Mechanically Controllable Break Junction Research Articles

Quantum Interference Effects in Charge Transport through Single-Molecule Junctions: Detection, Manipulation, and Application.

Quantum interference effects (QIEs), which offer unique opportunities for the fine-tuning of charge transport through molecular building blocks by constructive or destructive quantum interference, have become an emerging area in single-molecule electronics. Benefiting from the QIEs, charge transport through molecular systems can be controlled through minor structural and environmental variations, which cause various charge transport states to be significantly changed from conductive to insulative states and offer promising applications in future functional single-molecule devices. Although QIEs were predicted by theoreticians more than two decades ago, only since 2011 have the challenges in ultralow conductance detection originating from destructive quantum interference been overcome experimentally. Currently, a series of single-molecule conductance investigations have been carried out experimentally to detect constructive and destructive QIEs in charge transport through various types of molecular junctions by altering molecular patterns and connectivities. Furthermore, the use of QIEs to tune the properties of charge transport through single-molecule junctions using external gating shows vital potential in future molecular electronic devices. The experimental and theoretical investigations of QIEs offer new fundamental understanding of the structural-electronic relationships in molecular devices and materials at the nanoscale. In this Account, we discuss our progress toward the experimental detection, manipulation, and further application of QIEs in charge transport through single-molecule junctions. These experiments were carried out continuously in our previous group at the University of Bern and in our lab at Xiamen University. As a result of the development of mechanically controllable break junction (MCBJ) and scanning tunneling microscope break junction (STM-BJ) techniques, we could detect ultralow charge transport through the cross-conjugated anthraquinone center, which was one of the earliest experimental studies of QIEs. In close cooperation with organic chemists and theoretical physicists, we systematically investigated charge transport through single-molecule junctions originating from QIEs in conjugated centers ranging from simple single benzene to polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons (PAHs), heteroaromatics, and even complicated metalla-aromatics at room temperature. Then we further investigated the quantitative correlation between molecular structure and quantum interference by altering different molecular patterns and connectivities in homologous series of PAHs and heteroatom systems. Additionally, external chemical and electrochemical gating of single-molecule devices can be used for direct QIE manipulation via not only tuning molecular conjugation but also shifting the electrode Fermi level. Our study further suggested that distinguishable differences in conductance resulting from QIEs offer opportunities to detect photothermal reaction kinetics and to recognize isomers at the single-molecule scale. These investigations demonstrate the universality of QIEs in charge transport through various molecular building blocks. Moreover, effective manipulation of QIEs leads to various novel phenomena and promising applications in molecular electronic devices.

Mechanically controlled quantum interference in graphene break junctions.

The ability to detect and distinguish quantum interference signatures is important for both fundamental research and for the realization of devices such as electron resonators1, interferometers2 and interference-based spin filters3. Consistent with the principles of subwavelength optics, the wave nature of electrons can give rise to various types of interference effects4, such as Fabry-Pérot resonances5, Fano resonances6 and the Aharonov-Bohm effect7. Quantum interference conductance oscillations8 have, indeed, been predicted for multiwall carbon nanotube shuttles and telescopes, and arise from atomic-scale displacements between the inner and outer tubes9,10. Previous theoretical work on graphene bilayers indicates that these systems may display similar interference features as a function of the relative position of the two sheets11,12. Experimental verification is, however, still lacking. Graphene nanoconstrictions represent an ideal model system to study quantum transport phenomena13-15 due to the electronic coherence16 and the transverse confinement of the carriers17. Here, we demonstrate the fabrication of bowtie-shaped nanoconstrictions with mechanically controlled break junctions made from a single layer of graphene. Their electrical conductance displays pronounced oscillations at room temperature, with amplitudes that modulate over an order of magnitude as a function of subnanometre displacements. Surprisingly, the oscillations exhibit a period larger than the graphene lattice constant. Charge-transport calculations show that the periodicity originates from a combination of the quantum interference and lattice commensuration effects of two graphene layers that slide across each other. Our results provide direct experimental observation of a Fabry-Pérot-like interference of electron waves that are partially reflected and/or transmitted at the edges of the graphene bilayer overlap region.

