Masonry Structures Research Articles

Predicting compressive strength of hollow concrete prisms using machine learning techniques and explainable artificial intelligence (XAI)

The design of masonry structures requires accurate estimation of compressive strength (CS) of hollow concrete masonry prisms. Generally, the CS of masonry prisms is determined by destructive laboratory testing which results in time and resource wastage. Thus, this study aims to provide machine learning-based predictive models for CS of hollow concrete masonry blocks using different algorithms including Multi Expression Programming (MEP), Random Forest Regression (RFR), and Extreme Gradient Boosting (XGB) etc. A dataset of 159 experimental results was collected from published literature for this purpose. The collected dataset consisted of four input parameters including strength of masonry units (fb), height-to-thickness ratio (h/t), strength of mortar (fm), and ratio of fm/fb and only one output parameter i.e., CS. Out of all the algorithms employed in current study, only MEP and GEP expressed their output in the form of an empirical equation. The accuracy of developed models was assessed using root mean squared error (RMSE), objective function (OF), and R2 etc. Among all algorithms assessed, XGB turned out to be the most accurate having R2 = 0.99 and least OF value of 0.0063 followed by AdaBoost, RFR, and other algorithms. The developed XGB model was also used to conduct different explainable artificial intelligence (XAI) analysis including sensitivity and shapley analysis and the results showed that strength of masonry unit (fb) is the most significant variable in predicting CS. Thus, the ML-based predictive models presented in this study can be utilized practically for determining CS of hollow concrete masonry prisms without requiring expensive and time-consuming laboratory testing.

Applying a 2D Variational Rigid Block Modeling Method to Rubble Stone Masonry Walls Considering Uncertainty in Material Properties

ABSTRACT The computational cost of detailed micro-modeling of masonry structures can be minimized with rigid block analysis methods, where a variational formulation is particularly interesting as it allows for nonlinear pushover analysis. This work investigates the accuracy of this modeling method in predicting the response of rubble stone masonry walls in shear compression tests. To this end, we extend the mathematical programming problem by including cohesion, compressive strength, and tensile strength in the formulation and implement an improved pushover procedure, which guards compatibility of the displaced shape and crack patterns at the intersection of elastic and rigid contact models. Additionally, we reduce model uncertainty, introduced through sampling material properties with distributions estimated based on results from tests on mortar masonry joints and on mortar specimens, by correlating the predicted crack patterns with the observed ones. The findings show that (i) model falsification based on crack pattern is an effective method for reducing the parameter uncertainty of stone masonry walls; and that (ii) the improved pushover procedure predicts the pre- and post-peak response of stone masonry walls very well with analysis times of less than 20 minutes for 2D models where stones and mortar are modeled explicitly.

Experimental and Numerical Research on a Sand Cushion Geotechnical Seismic Isolation System in Strong Earthquakes and Cold Regions

Masonry buildings in high-intensity seismic and cold regions of China face the dual challenges of frost heaving and seismic hazards. To explore the potential of a sand cushion instead of the frozen soil layer to deal with these problems, a cost-effective sand cushion-based Geotechnical Seismic Isolation System (GSI-SC) was developed in this study, where a sand cushion is introduced between the structural foundation and natural soil, while the space around the foundation is backfilled with sand. Shaking table tests on a one-story masonry structure equipped and non-equipped with the GSI-SC system were undertaken to investigate its effectiveness in seismic isolation, where the input wave adopted the north–south component of the EL Centro wave recorded in 1940, and the peak input acceleration (PIA) was set as 0.1 g, 0.2 g, and 0.4 g. It is found that the GSI-SC system significantly reduced the seismic response of the structure, effectively achieving seismic isolation. For a PIA of 0.4 g, the GSI-SC system reduced the acceleration of the roof panel and the inter-story displacement of the structure by 33% and 39%, respectively. Numerical simulations were performed to evaluate the seismic response of buildings equipped and non-equipped with the GSI-SC system. The simulation results matched well with the experimental results, verifying the effectiveness of the newly developed seismic isolation system. The GSI-SC system can provide the potential to reduce frost heave and earthquake disasters for buildings in high-intensity seismic and cold regions.

