Low-frequency Interaural Time Differences Research Articles

The frequency and level dependence of across-frequency binaural interference for interaural time differences

Binaural hearing enables listeners to localize sound in the horizontal plane, even when dealing with intricate speech-like signals characterized by distributed energy across a broad range of frequencies and varying sound pressure levels. Low-frequency interaural time differences (ITDs) are the most important cue for human horizontal-plane sound localization. Across-frequency binaural interference tasks (where changes in ITD discrimination thresholds of a target signal are measured in the presence of a remote interferer signal) can be used to measure how a listener weighs different frequency regions for ITD. While it is known that low-frequency (0.5 kHz) targets experience less binaural interference from higher-frequency (4 kHz) interferers than vice versa, the impact of the relative level of the two signals has remained mostly unexplored. ITD discrimination thresholds were measured in normal-hearing listeners with target/interferer intensities of 35, 55, and 75 dB-A and frequencies of 0.5, 4, and 8 kHz. Besides the expected frequency effects, data to date show binaural interference increases with increasing interferer level. These results help better understand how sound level variation and more realistic complex sounds like speech are localized.

Analysis and Experiment on the Limitations of Static and Dynamic Transaural Reproduction with Two Frontal Loudspeakers

By duplicating the binaural pressures of an actual source, transaural reproduction with two frontal loudspeakers is expected to recreate a virtual source in arbitrary direction. However, experiments indicated that in static transaural reproduction, the perceived virtual source is usually limited to the frontalhorizontal plane. The reasons for this limitation, as guessed, are that, in static reproduction, the dynamic cues for front-back and vertical localisation are incorrect, and the high-frequency spectral cues are unstable with head movement. To validate this hypothesis, the variations of ITD (interaural time difference) caused by head turning in both static and dynamic transaural reproductions are analysed. The results indicate that dynamic reproduction is able to create appropriate low-frequency ITD variations, and the static transaural reproduction is unable to do so. Psychoacoustic experiments are conducted to compare virtual source localisation in static and dynamic reproductions. The results indicate that dynamic reproduction is able to recreate the front, back, and vertical virtual source for low-pass stimuli below 3 kHz, while for full audible bandwidth stimulus, appropriate low-frequency dynamic cue and unstable high-frequency spectral cues in dynamic reproduction result in two splitting virtual sources.

Spectral weighting functions for localization of complex sound. II. The effect of competing noise.

Spectral weighting of sound localization cues was measured in the presence of three levels of competing noise presented in the free field. Target stimuli were complex tones containing seven tonal components, presented from an ∼120° range of frontal azimuths. Competitors were two independent Gaussian noises presented from 90° left and right azimuth at one of three levels yielding +9, 0, and -6 dB signal-to-noise ratio. Results revealed the greatest perceptual weight for components within the interaural time difference (ITD) "dominance region," which was found previously to peak around the 800-Hz component in quiet [Folkerts and Stecker (2022) J. Acoust. Soc. Am. 151, 3409-3425]. Here, peak weights were shifted toward lower-frequency components (i.e., 400 Hz) in all competing noise conditions. These results contradict the hypothesis of a shift in the peak weights toward higher frequencies based on previous behavioral localization performance in competing noise but are consistent with binaural cue sensitivity, availability, and reliability; measured low-frequency ITD cues within the dominance region were least disrupted by the presence of competing noise.

Age-Related Changes in Interaural-Level-Difference-Based Across-Frequency Binaural Interference.

