Maternal Responsive Behaviors Research Articles

Influence of an Inquiry-Based Learning Model on Maternal Behavior in Response to Diarrhea in Children under the Age of Five Years at the Tempe Health Center, Wajo Regency, Indonesia

Influence of an Inquiry-Based Learning Model on Maternal Behavior in Response to Diarrhea in Children under the Age of Five Years at the Tempe Health Center, Wajo Regency, Indonesia

Measuring maternal responsiveness in a community-based sample of slow-to-talk toddlers: a cross-sectional study.

Maternal responsiveness is important in early language development, but its measurement by direct observation has to date been unrealistic in community settings because of training and time constraints. We report on the development and cross-sectional comparison of a global rating of maternal responsiveness against a detailed measure of responsiveness at age 24 months. The community-based sample comprised 246 toddlers and their mothers, identified as being slow-to-talk at age 18 months within the Let's Learn Language population-based randomized controlled trial. At age 24 months, mother-child dyads were videotaped during 15 minutes of free-play and children undertook a standardized language assessment. Videos were blindly rated on both the new global measure, comprising a single rating of responsiveness on a five-point Likert scale, and a detailed rating of responsiveness known to predict language outcomes, comprising a sum of specific maternal responsive behaviours. The global rating scale required relatively little training and ratings could be conducted in real time. The global and detailed ratings of maternal responsiveness showed moderate correlation (r = 0.44; P < 0.001). Small positive correlations were found between the global rating and expressive (r = 0.23; P < 0.001), receptive (r = 0.28, P < 0.001) and total language (r = 0.28; P < 0.001) at age 24 months. The global rating scale was efficient and moderately effective as a measure of maternal responsiveness. It is possible that, combined with other risk measures including concurrent language skills, it could strengthen prediction of which children will and will not go on to experience lasting language difficulties.

Infant behaviors influence mothers’ provision of responsive and directive behaviors

Mother–infant interactions are important to infant development because they are predictive of infants’ social, cognitive, and language development (Lamb, Bornstein, & Teti, 2002; Tamis-LeMonda, Bornstein, & Baumwell, 2001). Because maternal responsive and directive behaviors are associated with differential infant outcomes, it is important to investigate influences on mothers’ provision of responsive and directive behaviors. Yet, the dyadic interaction literature is predominantly unidirectional from maternal behavior to infant outcomes. Therefore, the current study examined infant initiating behaviors and consequent maternal responses in a sample of 26 13-month-old infants and their mothers, videotaped during 5min of free-play. Findings revealed that infants produced a variety of initiatives, and that these different infant initiatives prompted differential patterns of maternal responsive versus directive behaviors. Further, results of analyses of divergent types of maternal directive behaviors – Responsive Directives, ReDirectives, and Intrusive Directives – also may help clarify major discrepancies in the current literature regarding the positive and negative effects of maternal directiveness.

Maternal behaviors promoting language acquisition in slow-to-talk toddlers: prospective community-based study.

To determine, in a community-based sample of slow-to-talk toddlers, the extent to which specific maternal responsive behaviors at 24 months predict child language at 24 and 36 months. Mother-child dyads were recruited for this prospective longitudinal study from 3 local government areas spanning low, middle, and high socioeconomic status in Melbourne, Australia. At child age 18 months, 1138 parents completed a 100-word expressive vocabulary checklist; the 251 (22.1%) children scoring ≤20th percentile were then followed up to comprise this study. Six maternal responsive behaviors (imitations, interpretations, labels, expansions, supportive directives and responsive questions) were derived from mother-child free-play videos collected at 24 months of age and coded using the Observer XT system. Expressive and receptive language measured at 24 and 36 months of age (Preschool Language Scale-4), blind to maternal responsiveness ratings. Two hundred and twenty-six of the 251 (90.0%) mother-child dyads were followed up at 36 months. In confounder-adjusted linear regression analyses, expansions, imitations, and responsive questions were strongly associated with better receptive and expressive language at 24 and 36 months. Labels unexpectedly predicted poorer expressive language at 36 months. Expansions were the only maternal behavior that predicted improvement in language between 24 and 36 months. Maternal responsive behaviors, particularly expansions, offer promise in enhancing early language learning in slow-to-talk toddlers. Parent-child interactions characterized by frequent use of maternal labels at 24 months could also be a predictive marker of those slow-to-talk toddlers at greater risk of persistent language problems.

“My Baby &amp; Me”: Effects of an early, comprehensive parenting intervention on at-risk mothers and their children.

