Intraductal papillary mucinous neoplasms (IPMN) are potentially malignant intraductal epithelial neoplasms that are composed of mucin-producing columnar cells. The lesions show papillary proliferation, cyst formation, and may involve the main pancreatic duct, the branch ducts, or both. IPMNs have varying degrees of malignant potential based on anatomic location, with main duct lesions progressing in 38-68% of cases. Therefore, surgical removal is indicated for these types of lesions. Most patients are asymptomatic and incidental diagnosis is made with advances in imaging and endoscopic procedures. Here we report a case of a 66-year-old male with a history of pancreas divisum and family history of pancreatic cancer who presented with pancreatitis. Initial symptoms were progressively worsening mid-epigastric pain with elevated amylase and lipase levels. After initial medical treatment for his pancreatitis, further evaluation with upper endoscopy showed a patulous minor papilla with a “fish eye” appearance that excreted mucin. Endoscopic ultrasound identified a markedly dilated pancreatic duct in addition to an anatomic variation called pancreas divisum. Subsequent ERCP with SpyGlass DS pancreatoscopy revealed a papillary lesion at the junction of the head and body of the pancreas. Biopsy confirmed the diagnosis of this main duct IPMN. Pancreatic divisum is an anatomic variant which results when the embryologic dorsal and ventral pancreatic ducts fail to fuse properly. Our background research revealed only a few reported cases of IPMN and pancreas divisum occurring in tandem. It has been noted that IPMN in the setting of pancreas divisum carries a higher rate of malignancy. Surgical intervention based on the Sendai and Fukuoka consensus is appropriate for IPMNs and is indicated in main duct IPMN in the setting of pancreas divisum, since these patients have better survival with surgical removal. This case emphasizes the need to appropriately evaluate patients presenting with pancreatitis, as there is a possibility of an underlying malignant process.