Phosphorus, a vital macronutrient, often limits primary productivity in marine environments. Marine Synechococcus strains, including WH8102, rely on high-affinity phosphate-binding proteins (PstS) to scavenge inorganic phosphate in oligotrophic oceans. However, WH8102 possesses three distinct PstS homologs whose substrate specificity and ecological roles are unclear. The three PstS homologs were heterologously expressed and purified to investigate their substrate specificity and binding kinetics. Our study revealed that all three PstS homologs exhibited a high degree of specificity for phosphate but differed in phosphate binding affinities. Notably, PstS1b displayed nearly 10-fold higher binding affinity (KD = 0.44 µM) compared to PstS1a (KD = 3.3 μM) and PstS2 (KD = 4.3 μM). Structural modeling suggested a single amino acid variation in the binding pocket of PstS1b (threonine instead of serine in PstS1a and PstS2) likely contributed to its higher Pi affinity. Genome context data, together with the protein biophysical data, suggest distinct ecological roles for the three PstS homologs. We propose that PstS1b may be involved in scavenging inorganic phosphorus in oligotrophic conditions and that PstS1a may be involved in transporting recycled phosphate derived from organic phosphate cleavage. The role of PstS2 is less clear, but it may be involved in phosphate uptake when environmental phosphate concentrations are transiently higher. The conservation of three distinct PstS homologs in Synechococcus clade III strains likely reflects distinct adaptations for P acquisition under varying oligotrophic conditions.IMPORTANCEPhosphorus is an essential macronutrient that plays a key role in marine primary productivity and biogeochemistry. However, intense competition for bioavailable phosphorus in the marine environment limits growth and productivity of ecologically important cyanobacteria. In oligotrophic oceans, marine Synechococcus strains, like WH8102, utilize high-affinity phosphate-binding proteins (PstS) to scavenge inorganic phosphate. However, WH8102 possesses three distinct PstS homologs, with unclear substrate specificity and ecological roles, creating a knowledge gap in understanding phosphorus acquisition mechanisms in picocyanobacteria. Through genomic, functional, biophysical, and structural analysis, our study unravels the ecological functions of these homologs. Our findings enhance our understanding of cyanobacterial nutritional uptake strategies and shed light on the crucial role of these conserved nutrient uptake systems in adaptation to specific niches, which ultimately underpins the success of marine Synechococcus across a diverse array of marine ecosystems.