IT IS my intention to present to you a description of the principals and to some extent the scene in the courtroom where the first X-ray plate was introduced as evidence. Try to visualize my description of a courtroom well filled with prominent people in an action for alleged malpractice in the treatment of a fractured femur against a surgeon of national reputation. This surgeon was, and still is, eminent. He was the first to do an appendectomy in this country; the first to accomplish an anastomosis of the spinal accessory to the facial and descending hypoglossal nerves; a man who has simplified many of our extensive surgical procedures; one of the founders of the American College of Surgeons and the Western Surgical Association, and a member of the Board of Governors of the College of Surgeons. Defending this suit were a United States Senator, former judges and other attorneys with distinguished records, known throughout this country. The suit was brought April 14, 1896, by one James Smith, a poor boy who was reading law and doing odd jobs to pay his expenses. He was injured in a fall from a ladder while trimming some trees, and after some time he consulted the distinguished surgeon, who made no attempt at immobilization of the thigh but advised exercise of various kinds as though treating a contusion. Prosecuting this suit for James Smith, plaintiff, were Ben B. Lindsey, a young attorney in his early twenty's, and his associate, Fred W. Parks. We have all come to know the name of Ben B. Lindsey as the founder of the Denver Court of Domestic Relations—otherwise known as the Denver Juvenile Court. It is remarkable, too, that Mr. Parks later became the youngest Senator in this State and had a varied and interesting political career. The docket number of this case is 24,159 in the District Court of Arapahoe County, now the District Court of Denver, Colorado. At that time there was only one higher court in Colorado, the Appellate Court. On the day in question, Thursday, December 2, 1896, there sat upon the bench Judge Owen E. Le Fevre, a man who had made a considerable fortune in mining, who had been a lawyer whom every one trusted, who loved horses, sports, and his fellow-men—Judge Le Fevre, large of build and short in stature, with a very large head and a mass of snow-white hair, a closely clipped white mustache, and exceedingly pink face. The young attorneys, Lindsey and Parks, qualified one H. H. Buckwalter as an expert in photography and in the use of roentgen rays, for he had been making X-ray shadowgraphs for the past eight months for his own amusement and that of his friends. He, with Dr. C. E. Tennant, of Denver, had become acquainted with Roentgen's work and, after similar experiments, agreed to attempt to take a picture of the hip of James Smith. Plates were made November 7, 11, 21, and 28, 1896. The most satisfactory one required an exposure of eighty minutes (personal communication from Dr. Tennant).
Read full abstract