Mechanical Tuning of Through‐Molecule Conductance in a Conjugated Calix[4]pyrrole

AbstractA conformationally flexible calix[4]pyrrole possessing a conjugated electronic structure (an N‐substituted oxoporphyrinogen (OxP) related to porphyrin) was used to investigate the influence of mechanical stretching on the single‐molecule conductance of these molecules using the mechanically‐controlled break junction (MCBJ) technique. The results show that the molecule can be immobilized in a single‐molecule break junction configuration, giving rise to different behaviours. These include step‐like features in the conductance vs. displacement traces as well as conductance traces that exhibit a slower decay (‘downhill’ traces) than measured for direct tunneling. The latter class of traces can be associated with the mechanical manipulation (i. e., stretching) of the molecule with inter‐electrode distances as long as 2 nm. Density functional theory (DFT) calculations reveal that OxP molecules are stable under stretching in the length regime studied.

Impurity effects of hydrogen and deuterium in vanadium nanoconstrictions

To study non-magnetic and magnetic impurity effects at the superconductor-normal metal interfaces, we have measured the differential conductance dI/dV for Josephson contacts made by vanadium (V) nanoconstrictions with a different amount of hydrogen (H) and deuterium (D) impurities, which are prepared by a mechanically controllable break junction (MCBJ) technique at low temperature. Below the superconducting transition temperature TC, we have found distinct peaks within and outside the gap, known as the sub-gap structure and an over-the-gap structure respectively, due to 5% concentration of atomic H and D on V nanocontact. Moreover, the temperature dependence of dI/dV spectra represents that both structures are survived until the critical temperature TC, which is consistent with the prediction of BCS energy gap. On the other hand, a very high concentrating phase (30atom%) behaves as a normal metal.

Electric-field induced bistability in single-molecule conductance measurements for boron coordinated curcuminoid compounds.

We have studied the single-molecule conductance of a family of curcuminoid molecules (CCMs) using the mechanically controlled break junction (MCBJ) technique. The CCMs under study contain methylthio (MeS-) as anchoring groups: MeS-CCM (1), the free-ligand organic molecule, and two coordination compounds, MeS-CCM-BF2 (2) and MeS-CCM-Cu (3), where ligand 1 coordinates to a boron center (BF2 group) and to a CuII moiety, respectively. We found that the three molecules present stable molecular junctions allowing detailed statistical analysis of their electronic properties. Compound 3 shows a slight increase in the conductance with respect to free ligand 1, whereas incorporation of BF2 (compound 2) promotes the presence of two conductance states in the measurements. Additional experiments with control molecules point out that this bistability is related to the combination of MeS- anchoring groups and the BF2 moiety within the structure of the molecules. Theoretical calculations show that this can be explained by the presence of two conformers once compound 2 is anchored between the gold electrodes. An energy minimum is found for a flat structure but there is a dramatic change in the magnitude and orientation of dipole moment (favouring a non-flat conformer in the presence of an external electric field) due to a conformational change of one of the terminal MeS- groups. The results thus point to an intricate interplay between the applied bias voltage and the molecule dipole moment which could be the basis for designing new molecules aiming at controlling their conformation in devices.

Macro-mechanics controls quantum mechanics: mechanically controllable quantum conductance switching of an electrochemically fabricated atomic-scale point contact

Here, we present a silver atomic-scale device fabricated and operated by a combined technique of electrochemical control (EC) and mechanically controllable break junction (MCBJ). With this EC-MCBJ technique, we can perform mechanically controllable bistable quantum conductance switching of a silver quantum point contact (QPC) in an electrochemical environment at room temperature. Furthermore, the silver QPC of the device can be controlled both mechanically and electrochemically, and the operating mode can be changed from ‘electrochemical’ to ‘mechanical’, which expands the operating mode for controlling QPCs. These experimental results offer the perspective that a silver QPC may be used as a contact for a nanoelectromechanical relay.

On-Chip Break Junctions and Period-Adjustable Grating Driven by Thermal Stress

The investigation of the electron transport through single molecule needs an efficient method to generate stable molecular junctions. There are various techniques, such as mechanically controllable break junction (MCBJ) technique and electromigration technique, to generate stable nanogaps and stable molecular junctions. However, it is a great challenge for MCBJ technique to obtain on-chip molecular junctions because of the constraint of the push rod components, which do not make it facile to fabricate highly integrated molecular devices. Meanwhile, the gap size between electrodes is nonadjustable for the electromigration method, which leads to a low yield of molecular junctions. In this report, a thermally controllable break junction method, which can overcome the above problem, is proposed for the first time. The device is based on a double-V-shaped symmetrical structure and mechanically driven by thermal expansion, thus the push rod is not needed. Furthermore, we proposed that the thermally controlled double-V-shaped structure can be employed to precisely adjust the period of the metal grating with nanometer accuracy, which is unavailable in other methods.

