Area Of Management Research Articles

Identifying measures for understanding and addressing county-level disparities in adolescent HPV vaccination coverage in North Carolina.

HPV vaccination coverage is characterized by geographic disparities in the US, with national studies finding lower coverage in rural versus nonrural areas. To direct quality improvement efforts in North Carolina, we sought to understand how different rurality measures characterize these disparities. We used separate negative binomial regression models to test associations between 5 dichotomized county-level rurality measures and HPV vaccination coverage (≥1 dose) among North Carolina adolescents, ages 11-12 (n=326,345). Rurality measures were derived from: Office of Management and Budget's Metropolitan Statistical Areas, Rural-Urban Continuum Codes, Index of Relative Rurality, US Census Bureau classifications, and North Carolina Rural Center classifications. Models controlled for Social Vulnerability Index (SVI) percentile and rate of pediatricians per county. Vaccination data came from the North Carolina Immunization Registry. HPV vaccination coverage was 29% across North Carolina's 100 counties (range: 13%, 46%). Agreement between rurality measures ranged from 54% to 93% of counties. In adjusted analyses, none of the 5 rurality measures correlated with HPV vaccination coverage, but higher SVI and higher rate of pediatricians were positively associated with coverage (p< 0.01). Exploratory moderation analyses suggested regional variation in the relationship between rurality and coverage, with a positive association in one region, a negative association in one region, and no association in four regions. County-level rurality measures did not identify disparities in HPV vaccination coverage in North Carolina. Measures related to social vulnerability and access to pediatricians may be better suited for understanding and addressing the state's substantial county-level vaccination disparities.

Agile Leadership and its Impact on Strategic Recovery

Purpose: The purpose of this study is to find out whether agile leadership is considered a critical factor in influencing the strategic recovery of leaders in the Iraqi Ministry of Communications or if there is another element that plays a vital role in promoting strategic recovery and what are the organization's steps in the field of study towards implementing agile leadership requirements? Does the organization take serious steps to implement the dimensions of strategic recovery in all its aspects? Is there an impact of agile leadership on strategic recovery in the organization? Theoretical framework: This study aimed to draw attention to how agile leadership influences strategic recovery as management ideas in the Iraqi Ministry of Communications. It also measured the effect of the independent variable (agile leadership) on the dependent variable (strategic recovery). It found out whether the researched organization could achieve strategic recovery by adopting agile leadership. Design/methodology/approach: The researchers used the descriptive analytical method, tabulating and analyzing the data using a ready-made program (SPSS). The researchers chose the Iraqi Ministry of Communications/Ministry Center to represent the Study Community. The questionnaire was distributed to the ministry, including 120 directors, making the total number of questionnaires distributed 120. One hundred twelve questionnaires were retrieved, while only five were excluded, making the final sample 107 managers. Statistical methods such as Cronbach's alpha, standard deviation, simple linear regression, and coefficient of determination (R2) were used to reach the study's conclusions. Findings: Results Through an analysis, agile leadership, and its dimensions influenced the organization's strategic recovery. Research, practical and social implications: Emphasizing the need for government agencies, especially the Ministry of Communications, to ensure the need to pay attention to research variables, agile leadership, and strategic recovery in the research service. Originality/value: The results indicate that the number of publications is growing, and the management and business areas contribute the most. The countries that produce in co-authorship also provide the most publications.

Get ready: disaster preparedness and response for people with chronic illnesses living in hazard-prone Petone, Aotearoa New Zealand

