Local Species Pool Research Articles

Restoring prairie pothole wetlands: does the species pool concept offer decision‐making guidance for re‐vegetation?

AbstractQuestion: Do regional species pools, landscape isolation or on‐site constraints cause plants from different guilds to vary in their ability to colonize restored wetlands?Location: Iowa, Minnesota, and South Dakota, USA.Methods: Floristic surveys of 41 restored wetlands were made three and 12 years after reflooding to determine changes in local species pools for eight plant guilds. The effect of landscape isolation on colonization efficiency was evaluated for each guild by plotting local species pools against distance to nearby natural wetlands, and the relative importance of dispersal vs. on‐site constraints in limiting colonization was explored by comparing the local species pools of restored and natural wetlands within the region.Results: Of the 517 wetland plant taxa occurring in the region, 50% have established within 12 years. The proportion of the regional species pool represented in local species pools differed among guilds, with sedge‐meadow perennials, emergent perennials and floating/submersed aquatics least represented (33‐36%) and annual guilds most represented (74‐94%). Colonization‐to‐extinction ratios suggest that floating/submersed aquatics have already reached a species equilibrium while sedge‐meadow and emergent perennials are still accumulating species. Increasing distance to nearest wetlands decreased the proportion of the regional species pool present in local pools for all guilds except native annuals and woody plants. The maximum proportion predicted, assuming no distance constraint, was comparable to the lowest‐diversity natural wetlands for most perennial guilds, and also lower than what was achieved in a planted, weeded restoration.Conclusions: A biotic constraints seem to limit the colonization of floating/submersed aquatics into natural or restored wetlands, whereas all other guilds are potentially constrained by dispersal or biotic factors (i.e. competition from invasive species). Using species pools to evaluate restoration progress revealed that immigration potential varies considerably among guilds, that local species richness does not necessarily correspond to immigration limitations, and that some guilds (e.g. sedge‐meadow perennials) will likely benefit more than others from being planted at restoration sites.

Floristic composition, environmental variation and species distribution patterns in burned grassland in southern Brazil

In regularly burned grassland on Morro Santana, Porto Alegre, RS, Brazil, we investigated differences in the floristic composition and their relation to soil properties, aspect and distance from the forest border. In 48 plots of 0.75 m2, we identified a total of 201 species from a local species pool of approximately 450 to 500 species. Most species occurred in low frequencies, showing clumpy distribution patterns in the studied area. Multivariate analysis showed that plots close to the forest edge clearly differed from plots in the open grassland concerning composition and structure. Plots exposed to the north differed from plots on the top of the hill both in the composition of species as well as in soil variables, mainly due to shallower soil in the former. No strong relation between soil properties and variation in vegetation composition could be detected at a finer scale. The studied grassland, as all grassland vegetation in southern Brazil, is very rich in species compared to other grassland formations worldwide. However, this high biodiversity and conservational value of Campos vegetation in general has so far not been recognized properly. Disturbance is essential to maintain this open vegetation type and its species richness. Fire should be considered as a management option in the absence of grazing.

Sampling saproxylic beetle assemblages in dead wood logs: comparing window and eclector traps to traditional bark sieving and a refinement

The use of saproxylic beetle community as a metric to evaluate nature conservation measures in forests requires efficient methods. We first compare traditional bark sieving to a potential improvement (extracting beetles from whole bark with Tullgren funnels) to determine the most efficient. Secondly we compare this most efficient bark sampling to eclector and window traps. At the species, family, and functional group levels, we consider species richness, abundance and practical aspects. Traditional bark sieving missed >50% of the individual beetles compared to whole bark sampling so we recommend the latter. Window traps caught large numbers of mobile saproxylic beetles, but a high proportion of non-saproxylics results in high sorting cost; bark sampling and eclector traps had a high proportion of saproxylics and obligate saproxylics. Compared to bark sampling, eclector traps are non-destructive, and monitor the whole saproxylic assemblage (i.e. also beetles inside the wood). Overall, window traps are useful because they capture saproxylic beetles attracted to dead wood and sample the local species pool, whereas eclector traps capture the saproxylics that actually emerge from a particular piece of dead wood, and thus are suited to detailed studies. Overall, we suggest that a combination of these two best methods is highly complementary.

