Peterson, Jane. SEXUAL REVOLUTIONS: GENDER AND LABOR AT THE DAWN OF AGRICULTURE, Walnut Creek, CA: AltaMira Press, 2002, Cloth 0-7591-0256-2 $75.00; Paper 0-7591 -0257-0 $29.95.Drawing on a feminist orientation, Jane Peterson has organized data on the emergence of agriculture in the Near East to explore questions of sex-specific behavior and division of labor in human groups transforming themselves from hunting-gathering to horticulture and village life. She rejects a simplistic model of a uniform, developmental trajectory of social change from foraging to farming but tries to construct a more nuanced picture from the available data, based upon secondary analysis of skeletal and archaeological studies.A relatively junior scholar, Peterson is to be congratulated for tackling questions from a time and place that has been under a strong anthropological lens for many years. The place is a portion of modern Israel, Palestine and Jordan, where there is evidence for plant domestication around 10,000 B.P. The time she studies is roughly 12,500 to 5,000 B.P. She has integrated a substantial literature that includes both field- and theory-based contributions, and the focus on Western Asia will assure that her work reaches a substantial readership. The problem is that the small amounts of data available to her can only support so much analysis. She can't be blamed for using too few skeletons to carry out her study, as there are only so many useable sites (she uses 14) and individuals found as exemplars of life at these sites (she uses 158 individuals, 65 female and 93 male). But whether the data is adequate to support any generalizations more than a suggestion is doubtful.She focuses on the results of research that show markers of occupational stress on skeletons. Noting that physical activity can influence the size, shape and robusticity of bones, and adding observations of joint modification as a response to habitual movement, teeth ware, and the effects of trauma, Peterson reanalyzes the 158 skeletons to assess any gender differences found as evidence for similar or different activities and occupations. Musculoskeletal analysis of many kinds of work activities is developed, looking for lateral and bilateral effects of chopping, throwing, digging, walking, weaving, carrying and many other activitiesAfter explaining the methods and showing the statistical analyses of the results of the tabulations (mostly by non-parametric methods appropriate for these small numbers) Peterson presents the theoretical conclusions of her study in the form of a series of drawings of life in a typical village of the period, showing male and female individuals carrying out activities supported by study of the skeletons of that period. The drawings are charming, and effective tools of communication of her results. But worries remain.In the research of biological anthropologists, musculoskeletal markers (MSM) are a subset of markers of occupational stress (MOS), the latter being all changes in the skeleton and teeth that were ostensibly caused by physical activities during life. …
Read full abstract