Quantum interference effect in the charge transport through single-molecule benzene dithiol junction at room temperature: An experimental investigation

The quantum interference effect in the charge transport through single-phenyl molecules received intensive interests from theory but remained as an experimental challenge. In this paper, we investigated the charge transport through single-molecule benzene dithiol (BDT) junction with different connectivities using mechanically controllable break junction (MCBJ) technique. By further improving the mechanical stability and the electronic measuring component of the MCBJ set-up, we obtained the conductance histograms of BDT molecules (BDTs) from the statistical analysis of conductance-distance traces without data selection. By tuning the connectivity, the conductance of BDTs is determined to be 10−1.2G0, 10−2.2G0 and 10−1.0G0 for para, meta, and ortho connectivity, following the trend that ortho-BDT>para-BDT>meta-BDT. Furthermore, the displacements of the junctions followed the trend that para>meta>ortho, suggesting the charge transport through the molecules via the gold-thiol bond. The different trends between conductance and displacement for different connectivities suggests the presence of destructive quantum interference effect on meta-BDT, which provides the experimental evidence for the quantum interference effect through single-phenyl molecular junctions.

Advance of Mechanically Controllable Break Junction for Molecular Electronics.

Molecular electronics stands for the ultimate size of functional elements, keeping up with an unstoppable trend over the past few decades. As a vital component of molecular electronics, single molecular junctions have attracted significant attention from research groups all over the world. Due to its pronounced superiority, the mechanically controllable break junctions (MCBJ) technique has been widely applied to characterize the dynamic performance of single molecular junctions. This review presents a system analysis for single-molecule junctions and offers an overview of four test-beds for single-molecule junctions, thus offering more insight into the mechanisms of electron transport. We mainly focus on the development of state-of-the-art mechanically controlled break junctions. The three-terminal gated MCBJ approaches are introduced to manipulate the electron transport of molecules, and MCBJs are combined with characterization techniques. Additionally, applications of MCBJs and remarkable properties of single molecules are addressed. Finally, the challenges and perspective for the mechanically controllable break junctions technique are provided.

Electronic transport in gadolinium atomic-size contacts

We report on the fabrication, transport measurements, and density functional theory (DFT) calculations of atomic size contacts made out of gadolinium (Gd). Gd is known to have local moments mainly associated with $f$ electrons. These coexist with itinerant $s$ and $d$ bands that account for its metallic character. Here we explore whether and how the local moments influence electronic transport properties at the atomic scale. Using both Scanning Tunneling Microscope (STM) and lithographic Mechanically Controllable Break Junction (MCBJ) techniques under cryogenic conditions, we study the conductance of Gd when only few atoms form the junction between bulk electrodes made out of the very same material. Thousands of measurements shows that Gd has an average lowest conductance, attributed to an atom-size contact, below $\frac{2e^2}{h}$. Our DFT calculations for monostrand chains anticipate that the $f$ bands are fully spin polarized and insulating, and that the conduction may be dominated by $s$, $p$, and $d$ bands. DFT quantum transport calculations quantitatively reproduce the experimental results for zero bias and reveal that, while $s-p$ bands are dominant for transport, $d$ orbitals seem to have a relevant contribution in some cases.

Kondo-Fano resonance in atomic-scale contacts for ferromagnetic metals

The electrical conductance of cobalt (Co) nano-scale contacts prepared by a Mechanically Controllable Break Junction (MCBJ) technique has been studied to understand the origin of Fano resonance in ferromagnetic atomic-sized contacts. In an atomic-scale contacts, the zero-bias anomaly is well-fitted by the Fano formula. The characteristic temperature, which is introduced as the fitting parameter of that formula, exhibits the log-normal distribution. These indicate that the anomaly is likely caused by Kondo effect. Moreover, the zero-bias anomaly is observed in large scale contacts where the bulk ferromagnetic properties should be retained. This suggests the coexistence of Kondo effect and ferromagnetism.

Fast and low-noise tunnelling current measurements for single-molecule detection in an electrolyte solution using insulator-protected nanoelectrodes.

