Liquid-state Dynamic Nuclear Polarization Research Articles

Overhauser enhanced liquid state nuclear magnetic resonance spectroscopy in one and two dimensions

Nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) is fundamental in the natural sciences, from chemical analysis and structural biology, to medicine and physics. Despite its enormous achievements, one of its most severe limitations is the low sensitivity, which arises from the small population difference of nuclear spin states. Methods such as dissolution dynamic nuclear polarization and parahydrogen induced hyperpolarization can enhance the NMR signal by several orders of magnitude, however, their intrinsic limitations render multidimensional hyperpolarized liquid-state NMR a challenge. Here, we report an instrumental design for 9.4 Tesla liquid-state dynamic nuclear polarization that enabled enhanced high-resolution NMR spectra in one and two-dimensions for small molecules, including drugs and metabolites. Achieved enhancements of up to two orders of magnitude translate to signal acquisition gains up to a factor of 10,000. We show that hyperpolarization can be transferred between nuclei, allowing DNP-enhanced two-dimensional 13C–13C correlation experiments at 13C natural abundance. The enhanced sensitivity opens up perspectives for structural determination of natural products or characterization of drugs, available in small quantities. The results provide a starting point for a broader implementation of DNP in liquid-state NMR.

Large 31P-NMR enhancements in liquid state dynamic nuclear polarization through radical/target molecule non-covalent interaction.

Dynamic nuclear polarization (DNP) is a method to enhance the low sensitivity of nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) via spin polarization transfer from electron spins to nuclear spins. In the liquid state, this process is mediated by fast modulations of the electron-nuclear hyperfine coupling and its efficiency depends strongly on the applied magnetic field. A peculiar case study is triphenylphosphine (PPh3) dissolved in benzene and doped with BDPA radical because it gives 31P-NMR signal enhancements of two orders of magnitude up to a magnetic field of 14.1 T. Here we show that the large 31P enhancements of BDPA/PPh3 in benzene at 1.2 T (i) decrease when the moieties are dissolved in other organic solvents, (ii) are strongly reduced when using a nitroxide radical, and (iii) vanish with pentavalent 31P triphenylphosphine oxide. Those experimental observations are rationalized with numerical calculations based on density functional theory that show the tendency of BDPA and PPh3 to form a weak complex via non-covalent interaction that leads to large hyperfine couplings to 31P (ΔAiso ≥ 13 MHz). This mechanism is hampered in other investigated systems. The case study of 31P-DNP in PPh3 is an important example that extends the current understanding of DNP in the liquids state: non-covalent interactions between radical and target can be particularly effective to obtain large NMR signal enhancements.

THz-enhanced dynamic nuclear polarized liquid spectrometer

Dynamic nuclear polarization (DNP) technology can be utilized to dramatically enhance NMR signal. In this paper, we report on the development of a self-constructed 5 T DNP spectrometer for liquid samples and the 13C DNP enhancement achieved with this spectrometer. The DNP spectrometer is comprised of a wide-bore superconducting magnet, a home-made console, a dual resonance probe and a self-built 140 GHz microwave source for the spectrometer. Specifically, a microwave source of traveling wave tube (TWT) amplifier has been developed, which can provide a maximum power output of 4.4 W and a wide frequency tuning range of 1 GHz. The excellent performance of our built liquid-state DNP spectrometer is verified by the observation of more than 100-fold DNP enhancement of the 13C NMR signal for liquid 13CCl4 sample. Our result shows the superiority of DNP technology in the liquid-state high-field NMR spectrometer.

Challenges and Advances in the Application of Dynamic Nuclear Polarization to Liquid-State NMR Spectroscopy.

Nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) spectroscopy is a powerful method to study the molecular structure and dynamics of materials. The inherently low sensitivity of NMR spectroscopy is a consequence of low spin polarization. Hyperpolarization of a spin ensemble is defined as a population difference between spin states that far exceeds what is expected from the Boltzmann distribution for a given temperature. Dynamic nuclear polarization (DNP) can overcome the relatively low sensitivity of NMR spectroscopy by using a paramagnetic matrix to hyperpolarize a nuclear spin ensemble. Application of DNP to NMR can result in sensitivity gains of up to four orders of magnitude compared to NMR without DNP. Although DNP NMR is now more routinely utilized for solid-state (ss) NMR spectroscopy, it has not been exploited to the same degree for liquid-state samples. This Review will consider challenges and advances in the application of DNP NMR to liquid-state samples. The Review is organized into four sections: (i) mechanisms of DNP NMR relevant to hyperpolarization of liquid samples; (ii) applications of liquid-state DNP NMR; (iii) available detection schemes for liquid-state samples; and (iv) instrumental challenges and outlook for liquid-state DNP NMR.