This study examined the efficacy of a multimodule parenting intervention, "My Baby & Me," that began prenatally and continued until children reached 2.5 years of age. The intervention targeted specific parenting skills designed to alter trajectories of maternal and child development. Of 361 high-risk mothers (193 adolescents, 168 adults) enrolled across 4 states, half were randomly assigned to the high-intensity (HI) home visitation coaching program (55 sessions), and half to a low-intensity (LI) condition that included monthly phone calls from a coach, printed informational materials, and community resource referrals. Videotaped observations of mother-child play were coded at 5 time points for multiple maternal and child behaviors and skills. Compared to mothers in the LI group, mothers in the HI group showed higher levels of contingent responsiveness, higher quality verbal stimulation, and more verbal scaffolding by 30 months, with higher levels of warmth and greater decreases in physical intrusiveness and negativity when their children were 24 months. By 30 months, children in the HI group showed more rapid increases and higher levels of engagement with the environment, expressive language skills, and social engagement, as well as more complex toy play and fewer problem behaviors than those in the LI group. Gains in maternal responsive behaviors mediated the effects of the intervention on child outcomes. Results were comparable for adolescent and adult mothers. A strong theoretical framework, consistent focus on maternal responsiveness, high dosage, and trusting relationships with coaches are thought to explain the positive outcomes.

Subjective and Objective Measures of Parent-Child Relationship Dysfunction, Child Separation Distress, and Joint Attention

The literature suggests an adverse impact of maternal stress related to interpersonal violence on parent-child interaction. The current study investigated associations between a mother's self-reported parent-child relationship dysfunction and what she does in response to her child's cues. It also examined whether maternal perception of parent-child dysfunctional interaction and child behavior when stressed by separation, along with maternal behavior in response to child distress, predicted impaired joint attention (JA) during play. Participant mothers (n = 74) and their children ages 12–48 months were recruited from community pediatrics clinics and completed two videotaped visits. After correlations, multiple linear regression was applied to find the best model fit that would predict outcomes of interest. We found that both maternal subjective report of self-reported parent-child relationship dysfunction and observed child separation distress together predicted atypical maternal behavior. Self-reported parent-child relationship dysfunction, observed atypical maternal behavior, and child separation distress combined significantly predicted less time spent in joint attention during play. Maternal posttraumatic stress predicted less maternal availability after separation stress. Clinicians should thus carefully assess and listen to parents' communication of disturbances in their relationship with their young child. Left untreated, parent-child relationship dysfunction may well lead to impairment in learning and social-emotional development.

Effects of rat odour and shelter on maternal behaviour in C57BL/6 dams and on fear and stress responses in their adult offspring

Recent studies in rats and mice suggest that developmental plasticity of HPA-stress and fear responses could be mediated by environment-dependent variations in maternal behaviour. The present study was designed to examine this question further by varying the adversity of the maternal environment to study its effects on nest-attendance and maternal care and on the HPA and fear responses in the adult offspring. C57BL/6 dams and their litter were housed in a cage system composed of a nest cage (NC) and a foraging cage (FC) connected by a tunnel. Using a 2 × 2 factorial design, we varied the maternal foraging environment (FC) by the presence or absence of rat odour (feces) and shelters (MouseHouse and tube) from postnatal days 1–14 and assessed the adult offspring's corticosterone response to isolation/novelty stress and their behaviour in three tests of fearfulness (elevated-O-maze, open-field, free exploration). While the presence of shelters in the FC reduced time spent in the NC (nest site attendance), the presence of rat odour in the FC increased active maternal care without altering nest site attendance. Alterations of the offspring's HPA and fear responses were rather subtle. The presence of shelters in the dam's foraging environment decreased fearfulness in the offspring in the free exploration test. In addition, males reared by dams exposed to rat odour were less fearful in the open-field test, and both males and females reared by dams without shelters and rat odour in the FC showed a greater corticosterone response to isolation/novelty stress. Multiple regression analysis indicated a negative relationship between maternal licking/grooming and fearfulness in males and a positive relationship between nest site attendance and fearfulness in females. Taken together, these results indicate that mouse dams adjust specific aspects of maternal behaviour in response to the specific properties of their environment, and that active maternal care and nest site attendance are two aspects of maternal behaviour that may affect the offspring's stress and fear systems independent of each other and in a sex-specific way.