Low-frequency interaural time differences and high-frequency interaural level differences (ILDs) are used to localize sounds in the horizontal plane. Older listeners appear to be worse at horizontal-plane sound localization to compared younger listeners, but little is understood about age-related changes to across-frequency binaural processing. This study investigated if the frequency dependence of across-frequency ILD processing is altered for older compared to younger listeners, which was done by using an across-frequency binaural interference task (when the interaural difference sensitivity for a target sound is decreased by a spectrally remote interfering sound with zero interaural differences). It was hypothesized that as listeners experience advancing age and age-related high-frequency hearing loss (i.e., presbycusis), they will demonstrate worse binaural performance and experience more across-channel binaural interference (because of age-related temporal processing deficits), and will increasingly be affected by interferers at lower frequencies (because of age-related hearing loss) when compared to younger listeners. There were 11 older (>65 yrs) and 20 younger (<30 yrs) listeners with normal to near-normal audiometric thresholds up to 2 kHz. They were tested using a left-right ILD lateralization discrimination task. Single-tone ILD discrimination thresholds and across-frequency binaural interference were measured at 0.5, 1, 2, 4, and 8 kHz. ILD thresholds and interference were about twice as large for older compared to younger listeners. Interferers ≤1 kHz produced 2–3 times as much across-frequency binaural interference for older compared to younger listeners. Hearing thresholds were significant predictors of single-tone ILD thresholds; in addition, both target and interferer hearing thresholds were significant predictors of binaural interference. The results suggest a reweighting of binaural information that occurs with advancing age and age-related high-frequency hearing loss. This evidence of plasticity may help explain some of the age-related changes in spatial-hearing abilities.

Spectral weighting functions for lateralization and localization of complex sound.

Perceptual weighting of sound localization cues across spectral components was measured over headphones [experiment (expt.) 1] and in the free field (expt. 2) and quantified in the form of spectral weighting functions (SWFs). Stimuli consisted of five complex sounds (conditions), each containing seven frequency components. Participants judged the spatial position of the stimuli with spatial cues varying across frequency components. In separate experiments, free-field stimuli were presented anechoically (expt. 2), in the presence of simulated reverberation (expt. 3), or with stimuli varying in level either corrected for equal loudness (expt. 4.1) or sloped by ±6 dB per component (expt. 4.2). Overall results revealed greatest weight in the vicinity of 800 Hz, for both localization and interaural time difference (ITD)-based lateralization, although specific features of the SWFs did vary across stimulus conditions. The shape of the SWF follows the pattern of ITD sensitivity across frequency and is consistent with previous descriptions of an ITD "dominance region" peaking around 600-800 Hz. The close similarity of free field and ITD-based SWFs is further consistent with the hypothesized dominant role of low-frequency ITD in localization of broadband sounds. Other conditions revealed relatively modest effects of reverberation and component level.

The effect of target and interferer frequency on across-frequency binaural interference of interaural-level-difference sensitivity.

Across-frequency binaural interference occurs when the sensitivity to changes in interaural differences in a target sound is decreased by a spectrally remote diotic interfering sound. For interaural time differences (ITDs), low-frequency (e.g., 0.5 kHz) interferers cause more interference on high-frequency (e.g., 4 kHz) targets than vice versa. For interaural level differences (ILDs), however, it is unclear if a frequency dependence exists. Therefore, ILD discrimination thresholds and across-frequency binaural interference were measured for target and interferer frequencies between 0.5 and 8 kHz (for tones) or 12 kHz (for narrowband noises). For tones, 8-kHz targets experienced the least interference and 8-kHz interferers produced the most interference, suggesting that higher-frequency ILDs are a more heavily weighted localization cue than lower-frequency ILDs. For narrowband noises, the frequency-dependent interference patterns increased in complexity in comparison to tones. Low-frequency ITD dominance (from randomly varying onset ITDs) and grouping cues (e.g., envelope modulations) might explain some of the complexity in the interference patterns for the noises. These data contribute to a better understanding of across-frequency ILD processing, which remains poorly understood.

