The Journal of Bone and Joint Surgery. British volumeVol. 89-B, No. 11 Book ReviewsFree AccessSports injuries of the knee: surgical approaches Edited by P. T. Simonian, B. J. Cole and B. R. Bach Jr Pp. 240. New York: Thieme, 2006. ISBN: 3-13-140291-1. € 129.95.D. BickerstaffD. BickerstaffSearch for more papers by this authorPublished Online:1 Nov 2007https://doi.org/10.1302/0301-620X.89B11.20311AboutSectionsPDF/EPUB ToolsDownload CitationsTrack CitationsPermissionsAdd to Favourites ShareShare onFacebookTwitterLinked InRedditEmail The three editing authors have sought to bring together leading sports injury surgeons, each to write a chapter on a defined subject. The intention is to produce a book which covers the breadth of arthroscopic and reconstructive knee surgery and sports-related injuries. Each author describes the surgical technique that is used to address a particular injury and the problems that might be encountered.It was perhaps disappointing to see that of the 53 authors used, 51 were from the USA. Whilst it is understood that the USA are certainly leaders in sports injury management, to provide an international flavour, one might consider that the breadth of sports injury experience emanating from Europe and Australasia may have made more of an impact.The chapters are organised to deal with various pathologies including those of the meniscus, articular surface, ligamentous rupture and finally patellofemoral problems, tendon injuries and fractures around the knee. There is, therefore, a huge amount of information to be imparted to the reader and all encapsulated within 200 pages.Although the remit of the book is to describe surgical approaches, many of the chapters begin with patient presentation, the indications for surgery and contraindications, some diagnostic tests and the timing of surgery. Other chapters more specifically deal only with the surgical approach. Some chapters are really lists of the presenting pathology. When one comes to the actual description of the surgical approach, we are given one particular surgeon’s view of how the operation is performed, or “how I do it”.During training in orthopaedics and attendance at specialist fellowships in sports medicine, the trainee is exposed to a variety of surgical procedures which mould his own approach to the problem. In this book, the reader is given only one author’s surgical style which, for someone with very little experience in sports surgery, may give them a false view of the diversity of options. For someone with much experience in sports surgery, one is left disappointed that other aspects of surgical management have been omitted.The presentation is good with excellent line drawings and full colour surgical photographs, but the book seems to fall between two stools. It tries to impart too much knowledge in too brief a format. Whilst knowledge of the pathology is vital, I believe it should be imparted in full or not at all. Nothing can replace the apprenticeship of a specialist fellowship, attending skills courses where there are many instructors. The depth of knowledge needed to formulate one’s own surgical approach to deal with a particular problem cannot be imparted by such a narrow overview as provided by this book.FiguresReferencesRelatedDetails Vol. 89-B, No. 11 Metrics Downloaded 61 times History Published online 1 November 2007 Published in print 1 November 2007 InformationCopyright © 2007, The British Editorial Society of Bone and Joint Surgery: All rights reservedPDF download