Reconstruction of upper lip defects can be challenging even for experienced surgeons. In order to restore both function and morphology, the use of quality soft tissue is essential. To this effect, the most common solution is the use of local flaps, or, in extreme situations, a free flap. However, a thin cutaneous upper lip defect may require a different approach. Perforator flaps are versatile and may allow an efficient reconstruction of soft tissue defects using adjacent similar tissues, providing the benefit of "like with like" coverage. We present the case of a 41-year-old female with a 1 × 1.5 cm basal cell carcinoma of the right-side upper lip, initially treated with a full thickness skin graft. Due to poor aesthetic and functional result, a thin submental artery perforator (SMAP) flap reconstruction was performed. Flaps' dimensions were 6 cm long and 4 cm wide and it was based on a perforator arising from the submental artery. Dissection was conducted above the platysma muscle, and the SMAP flap was transferred into the defect through a subcutaneous tunnel created below the mandible and posterior to the anterior belly of digastric muscle. The pedicle length of 6.5 cm was adequate for a tension free inset of the flap. Postoperative course was uneventful and the patient was discharged after 2 days. The 4-month follow-up showed a satisfying functional and aesthetic outcome with a concealed donor site scar. This report points out the coverage potential of the thin SMAP flap, which can be successfully used for a harmonious reconstruction in both color and texture of the upper lip.