Effects of Rewetting Measures in Dutch Raised Bog Remnants on Assemblages of Aquatic Rotifera and Microcrustaceans

Species differ in their life cycle, habitat demands and dispersal capacity. Consequently different species or species groups may respond differently to restoration measures. To evaluate effects of restoration measures in raised bog remnants on aquatic microinvertebrates, species assemblages of Rotifera and microcrustaceans were sampled in 10 rewetted and 10 non-rewetted sites, situated in 7 Dutch raised bog remnants. A total of 129 species (Rotifera 108, Cladocera 15, Copepoda 6 species) were found. The species assemblages, total numbers of species and numbers of characteristic raised bog species did not differ between the 10 rewetted and 10 non-rewetted sites. The dominant pattern in the variation in microinvertebrate assemblages could be explained by the presence or absence of open water and variation in physico-chemical variables of surface water and organic matter. Furthermore, the species assemblages of water bodies situated in the same area were on average more similar to each other than to assemblages from other areas. These differences between areas may be due to differences in environmental conditions of water bodies, and possibly also to differences in the local species pool and the subsequent immigration sequence of species. We conclude that, in contrast to earlier findings on aquatic macroinvertebrates, populations of microinvertebrate species, including characteristic species, can either persist in the raised bog remnants during the process of rewetting or (re-)establish within a relatively short period of time (less than about 5 years).

Scale, Environment, and Trophic Status: The Context Dependency of Community Saturation in Rocky Intertidal Communities

Our understanding of the relative influence of different ecological drivers on the number of species in a place remains limited. Assessing the relative influence of local ecological interactions versus regional species pools on local species richness should help bridge this conceptual gap. Plots of local species richness versus regional species pools have been used to address this question, yet after an active quarter-century of research on the relative influence of local interactions versus regional species pools, consensus remains elusive. We propose a conceptual framework that incorporates spatial scale and ecological interaction strength to reconcile current disparities. We then test this framework using a survey of marine rocky intertidal algal and invertebrate communities from the northeast Pacific. We reach two main conclusions. First, these data show that the power of regional species pools to predict local richness disintegrates at small spatial scales coincident with the scale of biological interactions, when studying ecologically interactive groups of species, and in generally more abiotically stressful habitats (e.g., the high intertidal). Second, conclusions of past studies asserting that the regional species pool is the primary driver of local species richness may be artifacts of large spatial scales or ecologically noninteractive groups of species.

Neither Host-specific nor Random: Vascular Epiphytes on Three Tree Species in a Panamanian Lowland Forest

A possible role of host tree identity in the structuring of vascular epiphyte communities has attracted scientific attention for decades. Specifically, it has been suggested that each host tree species has a specific subset of the local species pool according to its own set of properties, e.g. physicochemical characteristics of the bark, tree architecture, or leaf phenology patterns. A novel, quantitative approach to this question is presented, taking advantage of a complete census of the vascular epiphyte community in 0.4 ha of undisturbed lowland forest in Panama. For three locally common host-tree species (Socratea exorrhiza, Marila laxiflora, Perebea xanthochyma) null models were created of the expected epiphyte assemblages assuming that epiphyte colonization reflected random distribution of epiphytes in the forest. In all three tree species, abundances of the majority of epiphyte species (69-81 %) were indistinguishable from random, while the remaining species were about equally over- or under-represented compared with their occurrence in the entire forest plot. Permutations based on the number of colonized trees (reflecting observed spatial patchiness) yielded similar results. Finally, a third analysis (canonical correspondence analysis) also confirmed host-specific differences in epiphyte assemblages. In spite of pronounced preferences of some epiphytes for particular host trees, no epiphyte species was restricted to a single host. The epiphytes on a given tree species are not simply a random sample of the local species pool, but there are no indications of host specificity either.