Reliable ways of DNA sequencing by tunnelling current require low-noise and high-speed measurements of tunnelling current in aqueous environments. Here we report a use of insulator-protected nanoprobes for achieving 7.6 pA rms noise at 50 kHz sampling rates in an electrolyte solution. We utilized dielectric-covered mechanically-controllable break junctions to create a pair of nano-exposed insulator/Au coaxial electrodes closely separated by 1 nm. We observed insulator layer thickness dependent noise levels, which was attributed to decreased capacitance through replacing capacitive electric double layers by the low-k dielectrics. We also demonstrated the detection of sharpened features in tunnelling current signatures that reflect dynamic motions of single-nucleotides in the electrode gaps by virtue of suppressed smearing effects in the low-capacitance nanoelectrode system.

Insulator-protected mechanically controlled break junctions for measuring single-molecule conductance in aqueous environments

We present a method to fabricate insulated gold mechanically controlled break junctions (MCBJ) by coating the metal with a thin layer of aluminum oxide using plasma enhanced atomic layer deposition. The Al2O3 thickness deposited on the MCBJ devices was varied from 2 to 15 nm to test the suppression of leakage currents in deionized water and phosphate buffered saline. Junctions coated with a 15 nm thick oxide layer yielded atomically sharp electrodes and negligible conductance counts in the range of 1 to 10−4 G0 (1 G0 = 77 μS), where single-molecule conductances are commonly observed. The insulated devices were used to measure the conductance of an amphiphilic oligophenylene ethynylene derivative in deionized water.

C-Au Covalently Bonded Molecular Junctions Using Nonprotected Alkynyl Anchoring Groups.

We report on an approach to realize carbon-gold (C-Au) bonded molecular junctions without the need for an additive to deprotect the alkynyl carbon as endstanding anchor group. Using the mechanically controlled break junction (MCBJ) technique, we determine the most probable conductance value of a family of alkynyl terminated oligophenylenes (OPA(n)) connected to gold electrodes through such an akynyl moiety in ambient conditions. The molecules bind to the gold leads through an sp-hybridized carbon atom at each side. Comparing our results with other families of molecules that present organometallic C-Au bonds, we conclude that the conductance of molecules contacted via an sp-hybridized carbon atom is lower than the ones using sp(3) hybridization due to strong differences in the coupling of the conducting orbitals with the gold leads.

Determination of the number of atoms present in nano contact based on shot noise measurements with highly stable nano-fabricated electrodes

A highly stable experimental setup was developed for the measurement of shot noise in atomic contacts and molecular junctions to determine the number of atoms or molecules present. The use of a nano-fabricated mechanically controllable break junction (MCBJ) electrode improved the overall stability of the experimental setup. The improved stability of the system and optimization of measurement system enabled us to comprehensively investigate the shot noise as well as charge transport properties in Au atomic contacts and molecular junctions. We present a solid proof that the number of atoms (cross sectional atom) in the Au atomic contacts was exactly one. In the atomic contacts, contribution from the additional channels was under the detection limit. Furthermore, the effect of molecular adsorption on the charge transport in the Au atomic contact was investigated. Additional transport channels were opened by exposing pyrazine molecules to the Au contacts, which gave rise to an increase in the Fano factor in the shot noise.

Thermo-voltage measurements of atomic contacts at low temperature.

We report the development of a novel method to determine the thermopower of atomic-sized gold contacts at low temperature. For these measurements a mechanically controllable break junction (MCBJ) system is used and a laser source generates a temperature difference of a few kelvins across the junction to create a thermo-voltage. Since the temperature difference enters directly into the Seebeck coefficient S = −ΔV/ΔT, the determination of the temperature plays an important role. We present a method for the determination of the temperature difference using a combination of a finite element simulation, which reveals the temperature distribution of the sample, and the measurement of the resistance change due to laser heating of sensor leads on both sides next to the junction. Our results for the measured thermopower are in agreement with recent reports in the literature.

Shot Noise of 1,4-Benzenedithiol Single-Molecule Junctions.

We report measurements of the shot noise on single-molecule Au-1,4-benzenedithiol-Au junctions, fabricated with the mechanically controllable break junction (MCBJ) technique at 4.2 K in a wide range of conductance values from 10(-2) to 0.24 conductance quanta. We introduce a simple measurement scheme using a current amplifier and a spectrum analyzer and that does not imply special requirements regarding the electrical leads. The experimental findings provide evidence that the current is carried by a single conduction channel throughout the whole conductance range. This observation suggests that the number of channels is limited by the Au-thiol bonds and that contributions due to direct tunneling from the Au to the π-system of the aromatic ring are negligible also for high conductance. The results are supported by quantum transport calculations using density functional theory.