Behavior of self-sensing masonry structures exposed to high temperatures and rehydration

High temperatures can compromise the structural integrity of structural masonry. Therefore, assessing the post-fire mechanical behavior is crucial for selecting suitable rehabilitation methods. Recent research has proposed the application of self-sensing cementitious composites for monitoring strains, stresses, and damage of structural masonry in room temperature. No previous research has been found on the self-sensing performance of fire-damaged masonry prisms exposed to elevated temperatures, with or without subsequent rehydration. Masonry prisms with integrated self-sensing joints and blocks were produced and exposed to different maximum temperature levels, followed or not by rehydration. Then, experimental tests for determination of compressive strength, modulus of elasticity, gauge factor (GF) and damage-detection performance were carried out. The exposure to 300 ºC caused a 7.4 % decrease in compressive strength and a 44.5 % reduction in elastic modulus. Rehydration methods had negligible effects in this case. After 600 ºC, substantial reductions of 42.2 % in compressive strength and 81.5 % in elastic modulus occurred. In this case, rehydration led to a 15.9 % increase in compressive strength and a 117.4 % increase in elastic modulus. Regardless of the exposure temperature, the predominant rupture mode initiated by vertical cracks originating at the block-mortar interfaces. After 300 ºC, slight GF increases occurred due to the thermal decomposition of hydrates of the cementitious matrix, while exposure to 600 ºC resulted in high GF increases due to partial oxidation of nanomaterials and substantial microcracking propagation. Post-fire curing improved the GF by sealing microcracks with nonconductive rehydration products and enhancing tunneling conduction mechanisms. The self-sensing prisms also demonstrated the ability for real-time damage detection and quantification, providing valuable predictive insights into the propagation of damage.

Advantages of using DIC for capturing mechanical shear sliding behaviour of the FRCM strengthened masonry

This paper aims to analyse the advantages of using Digital Image Correlation (DIC) method to capture the effects of the FRCM on masonry wall shear failure. In the scientific literature, most of the experimental programs is focused on strengthening against flexural failure by means of bending tests and against shear, diagonal cracking, by means of diagonal compression tests. The shear failures are one of the main failure modes for the in-plane behaviour of masonry walls in case of horizontal loads. This study primarily focuses on experimentally determining the capacity of clay brick masonry under sliding shear loads for different normal stress levels with a standard test method. The assessment of shear capacity is based on a Mohr-Coulomb failure criterion depending on the external axial load, the internal friction angle and the cohesion values for unreinforced masonry. The experimental tests have been carried out on both unreinforced and strengthened specimens. The results of the tests demonstrate that FRCM, despite the reduced anchorage length in the tests, can significantly enhance the structural performance of masonry structures for sliding shear failure mode. In addition, DIC method is used to analyse, in greater detail, the cracks and the strain evolution in order to analyse the failure of specimens.

Genetic algorithms applied to nonlinear analysis for the identification of masonry structures collapse mechanisms

Genetic algorithms applied to nonlinear analysis for the identification of masonry structures collapse mechanisms

Impacts of the mechanical connectors on seismic performance of the restored masonry Plaka Bridge using experimental and numerical studies

The use of clamp and dowel materials in the arch of the masonry bridges holds pivotal significance in enhancing the seismic resilience of these structures, as these elements contribute crucially to the structural integrity and dynamic response of these venerable structures. For this reason, the seismic performance of the restored historic Plaka Bridge, originally constructed in 1866 in Arta, Greece, and later restored in 2015 after flooding, was investigated considering the dowels and clamps in the arch section of this study. A combination of experimental and numerical analyses was conducted and verified to understand the in-situ interface behavior of the arch stones. In the first phase of the study, the mechanical properties of the dowels and clamps were characterized by the experimental tests. Compression and tension tests were conducted on the stone samples containing dowel bars and clamps respectively to determine the mechanical properties, The experimental outcomes were subsequently validated through Three-Dimensional (3D) Finite Difference Models (FDM). It was obtained that the dowels and clamps represent the bi-linear material model at the interfaces. Finally, the idealized interface behavior was constructed with normal and tangential spring stiffness properties in 3D-FD Models. These springs successfully simulate the interface delamination failure of the stones in all directions. In the final phase of the study, a 3D-FD model of the Plaka Bridge was constructed employing the previously validated normal and tangential stiffness elements in the arch of the bridge. A free-field non-reflecting boundary condition was imposed on the base and lateral boundaries of the bridge model. Seismic analyses were conducted utilizing the significant seismic events including 2023 Kahramanmaraş earthquakes. The results revealed significant alterations in the structural behavior of the bridge under considered earthquakes. Furthermore, the displacements, principal stresses and tensile-compressive damages in the main arch significantly reduced with the adopted stiffness values. This study proposes the undeniably realistic and efficient implementation of interface material modeling for the mechanical connections as opposed to the traditionally assumed mortar properties in literature. Furthermore, the combined behavior of the dowel, clamp, and Khorasan mortar proposes non-linear interface material model to the existing literature by invalidating commonly assumed linear interface behavior in masonry structures.