Using functional traits to assess the role of hedgerow corridors as environmental filters for forest herbs

Linear habitats such as hedgerows can constitute important refuges for native flora and fauna, possibly providing connectivity between landscape elements. The effectiveness of these functions, however, depends on the ability of linear habitats to benefit a significant proportion of the local species pool and their functional attributes. This study aims to identify life-history traits that appear to either limit or facilitate survival or colonization of forest herbs in hedgerows. The distribution patterns of 47 native forest herbaceous species and their associated traits were compared in a system of hedgerows and attached forest patches of southern Quebec. Although 83% of the species surveyed in forest patches were present in hedgerows, significant differences in abundance suggest the existence of a selective pressure on forest species in linear habitats. Early spring flowering was negatively associated with hedgerows, possibly because of unfavourable microclimatic conditions. Seed dispersal phenology partly mirrors results for flowering phenology with early summer dispersal and late fall dispersal being less common in hedgerows than in forests. Slow dispersal mainly through myrmecochory was also less common in hedgerows compared to forest sites, suggesting a selective pressure on slow dispersers in linear habitats. The capacity for vegetative propagation was positively associated with hedgerows, possibly because it provides an alternative strategy to survive and expand when conditions are less favourable for sexual reproduction. Our approach highlights traits that can help determine the vulnerability of native forest species in linear habitats or their likelihood to benefit from the maintenance of wooded corridors in an inhospitable matrix.

Trait convergence and trait divergence in herbaceous plant communities: Mechanisms and consequences

In landscapes subject to intensive agriculture, both soil fertility and vegetation disturbance are capable of impacting strongly, evenly and simultaneously on the herbaceous plant cover and each tends to impose uniformity on the traits of constituent species. In more natural and ancient grasslands greater spatial and temporal variation in both productivity and disturbance occurs and both factors have been implicated in the maintenance of species‐richness in herbaceous communities. However, empirical data suggest that disturbance is the more potent driver of trait differentiation and species co‐existence at a local scale. This may arise from the great diversity in opportunities for establishment, growth or reproduction that arise when the intensity of competition is reduced by damage to the vegetation.In contrast to the diversifying effects of local disturbances, productivity‐related plant traits (growth rate, leaf longevity, leaf chemistry, leaf toughness, decomposition rate) appear to be less variable on a local scale. This difference in the effects of the productivity and disturbance filters arises from the relative constancy of productivity within the community and the diversity in agency and in spatial and temporal scales exhibited by disturbance events. Also, evolutionary responses to disturbances involve minor adaptive shifts in phenological and regenerative traits and are more likely to occur as micro‐evolutionary steps than the shifts in linked traits in the core physiology associated with the capacity to exploit productive and unproductive habitats.During the assembly of a community and over its subsequent lifespan filters with diversifying and convergent effects may operate simultaneously on recruitment from the local species pool and impose contrasted effects on the similarity of the trait values exhibited by co‐existing species. Moreover, as a consequence of the frequent association of productivity with the convergence filter, an additional difference is predicted in terms of the effects of the two filters on ecosystem functioning. Convergence in traits selected by the productivity filter will exert effects on both the plant community and the ecosystem while divergent effects of the disturbance filter will be restricted to the plant community.

Restoring prairie pothole wetlands: does the species pool concept offer decision-making guidance for re-vegetation?

ABSTRACT Question: Do regional species pools, landscape isolation or on-site constraints cause plants from different guilds to vary in their ability to colonize restored wetlands? Location: Iowa, Minnesota, and South Dakota, USA. Methods: Floristic surveys of 41 restored wetlands were made three and 12 years after reflooding to determine changes in local species pools for eight plant guilds. The effect of landscape isolation on colonization efficiency was evaluated for each guild by plotting local species pools against distance to nearby natural wetlands, and the relative importance of dispersal vs. on-site constraints in limiting colonization was explored by comparing the local species pools of restored and natural wetlands within the region. Results: Of the 517 wetland plant taxa occurring in the region, 50% have established within 12 years. The proportion of the regional species pool represented in local species pools differed among guilds, with sedge-meadow perennials, emergent perennials and floating...