PurposeThe purpose of this research is to understand how people living with chronic illness understand their healthcare needs, particularly as they can be disrupted by natural hazards events (e.g. earthquakes, flooding and landslides), which can result in chronic health conditions becoming acute. Research has shown that, because of such disruption, people with chronic illness face the greatest risk of adverse health outcomes during a disaster, placing significant demand on healthcare systems.Design/methodology/approachThe research draws on a narrative analysis of in-depth, semi-structured interviews with eight people who have a chronic illness and live in a hazard-prone location, namely Petone, Lower Hutt, Aotearoa New Zealand.FindingsTwo major narrative themes were identified: “Social Capital”, which included the three subthemes of community, social connection and support and family and friends. Tellers also experienced a strong sense of “Independence”, as demonstrated through seven subthemes that included declaration, defiance, rules, experience, acceptance, responsibility, self-surveillance and self-management.Practical implicationsPractice output from this research includes the development of fit for purpose emergency management policies and other educational resources to ensure equity, access and choice for people with a chronic illness and their communities.Social implicationsThis research produces in-depth knowledge and insight into the preparedness and response needs of people who live with a chronic illness. This is an under-research area in disaster management in Aotearoa New Zealand.Originality/valueRoutine medical treatment for people living with chronic illness can be disrupted by natural hazard events (e.g. earthquakes, flooding and landslides), which can result in chronic health conditions becoming acute. Research has shown that, because of such disruption, the chronically ill face the greatest risk of adverse health outcomes during a disaster, placing significant demand on healthcare. This research investigates how people living with chronic illness experience disaster preparedness and response while residing in a hazard-prone location, namely Petone, Lower Hutt, Aotearoa New Zealand. The study argues that it is imperative to acknowledge the experiences of people with chronic illness as they provide specific insights into their needs during a disaster.

Application of Sentinel-2 imagery for total suspended solids mapping off the Bodri River, Kendal Regency, Indonesia

Total suspended solids (TSS) is one of the key parameters in water quality monitoring. TSS dynamics off the seas of Bodri River can be observed using Sentinel-2. This research validates Wirasatriya and Laili's algorithm and redevelops a TSS retrieval algorithm based on in situ TSS and Sentinel-2 reflectance (Rrs). During the satellite's passing time, water sampling for TSS was conducted at 64 stations at a depth of 0.5m in October 2023. Bottom of Atmosphere (BoA) Rrs data were obtained from SNAP software, which had previously performed image cropping and resampling. Rrs data from all bands were initially correlated with in situ TSS. The validation results of Wirasatriya and Laili's algorithms obtained very high of RMSE values reaching 272.23 mg/L and 33.08 mg//L. While the results of generating the algorithm produced better the performance of the algorithmic model with RMSE = 7.34 mg/L, MAPE = 14.24%, and bias = 0.99. The development of the algorithms in the study based on the green band (B3) resulted in the equation: TSS (mg/L) = 4.6698exp10.609∗B3, which was further used for temporal mapping. High TSS was found in nearshore areas and river mouths influenced by shallow waters. Temporally, high TSS was found in October (55.65 mg/L) and low in May (11 mg/L). The temporal variation pattern is influenced by precipitation and tides. The findings of this algorithm are very important for analyzing the evolution of land accretion in the Bodri River estuary and as a review for land management in upland areas and can be used to monitor other shallow areas.

Social and Ecological Contributions of the Taungya Agroforestry System in the Restoration of Mount Elgon National Park, Uganda

Balancing conservation objectives with the livelihood needs of local communities remains a significant challenge in the management of protected areas. The Taungya agroforestry system, introduced in Mount Elgon National Park, Uganda, in 2009, aims to address this issue by integrating forest restoration with agricultural production for food security. This study assesses the social and ecological contributions of the Taungya system in Kapkwata sub-county, Kapchorwa district, focusing on its impact on forest cover restoration, food security, income generation, and the provision of ecosystem services. Using a mixed-methods approach, data were collected from 240 participants selected through random sampling, supplemented by key informant interviews. Quantitative data were analyzed using SPSS, and qualitative insights were analyzed through thematic analysis. The results indicate that the Taungya system significantly improved vegetation cover, with the majority of participants reporting an increase in forest cover from 0-25% to 51-75%. The program also contributed to household food security and income generation, with participants cultivating crops like Irish potatoes, maize, and onions for both consumption and sale. Non-crop benefits, including access to firewood and clean water, further enhanced household resilience. However, challenges such as small land allocations, crop pests, and wildlife conflicts were identified as barriers to maximizing the program's impact. To optimize outcomes, the study recommends increased land allocations per household and the introduction of integrated pest management strategies. The findings underscore the potential of agroforestry systems like Taungya to achieve sustainable conservation and community development in protected areas

LEVEL OF INVOLVEMENT OF LOCAL COMMUNITIES IN THE MANAGEMENT OF THE CONSERVATION AREA OF THE CHIPANJE CHETU PROGRAM IN NIASSA, MOZAMBIQUE

Level of involvement of local communities in the management of the conservation area of the Chipanje Chetu program in Niassa, Mozambique. Developing projects for management of community conservation areas is a process that involves several entities, including governmental institutions, NGOs, private sectors and local communities. With the aim of evaluating the “level of involvement of local communities in the management of the conservation area of the Chipanje Chetu (our wealth) program in Niassa, Mozambique”, a participatory survey was carried out in the five communities. Semi-structured interviews, direct observation and document analysis were carried out, and subsequently analyzed using R Software, based on the analysis of pattern consistency, methodological triangulation and the citizen participation scale. It was observed that the participation of communities in the process of management and conservation of natural resources is at the delegated power level. The level of community participation and the degree of importance are associated with issues of benefit sharing and man-animal conflicts in this area.