Maternal responsive and directive behaviours and utterances as predictors of children's lexical development

Predictive relations were examined between measures of 20 mothers' behavioural and verbal general and specific responsiveness and intrusive and supportive directiveness and their children's subsequent expressive vocabularies during three developmental periods with endpoints at the beginning, middle, and end of the second year: 0; 10 to 1; 1, 1 ; 1 to 1; 5, and 1;5 to 1;9. Regression analyses, controlling for mothers' utterance frequencies and children's initial lexicons, revealed considerable consistency between reported and observed lexicons but changing patterns of predictive relations with development. During the first period, behavioural, but not verbal, measures of maternal responsiveness and supportive directiveness were positively predictive. In period two, verbal, but not behavioural, measures predicted children's vocabularies, with specific responsiveness and supportive directiveness as positive predictors and intrusive directiveness as a negative predictor. During the final period, mothers' behavioural and verbal responsiveness and behavioural supportive directiveness positively predicted and their verbal intrusive directiveness negatively predicted children's lexical growth.

A role for the periaqueductal grey in opioidergic inhibition of maternal behaviour.

Opiates are known to be involved in the regulation of various events surrounding parturition and lactation, such as maternal behaviour in rats. The onset of this behaviour has been closely linked to opiate action in the medial pre-optic area, where administration of morphine disrupts maternal behaviour during lactation. By combining the use of Fos protein immunohistochemical detection and pharmacological manipulations, in the present paper we show that the periaqueductal grey (PAG) is another region critically involved in the opioidergic blockade of maternal behaviour. According to our observations, a critical level of morphine-induced activation of the rostral lateral PAG appears to be required to inhibit maternal behaviour in lactating rats. This hypothesis was further confirmed in experiments showing that morphine's inhibitory effect on maternal responsiveness was blocked by unilateral naloxone injection into the rostral PAG, but not into nearby regions of the mesencephalic reticular nucleus. Therefore, only a partial inhibition of the opiate's effect on the rostral PAG was needed to block the inhibitory effect of morphine on maternal behaviour. Further studies are needed to ascertain whether the rostral lateral PAG plays a role in the natural onset of maternal behaviour, playing a complementary role to the medial pre-optic area, or merely inhibits maternal behaviour in response to this specific pharmacological challenge. Conversely, the present findings may well reflect a more general role of the PAG, seemingly providing an important piece of information for proposing a hitherto unexplored concept of the PAG as an important centre for the selection of adaptive behavioural responses.

Repeatability of microenvironment-specific nesting behaviour in a turtle with environmental sex determination

Evolutionary thermal adaptation is increasingly being elucidated in a variety of systems. However, one of the most striking examples, temperature-dependent sex determination (TSD) in reptiles, has proven stubbornly difficult to decipher. Theoretical models suggest that selection on and heritable variation in thermal sensitivity of embryonic sex determination and maternal behavioural choice of thermal qualities of nest sites control the microevolutionary potential of TSD. To begin addressing this important issue, we conducted a multiyear field study of nesting behaviour in painted turtles (Chrysemys picta), which display TSD. We detected a significant field repeatability for overstory vegetation cover around nests at oviposition, a trait that is correlated inversely with nest temperature during embryonic sex determination and positively with offspring sex ratio (percentage of male). Neither clustered nesting nor individual spatial repeatability in nest site choice caused this striking pattern. Instead, females consistently preferred nest environments with particular quantities of overstory vegetation cover. These findings confirm a crucial assumption of models concerning the microevolution and adaptive significance of TSD in reptiles. The results also indicate that this system may be able to evolve via long-term maternal nesting behaviour in response to skewed sex ratios caused by environmental perturbations, such as gradual long-term climate change.

Characteristics of maternal directiveness and responsiveness with young children with visual impairments

The purpose of this study was to investigate the relation between maternal responsive and directive behaviours and the development of young children with visual impairments. The participants were 17 mother-child dyads, and the children's ages ranged from 20 to 36 months of age. The amount, quality, and appropriateness of four maternal behaviours were rated during a free play session between mother and child and compared with a developmental outcome measure designed for young children with visual impairments. In general, the results showed that the quality of maternal control and appropriateness of directiveness were positively related to children's language development; whereas, the amount of these same behaviours was negatively related to language development. The findings also indicated that both the quality and amount of maternal goal-setting behaviours, and the quality of responsiveness were positively related to children's language skills, exploration of the environment and sensorimotor development. The findings are discussed in terms of maternal influence on child development.