Electrical properties and mechanical stability of anchoring groups for single-molecule electronics.

We report on an experimental investigation of transport through single molecules, trapped between two gold nano-electrodes fabricated with the mechanically controlled break junction (MCBJ) technique. The four molecules studied share the same core structure, namely oligo(phenylene ethynylene) (OPE3), while having different aurophilic anchoring groups: thiol (SAc), methyl sulfide (SMe), pyridyl (Py) and amine (NH2). The focus of this paper is on the combined characterization of the electrical and mechanical properties determined by the anchoring groups. From conductance histograms we find that thiol anchored molecules provide the highest conductance; a single-level model fit to current–voltage characteristics suggests that SAc groups exhibit a higher electronic coupling to the electrodes, together with better level alignment than the other three groups. An analysis of the mechanical stability, recording the lifetime in a self-breaking method, shows that Py and SAc yield the most stable junctions while SMe form short-lived junctions. Density functional theory combined with non-equlibrium Green’s function calculations help in elucidating the experimental findings.

Electrochemical Gating of Charge Transport in Single Macrocycle Molecular Switches

Molecular switches, i.e., molecular scale devices that can be turned on and off, are of long standing interest. In the quest for miniaturization of electronic devices, the development of electrical switches of molecular dimensions has been identified as an important target of practical importance. While much progress has been made in designing functional molecular scale electrical switches, i.e., molecular cores whose intrinsic conductivity can be externally modulated, the question of contact resistance has not been sufficiently addressed. Our novel strategy for the regulation of charge transport through single molecule junctions combines external stimuli using a variation of electrode potential in an electrochemical environment, internal modulation of molecular structures and optimization of anchoring groups. Our synthetic collaborators have designed redox-active benzodifuran (BDF) compounds as functional electronic units which we have used to fabricate metal-molecule-metal (m-M-m) junction devices by scanning tunneling microscopy (STM) and mechanically controllable break junctions (MCBJ).[1] The conductance of BDF terminated thiol, the standard anchoring group for molecular scale electronic components, can be tuned by changing the electrode potentials in an ionic liquid electrolyte to show a clear single molecule field effect transistor (FET) behavior. We hypothesized that we could optimize the response by appropriate choice of molecular anchoring group.[2] Guided by our earlier investigations, a BDF molecule tailored with carbodithioate (-CS2-) anchoring groups was synthesized. Our studies show that replacement of thiol by carbodithioate not only increases the junction conductance, but also substantially improves the FET response by enhancing the on/off ratio from 2.5 to 8. [1] Regulating a Benzodifuran Single Molecule Redox Switch via Electrochemical Gating and Optimization of Molecule/Electrode Coupling, Zhihai Li, Hui Li, Songjie Chen, Toni Froehlich, Christian Schönenberger, Michel Calame, Silvio Decurtins, Shi-Xia Liu and Eric Borguet, Journal of the American Chemical Society 136, 25 8867-8870 (2014). [2] Optimizing Single-Molecule Conductivity of Conjugated Organic Oligomers with Conjugated Carbodithioate Linkers, Yangjun Xing, Tae-Hong Park, Ravindra Venkatramani, Shahar Keinan, David N. Beratan, Michael J. Therien, and Eric Borguet, Journal of the American Chemical Society 132 (23), 7946-7956 (2010). Figure 1

Charge transport in C60-based dumbbell-type molecules: mechanically induced switching between two distinct conductance states.

Single molecule charge transport characteristics of buckminsterfullerene-capped symmetric fluorene-based dumbbell-type compound 1 were investigated by scanning tunneling microscopy break junction (STM-BJ), current sensing atomic force microscopy break junction (CS-AFM-BJ), and mechanically controlled break junction (MCBJ) techniques, under ambient conditions. We also show that compound 1 is able to form highly organized defect-free surface adlayers, allowing the molecules on the surface to be addressed specifically. Two distinct single molecule conductance states (called high G(H)(1) and low G(L)(1)) were observed, depending on the pressure exerted by the probe on the junction, thus allowing molecule 1 to function as a mechanically driven molecular switch. These two distinct conductance states were attributed to the electron tunneling through the buckminsterfullerene anchoring group and fully extended molecule 1, respectively. The assignment of conductance features to these configurations was further confirmed by control experiments with asymmetrically designed buckminsterfullerene derivative 2 as well as pristine buckminsterfullerene 3, both lacking the G(L) feature.