Multi-scale experimental investigation on the structural behaviour of novel nanocomposite/natural textile-reinforced mortars

Natural fibre composites present a very appealing area of research for the structural strengthening of masonry structures. Natural fibres possess several drawbacks, such as low initial stiffness and poor interfacial bond behaviour with inorganic matrices that hinder their functions. Such challenges were overcome by applying an innovative nanocomposite-based impregnation system that was pre-engineered and presented by the authors previously. In this paper, a full experimental study involving pullout, tensile tests and large-scale testing via diagonal compression test was carried out to evaluate the structural efficiency of the developed system. Remarkable improvement at yarn-to-matrix level upon nanocomposite coating was observed. At a medium bond length, yarn rupture was observed, highlighting the great anchorage provided by the nanocomposite coating within the matrix. Coupons cast with the developed system demonstrated outstanding composite behaviour and multicracking under tensile loading. Finally, wallets strengthened with the developed system displayed multiple cracks and maintained high shear capacity (40–60 % of τmax) at remarkably large displacements developed at later stages of the test. Such ductility is crucial for retrofitting masonry structures, especially in seismic areas.

Experimental Evaluation of Compressive Properties of Early-Age Mortar and Concrete Hollow-Block Masonry Prisms within Construction Stages.

Early-age masonry structures require temporary support until they achieve full strength. Nevertheless, there is a limited understanding of the properties of freshly laid masonry and the design of newly constructed, unsupported masonry walls. This situation has led to numerous instances of structural damage and injuries to workers, prompting conservative construction bracing techniques. This paper presents comprehensive experimental studies on early-age mortar cubes and masonry prisms to assess the effects of curing time on the compressive properties of masonry assemblies, which is necessary for the design of temporary bracing. The change in modulus of elasticity and compressive strength of masonry prisms and mortar with curing time has been experimentally assessed. The results indicate that the compressive strength of freshly cast mortar cubes is relatively insignificant until approximately 24 h after construction, when it was observed to increase logarithmically. Regarding the performance perspective, the compressive strength of early-age masonry prisms is inconsiderable, less than 15% of full strength during the first day after construction. By contrast, regarding the life safety perspective, the compressive properties of a mortar joint within a masonry assembly (which is of more practical interest) appear to have no effect on the failure strength of concrete masonry prisms over the range of ages tested. The failure modes of the early-age mortar cubes and early-age masonry prism samples depend on the curing time, and different failure modes occurred before and after the start of the primary hydration phase, which is 20.8 h after construction. It is anticipated that the proposed research will provide valuable material properties leading to efficient design of control devices (e.g., temporary bracing) and improved guidelines for concrete-block masonry construction.

Seismic performance assessment of stone masonry buildings: Efficacy of various strengthening elements