Nitroxide Derivatives for Dynamic Nuclear Polarization in Liquids: The Role of Rotational Diffusion.

Polarization transfer efficiency in liquid-state dynamic nuclear polarization (DNP) depends on the interaction between polarizing agents (PAs) and target nuclei modulated by molecular motions. We show how translational and rotational diffusion differently affect the DNP efficiency. These contributions were disentangled by measuring 1H-DNP enhancements of toluene and chloroform doped with nitroxide derivatives at 0.34 T as a function of either the temperature or the size of the PA. The results were employed to analyze 13C-DNP data at higher fields, where the polarization transfer is also driven by the Fermi contact interaction. In this case, bulky nitroxide PAs perform better than the small TEMPONE radical due to structural fluctuations of the ring conformation. These findings will help in designing PAs with features specifically optimized for liquid-state DNP at various magnetic fields.

Photo-induced radical polarization and liquid-state dynamic nuclear polarization using fullerene nitroxide derivatives.

We report on radical polarization and optically-driven liquid DNP using nitroxide radicals functionalized by photoexcitable fullerene derivatives. Pulse laser excitation of the fullerene moiety leads to transient nitroxide radical polarization that is one order of magnitude larger than that at the Boltzmann equilibrium. The life time of the radical polarization increases with the size of the fullerene derivative and is correlated with the electronic spin-lattice relaxation time T1e. Overhauser NMR signal enhancements of toluene solvent protons were observed under steady-state illumination, which replaced microwave irradiation.

Simultaneous acquisition of multi-nuclei enhanced NMR/MRI by solution-state dynamic nuclear polarization

Dynamic nuclear polarization (DNP) has become a very important hyperpolarization method because it can dramatically increase the sensitivity of nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) of various molecules. Liquid-state DNP based on Overhauser effect is capable of directly enhancing polarization of all kinds of nuclei in the system. The combination of simultaneous Overhauser multi-nuclei enhancements with the multi-nuclei parallel acquisitions provides a variety of important applications in both MR spectroscopy (MRS) and image (MRI). Here we present two simple illustrative examples for simultaneously enhanced multi-nuclear spectra and images to demonstrate the principle and superiority. We have observed very large simultaneous DNP enhancements for different nuclei, such as 1H and 23Na, 1H and 31P, 19F and 31P, especially for the first time to report sodium ion enhancement in liquid. We have also obtained the simultaneous images of 19H and 31P, 19F and 31P at low field by solution-state DNP for the first time.

Liquid state DNP at high magnetic fields: Instrumentation, experimental results and atomistic modelling by molecular dynamics simulations

Dynamic nuclear polarization (DNP) at high magnetic fields has recently become one of the major research areas in magnetic resonance spectroscopy and imaging. Whereas much work has been devoted to experiments where the polarization transfer from the electron spin to the nuclear spin is performed in the solid state, only a few examples exist of experiments where the polarization transfer is performed in the liquid state. Here we describe such experiments at a magnetic field of 9.2 T, corresponding to a nuclear Larmor frequency of 400MHz for proton spins and an excitation frequency of 263GHz for the electron spins. The technical requirements to perform such experiments are discussed in the context of the double resonance structures that we have implemented. The experimental steps that allowed access to the enhancement factors for proton spins of several organic solvents with nitroxide radicals as polarizing agents are described. A computational scheme for calculating the coupling factors from molecular dynamics (MD) simulations is outlined and used to highlight the limitations of the classical models based on translational and rotational motion that are typically employed to quantify the observed coupling factors. The ability of MD simulations to predict enhancements for a variety of radicals and solvent molecules at any magnetic field strength should prove useful in optimizing experimental conditions for DNP in the liquid state.

Optimization and prediction of the electron-nuclear dipolar and scalar interaction in 1H and 13C liquid state dynamic nuclear polarization.

During the last 10-15 years, dynamic nuclear polarization (DNP) has evolved as a powerful tool for hyperpolarization of NMR and MRI nuclides. However, it is not as well appreciated that solution-state dynamic nuclear polarization is a powerful approach to study intermolecular interactions in solution. For solutions and fluids, the 1H nuclide is usually dominated by an Overhauser dipolar enhancement and can be significantly increased by decreasing the correlation time (τc) of the substrate/nitroxide interaction by utilizing supercritical fluids (SF CO2). For molecules containing the ubiquitous 13C nuclide, the Overhauser enhancement is usually a profile of both scalar and dipolar interactions. For carbon atoms without an attached hydrogen, a dipolar enhancement usually dominates as we illustrate for sp2 hybridized carbons in the fullerenes, C60 and C70. However, the scalar interaction is dependent on a Fermi contact interaction which does not have the magnetic field dependence inherent in the dipolar interaction. For a comprehensive range of molecular systems we show that molecules that exhibit weakly acidic complexation interaction(s) with nitroxides provide corresponding large scalar enhancements. For the first time, we report that sp hybridized (H-C) alkyne systems, for example, the phenylacetylene-nitroxide system exhibit very large scalar dominated enhancements. Finally, we demonstrate for a wide range of molecular systems that the Fermi contact interaction can be computationally predicted via electron-nuclear hyperfine coupling and correlated with experimental 13C DNP enhancements.

