The demand for red blood cells (RBCs) is on the rise due to the increasing diagnosis of chronic diseases such as sickle cell anemia, malaria, and thalassemia. Despite many commercial attempts, there are no U.S. FDA-approved artificial RBCs for use in humans. Existing RBC substitutes have employed various strategies to transport oxygen, extend the circulation time, and reduce organ toxicity, but none have replicated the natural protective mechanisms of RBCs, which prevent hemoglobin (Hb) dimerization and heme iron oxidation. Lumbricus terrestris (earthworm) erythrocruorin (LtEc) is a naturally occurring extracellular hemoglobin (Hb) with promising attributes: large molecular diameter (30 nm), high molecular weight (3.6 MDa), low auto-oxidation rate, and limited nitric oxide-scavenging properties. These characteristics make LtEc an ideal candidate as an RBC substitute. However, LtEc has a significant drawback, its short circulatory half-life. To address this issue, we explored thiol-mediated surface PEGylation of LtEc (PEG-LtEc) at varying polyethylene glycol (PEG) surface coverages. Increasing PEG surface coverage beyond 40% destabilizes LtEc into smaller subunits that are 1/12th the size of LtEc. Therefore, we evaluated two PEG surface coverage options: PEG-LtEc-0.2 (20% PEGylation) and PEG-LtEc-1.0 (100% PEGylation). We conducted experiments using golden Syrian hamsters with dorsal window chambers and catheters to assess the efficacy of these solutions. We measured microvascular parameters, organ function, cerebral blood flow, circulation time, mean arterial pressure, heart rate, and blood gases and performed histology to screen for toxicity. Our findings indicate that both PEG-LtEc molecules offer significant benefits in restoring microvascular parameters, organ function, cerebral blood flow, and circulation time compared to LtEc alone. Notably, PEG-LtEc-1.0 showed superior microvascular perfusion, although it exhibited a higher rate of auto-oxidation compared to PEG-LtEc-0.2. These results underscore the advantages of PEGylation in terms of tissue perfusion and organ health while highlighting its limitations.