Post the 2015 Gorkha earthquake in Nepal, various codes and guidelines were introduced and implemented to enhance the seismic resistance of masonry structures. These provisions encompass diverse seismic measures such as incorporating horizontal bands and vertical reinforcements to fortify structures against seismic forces. Nevertheless, a comprehensive investigation and validation of effectiveness of horizontal bands and vertical reinforcement on the performance of such buildings is still lacking. This paper addresses this gap by presenting the seismic fragility assessment of stone masonry buildings constructed with mud mortar (SMM) and cement mortar (SMC), with a case study involving three distinct building prototypes, presented in the catalogue by the Department of Urban Development and Building Construction (DUDBC), Nepal. The research evaluates the effectiveness of several strengthening components on the buildings' performance, making comparisons among four different scenarios: (a) RM (a reinforced model with all horizontal bands, vertical reinforcement, and through stones), (b) RM-WOV (a reinforced model excluding vertical reinforcement), (c) RM-WOV-St (a reinforced model excluding vertical reinforcement and stitches), and (d) URM (an unreinforced model lacking all horizontal bands, vertical reinforcement, and through stones). The cracking mechanisms reveals the importance of the horizontal bands and through stones. The fragility analysis performed for slight, moderate, extensive and collapse damage states shows that unreinforced models are more susceptible than their reinforced counterparts, irrespective of whether mud or cement mortar is used. The maximum reduction in probability of exceedance of collapse and extensive damage for SMM and SMC buildings with the introduction of horizontal bands at sill and lintel level together with through stones are around 82 % and 81 % respectively. This shows that horizontal bands at sill and lintel level play an important role in preventing the damage of the buildings. Furthermore, it is found that the effect of using vertical reinforcement and horizontal stitches is minimal in preventing the structural damage in cement mortar buildings. However, for mud mortar buildings, these measures have a noticeable effect.

A contact-based constitutive model for the numerical analysis of masonry structures using the distinct element method

This study presents a robust contact constitutive model in the distinct element method (DEM) framework for simulating the mechanical behavior of masonry structures. The model is developed within the block-based modeling strategy, where the masonry unit is modeled as deformable blocks with potential crack surfaces in the middle of the bricks, while the mortar joints are defined as zero-thickness interfaces. The modeling strategy implements multi-surface plasticity with damage mechanics, including a tension cut-off, Coulomb failure criterion, and an elliptical compressive cap for the damage in tension, shear, and compression, respectively. Two new features are introduced in this contact model: a piecewise linear softening function for strength degradation in tension and shear and a hardening/softening function to phenomenologically define the compressive damage of masonry composite into the unit-mortar interface. The constitutive model is implemented in commercial DEM software using the small displacement configuration and validated against material and experimental tests on masonry walls subjected to constant pre-compression and monotonically increasing in-plane load. The experimental and numerical results regarding the force-displacement relationship and damage pattern produced by the proposed constitutive model are compared and critically discussed, demonstrating the capability of DEM coupled with the suitable constitutive law in simulating the behavior of masonry structures.

Nonlinear static analysis of masonry structures with mortar joints and cracking units by optimization‐based rigid block models

AbstractA rigid block model with elasto‐plastic softening interfaces is developed for nonlinear static analysis of masonry structures subject to monotonic loading. Cracking, crushing, and shear failures are taken into account at interfaces, following a simple micro‐modeling approach. An optimization‐based formulation is used for the solution of the equation systems governing the behavior of the rigid block assemblage. A simple incremental solution procedure is implemented to take into account the material softening behavior and the effects of large displacements on equilibrium conditions. The interface models are validated against tension and shear tests on bi‐block prisms from the literature. Applications to numerical and experimental out‐of‐plane loaded masonry walls as well as to circular arches with mortar joints are presented to evaluate the effects of tensile strength and the accuracy of the developed model against responses involving P‐Δ effects. Comparisons with experimental tests on shear walls also involving cracking of the units in the failure mechanisms are finally reported to discuss the potentialities and limitations of the proposed modeling approach.

Effects on the Indoor Environment in a Stable for Horses in Winter: A Case Study

The aim of this article is to show the most significant factors influencing the indoor environment in winter considering the operating conditions of an older stable modified for housing 12 horses and an indoor riding arena for teaching and sports purposes. This research focused on assessing the influences affecting the internal environment from the point of view of the construction of the building and ventilation control in the operating conditions of working and non-working days. The analysis of the results showed that the massive masonry structure has sufficient thermal insulation and accumulation, which was manifested by good temperature stability inside the stable of 7.2 ± 1.7 °C when the outside air temperature was −4.80 ± 1.5 °C. At low outdoor air temperatures of −6.44 ± 0.4 °C, the following conditions were found: a higher relative air humidity (76.0 ± 5.3%), a high CO2 concentration 2317.1 ± 931.7 ppm, and a high airborne dust concentration PM10 = 231.94 ± 19.13 μg·m−3 and PM2.5 = 160.13 ± 6.28 μg·m−3. Therefore, it is necessary to improve the solution and function of the stable ventilation. The small size of the windows and their uneven distribution (average daylight factor ei from 0.313 ± 0.154 to 0.835 ± 0.309) caused insufficient daylight in some individual boxes.

