The two poorly soluble iron containing solid aerosols of siderite (FeCO3) and magnetite (Fe3O4) were compared in a 4-week inhalation study on rats at similar particle mass concentrations of approximately 30 or 100 mg/m3. The particle size distributions were essentially identical (MMAD ≈1.4 μm). The iron-based concentrations were 12 or 38 and 22 or 66 mg Fe/m3 for FeCO3 and Fe3O4, respectively. Modeled and empirically determined iron lung burdens were compared with endpoints suggestive of pulmonary inflammation by determinations in bronchoalveolar lavage (BAL) and oxidative stress in lung tissue during a postexposure period of 3 months. The objective of study was to identify the most germane exposure metrics, that are the concentration of elemental iron (mg Fe/m3), total particle mass (mg PM/m3) or particle volume (μl PM/m3) and their associations with the effects observed. From this analysis it was apparent that the intensity of pulmonary inflammation was clearly dependent on the concentration of particle-mass or -volume and not of iron. Despite its lower iron content, the exposure to FeCO3 caused a more pronounced and sustained inflammation as compared to Fe3O4. Similarly, borderline evidence of increased oxidative stress and inflammation occurred especially following exposure to FeCO3 at moderate lung overload levels. The in situ analysis of 8-oxoguanine in epithelial cells of alveolar and bronchiolar regions supports the conclusion that both FeCO3 and Fe3O4 particles are effectively endocytosed by macrophages as opposed to epithelial cells. Evidence of intracellular or nuclear sources of redox-active iron did not exist. In summary, this mechanistic study supports previous conclusions, namely that the repeated inhalation exposure of rats to highly respirable pigment-type iron oxides cause nonspecific pulmonary inflammation which shows a clear dependence on the particle volume-dependent lung overload rather than any increased dissolution and/or bioavailability of redox-active iron.