Measurement Of Residual Dipolar Couplings Research Articles

An Analysis of the Effects of 1HN−1HN Dipolar Couplings on the Measurement of Amide Bond Vector Orientations in Invisible Protein States by Relaxation Dispersion NMR

Marginally and transiently populated conformational states of biomolecules can play important functional roles in biochemical processes. It is of significant interest, therefore, to develop tools for characterizing the structural and dynamical properties of these excited states. One recent development has been the emergence of spin-state-selective relaxation dispersion methods for quantifying dipolar vector orientations in invisible excited-state conformers through measurement of residual dipolar couplings (RDCs). Particularly powerful are 1HN-(15)N RDCs that can be measured with high sensitivity on fractionally aligned, deuterated, uniformly 15N-labeled protein samples. Fractional alignment also produces nonzero 1HN-(1)HN dipolar couplings. These can be problematic for the extraction of robust 1HN-(15)N RDC values, and hence amide bond vector orientations, in cases where the amide proton of interest and a proximal amide proton have small chemical shift differences and a significant 1HN-(1)HN dipolar coupling. Here, we show that while this strong coupling effect leads to aberrant relaxation dispersion profiles, extracted excited-state 1HN-(15)N RDCs are for the most part only marginally affected. Experimental examples of such aberrant profiles are provided, as well as a theoretical consideration of the influence of this strong coupling effect and numerical simulations that assess its impact on extracted parameters.

Using multiple quantum coherence to increase the 15N resolution in a three-dimensional TROSY HNCO experiment for accurate PRE and RDC measurements

We present a new version of the 3D TROSY HNCO pulse scheme, referred to as HR-TROSY HNCO, with comparable resolution in the 15N dimension to a 2D 1H– 15N HSQC experiment. In the conventional 3D TROSY HNCO, the constant time period (1/2 J NC ∼ 32 ms) severely limits the maximum resolution in the 15N dimension. In the HR-TROSY HNCO experiment presented here, both constant time periods (∼32 ms each) for coherence forward and backward transfer between 15N and 13C′ are utilized to double the 15N evolution time. This leads to a dramatic enhancement in peak separation along the 15N dimension, making the HR-TROSY HNCO an ideal pulse scheme for accurate paramagnetic relaxation enhancement and residual dipolar coupling measurements.

Simultaneous measurement of residual dipolar couplings for proteins in complex using the isotopically discriminated NMR approach

One-bond residual dipolar couplings (RDCs) measured for the amide groups of proteins partially aligned in a magnetic field provide valuable information regarding the relative orientation of protein units. In order for RDCs obtained for individual proteins to be useful in the structure determination of heterodimer complexes, they should be measured for exactly the same alignment of the complex. Here, an isotopically discriminated IDIS-RDC-TROSY NMR experiment is proposed, which enables the measurement of HN RDCs for two proteins simultaneously and independently, but in the same sample, while they are part of the same complex. The signals for both proteins, one of which should be labeled with (15)N and the other with (15)N and (13)C, are observed in different subspectra, thus reducing spectral overlap. The approach uniquely ensures that RDCs measured for both proteins relate to exactly the same alignment tensor, allowing accurate measurement of the relative angle between the two proteins. The method is also applicable for complexes containing three or more protein components. The experiment can speed up and lead to automation of protein-protein docking on the basis of angular restraints.

Probing Mutation‐Induced Structural Perturbations by Refinement Against Residual Dipolar Couplings: Application to the U4 Spliceosomal RNP Complex

Confident interpretation of biochemical experiments performed with mutated proteins relies on verification of the integrity of the mutant structures. We present a simple and rapid refinement protocol for comparing the structures of mutated and wild-type proteins. Our approach involves measurement of residual dipolar couplings, and only requires assignment of the backbone resonances of the mutant species. We demonstrate application of the protocol to a mutant of the 15.5K protein, a core component of the U4 spliceosomal ribonucleoprotein (RNP) complex. Confirmation of the unperturbed structure of the mutated protein prompted re-examination of a previous mutagenesis study and indicated that the interpretation of mutant binding affinities in terms of direct interfacial contacts should be applied with caution.