Plant dispersal along rivers fragmented by dams

AbstractTo understand the influence of dams on connectivity of riparian plant communities along rivers, we examined plant dispersal by water (hydrochory) and riparian plant community attributes upstream and downstream from dams on two rivers in the southern Rocky Mountains, Colorado, USA. Drifting plant propagules were collected from the water column along reaches upstream and downstream from dams to examine the longitudinal and temporal variation in seed‐pool species composition and concentration of water‐transported seeds. Similarities between species composition of the hydrochoric seed pool and local standing riparian vegetation were used to evaluate the degree of longitudinal connectivity along river corridors and to isolate the relative contributions of local versus regional species pools to hydrochoric species composition. Furthermore, several synthetic attributes (longevity, origin, life‐form and dispersal mode) and species composition of riparian plant communities were examined to explore the effects of interrupted propagule dispersal on standing vegetation.We estimated that as many as 120 million seeds were transported via hydrochory along free‐flowing reaches of the Rocky Mountain streams in a single growing season. Seed concentration (seeds/m3) in the water column was reduced by 70–94% along reaches downstream from dams compared to free‐flowing reaches. The similarity in species composition of hydrochoric seeds and local standing vegetation was nearly two times greater downstream from reservoirs compared to upstream. This suggests that hydrochory complements local species pools by importing seeds from throughout the upstream catchment area along free‐flowing river reaches, but that hydrochoric seeds are derived primarily from local sources along regulated river reaches. Species richness recovers as a function of downstream distance from contributions of standing vegetation and seeds from tributary streams. Hydrochory may extend the period over which viable seeds of a parent population are dispersed. Even after dispersal of parent populations has terminated, seeds may continue to be available due to residence time in water transport. This extension of the ‘effective dispersal window’ of some species may exceed two weeks or more and may influence the likelihood of successful establishment.In this study, synthetic attributes of riparian vegetation did not differ significantly between free‐flowing and regulated reaches, whereas formal statistical comparisons of community composition upstream and downstream from reservoirs indicate that there are differences in community composition upstream and downstream from dams. These findings suggest that the consequences of 50 to 100 years of fragmentation result in community‐wide effects along Rocky Mountain streams and that these effects may be partially explained by dam‐caused disruption in connectivity of plant populations. Copyright © 2005 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.

Helminths of the exotic lizard Hemidactylus mabouia from a rock outcrop area in southeastern Brazil

The helminth fauna of 291 Hemidactylus mabouia (Lacertilia: Gekkonidae) from a rock outcrop area in the state of São Paulo, Southeastern Brazil, was studied. Five species were recovered, namely one unidentified species of centrorhynchid acanthocephalan (present only as cystacanths) and the nematodes Parapharyngodon sceleratus, P. largitor (Oxyuroidea: Pharingodonidae), Physaloptera sp. (Spiruroidea: Physalopteridae) and one indeterminate species of Acuariidae (Acuaroidea), with the latter two forms present only as larvae. Infection rates tended to increase with host size, but appeared to be unaffected by season. Hemidactylus mabouia shared most of its helminth fauna with two other sympatric lizard hosts, Mabuya frenata and Tropidurus itambere. The helminth assemblage of the H. mabouia population appears to have been entirely acquired by this exotic gecko from the local helminth species pool, rather than possessing any species from the parasite faunas of the original African populations.

The Relationship between Local Species Richness and Species Pool: A Case Study from the High Mountains of the Greater Caucasus

The causes of linear relationships between local species richness and the size of the actual species pool in closed subalpine meadow communities and open plant communities of the alpine stony substrate (the Greater Caucasus Mountains) were analyzed using a computer simulation model. The results demonstrated that this relationship is insufficient evidence for the variation of local species richness among communities is wholly or partly determined by regional processes (the species-pool hypothesis). A relatively proportional ratio between these variables can also arise where local species richness and the size of the species pool both depend on local processes, or where local species richness is determined by local factors alone while the size of the species pool is determined by both local and regional factors.