A Low-Frequency Panning Method With Compensation for Head Rotation

Amplitude panning produces interaural time difference (ITD) cues that help localize images in directions between loudspeakers. However, if the panning gains are static, then the ITD cues produced in this way vary inconsistently as the listener's head rotates, compared with a real source, and so the dynamic ITD cues are inaccurate. This effect destabilizes the perception of the image and overall scene, and is worse for loudspeakers that are more widely spaced relative to the listener. Based on a simple head model that is accurate in the low-frequency ITD regime, the ITD is calculated for a general field, including those produced by panning. A simple formula is derived relating head orientation, image direction, and a field description vector. Panning functions are then found that compensate for head orientation and are valid for any image direction. For the special case when the listener is facing the image, the functions are equivalent to vector base amplitude panning. The performance is first assessed objectively using measured binaural responses, rather than the simple head model. Subjective comparison is then made with pre-existing listening tests and new listening tests in which the listener's head is tracked to control the panning gains in real-time. These show that images can be stabilized as predicted, and, furthermore, that with the same panning functions, images can be produced in all directions using two loudspeakers placed in front.

On the localization of complex sounds: temporal encoding based on input-slope coincidence detection of envelopes.

Behavioral and neural findings demonstrate that animals can locate low-frequency sounds along the azimuth by detecting microsecond interaural time differences (ITDs). Information about ITDs is also available in the amplitude modulations (i.e., envelope) of high-frequency sounds. Since medial superior olivary (MSO) neurons encode low-frequency ITDs, we asked whether they employ a similar mechanism to process envelope ITDs with high-frequency carriers, and the effectiveness of this mechanism compared with the process of low-frequency sound. We developed a novel hybrid in vitro dynamic-clamp approach, which enabled us to mimic synaptic input to brain-slice neurons in response to virtual sound and to create conditions that cannot be achieved naturally but are useful for testing our hypotheses. For each simulated ear, a virtual sound, computer generated, was used as input to a computational auditory-nerve model. Model spike times were converted into synaptic input for MSO neurons, and ITD tuning curves were derived for several virtual-sound conditions: low-frequency pure tones, high-frequency tones modulated with two types of envelope, and speech sequences. Computational models were used to verify the physiological findings and explain the biophysical mechanism underlying the observed ITD coding. Both recordings and simulations indicate that MSO neurons are sensitive to ITDs carried by spectrotemporally complex virtual sounds, including speech tokens. Our findings strongly suggest that MSO neurons can encode ITDs across a broad-frequency spectrum using an input-slope-based coincidence-detection mechanism. Our data also provide an explanation at the cellular level for human localization performance involving high-frequency sound described by previous investigators.

How high frequency envelopes influence spatial localization in rooms

Perception of sound laterality (left-right angle) is mediated by both interaural time differences (ITD) and interaural level differences (ILD). Previous localization studies in anechoic settings consistently show that low-frequency ITDs dominate perception of source laterality. However, reverberant energy differentially degrades ITDs and ILDs; the effects of room reflections on the perceptual weight given to ITDs and ILDs are not well understood. Here, we tested the hypothesis that high-frequency envelope ITD cues are important for spatial judgments in reverberant rooms by measuring the perceived laterality of high-pass, low-pass and broadband sounds. Results show that when ILD cues and ITD envelope cues are both available, reverberant energy has the smallest effect on localization of high-pass stimuli. When ILD cues are set to zero, localization of high-pass stimuli with strong envelopes (i.e., click trains and speech tokens) is also minimally affected by reverberant energy; however, as envelope modulation is reduced, subjects show increasing localization bias, responding towards the center. Moreover, for stimuli with strong envelopes, subjects with better modulation detection sensitivity are affected less by the addition of reverberant energy. These results suggest that, in contrast to in anechoic space, high-frequency envelope ITD cues influence localization in reverberant settings.