Creating Conformational Entropy by Increasing Interdomain Mobility in Ligand Binding Regulation: A Revisit to N-Terminal Tandem PDZ Domains of PSD-95

The two N-terminal PDZ domains of postsynaptic density protein-95 (PDS-95 PDZ1 and PDZ2) are closely connected in tandem by a conserved peptide linker of five amino acids. The interdomain orientation between PDZ1 and PDZ2 of the ligand-free PDZ12 tandem is restrained, and this conformational arrangement facilitates the synergistic binding of PDZ12 to multimeric targets. (1) The interdomain orientation of the target-bound state of PDZ12 is not known. Here, we have solved the structure of PDZ12 in complex with its binding domain from cypin. Both chemical shift data and residual dipolar coupling measurements showed that the restrained interdomain orientation disappeared upon cypin peptide binding. NMR-based relaxation experiments revealed slow interdomain motions in the PDZ12/cypin peptide complex. Molecular dynamics simulations also showed that the PDZ12/cypin complex has larger conformational flexibility than the ligand-free PDZ12. This dramatic change of protein dynamics provides extra conformational entropy upon ligand binding, thus enhancing the ligand binding affinity of the PDZ12 tandem. Modulation of ligand binding affinity through concerted interdomain structural and dynamic rearrangements may represent a general property of multidomain scaffold proteins.

A tool for the prediction of structures of complex sugars

In two recent back to back articles(Xia et al., J Chem Theory Comput 3:1620-1628 and 1629-1643, 2007a, b) we have started to address the problem of complex oligosaccharide conformation and folding. The scheme previously presented was based on exhaustive searches in configuration space in conjunction with Nuclear Overhauser Effect (NOE) calculations and the use of a complex rotameric library that takes branching into account. NOEs are extremely useful for structural determination but only provide information about short range interactions and ordering. Instead, the measurement of residual dipolar couplings (RDC), yields information about molecular ordering or folding that is long range in nature. In this article we show the results obtained by incorporation RDC calculations into our prediction scheme. Using this new approach we are able to accurately predict the structure of six human milk sugars: LNF-1, LND-1, LNF-2, LNF-3, LNnT and LNT. Our exhaustive search in dihedral configuration space combined with RDC and NOE calculations allows for highly accurate structural predictions that, because of the non-ergodic nature of these molecules on a time scale compatible with molecular dynamics simulations, are extremely hard to obtain otherwise (Almond et al., Biochemistry 43:5853-5863, 2004). Molecular dynamics simulations in explicit solvent using as initial configurations the structures predicted by our algorithm show that the histo-blood group epitopes in these sugars are relatively rigid and that the whole family of oligosaccharides derives its conformational variability almost exclusively from their common linkage (beta-D: -GlcNAc-(1-->3)-beta-D: -Gal) which can exist in two distinct conformational states. A population analysis based on the conformational variability of this flexible glycosidic link indicates that the relative population of the two distinct states varies for different human milk oligosaccharides.

Residual dipolar coupling measurements of transmembrane proteins using aligned low-q bicelles and high-resolution magic angle spinning NMR spectroscopy.

