We examined the validity (accuracy and precision) of using scales and cleithra to assess the structure of the small population of northern pike Esox lucius (N = 220–270 fish age 3 or older) found in Squeers Lake, Ontario (48°31'N, 90°33'W). The high percent frequency of agreement, low index of average error, and low index of precision indicate that both scales and cleithra are equally suitable tissues for assigning age structure to Squeers Lake northern pike. An examination of the accuracy of age estimates through the use of oxytetracycline (OTC) labeling and mark–recapture of fish confirmed that marks identified on both tissues were in fact annuli. Cleithra, however, yielded more accurate results for northern pike older than age 10. Future northern pike age-assessment studies require further mark–recapture and OTC-labeling programs, particularly when precision levels exceed 5%. The collection of this additional data from any ongoing mark–recapture program would not only quickly validate the population's age structure, but would also ensure the accuracy of any future comparison based on age composition.