The role of high-frequency cues for spatial hearing in rooms

The ability to attend to a sound source of interest while ignoring competing sounds is vital to navigating everyday acoustic scenes. Commonly, this ability depends on the ability to focus on a sound source using acoustic spatial cues, particularly interaural time differences (ITDs) and interaural level differences (ILDs). Based on past studies of localization in anechoic settings, low-frequency ITDs have been thought to dominate perception of source location. However, reverberant environments differentially degrade ITDs and ILDs, which may affect their relative influence on localization. Moreover, a recent study suggests that ILDs play a bigger role on spatial perception in reverberant settings than in anechoic settings. Here, in a series of localization and spatial attention experiments using high-pass, low-pass and broadband sounds, we tested the hypothesis that high-frequency ILD and envelope ITD cues are important for spatial judgments in reverberant rooms. We also measured the brainstem frequency following responses (FFRs) of individual subjects in response to click trains and spoken syllables. Results suggest that compared to in anechoic space, in reverberant settings, high-frequency cues are more reliable and influential on perception and that the strength of FFR phase locking to stimulus envelope predicts how well individual listeners can direct spatial attention.

Cue weighting and vestibular mediation of temporal dynamics in sound localization via head rotation

Our studies have quantified the salience and weighting of dynamic acoustic cues in sound localization via head rotation. Results support three key findings: 1) low-frequency interaural time-difference (ITD) is the dominant dynamic binaural difference cue; 2) dynamic cues dominate front/rear localization only when spectral cues are unavailable; and 3) the temporal dynamics of dynamic cue processing are particular to auditory-vestibular integration. ITD dominance is shown indirectly in findings that head movements are highly effective for localizing low-frequency targets but not narrow-band high-frequency targets. Direct evidence comes from manipulation of dynamic binaural cues in spherical-head simulations lacking spectral cues. If the stimulus provides access to dominant high-frequency spectral cues, location illusions involving head-coupled source motion fail. For low-frequency targets, localization performance improves with increasing head-turn angle, but decreases with increasing velocity such that performance depends primarily on stimulus duration; ~100 ms being required for accurate front/back localization. That duration threshold only applies in dynamic localization tasks, and not in auditory-only tasks involving similar stimuli. Correct spatial interpretation of dynamic acoustic cues appears to require vestibular information about head motion, thus the temporal threshold is likely a property of vestibular-auditory integration.

Temporal weighting for interaural time differences in low-frequency pure tones

In contrast to envelope-based interaural time differences (ITD) at high frequencies, where sound onsets play a dominant role, the reliability and salience fine-structure ITD at low frequency (&amp;lt;1500 Hz) suggests uniform sensitivity to information across periods of an ongoing stimulus waveform. Several past studies, however, have demonstrated low-frequency ITD thresholds to improve sub-optimally with increasing sound duration [e.g. Houtgast &amp; Plomp 1968, JASA 44:807-12], suggesting that the initial periods of a brief tone play a greater role in ITD processing than do later periods. Here, we measured the temporal profile of ITD sensitivity in pure tones ranging from 250-1000 Hz. Sounds were presented with ITD that either remained fixed over the sound duration (condition RR) or progressed linearly to eliminate the ITD cue from either the beginning (condition 0R) or end (R0) of the sound. Durations varied from 40-640 ms, including 20 ms ramps applied diotically to minimize envelope cues. ITD detection thresholds demonstrated (a) suboptimal improvement with duration and (b) greater sensitivity to ITD available early (R0) rather than late (0R) in the stimulus, a pattern nearly identical to that observed for high-frequency envelope ITD. [Supported by NIH R01 DC011548.]

Similar patterns of learning and performance variability for human discrimination of interaural time differences at high and low frequencies

Sound source localization on the horizontal plane is primarily determined by interaural time differences (ITDs) for low-frequency stimuli and by interaural level differences (ILDs) for high-frequency stimuli, but ITDs in high-frequency complex stimuli can also be used for localization. Of interest here is the relationship between the processing of high-frequency ITDs and that of low-frequency ITDs and high-frequency ILDs. A few similarities in human performance with high- and low-frequency ITDs have been taken as evidence for similar ITD processing across frequency regions. However, such similarities, unless accompanied by differences between ITD and ILD performance on the same measure, could potentially reflect processing attributes common to both ITDs and ILDs rather than to ITDs only. In the present experiment, both learning and variability patterns in human discrimination of ITDs in high-frequency amplitude-modulated tones were examined and compared to previously obtained data with low-frequency ITDs and high-frequency ILDs. Both patterns for high-frequency ITDs were more similar to those for low-frequency ITDs than for high-frequency ILDs. These results thus add to the evidence supporting similar ITD processing across frequency regions, and further suggest that both high- and low-frequency ITD processing is less modifiable and more noisy than ILD processing.