Bicelles are a major medium form to produce weak alignment of soluble proteins for residual dipolar coupling (RDC) measurements. The obstacle to using the same type of bicelles for transmembrane proteins with solution-state NMR spectroscopy is the loss of signals due to the adhesion or penetration of the proteins into large bicelles, resulting in slow protein tumbling. In this study, weak alignment of the second and third transmembrane domains (TM23) of the human glycine receptor (GlyR) was achieved in low-q bicelles (q = DMPC/DHPC). Although protein-free bicelles with such low q would likely show isotropic properties, the insertion of TM23 induced weakly preferred orientations so that the RDC of the embedded protein can be measured. The extent of the alignment increased but the TM23 signal intensity decreased when q was varied from 0.19 to 0.60. A q of 0.50 was found to be an optimal compromise between alignment and the signal-to-noise ratio. In each pair of NMR experiments for RDC measurements, the same sample and pulse sequence were used, with one being performed at high-resolution magic-angle spinning to obtain pure J-couplings without RDC. A meaningful structure refinement in bicelles was possible by iteratively fitting the experimental RDCs to the back-calculated RDCs using the high-resolution NMR structure of GlyR TM23 in trifluoroethanol as the starting template. Combination of this method with the conventional high-resolution NMR in membrane mimicking mixtures of water and organic solvents offers an attractive way to derive structural information for membrane proteins in their native environment.

Tyr130 phosphorylation triggers Syk release from antigen receptor by long-distance conformational uncoupling.

The Syk protein-tyrosine kinase plays a major role in signaling through the B cell receptor for antigen (BCR). Syk binds the receptor via its tandem pair of SH2 domains interacting with a doubly phosphorylated immunoreceptor tyrosine-based activation motif (dp-ITAM) of the BCR complex. Upon phosphorylation of Tyr-130, which lies between the two SH2 domains distant to the phosphotyrosine binding sites, Syk dissociates from the receptor. To understand the structural basis for this dissociation, we investigated the structural and dynamic characteristics of the wild type tandem SH2 region (tSH2) and a variant tandem SH2 region (tSH2(pm)) with Tyr-130 substituted by Glu to permanently introduce a negative charge at this position. NMR heteronuclear relaxation experiments, residual dipolar coupling measurements and analytical ultracentrifugation revealed substantial differences in the hydrodynamic behavior of tSH2 and tSH2(pm). Although the two SH2 domains in tSH2 are tightly associated, the two domains in tSH2(pm) are partly uncoupled and tumble in solution with a faster correlation time. In addition, the equilibrium dissociation constant for the binding of tSH2(pm) to dp-ITAM (1.8 microM) is significantly higher than that for the interaction between dp-ITAM and tSH2 but is close to that for a singly tyrosine-phosphorylated peptide binding to a single SH2 domain. Experimental data and hydrodynamic calculations both suggest a loss of domain-domain contacts and change in relative orientation upon the introduction of a negative charge on residue 130. A long-distance structural mechanism by which the phosphorylation of Y130 negatively regulates the interaction of Syk with immune receptors is proposed.

Precise Measurement of RDCs in Water and DMSO Based Gels Using a Silicone Rubber Tube for Tunable Stretching

Residual dipolar couplings (RDCs) are of great interest for the structure determination of biomacromolecules as well as of organic molecules like synthetic or natural products. Their accurate measurement requires a proper degree of alignment for the molecule under investigation. As has been shown recently, a stretching device based on a flexible sili- cone rubber tube provides an easy, rapid, and reversible variation of alignment strength. We show in this article that such an apparatus is not limited to gelatin, but can also be used with covalently cross-linked hydrogels and even gels with polar organic solvents like DMSO. Using sucrose and a cyclic hexapeptide, we were able to demonstrate that the approximately linear relation of alignment with the extension factor of the stretched gel allows the measurement of RDCs with high pre- cision if corresponding spectra are acquired at various alignment strengths. The method seems to be widely applicable to the structure determination of molecules of arbitrary size using standard 5 mm NMR equipment. For verification of the alignment properties of the stretch- ing apparatus, we prepared a 40% (w/v) sample of porcine gelatin with an approximate Bloomgrade of 250 dissolved at 50°C in D2O. As a solute molecule for measuring RDCs we added 43 mg of sucrose to a final concentration of approxi- mately 500 mM. Gelatin is a special gel which can be re- casted inside the rubber tube by a simple heating and recool- ing cycle, as it is cross-linked via hydrogen bonds only. In order to test how far the apparatus is applicable to conven- tional polymer gels with covalent cross-linking, we prepared several gel samples using published protocols with gel di- ameters adjusted to accomodate for the dimensions of the stretching apparatus. The results presented in this article were obtained using the following gel preparations: The poly(acrylamide) (PAA) gel was prepared from a solution of 8.55% (w/v) acrylamide and 0.45% (w/v) N,N'- methylenebis(acrylamide) with 0.1% (w/v) ammonium per- sulfate and 0.1% (v/v) N,N,N',N'-tetramethylethylendiamin for cross-linking (5). Radical polymerization was allowed for 1 h within glass tubes of 2.4 mm inner diameter. Gels were washed three times with water to remove free acrylamide before they were dried at room temperature.