Local and regional processes in low‐productive mountain plant communities: the roles of seed and microsite limitation in relation to grazing

It is becoming widely accepted that plant community structure is determined not only by local scale factors, but that regional factors may play considerable role. The research studying the associated processes in different environments with different species assemblages is still limited. We conducted a two‐year seed sowing experiment to test whether a plant community in a low‐productive mountain snowbed is limited by seed or microsite availability and how these variables depend on natural grazing. In a factorial design, half of the plots received a mixture of seeds of fourteen species naturally occurring at the study site and above ground biomass was removed from half of the plots. These treatments were applied to plots with long term grazer exclosures and to plots accessible to grazers. Both sowing and biomass removal increased the number of seedlings, the species richness of seedlings and total species richness. The number of seedlings was higher in open plots than in exclosures in the second year. Both seedling richness and total species richness were higher in open plots. Seedling recruitment was negatively related to the amount of above ground biomass and positively to the initial species richness. These results suggest that even fairly low‐productive environments can be both seed and microsite limited and that these depend on grazing pressure. Natural grazing by mammal herbivores (e.g. lemmings and reindeer) favours species colonization and seedling emergence. Low‐productive mountain snowbeds are prone to colonization from the local species pool and even high species richness may not constrain ingression of new species.

The inselberg flora of Atlantic Central Africa. I. Determinants of species assemblages

AbstractAims To identify the relative contributions of environmental determinism, dispersal limitation and historical factors in the spatial structure of the floristic data of inselbergs at the local and regional scales, and to test if the extent of species spatial aggregation is related to dispersal abilities.Location Rain forest inselbergs of Equatorial Guinea, northern Gabon and southern Cameroon (western central Africa).Methods We use phytosociological relevés and herbarium collections obtained from 27 inselbergs using a stratified sampling scheme considering six plant formations. Data analysis focused on Rubiaceae, Orchidaceae, Melastomataceae, Poaceae, Commelinaceae, Acanthaceae, Begoniaceae and Pteridophytes. Data were investigated using ordination methods (detrended correspondence analysis, DCA; canonical correspondence analysis, CCA), Sørensen's coefficient of similarity and spatial autocorrelation statistics. Comparisons were made at the local and regional scales using ordinations of life‐form spectra and ordinations of species data.Results At the local scale, the forest‐inselberg ecotone is the main gradient structuring the floristic data. At the regional scale, this is still the main gradient in the ordination of life‐form spectra, but other factors become predominant in analyses of species assemblages. CCA identified three environmental variables explaining a significant part of the variation in floristic data. Spatial autocorrelation analyses showed that both the flora and the environmental factors are spatially autocorrelated: the similarity of species compositions within plant formations decreasing approximately linearly with the logarithm of the spatial distance. The extent of species distribution was correlated with their a priori dispersal abilities as assessed by their diaspore types.Main conclusions At a local scale, species composition is best explained by a continuous cline of edaphic conditions along the forest‐inselberg ecotone, generating a wide array of ecological niches. At a regional scale, these ecological niches are occupied by different species depending on the available local species pool. These subregional species pools probably result from varying environmental conditions, dispersal limitation and the history of past vegetation changes due to climatic fluctuations.

Can long-distance dispersal shape the local and regional species pool?

Long-distance dispersal events are irregular and their role in shaping plant diversity is often discussed and modeled but rarely studied experimentally. We mimicked long-distance dispersal experimentally by sowing eleven exotic and fourteen native species into a calcareous grassland community in Estonia. Exotic species were randomly chosen from the collection of 500 herbaceous species in the Botanical Garden of the Tartu University. All exotic species were able to complete their life-cycles under the climatic and edaphic conditions in the garden. Native species originated from open dry calcareous habitats in the surroundings of the study site, but did not occur in the experimental grassland. Seven exotic species and seven native species established during the first year. In the third year, there were still three exotic species with five premature individuals, and three sown native species with sixteen individuals in the plots. These results show that long-distance dispersal both within and between regions may have an impact on species composition in target plant communities. If relatively the best established exotic speciesPhyteuma scheuchzeri would be classified as casual, one may conclude that transition among introduction and casual stages corresponds to ten’ rule. The species richness of seedlings, taking both local and sown species into account, was higher in plots with higher native established plant species richness.