Liquid state dynamic nuclear polarization of ethanol at 3.4 T (95 GHz)

Dynamic Nuclear Polarization (DNP) in the liquid state has become the focus of attention to improve the NMR sensitivity of mass limited samples. The Overhauser model predicts a fast reduction in DNP enhancement at high magnetic fields where the electron Larmor frequency exceeds the typical inverse correlation time of the magnetic interaction between an unpaired electron spin of a radical and proton spins of the solvent molecules. The Overhauser hard sphere model is able to predict quantitatively the DNP enhancement for water TEMPOL solutions. The increase in temperature due to dielectric heating of the sample acts to reduce the correlation times and allows a substantial Overhauser DNP. In this paper we extend the work done on water towards other small molecules, such as ethanol. Experimentally we observe a similar enhancement for all three proton groups in the ethanol molecule. The classical interpretation of the low field Overhauser experiments on ethanol invokes a very fast anisotropic rotation of the hydrogen bonded TEMPOL-ethanol complex to explain the fast relaxation of the OH proton. Here we will discuss W-band relaxation and DNP enhancement within this classical model. Although the description can be made quantitative, the invoked parameters do not seem to be realistic. We will propose an alternative model based on the dynamic interaction both in free collision and due to modulation of the hydrogen bond length of the complex.

Liquid state Dynamic Nuclear Polarization probe with Fabry–Perot resonator at 9.2 T

Recent achievements in liquid state DNP at high magnetic fields showing significant enhancements on aqueous solutions have initiated strong interest in possible applications of this method to biomolecular research. However, in situ DNP of biomolecules at ambient temperatures is a challenging task due to high microwave losses leading to excessive sample heating. To avoid such heating the sample volume has to be reduced strongly to keep it away from the electric component of the microwave field. A helical double resonance structure, used for the first demonstrations of the applicability of Overhauser DNP to aqueous solutions at high magnetic fields (9.2T), restricted the sample size to a very small volume of 2nl. Together with a poor spectral resolution this resulted in small overall signal amplitude, hampering observations of biomolecules. Here we present a new type of the double resonance structure for liquid-state DNP which consists of a Fabry–Perot resonator for the microwave excitation and a stripline resonator for the NMR detection. This new double resonance structure (260GHz/400MHz) offers a 30-fold increase in aqueous sample volume (80nl) with respect to the helical probe and exhibits improved NMR sensitivity and linewidth.

Solution NMR of Polypeptides Hyperpolarized by Dynamic Nuclear Polarization

Hyperpolarization of nuclear spins through techniques such as dynamic nuclear polarization (DNP) can greatly increase the signal-to-noise ratio in NMR measurements, thus eliminating the need for signal averaging. This enables the study of many dynamic processes which would otherwise not be amenable to study by NMR spectroscopy. A report of solid- to liquid-state DNP of a short peptide, bacitracin A, as well as of a full-length protein, L23, is presented here. The polypeptides are hyperpolarized at low temperature and dissolved for NMR signal acquisition in the liquid state in mixtures of organic solvent and water. Signal enhancements of 300-2000 are obtained in partially deuterated polypeptide when hyperpolarized on (13)C and of 30-180 when hyperpolarized on (1)H. A simulated spectrum is used to identify different resonances in the hyperpolarized (13)C spectra, and the relation between observed signal enhancement for various groups in the protein and relaxation parameters measured from the hyperpolarized samples is discussed. Thus far, solid- to liquid-state DNP has been used in conjunction with small molecules. The results presented here, however, demonstrate the feasibility of hyperpolarizing larger proteins, with potential applications toward the study of protein folding or macromolecular interactions.

