Background Recently, laparoscopic totally extraperitoneal (TEP) inguinal hernia repair has been considered one of the most effective and widely performed techniques for repairing inguinal hernias by avoiding entry into the peritoneal cavity. Its indications have evolved and expanded to almost encompass the entire range of groin hernias. This retrospective study aims to determine the outcomes and postoperative complications in patients undergoing TEP inguinal hernia repairperformed by a single surgeon for groin hernias at a single center. Methodology We retrospectively evaluated the prospectively collected data of 900 patients who underwent elective TEP repair over 18 years at a single center performed by a single surgeon from April 2004 to February 2023. Patients were evaluated for age, sex, type of hernia, time taken for surgery, open from laparoscopy, intra and postoperative complications, hospital stay, and days taken to resume regular activity. Results The mean age of the 900 patients was 59 years (range = 21-83 years). The mean age of males and females was 59 and 56 years, respectively. The mean operative time was 40 and 55 minutes for a unilateral and bilateral hernia, respectively. In total, 369 (41%) patients had a right-sided groin hernia, 382 (42%) patients had a left-sided groin hernia, and 149 (16.5%) patients had bilateral groin hernias. A total of 121 (13%) patients had occult hernias, and 17 patients underwent concurrent TEP and transurethral resection of the prostate. Of the 900 patients, 20 (2.2%) had a recurrent hernia after a previous open inguinal hernia repair. Seven (0.8%) patients had a recurrence of hernias post-TEP and subsequently underwent open inguinal hernia repair. Seven (0.7%) patients needed conversion from TEP to the transabdominal pre-peritoneal approach. Only minor complications were noted intra and postoperatively. The average time of hospitalization was 24 hours. The time to resume normal activities was five (±1) days. Conclusions Our experience suggests that TEP repair with mesh fixation is a safe and effective procedure with a marginal recurrence rate. Apart from the obvious cosmetic benefits of minimal tissue invasion, a significant advantage of TEP is the visualization of the contralateral groin along with the surgical repair of a hernia, if required, in the same sitting and without the insertion of any extra trocars.