Background: Tibialis posterior tendon (TPT) dysfunction is a common disorder that affects both men and women. Stage I dysfunction is characterised by pain and swelling around the medial malleolus, along with mild weakness of the single heel raise test. Initial management consists of non-operative measures such as physiotherapy, anti-inflammatory drugs and medial arch supports. Surgery is rarely required as most cases settle with non-operative measures. Surgical decompression of the TPT should be performed if non-operative measures fail to relieve pain. Objective: The aim of this study was to assess the outcome of surgical decompression for stage I TPT dysfunction. Method: We prospectively studied 10 consecutive patients who underwent surgical decompression for stage I TPT dysfunction. Results: Our results demonstrate that surgical decompression reduces pain and permits an early return to normal activities. Conclusion: Surgical decompression should be performed for stage I TPT dysfunction if non-operative measures have failed to provide symptomatic relief.