Facial rejuvenation procedures for lower eyelid bags and tear trough deformity have recently gained increasing attention. This study introduced a treatment algorithm tailored to the severity of tear trough deformity, categorized using the Barton grading system, to tackle this concern effectively. One hundred seventy-six patients with combined lower eyelid bags and tear trough deformity underwent lower lid blepharoplasty at our center between 2018 and 2023. Preoperative assessment utilized the Barton grading system to categorize the severity of tear trough deformity, guiding personalized surgical approaches for each patient. Postoperative outcomes, including satisfaction levels, complications, and tear trough deformity improvement, were evaluated. Following surgery, 175 out of 176 patients achieved a reduction to Barton grade level of 0. Postoperative satisfaction scores averaged 4.4, with a satisfaction rate of 96.6%. Complications were minimal, including mild postoperative ectropion in patients and single occurrences of postoperative hematoma, infection, insufficient improvement, and recurrence. Our treatment algorithm offers a straightforward and effective approach for addressing tear trough deformity and lower eyelid bags. Further research is warranted to validate these findings.