under optical microscope, which is related to a more homogeneous microstructure with less eutectic phase at grain boundaries. Electron backscatter diffraction (EBSD) analysis was employed for grain orientation and nanoparticle distributions, where the lower Confidence Index (CI) served as an indicator for intragranular nanoparticle segregation. The EBSD results show a strong (110) texture in the conventional WAAM builds. High-resolution backscattered electron (BSE) imaging reveals nanoparticles tend to segregate into preferred (001) and (111) grains. UA suppresses the epitaxial growth of (110) grains and promotes a more randomly orientated microstructure. Accordingly, more (001) and (111) grains are available to accommodate nanoparticles and promote a more homogeneous dispersion.

Towards an Understanding of the Challenges in Laser Beam Welding of Copper – Observation of the Laser-Matter Interaction Zone in Laser Beam Welding of Copper and Steel Using in Situ Synchrotron X-Ray Imaging

The increasing demand for contacting applications in electric components such as batteries, power electronics and electric drives is boosting the use of laser-based copper processing. Laser beam welding is a key for an efficient and high-quality electric vehicle production due to its local, non-contact energy input and high automation capability enabling reproducible weld quality. Nevertheless, a major challenge in process design is the combination of energy-efficiency and precise process guidance with regard to weld seam depth and defect prevention (i.e. spatter, melt ejections), partly caused by the high thermal conductivity of copper. High power lasers in the near infrared range and emerging visible laser beam sources with excellent beam quality can provide a suitable joining solution for this purpose. However, the underlying physical phenomena are currently only partly understood and a reflection on the challenges of laser beam welding of copper compared to well researched steel processing has not yet been carried out. In order to improve the understanding of the effect of the different material properties and the influence of process parameters on the vapor capillary and melt pool geometry in laser beam welding, in situ synchrotron investigations on Cu-ETP and S235 using 515 and 1030 nm laser sources were conducted. The material phase contrast analysis was successfully used to distinguish vapor capillary and melt pool phase boundaries during the welding process with high spatial and temporal resolution up to 5 kHz. A significantly different vapor capillary geometry and sensitivity to parameter variation were found between the steel and copper material. In addition, the visualization of characteristic melt flows revealed different melt pool dynamics and a pronounced eddy close to the melt pool surface for copper, which is assumed to be causal for the observation of pronounced spatter formation during copper welding in a certain process window.

Laser butt welding of thin stainless steel 316L sheets in asymmetric configurations: A numerical study

Laser butt welding of thin metal sheets is a widely used fusion-based joining technique in industrial manufacturing. A comprehensive understanding of the complex transport phenomena during the welding process is essential for achieving high-quality welds. In the present work, high-fidelity numerical simulations are employed to investigate the influence of various symmetric and asymmetric welding configurations on the melt-pool behaviour in conduction-mode laser butt welding of stainless steel sheets. The analysis focuses on the effects of laser power density, heat source misplacement and different welding scenarios, including plates with a root gap, high-low mismatches, and dissimilar thicknesses, on the molten metal flow and heat transfer. The results show that advection is the dominant mechanism for energy transfer in the melt pool, and its contribution increases with higher laser power. The non-uniform temperature distribution over the melt-pool surface induces Marangoni shear forces, driving the flow of molten metal and leading to the formation of vortices and periodic flow oscillations within the pool. The effects of various types of asymmetries on the thermal and molten metal flow fields, as well as the process stability, are thoroughly examined and compared with symmetrical welding configurations. These comprehensive simulations provide valuable insights into the fluid flow dynamics and thermal field evolution during laser butt welding of thin metal sheets. The knowledge gained from this study can facilitate process optimisation and guide the improvement of weld quality in practical applications.

Pore formation driven by particle impact in laser powder-blown directed energy deposition.

Process defects currently limit the use of metal additive manufacturing (AM) components in industries due to shorter fatigue life, potential for catastrophic failure, and lower strength. Conditions under which these defects form, and their mechanisms, are starting to be analyzed to improve reliability and structural integrity of these highly customized parts. We use in situ, high-speed X-ray imaging in conjunction with a high throughput laser, powder-blown directed energy deposition setup to observe powder particle impact behavior within the melt pool. Through fundamental observations of the stochastic, violent powder delivery in powder-blown DED, we uncover a unique pore formation mechanism. We find that a pore can form due to air-cushioning, where vapor from the carrier gas or environment is entrapped between the solid powder particle surface and liquid melt pool surface. A critical time constant is established for the mechanism, and X-ray computed tomography is used to further analyze and categorize the new type of "air-cushioning" pores. It is shown that the air-cushioning mechanism can occur under multiple laser processing conditions, and we show that air-cushioning pores are more likely to be formed when powder particles are larger than 70 m. By quantifying the effect of powder particle impact, we identify new avenues for development of high-quality laser, powder-blown DED products. Furthermore, we deepen knowledge on defect formation in metal additive manufacturing, which is being increasingly utilized in high performance situations such as aerospace, automotive, and biomedical industries.