Impact of Phosphorylation on Structure and Thermodynamics of the Interaction between the N-terminal Domain of Enzyme I and the Histidine Phosphocarrier Protein of the Bacterial Phosphotransferase System

The structural and thermodynamic impact of phosphorylation on the interaction of the N-terminal domain of enzyme I (EIN) and the histidine phosphocarrier protein (HPr), the two common components of all branches of the bacterial phosphotransferase system, have been examined using NMR spectroscopy and isothermal titration calorimetry. His-189 is located at the interface of the alpha and alphabeta domains of EIN, resulting in rather widespread chemical shift perturbation upon phosphorylation, in contrast to the highly localized perturbations seen for HPr, where His-15 is fully exposed to solvent. Residual dipolar coupling measurements, however, demonstrate unambiguously that no significant changes in backbone conformation of either protein occur upon phosphorylation: for EIN, the relative orientation of the alpha and alphabeta domains remains unchanged; for HPr, the backbone /Psi torsion angles of the active site residues are unperturbed within experimental error. His --> Glu/Asp mutations of the active site histidines designed to mimic the phosphorylated states reveal binding equilibria that favor phosphoryl transfer from EIN to HPr. Although binding of phospho-EIN to phospho-HPr is reduced by a factor of approximately 21 relative to the unphosphorylated complex, residual dipolar coupling measurements reveal that the structures of the unphosphorylated and biphosphorylated complexes are the same. Hence, the phosphorylation states of EIN and HPr shift the binding equilibria predominantly by modulating intermolecular electrostatic interactions without altering either the backbone scaffold or binding interface. This facilitates highly efficient phosphoryl transfer between EIN and HPr, which is estimated to occur at a rate of approximately 850 s(-1) from exchange spectroscopy.

REDOR recoupling in polymer-stabilized liquid crystals undergoing MAS — Two-dimensional NMR applications with strongly aligned proteins

We recently introduced a technique, termed SAD-REDOR, for recoupling residual dipolar couplings in a single-domain polymer-stabilized liquid crystal (PSLC) undergoing magic-angle spinning (MAS). The experiment was demonstrated with 1H–15N dipolar couplings in a small molecule. Here, we show the applicability of the technique to a strongly aligned protein and we describe a novel two-dimensional experiment to generate in-phase and anti-phase (IPAP) doublets in the 1H dimension of an HSQC NMR spectrum. This pulse sequence, SAD-IPAP, was tested on a sample of 15N-labeled ubiquitin (5 mmol/L) in a polyacrylamide-stabilized Pf1 phage liquid crystal (20 mg/mL). 15N–1H residual dipolar couplings (RDCs) were measured with the SAD-IPAP pulse sequence at spinning speeds of 1000 and 1250 Hz. RDSs were also measured using the conventional HSQC-IPAP method in a sample of 15N-ubiquitin dissolved in a solution of Pf1 phage (1 mg/mL). The resulting RDCs were fitted to the solution structure of ubiquitin to estimate the alignment tensor and to determine the accuracy of the measured couplings. The results highlight the benefits of SAD-REDOR for the measurement of RDCs in strongly aligned macromolecules.Key words: residual dipolar couplings (RDCs), polymer-stabilized liquid crystals (PSLCs), rotational echo double resonance (REDOR) recoupling, magic-angle spinning (MAS), ubiquitin, biomolecular nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR), proteins.