Quantifying NO x Emission Sources in Houston, Texas Using Remote Sensing Aircraft Measurements and Source Apportionment Regression Models.

Air quality managers in areas exceeding air pollution standards are motivated to understand where there are further opportunities to reduce NO x emissions to improve ozone and PM2.5 air quality. In this project, we use a combination of aircraft remote sensing (i.e., GCAS), source apportionment models (i.e., CAMx), and regression models to investigate NO x emissions from individual source-sectors in Houston, TX. In prior work, GCAS column NO2 was shown to be close to the "truth" for validating column NO2 in model simulations. Column NO2 from CAMx was substantially low biased compared to Pandora (-20%) and GCAS measurements (-31%), suggesting an underestimate of local NO x emissions. We applied a flux divergence method to the GCAS and CAMx data to distinguish the linear shape of major highways and identify NO2 underestimates at highway locations. Using a multiple linear regression (MLR) model, we isolated on-road, railyard, and "other" NO x emissions as the likeliest cause of this low bias, and simultaneously identified a potential overestimate of shipping NO x emissions. Based on the MLR, we modified on-road and shipping NO x emissions in a new CAMx simulation and increased the background NO2, and better agreement was found with GCAS measurements: bias improved from -31% to -10% and r2 improved from 0.78 to 0.80. This study outlines how remote sensing data, including fine spatial information from newer geostationary instruments, can be used in concert with chemical transport models to provide actionable information for air quality managers to identify further opportunities to reduce NO x emissions.

Медиаменеджмент как перспективный инструмент цифрового управления

The issues of studying the concept of media management from the point of view of its use as a tool for managing the digital transformation of business processes and the economy as a whole are considered. Approaches to the definition and content of the term “media management” are analyzed, the specifics and conditions for digitalization of the media market are explored. The key factors determining the further active development of media management and the media environment are identified, and the content of the digital transformation of the media market is revealed. The most relevant models of modern media management in digital management have been identified. The attention is paid to the study of such issues as key factors in the development of media management; media management as an integrated management tool; media as a tool for managing the digital economy; trends in digital transformation and development of media tools. Scientific works devoted to this problem have been studied. The characteristic features of media management as a modern methodology for managing business development and list promising ways to organize the management process, types and tools for using media in digital management are highlighted. An analysis of the current state of the media market is carried out, as well as a forecast for its further development within the framework of the domestic digital economy. The most promising areas of media management are proposed and key trends in media management are listed. Media management at its core is a direction of the digital economy, the transition to which has received significant attention as part of the development of the domestic system of expanded reproduction. Media management as a modern management tool is a rather multifaceted concept that largely determines the trends in the further development of the domestic media market and the digitalization of the modern economy. The growth of the media market contributes to an even more active digital reorientation of basic economic and business processes.

Progress in carbon dioxide capture, storage and monitoring in geological landform

Carbon Capture and Storage (CCS) is recognized as a potent strategy for managing the accumulation of human-generated CO2 in the atmosphere, helping to alleviate climate change’s effects. The CO2 gas is captured from the point source through methods such as pre-treating fossil fuels, oxy-fuel combustion, or post-combustion capture; thereafter; it is transported to a storage location and injected into geological formations. This article provides an overview of carbon dioxide capture and sequestration, focusing on its key principles, technologies, associated risks, and challenges. Direct Air Capture (DAC) and Scalable Modelling, Artificial intelligence (Al), Rapid Theoretical calculations SMART technologies are detailed as emerging and promising approaches to CO2 capture. Numerous pilot and commercial projects commissioned to manage carbon dioxide emissions are presented. Additionally, the paper explores approaches combining geological, geophysical, geochemical, and environmental monitoring techniques to ensure the secure and sustainable storage of CO2 underground. These are essential to address uncertainties, minimize risks, and build public confidence in CCS as a viable climate mitigation strategy. The successful deployment of these technologies on a global scale will require continued innovation, particularly in the areas of monitoring, risk management, and public engagement. Emerging technologies such as AI and SMART systems could play a crucial role in enhancing the efficiency and safety of CCS operations. However, the integration of these advancements with existing infrastructure and regulatory frameworks remains a challenge. Ultimately, a multi-disciplinary approach, combining technological, economic, and regulatory perspectives, will be vital to realizing the full potential of CCS in combating climate change.

