Chronologies of earlywood vessel size of ring- porous trees contain valuable ecological information, but long preparation procedures limit their application in eco- logical studies. Recent and fast techniques for wood surface preparation combined with automated image analysis are reducing the work needed to build chronolo- gies, but might also entail measurement inaccuracy. In this study, we aim to evaluate the effect of a possible effi- ciency-accuracy trade-off on ecological signal strength. To this end, we compare measurements of mean vessel area from two recent and fast procedures carried out on sanded wood surfaces with a reference procedure based on an accurate survey from thin sections. Measurements were performed on increment cores of 15 sessile oaks (Quercus petraea (Mattuschka) Liebl.) for the period 1956-2006. Dissimilarities in results with the reference procedure were quantified and evaluated. Our data show that the workload can be reduced by more than 20-fold when using the highly automated procedure. Signal weakening caused by mea- surement errors is negligible for vessels (6,000 lm 2 and can be easily compensated by increasing the sample size. Manual correction of misrecognized vessels hardly reduced this error further. The new procedures constitute a major step towards an efficient and accurate analysis of early- wood vessel chronologies of ring-porous tree species.
Read full abstract