Collapse of the Dharahara Tower During the April 25, 2015 Nepal Earthquake: A New Interpretation Based on Video-Camera Footage

ABSTRACT Among the various important monuments impacted by the April 25, 2015 Mw7.8 Nepal earthquake, the Dharahara Tower located in Kathmandu suffered complete collapse. The collapse of the tower, a slender 60-meter-high old brick masonry structure with an almost cylindrical hollow shape, was captured by a low-quality video camera, which nonetheless helped to identify the critical moments. Initially, the tower descended more than 10 m vertically after a rupture at the base. After a few seconds, it overturned, disintegrating upon impact on the ground. At a distance of 1.3 km, an accelerometric station recorded the strong motion which was used as input of a discrete element model of the structure. Mechanical properties were taken from lab tests made on similar building materials. The Dharahara Tower had previously been analysed by other researchers using various methods. However, since they were apparently not aware of the mechanism observed in the video footage, their collapse models do not agree with this new evidence. For the initial phase of the collapse, the present model explains with great accuracy the observations of the video footage, but the final phase is dependent on various details, and modelling is not so robust.

Seismic Assessment of Existing Masonry Buildings Using Damage Mechanics

This paper presents research concerning the numerical simulation of existing masonry buildings when subjected to pushover analysis. A nonlinear static analysis is undertaken using the commercial software ABAQUS standard, in which masonry structures are modelled using damage mechanics. To validate the chosen input parameters, this study compares two different approaches for static nonlinear modelling, the Finite Element Method (FEM) and the Equivalent Frame Method (EFM), for a simple masonry building. The two methods are compared using the guidelines from Part 3 of Eurocode 8. This study identifies the advantages and disadvantages of various modelling approaches based on the results obtained. The results are also compared in terms of capacity curves and damage distributions for the simple case study of a masonry building created to compare numerical methods. Subsequently, nonlinear pushover analyses with ABAQUS (FEM) were performed on the North Tower of Monserrate Palace, Portugal, in which the material parameters were calibrated by considering the results of dynamic characterisation tests conducted in-situ. Regarding the circular body of Monserrate Palace, the damage distribution of the structure is analysed in detail, aiming to contribute to the modelling of such structural configurations through the Equivalent Frame Method.

Comparative eco-efficiency assessment of 3D-printed recycled aggregate concrete structure for mid-rise residential buildings

3D-printed concrete (3DPC) is an emerging construction technique that extrudes concrete to automatically fabricate structural elements. While prior studies indicate the environmental benefits of 3DPC, limitations include a lack of project-level inventory data and assessment of whole buildings. This study provided a comprehensive framework through a life cycle assessment (LCA) comparison by using 3DPC structures (3DPCS) with project-specific data and conventional masonry structures (CMS) for six-storey residential buildings sharing similar architecture designs. Findings showed that 3DPC reduced cost by 16.9 % due to a 64.1 % decrease in workforce requirements. Environmental impacts were lower by up to 72.5 % for 3DPCS compared to CMS, primarily due to the low-cement-content concrete mixture incorporating recycled aggregates. The research further identified opportunities to enhance the economic and sustainability advantages of 3DPCS versus traditional approaches by increasing the proportion of 3D-printed components and the utilization of 3D printers across different buildings. This empirical research validated 3DPCS sustainability benefits and provided strategies for further promotion of digital concrete techniques in urban and rural construction.