The Impact of Transport Costs on Business Decision-Making in Rural Areas

Mobility challenges in rural areas can have a negative impact on economic and demographic development. People in these areas often have to move to urban areas to find quality jobs or services, which can lead to a decline in population, and economic activity. In this paper we analyze the factors influencing business decisions in rural areas. Public transport infrastructure based on short energy cycles using solar energy represents a solution to boost business decision management in rural areas.

Теоретические основы построения систем управления современными предприятиями

Timely research and analysis of enterprise management systems, their competent decomposition into component parts in order to implement corrective actions to improve the final efficiency of the management process as a whole, are relevant areas of theoretical and practical scientific research. As a result of the study of existing approaches to the concept of a management system, its substantive characteristics as an anthropogenic system and directions for study, analysis and improvement at specific enterprises have been clarified. The importance of such properties of the management system in modern conditions is substantiated as: integrity, manifested in the presence of its own pattern of development and influence on the characteristics of the controlling and controlled subsystems; synergy, providing qualitatively new properties, and dynamic equilibrium, compensating for the effects of the internal and external environment on the functioning of the enterprise. As the main directions of the decomposition of the management system, the following are highlighted: functional areas of management – production subsystem, financial subsystem, personnel subsystem, etc.; management functions – planning, organization, motivation, control, etc.; object and subject of management; dynamic and static subsystems, where the static subsystem (structure, resources, controls) sets the framework for management activities, and the dynamic subsystem (management process carried out using management functions) transfers the system from one stable state to another to compensate for the effects exerted by the external and internal environment.

The IBM Model in Border Management of The Riau Islands Province to Increase Investment Competitiveness to Support State Defense

The position of the Riau Islands Province border area with Singapore is very strategic. Even though it has great potential to contribute to economic improvement, this position has not been utilized optimally, even though border areas are an attractive entry point for investors who intend to invest their capital. The aim of the research is to examine the Riau Islands Province Border Management Model based on Integrated Border Management (IBM) which refers to IBM parameters and competitiveness parameters as an effort to increase competitiveness in the investment sector. This research uses a qualitative analysis approach. The research results show that there are obstacles in the management of the Riau Islands-Singapore Province border area in the form of geographical, legal, management and security obstacles. Meanwhile, investment mechanisms and procedures in the border area of ​​Riau Islands Province with Singapore are not complicated and are regulated using a server. The Integrated Border Management (IBM) implementation model in managing the border between Riau Islands Province and Singapore to increase investment competitiveness uses the Single Window Model which is an integrated public service system.

Collaborative water governance model for potable urban water supply in Riau Province, Indonesia

ABSTRACT The literature suggests that collaborative governance is a promising framework for addressing complex public problems while some cases have also marked failure in its implementation. Furthermore, the complexities and factors of the collaborative governance context must be understood at the early stage, as they may affect its sustainability. Therefore, this study aims to understand ‘what works and what doesn't’ and the need for sustainability of urban potable water management in Dumai City, Rokan Hilir Regency, and Bengkalis Regency through cross-sectoral collaboration and develop the best model to be developed for this collaboration. This study uses a soft system methodology in the urban potable water supply system of Riau Province with a wide range of stakeholders through in-depth interviews, thematic analysis, and the creation of purposeful activity models and rich pictures to uncover and address complex issues. The study found that the implementation of collaborative water management in urban areas with the collaborative water governance approach has worked well in the short term. However, it has not enhanced organizational autonomy or fostered trust and reciprocity dimensions in the long term. Additionally, we emphasize the importance of a collaborative supervisory board that will open internal and external opportunities.