Effect of Gestational Stress on Maternal Behavior in Response to Cage Transfer and Handling of Pups in Two Strains of Rat

The influence of gestational stress was determined on the mother's behavior in two rat strains after a disturbance in her routine. Daily 10 min observations were made for 9 days postpartum in Sprague-Dawley (S-D) and Sabra (SB) rats after transfer of the maternal cage to another room or transient pup removal. In response to cage transfer, SB spent much more time than S-D rats in nursing, licking and sitting on their pups, but less time in individual activities. The direction of effect of gestational stress depended on the strain and particular behavior. The duration of nursing was increased in S-D but decreased in SB rats, while that of pup-licking was increased in SB and unchanged or decreased in S-D. Pup-removal reduced the total amount of pup-directed behavior in control and stressed mothers of both strains and eliminated any differences resulting from gestational stress seen in response to cage transfer. It is concluded that the degree and direction of effect of gestational stress on the partition of time by a nursing mother between pup-directed and other behaviors during the early postnatal period is strongly influenced by the strain of rat and the conditions under which it is assessed.

The capacity to develop maternal behavior is enhanced during aging in rats

The induction of maternal behavior (MB) in response to stimulation by pups was studied in aged rats (19–20 months old). We used virgin female rats, neon androgenized female rats and male rats. Both groups of female rats showed a constant estrous vaginal smear. Maternal responsiveness was compared with that of young rats (3–4 months old). Normal and androgenized female aged rats showed a very high percentage of immediate maternal responsiveness and 100% of the rats were fully maternal within 24 hr of testing. The percentage of cyclic and androgenized young rats showing MB were significantly lower. Chronic ovariectomy performed 17 months before testing but not acute ovariectomy abolished MB. Estrogen treatment (5 μg 15 hours before pup presentation) to chronically ovariectomized aged rats was not sufficient to reestablish significantly t capacity of the normal female aged rats to become short-latency maternal. Young and aged male rats showed no difference in maternal responsiveness to the presence of foster pups. The percentage of maternal aged male rats was significantly lower than that of the normal and androgenized aged female rats, whereas young male and female rats showed a similar level of MB, indicating a sex difference in the development of MB with age. In conclusion the high percentage of rats becoming maternal and the short-latency maternal responsiveness in aged female rats appears to be the result of a prolonged estrogen and/or prolactin stimulation.

Maternal behavior in cyclic and androgenized female rats: Role of ovarian hormones

A comparative study on the induction of maternal behavior (MB) in response to pups was carried out in cyclic and androgenized rats. Moreover, the effects of exposure to ovarian hormones on the induction of MB in response to pups were studied in cyclic and androgenized rats. A high percentage of androgenized and proestrus rats displayed MB after 48 hr of exposure to pups (87.9% and 87.5% respectively). Diestrus day-1 rats were significantly less maternal (37.5%). Ovariectomy did not impair MB in androgenized rats. High serum progesterone levels induced in androgenized rats by treatment with 10 I.U. of HCG (40 hours before pup presentation) or with progesterone silastic implants prevented the onset of MB. Ovariectomy performed 8 hours before HCG administration restored MB. When behavioral testing began 72 hours after HCG treatment, 75% of the rats were maternal 12 hr after exposure to pups. This rapid onset of MB in proestrus and androgenized rats appeared to be estrogen dependent. The presence of progesterone inhibited the maternal response of androgenized rats.

The importance of vaginal-cervical stimulation for maternal behaviour in the rat

Non-parturient female rats were primed with oestrogen and given 5 minutes of vaginal-cervical stimulation before foster pups were introduced to them. Virgin and multiparous Wistar rats were used and half the females were ovariectomised. Half of each group was given vaginal-cervical stimulation and the other half was handled for the same time period. An animal was designated “maternal” if it showed all components of maternal behaviour (i.e., retrieving, licking, and crouching). A group of normal, parturient females was observed to compare their normal maternal behaviour with that of experimental animals. Significantly more intact multiparous females showed immediate maternal behaviour after stimulation (75%) than after handling (30%, p<0.04). However, virgin females showed no maternal behaviour in response to vaginal-cervical stimulation. This study shows that sensory input from the vagina plays an important role in the immediate induction of maternal behaviour, but this effect is synergistic with that of hormones and experience.

Effect of prenatal androgen treatment on maternal behavior in the female rat

The perinatal critical period when androgen suppresses the capacity of virgin female rats to display maternal behavior in response to pups in adulthood was studied. A single direct injection of a large dose of testosterone propionate (TP) to the fetuses on Days 19 or 21 of pregnancy, but not during the neonatal period, significantly suppressed maternal responses in females. Percentages of females with anovulatory ovaries were largest in groups treated with TP within 2 days after birth. It is suggested that the androgen-sensitive period of the maternal mediating systems in the female rat exists prenatally, whereas the critical period of the systems regulating the cyclic release of ovulatory hormone is in the neonatal period.