Laminar separation bubble (LSB) is the characteristic feature of the low speed flowfields with low Reynolds number, which has the strong non-linear and unsteady effects. There are three key influences of the LSB to the airfoil aerodynamic characteristics: (1) Rapidly decreasing of the lift coefficient and the ratio of the lift to drag, increasing of the drag coefficient; (2) Non-linear effects of the aerodynamic coefficients exist at the small angle of attack; (3) The non-linear static hystereses appear at the middle and large angle of attack. Based on the former authors numerical simulations about airfoil E387 and SD8020, the trailing-edge laminar separation bubble was found by author, which is different from the classical LSB. In this paper, furthermore, the unsteady numerical simulation methods and water tunnel PIV technologies were used to carefully study the alterations of the time-averaged and unsteady flow separation structures, the distributions of the pressure coefficients on the surface, around the SD8020 airfoil. Both the results of the CFD and experiment confirmed very well, which proved our former discovery through numerical simulations correct. The main conclusions of this paper are described briefly following: (1) The PIV experiments validated that the classical Long LSB (LLSB) is the time-averaged flow of a series laminar separation vortex, shedding from the upper surface. A stable long LSB does not exist; (2) the experimental results proved that the time-averaged trailing-edge laminar separation bubble(TLSB) really exists for the symmetrical airfoil at low Reynolds number with low incidence, which is obviously different with the LLSB, not only for the shape and structure but also for the evolvement. The sketch of the two kinds of LSB are painted and analyzed carefully in this paper; (3) the numerical simulations and the water tunnel experiments also showed that the structure and the pressure distribution of the unsteady flow fields of the two kinds of LSB are different with each other. And the non-linear effect of the lift coefficient of the symmetrical airfoil at low incidence are caused by the sudden alteration between the LLSB and TLSB; (4) the unsteady vortex structure about the TLSB almost keeps the dead water near the separation point, and alters to the Karman vortex street near the trailing-edge point. Otherwise, the unsteady flow field about the LLSB appears remarkable unsteady character near the separation point, and a series of independent vortexes generate, develop, move, incorporate and shed along the upper surface of the airfoil. Therefore, maybe the deep mechanism and reason that cause the sudden alteration between the LLSB and the TLSB are the unsteadiness of the flow field near the separation bubble.
Read full abstract