Limiting Dilution Cultures Research Articles

Anti-Idiotypic Network Induced by T Cell Vaccination Against Experimental Autoimmune Encephalomyelitis

In a study of the mechanism of resistance to autoimmune disease induced by T cell vaccination, rats were vaccinated against experimental autoimmune encephalomyelitis (EAE) by injecting them once in the hind footpads with a subencephalitogenic dose (10(4)) of a clone of T lymphocytes specific for myelin basic protein (BP). The response to vaccination was assayed by challenging the rats with an encephalitogenic dose (3 X 10(6)) of T lymphocytes of this BP-specific clone. Five to six days after vaccination, the cells responsible for mediating resistance to adoptively transferred EAE were concentrated in the popliteal lymph nodes draining the vaccination site. Transfer of the draining lymph node cells to unvaccinated rats led to loss of resistance in the donor rats and acquisition of resistance by the recipient rats. Limiting-dilution cultures of the draining lymph node cells were established with irradiated cells of the BP-specific clone as stimulators. Two sets of T lymphocytes specifically responsive to the BP-specific T cells from the clone were isolated: CD4+CD8- helper and CD4-CD8+ suppressor cells. The helper T cells, like the BP antigen, specifically stimulated the BP-specific vaccinating clone. In contrast, the suppressor T cells specifically suppressed the response of the BP-specific vaccinating clone to its BP antigen. These results suggest that T cell vaccination induces resistance to autoimmune disease by activating an antiidiotypic network.

Trinitrobenzenesulphonic acid-induced unresponsiveness at the systemic level.

To investigate the mechanism underlying B-cell tolerance, which is still discussed as being the consequence of (functional) clonal deletion or suppression, limiting dilution (LD) analysis of the frequencies of B cells as well as regulatory cells after tolerance induction with trinitrobenzenesulphonic acid (TNBS) was performed. It was shown that the frequency of functionally active hapten-specific B cells was decreased to less than 10% of the frequency in untreated BALB/c mice. After an immunogenic challenge, trinitrophenyl (TNP)-specific B cells of tolerized mice expanded, but did not reach the level of TNP-specific B cells in untreated mice. The expansion of TNP-specific B cells in TNBS-tolerized mice after challenge with TNP-horse red blood cells (HRBC) as observed in LD cultures was in contrast to the absence of anti-TNP plaque-forming cells (PFC) in freshly harvested spleen cells (SC) and the non-detectability of anti-TNP antibodies (AB). Hence, the functional deletion (= anergy) of B cells in vivo appears to be sustained by regulatory cells. Analysis of the regulatory compartment revealed that tolerance induction resulted in transient augmentation of TNP-specific helper T cells (TH), continuously elevated levels of suppressor T cells (TS), and a low level of contrasuppressor T cells (TCS). But, contrary to non-tolerized mice, TCS of tolerized mice were rather refractory to stimulation with TNP-HRBC. Hence, we would like to hypothesize that clonal anergy of B cells leads to inappropriate activation of TCS, whose nominal antigens are antibodies. This in turn sustains the persistence of high levels of TS, i.e. tolerance would be maintained by interruption of feedback activation of regulatory cells via effector cells/molecules.

Regulation of Carrier‐Specific Response via a Haptenic Epitope

Influences of haptenic epitopes on the regulation of carrier-specific responses are of importance in vaccination and heterogenization protocols. This situation was modelled by analysing the primary and secondary anti-horse red blood cell (HRBC) response under the influence of a haptenic epitope (trinitrophenol, TNP). Primary and secondary anti-HRBC responses were diminished in the presence of TNP. The primary response against the carrier was delayed in the presence of TNP and primary and secondary anti-carrier responses vanished more rapidly in response to TNP-HRBC than in response to HRBC. When frequencies of HRBC-specific B cells were determined under limiting dilution (LD) conditions, a lower frequency of HRBC-specific B cells was discovered in the presence of TNP-HRBC as compared to HRBC. Accordingly, after priming with HRBC, the frequency of B cells was increased by a factor of 49, while after priming with TNP-HRBC the frequency was only increased by a factor of 11. Furthermore, haptenic epitopes influenced the anti-carrier response via regulatory elements. Under physiological conditions, hapten-specific help was insufficient and hapten-specific B cells competed for carrier-specific helper T cells (TH). Suppression was more efficient in hapten-carrier-primed mice than in carrier-primed mice and in line with this observation, an increased frequency of suppressor T cells (Ts) was observed in LD cultures when TNP-HRBC instead of HRBC were used as antigen. It is concluded that haptenic epitopes are relevant for the anti-carrier response, since hapten-specific B cells compete for carrier-specific help, hapten-specific suppression down-regulates carrier-specific help, and the hapten may hide immunogenic epitopes of the carrier, resulting in incomplete activation of the B-cell repertoire.

