New therapeutic approaches to treat type 1 diabetes mellitus relies on pancreatic islet transplantation. Here, developing immuno-isolation strategies is essential to eliminate the need for systemic immunosuppression after pancreatic islet grafts. A solution is the macro-encapsulation of grafts in semipermeable matrixes with a double function: separating islets from host immune cells and facilitating the diffusion of insulin, glucose, and other metabolites.This study aims to synthesize and characterize different types of gelatin-collagen matrixes to prepare a macro-encapsulation device for pancreatic islets that fulfill these functions. While natural polymers exhibit superior biocompatibility compared to synthetic ones, their mechanical properties are challenging to reproduce. To address this issue, we conducted a comparative analysis between photo-crosslinked gelatin matrixes and chemically crosslinked collagen matrixes. We show that the different crosslinkers and polymerization methods influence the survival and glucose-stimulated insulin production of pancreatic β cells (INS1) in vitro, as well as the in vitro and in vivo stability of the matrix and the immuno-isolation in vivo.Among the matrixes, the stiff multilayer GelMA matrixes (8.5 kPa), fabricated by digital light processing, were the best suited for pancreatic β cells macro-encapsulation regarding these parameters. Within the alveoli of this matrix, pancreatic β cells spontaneously formed aggregates.