On 29 May 1453, after conquering Constantinople, the Ottoman Sultan Mehmed II (the Conqueror) visited Hagia Sophia, the main church of the Byzantine Empire. He climbed up to the building's dome and viewed the panorama of the newly conquered city. Today, standing on a platform under the dome of the Panorama 1453 History Museum, built in 2009 to commemorate the city's conquest, a visitor is surrounded by a panoramic image of the city about to be conquered, providing a virtual and constructed experience. This experience today under the dome of Panorama 1453 is reminiscent of the Sultan's awe when gazing upon the panoramic view of the city from the dome of Hagia Sophia. I place the Panorama 1453 History Museum at the centre of discussions on how architecture and political issues intertwine and how architecture is open to political manipulation. The museum is a grand political spectacle of the Islamist-nationalist government that attempts to shape Turkey's national subjects as new conquerors. Architecture, instrumental in this shaping, becomes the article's subject. How do architectural features, such as a dome, a higher platform, and a panoramic view, contribute to the instrumentalisation of the museum in transmitting the conquest as an ideology? To examine these questions, I use ‘distance’, a prerequisite of achieving illusion in panorama, as a conceptual device by which remoteness in physical space can stand in for distance in time and the level of intimacy with the ideal (here, the Conqueror or the Ottoman past). Distance as a mediator between past and present helps explore how the conquest panorama shapes visitors' engagement with the ideal through proximal encounters.
Read full abstract