The voltage gated proton channel, HV1, is the most selective ion channel known, and plays an important role in innate immunity, human sperm maturation, tumorigenesis, and dinoflagellate bioluminescence, to name a few examples. When the gene was identified in 2006, HV1 was found to be homologous to the voltage sensor domains of classic voltage gated cation channels; these homologous domains do not conduct ions. Phylogenetic analysis of VSDs showed that HV1, voltage sensing phosphatases, and c15orf27 are three twigs that occupy a branch distinct from other voltage gated ion channels, and that this branch is part of the larger group comprising voltage gated sodium and calcium channels, which split from potassium channels at least a billion years ago. We used a combination of sequence and phylogenetic analysis, structural modeling, and electrophysiological experimentation to identify the proton selectivity filter of HV1, an important milestone in elucidating the functional components of the protein. We proposed a “signature sequence” that defines all presently known HV1, and used it to identify the first dinoflagellate HV1, despite only 15% identity with hHV1. We combined molecular dynamics and sampling methods with other approaches, to help us choose and experimentally validate a refined model that we are using to help us discover the determinants of proton specific conduction.