Assessing the relative importance of dispersal in plant communities using an ecoinformatics approach

Increased insight into the factors that determine the importance of dispersal limitation on species richness and species composition is of paramount importance for conservation and restoration ecology. One way to explore the importance of dispersal limitation is to use seed-sowing experiments, but these do not enable the screening of large sets of species and habitats. In the present paper we present a complementary approach based on comparing small plots with larger regions with regard to species composition and distribution of functional traits. We developed a GIS tool based on ecological and geographical criteria to quantify species pools at various spatial scales. In this GIS tool, containing floristic, large databases, phytosociological and functional information are exploited. Our premise is that differences in the nature of the species in local and regional species pools with regard to functional traits can give important clues to the processes at work in the assembly of communities. We illustrate the approach with a case study for mesotrophic hay meadows (Calthion palustris). We tested the effects of differences in frequency in the local Habitat Species Pool and differences in dispersal and persistence traits of species on local species composition. Our results show that both species pool effects and functional traits affect the probability of occurrence in small plots. Species with a high propagule weight have, given the frequency in the Local Habitat Species Pool, a lower probability of occurrence in small plots. The probability of local occurrence, however, is increased by the ability to form a persistent soil seed bank and by adult longevity. This provides support for the view that the degree of dispersal limitation is dependent on the degree of spatial isolation of the focal site relative to source populations and moreover that species inherently differ in the degree to which dispersal limitation is a limiting factor for local occurrence.

A transient expansion of sown plants and diaspore limitation

Dispersal limitation was studied in a species-rich meadow (53–65 species of vascular plants per 1.1 m2) to which a mixture of weeds was accidentally sown. Even if none of the sown species belonged to the local species pool, five species successfully established. Of them one persisted for 7 years, however declined from 41 individuals in 1995 to 1 individual recorded in 2001. These results can be interpreted as an evidence for short-term diaspore limitation. In contrast, long-term data indicate no diaspore limitation. Establishment of weeds in subplots with a lower number of species and individuals was higher than in other subplots, indicating that plant establishment in the studied open-canopy grassland is affected by the spatial pattern of present plants.

From null community to non‐randomly structured actual plant assemblages: parsimony analysis of species co‐occurrences

Null community is a spatio‐temporal abstraction of an initial regional species pool from which local species pools and actual community assemblages are organized. Any process that causes joint responses of species with similar susceptibilities affects community assembly. Through time, sequential assembly processes change the composition of a species pool in a way analogous to the one in which evolutionary processes promote character changes from an ancestor to current species. The segregation of species occurrences in an actual community suggests that assembly processes non‐randomly structured the observed community assemblages. However, going backwards to imply the causes of a particular arrangement of species is a non‐trivial challenge. I merge these premises with the philosophical and methodological foundations of cladistics. I propound parsimony analysis of species co‐occurrences as an outstanding means of devising operational hypotheses about the assembly of any non‐randomly structured set of actual community assemblages related to a common species pool. To explore this approach, I used field data gathered in a suite of 10 wetland assemblages. First, I tested independence of 101 plant species occurrences by a null model. As significant non‐random species co‐occurrence was detected, I applied a parsimony analysis taking the species occurrences as attributes, the assemblages as terminal units, and a putative null community constituted by all the present local species as the root of the assembly suite. The analysis produced four most parsimonious trees of assembly relationships. These trees maximize the number of similarities among community assemblages that can be explained by the sole fact of sharing a common regional species pool. One most parsimonious spatio‐temporal arrangement of species occurrence changes was reconstructed on one of the trees. I interpret this reconstruction in terms of assembly events, species exclusions and recruitments, showing the potentialities of this analysis to formulate operational hypotheses about community organization.