KERAGAMAN JENIS BURUNG DI KAWASAN PENGAMATAN BURUNG BIDADARI KALI BATU PUTIH, HALMAHERA BARAT, MALUKU UTARA

Kali Batu Putih ‘Standardwing Bird of Paradise Observation Area’ is located in West Halmahera, North Maluku. The forest in this area is a habitat for various species of birds, such as the Standardwing Bird of Paradise which is the icon of this location. This research was conducted with the aim of analyzing the diversity of bird species in the Kali Batu Putih ‘Standardwing Bird of Paradise Observation Area’. Bird species observations were carried out using a combination of line transect and point count methods. Bird species data collection was also carried out using the MacKinnon species list method. The forest conditions at the research location are secondary lowland forests at an altitude of 100-200 m asl. A total of 32 species of birds from 22 families were found in the research location. The Psittacidae family, the parrot group, has the largest number of species. Based on the feeding guild, insectivorous and frugivorous species are more dominant. There are three bird species categorized as near threatened on the IUCN red list and 11 species are protected by law in Indonesia. The number of endemic bird species is quite abundant, as many as 14 species or 44% of all species found. The large number of endangered, protected, and endemic bird species needs to be a concern by area managers in increasing bird conservation efforts in the Kali Batu Putih area. Conservation steps can be taken through habitat management activities, periodic monitoring, increasing biodiversity research, and developing ecotourism governance by involving communities around the forest.

Coastal vulnerability index for the indented coastline of Primorje-Gorski Kotar County, Croatia

The study explores the general vulnerability of the coastline, with a focus on assessing vulnerability using the coastal vulnerability index (CVI) along the highly indented coastline of Primorje-Gorski Kotar County (PGC), Croatia. Vulnerability was assessed every 25 m of the 1235 km long coastline by calculating the CVI based on five representative variables: geological setting, coastal slope in relation to terrain instabilities (rockfalls and landslides), significant wave height, coastal flooding, and beaches, which were also integrated into a single overall CVI. The length of the coastline, characterised by different relief forms, and the scale of available data required an adaptation of the commonly used methodology. The results show a low overall vulnerability, mainly due to the prevalence of relatively resistant carbonate sedimentary rocks along the coasts. However, almost a quarter of the investigated coastline is highly or very highly vulnerable to coastal flooding. Of particular concern is the fact that many of the most vulnerable areas are inhabited. Analyses at this scale are suitable for regional spatial planning. The results of the conducted research are available publicly online, which enables their practical application for planning and management of coastal areas. Adaptation to the impacts of climate change is highly dependent on the location itself, but overall, this assessment provides indications of the most vulnerable locations in the PGC, where it is necessary to limit interventions in the coastal area.

Motivations of Ecotourists and Their Relationship with Sociodemographic Aspects, Satisfaction, and Loyalty: Puntilla de Santa Elena Marine Fauna Production Reserve, Ecuador

This study aims to investigate the demand for ecotourism in marine protected areas by (a) identifying motivations specific to marine protected areas, (b) establishing the relationship between social and demographic variables and motivations, and (c) determining the relationship between social and demographic characteristics, satisfaction, and loyalty variables. The study was conducted in Santa Elena Province at the reserve called “Puntilla”, which is a coastal marine and fauna production reserve in Ecuador, a country renowned for its biodiversity. The sample comprised 369 on-site surveys. Factor analysis and stepwise multiple regression methods were used for data analysis. The results revealed associations between social and demographic variables and tourist motivations. Specifically, lower-income tourists were most motivated by “escape and ego-defensive function motivation” and reported higher satisfaction levels. Conversely, tourists who visited the destination less frequently displayed stronger motivations related to nature and showed high satisfaction. Furthermore, visitors who spent less at the destination demonstrated a greater intention to return and recommend the area to others. These findings hold significant implications for protected areas management and contribute to the scientific literature on ecotourism in similar protected areas.

Predicting the Invasion Risk of the Highly Invasive Acacia mearnsii in Asia under Global Climate Change.

