A graph G admits an H-covering if every edge of G belongs to a subgraph isomorphic to a given graph H. G is said to be H-magic if there exists a bijection f:V(G)∪E(G)→{1,2,…,|V(G)|+|E(G)|} such that wf(H′)=∑v∈V(H′)f(v)+∑e∈E(H′)f(e) is a constant, for every subgraph H′ isomorphic to H. In particular, G is said to be H-supermagic if f(V(G))={1,2,…,|V(G)|}. When H is isomorphic to a complete graph K2, an H-(super)magic labeling is an edge-(super)magic labeling. Suppose that G admits an F-covering and H-covering for two given graphs F and H. We define G to be (F,H)-sim-(super)magic if there exists a bijection f′ that is simultaneously F-(super)magic and H-(super)magic. In this paper, we consider (K2,H)-sim-(super)magic where H is isomorphic to three classes of graphs with varied symmetry: a cycle which is symmetric (both vertex-transitive and edge-transitive), a star which is edge-transitive but not vertex-transitive, and a path which is neither vertex-transitive nor edge-transitive. We discover forbidden subgraphs for the existence of (K2,H)-sim-(super)magic graphs and classify classes of (K2,H)-sim-(super)magic graphs. We also derive sufficient conditions for edge-(super)magic graphs to be (K2,H)-sim-(super)magic and utilize such conditions to characterize some (K2,H)-sim-(super)magic graphs.