Learning to discriminate interaural time differences at low and high frequencies

This study investigated learning, in normal-hearing adults, associated with training (i.e. repeated practice) on the discrimination of ongoing interaural time difference (ITD). Specifically, the study addressed an apparent disparity in the conclusions of previous studies, which reported training-induced learning at high frequencies but not at low frequencies. Twenty normal-hearing adults were trained with either low- or high-frequency stimuli, associated with comparable asymptotic thresholds, or served as untrained controls. Overall, trained listeners learnt more than controls and over multiple sessions. The magnitudes and time-courses of learning with the low- and high-frequency stimuli were similar. While this is inconsistent with the conclusion of a previous study with low-frequency ITD, this previous conclusion may not be justified by the results reported. Generalization of learning across frequency was found, although more detailed investigations of stimulus-specific learning are warranted. Overall, the results are consistent with the notion that ongoing ITD processing is functionally uniform across frequency. These results may have implications for clinical populations, such as users of bilateral cochlear implants.

Learning to discriminate interaural time differences: An exploratory study with amplitude-modulated stimuli

The advent of bilateral cochlear implants (CIs) has increased interest in learning on binaural tasks, and studies in normal-hearing listeners provide important background information. However, few studies have considered learning with discrimination of interaural time difference (ITD). Here, learning with ITD was explored using stimuli that are more relevant to bilateral CIs than used previously. Inexperienced listeners were trained with envelope-based ITD using high-frequency amplitude-modulated tones with or without an interaural carrier frequency difference (IFD), the former to simulate asymmetrical bilateral CI insertions. All were tested with and without IFD before and after training. In most listeners, ITD thresholds improved substantially with training, not necessarily reaching asymptote after 3000 trials. In these, the magnitude and time-course of learning was larger than anticipated from a previous study with low-frequency ITD. Learning generalized across IFD and the effect of IFD on ITD thresholds at post-test was smaller than reported previously. These results have implications for studies of bilateral CIs, such as the need to provide extensive training to avoid over-estimating any apparent ‘impairment’.SumarioEl advenimiento de los implantes cocleares bilaterales (CI) ha aumentado el interés en aprender sobre tareas binauriculares, y los estudios en sujetos oyentes normales han aportado importante información pertinente. Sin embargo, pocos estudios han considerado el estudio del aprendizaje con base en la discriminación de diferencias interauriculares de tiempo (ITD). Aquí, el aprendizaje con ITD fue explorado utilizando estímulos más relevantes para los CI bilaterales que los usados previamente. Se entrenó a oyentes sin experiencia con una ITD con base en envolventes que comprendían tonos de alta frecuencia de amplitud modulada, con o sin diferencia interauricular de la frecuencia portadora (IFD), esta última para simular inserciones bilaterales asimétricas de CI. Todos fueron evaluados con y sin IFD antes y después del entrenamiento, sin alcanzar necesariamente la asíntota después de 3000 intentos. En ellos, la magnitud y el tiempo del aprendizaje fue mayor de lo anticipado en un estudio con una ITD de baja frecuencia. El aprendizaje en general en todas las IFD y el efecto de la IFD sobre los umbrales de ITD después de la prueba fue similar a los reportes previos. Estos resultados tienen implicaciones en los estudios de CI bilaterales, tales como la necesidad de proveer amplio entrenamiento para evitar la sobre-estimación de cualquier ‘impedimento’ aparente.