Activation of autoreactive cytolytic T lymphocyte clone against human melanoma by anti-T3 monoclonal antibody and autologous accessory cells

A cytotoxic T-lymphocyte (CTL) clone Tc1.8 was derived in a limiting dilution culture from a single cell that was derived from melanoma-involved lymph node lymphocytes activated in in vitro coculture against the autologous melanoma cells (VIP). The clone Tc1.8 (T3+, T8+, T4−, and Leu7−) expressed restricted cytolytic activity against only the autologous target VIP. As it aged in continuous culture containing interleukin 2, Tc1.8 lost cytolytic activity. The cytolytic function could be restored, however, with monoclonal antibody (MoAb) against T3 (OKT3) or with F(ab′) 2 fractions of OKT3, and upon restimulation with irradiated accessory cells. OKT3-mediated reinduction of cytotoxicity by the aged Tc1.8 could not be achieved if the T3 molecules were modulated from the effector cell surface following overnight incubation of Tc1.8 with saturating concentrations of OKT3 MoAb. Following reactivation with OKT3 Tc1.8 gained cytolytic function against NK targets in addition to VIP. Reactivation with F(ab′) 2 fractions of OKT3 and with autologous accessory cells, however, maintained its restricted antigen fidelity. The NK-like activity of Tc1.8 upon reactivation with OKT3 resulted from conjugate formation between the activated Tc1.8 and NK targets via the activating ligand itself. Thus, upon stimulation with anti-T3 MoAb and with autologous accessory cells, independently, the autoreactivity could be restored in an aged and inactive CTL clone.

Role of natural killer (NK) cells in the production of the murine T lymphocyte allorecognition repertoire

Limiting dilution cultures of alloreactive (anti-H2K b) CTL were established from thymocyte or spleen cell pools of C3H/HeJ and their congenic bg/bg partner, or of SJL/J and their congenic bg/bg partner. CTL populations in these cultures were assayed for cross-reactive lysis of a panel of splenic Con A blasts of H2K bm mutant mice. There was some slight elevation of frequency of CTL p in the thymocyte lymphoid pool of bg/bg mice; more strikingly, the repertoire of anti-H2K b specificities was clearly altered in both strains in the bg/bg animals. There was apparently an increased diversity (more specificities represented at higher frequencies) in the thymocyte pool and a decreased diversity in the spleen cell CTL p pool in animals with the bg/bg marker. Similar shifts in the allorecognition repertoire of normal C3H/HeJ mice were produced by inoculation of neonatal mice with a rabbit anti-NK heteroantibody (antiasialo GM1). Preabsorption of this serum such that it lost anti-NK activity also abolished this effect of in vivo neonatal injection. Furthermore, injection of bg/bg bone marrow-reconstituted C3H/HeJ ( bg/+) mice with a C3H spleen cell-derived NK line also caused a shift in the allorecognition repertoire toward that seen in the normal littermate control animals.

Kinetics and specificity at the clonal level of the cytotoxic T lymphocyte response to influenza pneumonia.

We have studied the kinetics and specificity of the cytotoxic T lymphocyte (CTL) response to influenza A/PR/8 (H1N1) virus pulmonary infection in the mouse detected using spleen cells from infected mice which were stimulated in bulk and limiting dilution cultures. A hybrid protein designated D-peptide, which contains the terminal 157 amino acids of the HA2 subunit of A/PR/8 virus, was used to stimulate influenza virus subtype-specific secondary CTL in vitro. Infection induced two specificities of precursor CTL, cross-reactive and subtype-specific. The kinetics of the subtype-specific CTL response detected by the D-peptide were similar to the cross-reactive CTL response detected by stimulation with live virus. The majority of the precursor CTL (CTL-p) are able to lyse virus-infected target cells in a cross-reactive fashion. The number of memory subtype-specific and cross-reactive CTL increased by approximately 2.5 logs10 during the first 3 weeks after infection.