Quantitative analysis of high field liquid state dynamic nuclear polarization

Dynamic Nuclear Polarization (DNP) in the liquid state has become the focus of attention to improve the NMR sensitivity of mass limited samples. The Overhauser model predicts a fast reduction in DNP enhancement at high magnetic fields where the Electron Larmor frequency exceeds the typical inverse correlation time of the magnetic interaction between a radical spin and proton spins of the water molecules. Recent experiments have shown that an appreciable DNP enhancement in the liquid state is possible also at magnetic fields of 3 to 9 Tesla. At present it is not clear whether the Overhauser model needs to be adapted to explain these results. In the present paper we aim to resolve this question by a combination of in situ temperature dependent NMR relaxation measurements, EPR and DNP experiments. Enhancement factors of up to -165 are obtained with microwave powers below 500 mW. We conclude that at 3.4 Tesla (95 GHz) the various measurements are consistent with each other and in quantitative agreement with Overhauser theory. Microwave heating of the sample does play an important role to reduce the correlation times and allow a substantial Overhauser DNP. The typical enhancement factors may allow new applications in microfluidic NMR.

Pushing the limit of liquid-state dynamic nuclear polarization at high field

Dynamic nuclear polarization in the liquid state was predicted more than 50 years ago by Overhauser. Its application for NMR sensitivity enhancement has been limited because of intrinsic and experimental problems to apply this method at high magnetic fields. Here we report on 95 GHz DNP experiments using the common TEMPO radical dissolved in water. In an efficient non-radiative microwave resonator, we observe average experimental enhancement factors up to -65. The local enhancement in the center of the resonator is calculated to reach a level of -94 at the highest microwave power. At high microwave power, the DNP enhancement shows a linear increase with no tendency to saturation. The results indicate that a substantial sensitivity enhancement is possible for liquid state NMR in nL sample volumes.

Liquid state DNP using a 260 GHz high power gyrotron

Dynamic nuclear polarization (DNP) at high magnetic fields (9.2 T, 400 MHz (1)H NMR frequency) requires high microwave power sources to achieve saturation of the EPR transitions. Here we describe the first high-field liquid-state DNP results using a high-power gyrotron microwave source (20 W at 260 GHz). A DNP enhancement of -29 on water protons was obtained for an aqueous solution of Fremy's Salt; in comparison the previous highest value was -10 using a solid-state microwave power source (maximum power 45 mW). The increased enhancements are partly due to larger microwave saturation and elevated sample temperature. These experimentally observed DNP enhancements, which by far exceed the predicted values extrapolated from low-field DNP experiments, demonstrate experimentally that DNP is possible in the liquid state also at high magnetic fields.

Dynamic nuclear polarization of water by a nitroxide radical: rigorous treatment of the electron spin saturation and comparison with experiments at 9.2 Tesla

The interaction between nuclear and electronic spins is of interest for structural characterization of biomolecules and biomedical imaging based on nuclear magnetic resonance. The polarization of the nuclear spins can be increased significantly if the electron spin polarization is kept out of equilibrium. We employ semiclassical relaxation theory to analyze the electronic polarization of the two-spin system characteristic of nitroxide radicals. Atomistic molecular dynamics simulations of the nitroxide TEMPOL in water are performed to account for the effects of tumbling and spin-rotation coupling on the spin-spin and spin-lattice relaxation times. Concentration effects on the electron saturation are introduced by allowing for Heisenberg spin exchange between two nitroxides. Polarization enhancement profiles, calculated from the computed saturation, are directly compared with liquid-state dynamic nuclear polarization experiments conducted at 260 GHz/400 MHz. The contribution of the separate hyperfine lines to the saturation can be easily disentangled using the developed formalism.

High-Field DNP Spectrometer for Liquids

The construction of a prototype 400 MHz/260 GHz (9.2 T) liquid-state dynamic nuclear polarization (DNP) spectrometer is described. For this purpose a 400 MHz Bruker Avance nuclear magnetic resonance spectrometer was extended with a 260 GHz microwave setup including microwave sources (45 mW continuous-wave and 200 mW pulsed output power), a metal-dielectric waveguide transmission system for decoupling of microwave excitation and reflection, which can also be used for electron paramagnetic resonance (EPR) detection, and special double-resonance structures which have been developed to avoid microwave heating of aqueous samples during DNP experiments. Microwave performance and first EPR and DNP applications on nitroxide radicals in water at room temperature are presented.

First DNP Results from a Liquid Water-TEMPOL Sample at 400 MHz and 260 GHz

Using a newly designed liquid-state dynamic nuclear polarization (DNP) spectrometer operating at a magnetic field of 9.2 T, a DNP enhancement of −4.0(1) was achieved for protons in a liquid water-TEMPOL sample. The DNP mechanism was observed to be the Overhauser effect, where the polarization was transfered via electron–proton dipolar relaxation. At full microwave power, the sample was heated by 17 K above room temperature, causing a significant increase in the DNP enhancement. These first results from the Frankfurt liquid-state DNP spectrometer represent a significant step towards the application of DNP to large biomolecules in the liquid state.