Powder catchment efficiency in laser cladding (directed energy deposition). An investigation into standard laser cladding and the ABA cladding technique

This paper investigates the efficiency of powder catchment in blown powder laser cladding (a directed energy deposition technique). A comparison is made between standard “track by overlapping track” cladding (“AAA” cladding) and “ABA” cladding, where the gaps left between an initial set of widely spaced tracks (“A” tracks), are filled in by subsequent “B” tracks. In both these techniques, the melt pool surface is the collection area for the cladding powder, and the shape of this pool can be affected by several parameters including cladding speed, intertrack spacing, and type of cladding technique. The results presented here are derived from of an analysis of high-speed videos taken during processing and cross sections of the resultant clad tracks. The results show that the first track in AAA cladding has a different melt pool shape to subsequent tracks, and that the asymmetry of the subsequent track melt pools results in a reduction in the powder catchment efficiency. In contrast to this, the geometry of the “B” track melt pools between their adjacent “A” tracks results in an enhanced powder catchment efficiency.

Detecting missing struts in metallic micro-lattices using high speed melt pool thermal monitoring

Metal lattices are an important class of cellular materials that offer great advantages by providing high-strength and lightweight structures as compared to bulk materials. Progress in additive manufacturing techniques has led to increased complexity in design and shape of produced objects and is greatly beneficial for the development of metallic lattice structures. However additive manufacturing of lattices suffers from unpredictable defect creation that can compromise mechanical integrity of lattice structure. Although post-build inspection techniques can provide quality assurance of the process, accurate assessment can be technically challenging, time consuming and costly. In this work, we investigate the use of high-speed measurements of thermal emission from the melt pool to identify defective individual struts formed with a missing bottom half in an otherwise fully built lattice structure produced with laser powder bed fusion. Surprisingly, results indicate lower photodiode signal, suggesting colder melt pool surface temperature, when printing struts with missing bottom half as compared to nominal struts. Additional thermographic imaging and multi-physics simulations reveal that the low photodiode signal is accompanied by presence of hot spatters carrying heat away from detection and continuous avalanche of powder on the melt pool. Based on these observations, a method was developed to identify defective individual struts with missing bottom half in full built lattices. This prediction approach provides valuable insights about part quality which are important for process qualification and illustrates the utility of melt pool thermal emission monitoring for identifying specific defects introduced by laser powder bed fusion.

Experimental study on water injection and stratified steam explosion at the top of metal molten pool

Metal layer induced heat flux focusing effect of In-Vessel melt Retention (IVR) strategy has become important weakness for high power core (APR1400, CAP1400). Injecting water on top of the metal layer can take heat away from the top and relief from heat flux focusing effect, but there can be stratified steam explosion and hydrogen risk. In this study, SUS321 steel melt pool (∼1600℃) top flooding experiments have been conducted, under diverse injecting modes, for exploring coolability and steam explosion risk. The tests results showed that the water jet, whose injecting velocity was 10 m/s, could be able to pierce the steel free surface and trigger steam explosion, and concurrently, the larger injecting flux was, the more violent steam explosion became. But steel melt pool was cooled quietly under water droplets injecting mode. The light refractory oxide layer, floating at the steel melt pool surface, could build a barrier to separate the injecting water.

Numerical Simulation in the Melt Pool Evolution of Laser Powder Bed Fusion Process for Ti6Al4V.

In order to track the free interface of the melt pool and understand the evolution of the melt pool, the flow of fluid, and the interface behavior of gas and liquid, a physical model is developed by using the VOF method in this paper. Its characteristics are a combined heat source model, including a parabolic rotation and a cylindrical distribution, and a powder bed stochastic distributed model with powder particle size. The unit interface between the metallic and gas phase in the laser-powder interaction zone can only be loaded by the heat source. Only the first and second laser scanning tracks are simulated to reduce the calculation time. The simulation results show that process parameters such as laser power and scanning speed have significant effects on the fluid flow and surface morphology in the melt pool, which are in good agreement with the experimental results. Compared with the first track, the second track has larger melt pool geometry, higher melt temperature, and faster fluid flow. The melt flows intensely at the initial position due to the high flow rate in the limited melt space. Because there is enough space for the metal flow, the second track can obtain smooth surface morphology more easily compared to the first track. The melt pool temperature at the laser beam center fluctuates during the laser scanning process. This depends on the effects of the interaction between heat conduction or heat accumulation or the interaction between heat accumulation and violent fluid flow. The temperature distribution and fluid flow in the melt pool benefit the analysis and understanding of the evolution mechanism of the melt pool geometry and surface topography and further allow regulation of the L-PBF process of Ti6Al4V.