Host specialization and species richness of fruit flies (Diptera: Tephritidae) in a New Guinea rain forest

Frugivorous dacine fruit flies were studied in a lowland tropical rain forest in Papua New Guinea to determine their host specificity, abundance, and the number of species attacking various plant species. Plant species hosted 0–3 fruit fly species at median (1–3 quartile) densities of 1 (0–17) fruit flies per 100 fruits. Fruit flies were mostly specialized to a single plant family (83% species) and within each family to a single genus (88% species), while most of the species (66%) were able to feed on >1 congeneric plant species. Only 30 from the 53 studied plant species were colonized by fruit flies. The plant–fruit fly food web, including these 30 plant species and the total of 29 fruit fly species feeding on them, was divided into 14 compartments, each including 1–8 plant species hosting mutually disjunct assemblages of fruit flies. This structure minimizes indirect interactions among plant species via shared herbivores. The local species pool was estimated at 152±32 (±SE) fruit fly species. Forty per cent of all taxonomically described species known from Papua New Guinea were reared or trapped in our study area. Such a high proportion indicates low beta-diversity of fruit flies. Steiner traps were highly efficient in sampling the lure-responsive fruit fly species as they re-collected 84% of all species trapped in the same area 5 y before. Fruit fly monitoring by these traps is a cheap, simple and efficient method for the study of spatial and temporal changes in rain-forest communities.

Plant diversity in a managed temperate deciduous forest: understorey response to two silvicultural systems

Summary Disturbances and resource availability are key factors affecting plant diversity in managed forests. As disturbance regimes vary among silvicultural systems and may simultaneously affect different types of resources, effects on biodiversity can be unpredictable. We compared the effects of two silvicultural systems on understorey plant diversity, including species composition, structural attributes and functional organization. One hundred and thirty‐five phytosociological relevés were sampled from 27 forest stands managed under either a traditional coppice‐with‐standards (CWS, n = 12) or a ‘close‐to‐nature’ selective cutting system (SC, n = 15), over similar edaphic conditions. Important environmental factors affecting vegetation were deduced using Ellenberg indicator values. Structural diversity was described using traditional indices of α and β diversity. Guilds were defined within the local pool of species using a set of 14 traits and their relationship with silviculture was assessed using correspondence analysis. Post‐logged CWS stands share some compositional and structural characteristics with selectively cut stands, including high species richness and a dominance of early successional species. However the species pool for all coppicing areas was higher than for selectively cut areas, suggesting that the high disturbance frequency occurring in the latter may progressively eliminate the most sensitive species. Functional diversity strongly differs between the two systems. Although it is conserved through the silvicultural cycle in the coppice‐with‐standards system, some guilds were lacking in selectively cut stands. The most negatively impacted guilds were tree and shrub saplings, prostrated ruderals, shade‐tolerant perennials and vernal geophytes. The latter two comprise ‘true forest species’ which may also be considered as ‘coppicing‐maintained species’. To reach the same values of guild richness (i.e. number of guilds) or redundancy (i.e. proportion of the maximal species richness within each guild), larger areas were required in SC compared with CWS systems. In the SC system, the high proportion of light reaching the forest floor induced a spectacular spread of blackberries Rubus fruticosus agg., which decreased species richness. It also caused shifts in guild composition: graminoids and ferns grew strongly to the detriment of true forest species. Synthesis and applications. Our results suggest long‐term negative effects of selective cutting on both structural and functional plant diversity, compared with coppice‐with‐standards. Cutting intervals are shorter than recovery times, so that early successional species‐dominated communities are maintained. Vernal geophytes and shade‐tolerant perennials seem to be limited by the frequency of disturbance rather than by the severity of disturbance. We conclude that, from a biodiversity point of view, this ‘close‐to‐nature’ system does not cope with the objective of sustainable forest management. The rotations currently in use do not match natural disturbances very closely and are applied to a managed system rather than a natural forest. Retaining remnants of old coppice woods and extending rotations to at least 50 years are recommended where biodiversity conservation is a goal of forest management.