Acacia mearnsii, among the 100 worst invasive weeds worldwide, negatively impacts native biodiversity, agriculture, and natural ecosystems. Global climate change, characterized by rising temperatures and altered precipitation patterns, enhances the risk of A. mearnsii invasion in Asia, making it crucial to identify high-risk areas for effective management. This study performed species distribution modeling using the maximum entropy (MaxEnt) algorithm to predict the potential introduction and spread of A. mearnsii under various climate scenarios based on shared socio-economic pathways (SSP2-4.5 and SSP5-8.5). Currently, only 4.35% of Asia is invaded, with a high invasion risk identified in six countries, including Bhutan, Lebanon, and Taiwan, where more than 75% of their areas are threatened. Under future climate scenarios, 21 countries face invasion risk, among which 14 countries, such as Georgia, Laos, Republic of Korea, and Turkey, are at moderate to very high risk, potentially encompassing up to 87.89% of their territories. Conversely, Northern Asian countries exhibit minimal changes in invasion risk and are considered relatively safe from invasion. These findings underscore that climate change will exacerbate invasion risks across Asia, emphasizing the urgent need for robust management strategies, including stringent quarantine measures and control efforts, to mitigate the threat of A. mearnsii expansion.

ANALYSIS OF ECOTOURISM AND DISASTER MITIGATION DATA AT THE KUALA LANGSA MANGROVE FOREST BY USING THE ANALYTIC HIERARCHY PROCESS

The problem in the management of a public area is to determine aspects that contribute most as its best practices. This paper explores the contributions of the Kuala Langsa Mangrove Forest located in Langsa City, Aceh Province, for ecotourism and disaster mitigation. This research was intended to analyze the aspects of forest management that has successfully reformed dry coast into an ecotourism site. The Analytic Hierarchy Process (AHP) as a multicriteria decision making method was used to analyze the best indicators data. This method was selected as the suitable method since it utilizes the objectivity of mathematics in comparing some subjective criteria to obtain the best indicators. The implementation of the AHP method consists of three stages: the development of the criteria’s hierarchy table; the development of pairwise matrix related to the intention of giving weights for the criterion’s elements; the logical concistency verification of the matrix. Indicators were written on a five point scale related to a value judgement. The results of the research show that as an ecotourism site, the activities of the mangrove forest are motivated and based on the existing rules which attract people to become interested. The role of the local government has resulted: developed the programs according to the existing mangrove management law that reached 67% among other law related indicators; budget allocation priority by self-generating which get priority of 59% among budget indicators; oriented on the increasing of fishermen, obtained 49% of economical function elements; encouraged the involvement and partnership of the local resources around the mangrove forest which reached 31% among other programs offered and sustainability approach by considering ecological functions aspect. For physical contribution for disaster mitigation, the largest dissipation is given by Rhizophora mucronata due to its height compared to the other types.

Developing a Calculation Workflow for Designing and Monitoring Urban Ecological Corridors: A Case Study

Urban ecological corridors play a crucial role in biodiversity conservation, connecting fragmented habitats in highly anthropized areas and generating benefits in terms of the sustainability of urban environments. These corridors mitigate the effects of habitat fragmentation, such as reduced genetic diversity and limited species dispersal, while improving the ecological health of urban environments and the well-being of citizens. This study proposes a calculation workflow for the identification of the necessary and most suitable ecological corridors to be planned in the urban-environmental planning phase and identifies some of the existing innovative technologies to evaluate and improve their functionality, enabling the real-time monitoring of habitat conditions and providing valuable information to optimize the design and management of these peri-urban natural areas. Urban ecological corridors also improve human well-being by contributing to cleaner air, better water quality and recreational opportunities to the point that the costs incurred for their construction are much lower than the economic and social benefits for the area.

EXPLORING THE EMERGING AREAS OF CORPORATE DISCLOSURES: A BIBLIOMETRIC ANALYSIS

In the current Indian scenario of the financial reporting regime, stakeholders are increasingly looking at the disclosure practices of the companies. Therefore, higher level of transparency is required which implies that there is need of higher level of disclosure. In the present era, the sources of information are not only restricted to annual reports for stakeholders to take decisions. Hence, it is very crucial to have encyclopaedic study on corporate disclosures. The main objective of this paper is to determine the current state of research on corporate disclosure practices across the world. In the present study, literature in subject areas business, management, accounting, economics, econometrics, and finance has been retrieved from Scopus Database and analysed for 15 years between 2009 &amp; 2023. The bibliometric analysis has been conducted using VOS Viewer. This study highlights the trend of publication across two decades, countries and journals along with most cited papers, top journals, most influential authors. Finally, through co-occurrence analysis of keywords, least explored areas have been identified. This paper highlights the gap in the available literature and make recommendations for future research in emerging areas.