Structure and Dynamics of Human Apolipoprotein CIII

Human apolipoprotein CIII (apoCIII) is a surface component of chylomicrons, very low density lipoproteins, and high density lipoproteins. ApoCIII inhibits lipoprotein lipase as well as binding of lipoproteins to cell surface heparan sulfate proteoglycans and receptors. High levels of apoCIII are often correlated with elevated levels of blood lipids (hypertriglyceridemia). Here, we report the three-dimensional NMR structure and dynamics of human apo-CIII in complex with SDS micelles, mimicking its natural lipid-bound state. Thanks to residual dipolar coupling data, the first detailed view is obtained of the structure and dynamics of an intact apolipoprotein in its lipid-bound state. ApoCIII wraps around the micelle surface as a necklace of six approximately 10-residue amphipathic helices, which are curved and connected via semiflexible hinges. Three positively charged (Lys) residues line the polar faces of helices 1 and 2. Interestingly, their three-dimensional conformation is similar to that of the low density lipoprotein receptor binding motifs of apoE/B and the receptor-associated protein. At the C-terminal side of apoCIII, an array of negatively charged residues lines the polar faces of helices 4 and 5 and the adjacent flexible loop. Sequence comparison shows that this asymmetric charge distribution along the solvent-exposed face of apoCIII as well as other structural features are conserved among mammals. This structure provides a template for exploration of molecular mechanisms by which human apoCIII inhibits lipoprotein lipase and receptor binding.

Quantitative Conformational Analysis of Partially Folded Proteins from Residual Dipolar Couplings: Application to the Molecular Recognition Element of Sendai Virus Nucleoprotein

A significant fraction of proteins coded in the human proteome do not fold into stable three-dimensional structures but are either partially or completely unfolded. A key feature of this family of proteins is their proposed capacity to undergo a disorder-to-order transition upon interaction with a physiological partner. The mechanisms governing protein folding upon interaction, in particular the extent to which recognition elements are preconfigured prior to formation of molecular complexes, can prove difficult to resolve in highly flexible systems. Here, we develop a conformational model of this type of protein, using an explicit description of the unfolded state, specifically modified to allow for the presence of transient secondary structure, and combining this with extensive measurement of residual dipolar couplings throughout the chain. This combination of techniques allows us to quantitatively analyze the level and nature of helical sampling present in the interaction site of the partially folded C-terminal domain of Sendai virus nucleoprotein (N(TAIL)). Rather than fraying randomly, the molecular recognition element of N(TAIL) preferentially populates three specific overlapping helical conformers, each stabilized by an N-capping interaction. The unfolded strands adjacent to the helix are thereby projected in the direction of the partner protein, identifying a mechanism by which they could achieve nonspecific encounter interactions prior to binding. This study provides experimental evidence for the molecular basis of helix formation in partially folded peptide chains, carrying clear implications for understanding early steps of protein folding.

Liquid crystalline phase of G-tetrad DNA for NMR study of detergent-solubilized proteins.

The liquid crystalline phase consisting of the potassium salt of the dinucleotide d(GpG) is compatible with detergents commonly used for solubilizing membrane proteins, including dodecylphosphocholine, the lysolipid 1-palmitoyl-2-hydroxy-sn-glycero-3-phosphocholine, and small bicelles consisting of dihexanoyl phosphatidylcholine and dimyristoyl phosphatidylcholine. The chiral nematic liquid crystalline phase of d(GpG) consists of long columns of stacked G-tetrad structures and carry a net negative charge. For water-soluble systems, the protein alignment induced by d(GpG) is very similar to that observed for liquid crystalline Pf1 bacteriophage, but of opposite sign. Alignment of the detergent-solubilized fusion domain of hemagglutinin is demonstrated to be homogeneous and stable, resulting in high quality NMR spectra suitable for the measurement of residual dipolar couplings.

