Background: Determination of orthodontic treatment plan with or without teeth extraction remains controversial, especially in borderline cases, so it requires more data and information to establish appropriate treatment plans in order to obtain optimal treatment results. Purpose: The study was aimed to determine the facial soft tissue changes in the borderline class I cases treated with and without tooth extraction on post-orthodontic treatment. Methods: The study was conducted on 28 lateral cephalograms, divided into two groups; 13 cases with tooth extraction, and 15 cases without tooth extraction. The subject criterias were as follows; class I malocclusion treated with straightwire technique, skeletal class I, in range of age between 18 to 30 years old, normal overjet 2-4 mm, arch length discrepancy between 2.5 to 5 mm, Index of Fossa Canine (IFC) between 37% to 44%, did not using extraoral devices, and treated with teeth extraction of 4 second premolars or without tooth extraction. The measurement of nasolabial angle, labiomental angle, and linear position of the upper and lower lip to E-Ricketts line were done on each cephalogram before and after orthodontic treatment. Results: In teeth extraction cases, there was a change on upper and lower lips positions (p 0.05). In non teeth extraction cases, there were no changes in nasolabial angle, labiomental angle, and lips positions (p>0.05). Both of groups also have indicated that there were no changes on linear position of the upper and lower lip (p>0.05). Post-orthodontic treatment indicated a significant differences between extraction and nonextraction cases on nasolabial and labiomental angle, and lips position (p 0,05). Pada kelompok tanpa pencabutan tidak terdapat perubahan pada sudut nasolabial, sudut labiomental, dan posisi bibir (p>0,05). Terdapat perbedaan sudut nasolabial, sudut labiomental, dan posisi bibir antara kelompok dengan pencabutan dan tanpa pencabutan sesudah perawatan ortodonti (p<0,05). Simpulan: Profil jaringan lunak wajah kelompok yang dirawat dengan pencabutan gigi menjadi lebih retrusi daripada profil jaringan lunak wajah kelompok yang dirawat tanpa pencabutan.