AbstractWarmer than normal late fall temperatures may change standard fall harvest management of alfalfa (Medicago sativa L.) in western Canada. The objective of this study was to evaluate the forage yield and nutritive value of three types of alfalfa cultivars under different harvest managements. A field experiment was conducted from 2013 to 2017 using rhizomatous type (RR), cv. AC Yellowhead (M. sativa subsp. falcata), tap root type (TR), cv. Equinox (ssp. sativa) and creeping root type (CR), cv. Spredor 4 alfalfa (ssp. sativa), at Melfort, SK, Canada. The five harvest treatments were two 1‐cut systems (early July or late July) and three 2‐cut systems (early July + early or late September, late July + late September). Total forage yield was greater in TR and CR alfalfa than RR alfalfa; however, RR alfalfa had higher total forage yield under dry growing conditions versus CR alfalfa. The three alfalfa cultivars had a similar response to 2‐cut harvest managements. The first cut yield was affected by the timing of the second cut of the previous year with the early September harvest reducing yield more than the late September. Three alfalfa cultivars had similar crude protein (CP), total digestible nutrient (TDN), and acid detergent fiber (ADF) concentrations. There was a significant nutrient yield benefit of TR and CR alfalfa under a 2‐cut system over the RR alfalfa. Although the prairie climate is warming, the findings suggest that a fall rest period until late September is recommended regardless of alfalfa types to maintain high hay yield over multiple years.