Numerical modelling of flexural performance of textile reinforced mortar strengthened concrete beams

In recent years, the application of textile reinforced mortar (TRM) as an overlay has become an important method for repairing and strengthening old masonry structures. However, the quantitative analysis and design of TRM-strengthened reinforced concrete (RC) beams are still limited. To address this gap, a nonlinear finite element (FE) model is proposed in this study to simulate the flexural behavior of TRM-strengthened RC beams. The developed model is validated using experimental results and subsequently utilized for the design of TRM-strengthened RC beams. Various TRM design parameters, including the number of textile layers, textile longitudinal length, and textile mesh size, are parametrically investigated. The modelling results reveal that increasing the number of textile layers and longitudinal length while decreasing the textile mesh size can enhance the bending strength of TRM-strengthened RC beams. Furthermore, an analytical model is proposed to predict the flexural strength of TRM-strengthened RC beams, facilitating rapid strength estimation of TRM-strengthened RC beams. The predicted results demonstrate good agreement with the numerical simulation results. The established FE models can predict the bending performance of TRM-strengthened RC beams under different reinforcement conditions, and the simulation outcomes can provide valuable guidance for their design.

Hurst Castle: collapse, stabilisation and future

Hurst Castle, a Henrician artillery fort with two Victorian wing batteries and scheduled monument, sits on the end of a shingle spit at the entrance to the Solent. Changes in long shore drift, increasing sea levels and more frequent storms led to the collapse of a section of the nineteenth century east wing battery in February 2021. The vaulted masonry structure of the west wing battery also sustained significant structural damage. English Heritage have since embarked on an ambitious project to attempt to stabilise the castle. A new permanent revetment to protect the most vulnerable area in front of the east wing and geotechnical investigations to allow the severely damaged west wing to be assessed and repaired have already been completed. The health and safety challenges and complex access, either by way of boat or along the mile-long shingle spit, have required the adoption of innovative design solutions and complex monitoring arrangements. Funds permitting, the next phase of works will include permanent structural repairs to the west wing along with further coastal protection work to ensure the longevity of the castle. However, before this can begin, complex questions around the future of the spit and the implications of climate-related loss in the long term must be answered.

The Jajarkot Earthquake: Revealed the Vulnerability of Load Bearing Structures in Western Nepal

The Jajarkot Earthquake, which occurred on 3rd November, 2023 of magnitude 5.7 (Mw) exposed Nepal’s longstanding vulnerability to seismic activity. This paper presents damage assessments derived from both on-site field observations and secondary resources to evaluate the damages sustained by load bearing masonry structures. In the region, 95% of the building structures are based on masonry construction. The damage status of structures in Jajarkot and Rukum East highlighted that about 50% of the building structures were partially and complete damage. The evaluation encompassed various aspects, including the types, mechanisms, and underlying causes of the damage incurred by structures. The observed damage was categorized using an established catalogue originally developed for the identification of failure mechanisms and vulnerability assessment. The common types of damage encompassed features like cracks in the load bearing external walls and corners, diagonal cracks originating from door and window corners, vertical out-of-plane displacement of external walls, collapse of external walls, and partial collapse of load bearing internal walls, fracturing of window and door lintels and complete collapse of structure. Some special forms of damage which was of new nature and distinct from those observed in prior seismic events such as the Gorkha earthquake included ruptures in the outer surfaces of loadbearing external walls, partial roof structure collapses, out-of-plane fragmentation or disintegration as well as rupture. The causes underlying this general damage were attributed to irregular bonding systems, weak mortar, stone block formation, size of stone blocks, absence of tie beams, weakly connected corners, insufficient connections of wall-roof and wall-floor systems, and differing internal wall systems. The mechanisms of damage varied based on the number and specifics of these causative factors, as well as certain structural attributes.

Fragility-based seismic assessment of traditional masonry buildings on Azores (Portugal) using simulated ground-motion records

Traditional unreinforced masonry structures are extremely vulnerable to seismic events, featuring large losses in many countries worldwide. This study focuses on the seismic assessment of a traditional masonry structures located in Faial Island—Azores (Portugal), which was hit by an earthquake of M w = 6.2 on 9 July 1998. A set of analyses was conducted through a probabilistic performance-based seismic approach, employing a stochastic finite-fault ground-motion simulation method to derive region-specific records and nonlinear numerical models to compute the capacity of the building. Subsequently, analytical fragility curves were derived considering different seismic scenarios. The results show a significant probability of the structural typology to reach moderate to extensive damage in the case of the specific earthquake, as observed in reality. The study holds significant importance in regions with limited recorded seismic activity, as they offer potential benefits for seismic risk management and mitigation strategies.