We present information on an aniline dye marking method for black flies. In the laboratory, adults were sprayed with 2% aqueous solutions of four colors of aniline dyes; brilliant blue and methyl orange gave the best results in longevity trials. In field trials we were able to recapture 1.3% of newly emerged marked and released flies at oviposition sites. Mark–release–recapture experiments were designed to distinguish among three competing models concerning oviposition site selection by gravid female black flies: (1) larval site fidelity (“Do flies return to the site that they experienced as larvae?”), (2) adult site fidelity (“Do flies return to the site that they experienced as adults?”), and (3) no site fidelity (“Do flies oviposit at random, i.e., without regard to adult or larval experience?”). Models 1 and 2 were rejected. There is, however, no reason to reject Model 3, the no site fidelity model. Thus, we conclude that for members of the S. venustum/verecundum complex (i.e., S. rostratum, S. venustum, and S. truncatum) females find an “apparently suitable” waterway in which to oviposit; this may or may not be their natal site.