De novo determination of internuclear vector orientations from residual dipolar couplings measured in three independent alignment media

The straightforward interpretation of solution state residual dipolar couplings (RDCs) in terms of internuclear vector orientations generally requires prior knowledge of the alignment tensor, which in turn is normally estimated using a structural model. We have developed a protocol which allows the requirement for prior structural knowledge to be dispensed with as long as RDC measurements can be made in three independent alignment media. This approach, called Rigid Structure from Dipolar Couplings (RSDC), allows vector orientations and alignment tensors to be determined de novo from just three independent sets of RDCs. It is shown that complications arising from the existence of multiple solutions can be overcome by careful consideration of alignment tensor magnitudes in addition to the agreement between measured and calculated RDCs. Extensive simulations as well applications to the proteins ubiquitin and Staphylococcal protein GB1 demonstrate that this method can provide robust determinations of alignment tensors and amide N-H bond orientations often with better than 10 degrees accuracy, even in the presence of modest levels of internal dynamics.

The Periplasmic Domain of TolR from Haemophilus influenzae Forms a Dimer with a Large Hydrophobic Groove: NMR Solution Structure and Comparison to SAXS Data,

TolR is a part of the Pal/Tol system which forms a five-member, membrane-spanning, multiprotein complex that is conserved in Gram-negative bacteria. The Pal/Tol system helps to maintain the integrity of the outer membrane and has been proposed to be involved in several other cellular processes including cell division. Obtaining the structure of TolR is of interest not only to help explain the many proposed functions of the Pal/Tol system but also to gain an understanding of the TolR homologues ExbD and MotB and to provide more targets for antibacterial treatments. In addition, the structure may provide insights into how colicins and bacteriophages are able to enter the cell. Here we report the solution structure of the homodimeric periplasmic domain of TolR from Haemophilus influenzae, determined with conventional, NOE-based NMR spectroscopy, supplemented by extensive residual dipolar coupling measurements. A novel method for assembling the dimer from small-angle X-ray scattering data confirms the NMR-derived structure. To facilitate NMR spectral analysis, a TolR construct containing residues 59-130 of the 139-residue protein was created. The periplasmic domain of TolR forms a C 2-symmetric dimer consisting of a strongly curved eight-stranded beta-sheet, generating a large deep groove on one side, while four helices cover the other face of the sheet. The structure of the TolR dimer together with data from the literature suggests how the periplasmic domain of TolR is most likely oriented relative to the cytoplasmic membrane and how it may interact with other components of the Pal/Tol system, particularly TolQ.

Lanthanide-Binding Peptides for NMR Measurements of Residual Dipolar Couplings and Paramagnetic Effects from Multiple Angles

Lanthanide-binding peptide tags (LBTs) containing a single cysteine residue can be attached to proteins via a disulfide bond, presenting a flexible means of tagging proteins site-specifically with a lanthanide ion. Here we show that cysteine residues placed in different positions of the LBT can be used to expose the protein to different orientations of the magnetic susceptibility anisotropy (delta chi) tensor and to generate different molecular alignments in a magnetic field. Delta chi tensors determined by nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) spectroscopy for LBT complexes with Yb3+, Tm3+, and Er3+ suggest a rational way of producing alignment tensors with different orientations. In addition, knowledge of the delta chi tensor of LBT allows modeling of the protein-LBT structures. Despite evidence for residual mobility of the LBTs with respect to the protein, the pseudocontact shifts and residual dipolar couplings displayed by proteins disulfide-bonded to LBTs are greater than those achievable with most other lanthanide binding tags.

Dynamics of Large Elongated RNA by NMR Carbon Relaxation

We present an NMR strategy for characterizing picosecond-to-nanosecond internal motions in uniformly 13C/15N-labeled RNAs that combines measurements of R1, R1rho, and heteronuclear 13C{1H} NOEs for protonated base (C2, C5, C6, and C8) and sugar (C1') carbons with a domain elongation strategy for decoupling internal from overall motions and residual dipolar coupling (RDC) measurements for determining the average RNA global conformation and orientation of the principal axis of the axially symmetric rotational diffusion. TROSY-detected pulse sequences are presented for the accurate measurement of nucleobase carbon R1 and R1rho rates in large RNAs. The relaxation data is analyzed using a model free formalism which takes into account the very high anisotropy of overall rotational diffusion (Dratio approximately 4.7), asymmetry of the nucleobase CSAs and noncollinearity of C-C, C-H dipolar and CSA interactions under the assumption that all interaction tensors for a given carbon experience identical isotropic internal motions. The approach is demonstrated and validated on an elongated HIV-1 TAR RNA (taum approximately 18 ns) both in free form and bound to the ligand argininamide (ARG). Results show that, while ARG binding reduces the amplitude of collective helix motions and local mobility at the binding pocket, it leads to a drastic increase in the local mobility of "spacer" bulge residues linking the two helices which undergo virtually unrestricted internal motions (S2 approximately 0.2) in the ARG bound state. Our results establish the ability to quantitatively study the dynamics of RNAs which are significantly larger and more anisotropic than customarily studied by NMR carbon relaxation.

Structure discrimination for the C-terminal domain of Escherichia coli trigger factor in solution

NMR measurements can give important information on solution structure, without the necessity for a full-scale solution structure determination. The C-terminal protein binding domain of the ribosome-associated chaperone protein trigger factor is composed of non-contiguous parts of the polypeptide chain, with an interpolated prolyl isomerase domain. A construct of the C-terminal domain of Escherichia coli trigger factor containing residues 113-149 and 247-432, joined by a Gly-Ser-Gly-Ser linker, is well folded and gives excellent NMR spectra in solution. We have used NMR measurements on this construct, and on a longer construct that includes the prolyl isomerase domain, to distinguish between two possible structures for the C-terminal domain of trigger factor, and to assess the behavior of the trigger factor C-terminal domain in solution. Two X-ray crystal structures, of intact trigger factor from E. coli (Ferbitz et al., Nature 431:590-596, 2004), and of a truncated trigger factor from Vibrio cholerae (Ludlam et al., Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 101:13436-13441, 2004) showed significant differences in the structure of the C-terminal domain, such that the two structures could not be superimposed. We show using NMR chemical shifts and long range nuclear Overhauser effects that the secondary and tertiary structure of the E. coli C-terminal domain in solution is consistent with the crystal structure of the E. coli trigger factor and not with the V. cholerae protein. Given the similarity of the amino acid sequences of the E. coli and V. cholerae proteins, it appears likely that the structure of the V. cholerae protein has been distorted as a result of truncation of a 44-amino acid segment at the C-terminus. Analysis of residual dipolar coupling measurements shows that the overall topology of the solution structure is completely inconsistent with both structures. Dynamics analysis of the C-terminal domain using T1, T2 and heteronuclear NOE parameters show that the protein is overall rather flexible. These results indicate that the structure of this domain in solution resembles the X-ray crystal structure of the E. coli protein in secondary structure and at least some tertiary contacts, but that the overall topology differs in solution, probably due to structural fluctuation.

Influence of the fluctuations of the alignment tensor on the analysis of the structure and dynamics of proteins using residual dipolar couplings

It has been suggested that the fluctuations of the alignment tensor can affect the results of procedures for characterizing the structure and the dynamics of proteins using residual dipolar couplings. We show here that the very significant fluctuations of the steric alignment tensor caused by the dynamics of proteins can be safely ignored when they do not correlate with those of the bond vectors. A detailed analysis of these correlations in the protein ubiquitin reveals that their effects are negligible for the analysis of backbone motions within secondary structure elements, but also that they may be significant in turns, loops and side chains, especially for bond vectors that have small residual dipolar couplings. Our results suggest that methods that explicitly consider the motions of the alignment tensor will be needed to study the large-scale structural fluctuations that take place on the millisecond timescale, which are often important for the biological function of proteins, from residual dipolar coupling measurements.