Antigen-presenting T cells. II. Clonal responses of alloreactive and virus-specific self-restricted human cytotoxic T cell responses stimulated by T lymphoblasts.

The capacity of various stimulator cell types to present alloantigens or viral antigens to resting human CD8+ cytotoxic lymphocyte precursors (CLP) was analyzed in a limiting dilution culture system. Cell sorter-separated T lymphoblasts of both CD4+ and CD8+ phenotypes but not resting T cells were found to efficiently stimulate the clonal development of allogeneic CD8+ CLP. Thus, 5000 CD4+ T lymphoblasts activated as many (one out of 200 to one out of 300) allogeneic CLP as 50,000 peripheral blood mononuclear stimulator cells. This potent stimulator activity was found in CD4+ and CD8+ T lymphoblasts activated by mitogen, anti-T3 monoclonal antibody, or mixed leukocyte reactions. Cytotoxic T cells generated in this system were highly specific for HLA class I antigens. Furthermore, T lymphoblasts infected with mumps virus efficiently induced development of autologous CLP into CTL clones that were virus specific and self-HLA restricted, as shown by split-well analysis. The possible in vivo significance of antigen-presenting T lymphoblasts is discussed.

Clonal activation of cytotoxic lymphocyte precursors by monoclonal anti-CD3 antibody: analysis of feeder cell requirements

Activation of cytotoxic lymphocyte precursors (CLP) by the mitogenic monoclonal anti-CD3 antibody OKT3 was studied under limiting dilution (LD) culture conditions. One out of 2–6 E-rosette-purified T cells gave rise to a cytotoxic T cell (CTL) clone when cultured in the presence of OKT3 (0.2–2 ng/ml), recombinant IL-2 (100 U/ml), and irradiated feeder cells. Clonal CLP activation was optimally supported by a combination of E-rosette-depleted non-T feeder cells with small numbers of T cells added back. Among the cell lines tested, Fc-receptor-bearing monocytic cell lines U937 and HL-60 were efficient feeder cells whereas T cell lines (Jurkat, Molt-4, Ke37) did not support clonal CLP activation. These data indicate that clonal activation of CLP and differentiation into cytotoxic effector cells under LD culture conditions are critically influenced by the type and number of feeder cells used.

Functional assessment of T cell depletion from bone marrow prior to therapeutic transplantation using limiting dilution culture methods.

We evaluate the usefulness of limiting dilution culture methods in assessing the extent of T lymphocyte depletion from bone marrow inocula, prior to transplant, using either ex vivo antibody/complement-mediated depletion or immunotoxin treatment. Complement-mediated depletion using anti-Leu-1 antibody was shown to result in a consistent decline of 99%-99.9% in the frequencies of T cells able to proliferate in mitogen-stimulated, interleukin-2 (IL-2)-supplemented cultures. Equivalent declines were demonstrated in frequencies of "helper" T cells able to respond to mitogen by making IL-2, and in "killer" T cells able to give rise to clones of cytotoxic effectors. In most experiments, a second cycle of anti-Leu-1 + complement treatment did not further diminish the fraction of proliferating cells, although T cells able to secrete IL-2 were additionally depleted following a second cycle of antibody and complement. The limiting dilution methods were found to be at least as sensitive as flow cytometric (FACS) methods for detecting residual T cell contamination after protocols involving complement-mediated lysis, and superior to FACS analysis for protocols involving T cell depletion by a ricin A chain-anti-T101 immunotoxin, in which treated T cells suffer functional impairment and eventual death after exposure to immunotoxin, but remain phenotypically detectable during FACS analysis. Although limiting dilution methods do not provide data as rapidly as FACS analyses, they do not require a cytofluorimeter, provide equal or greater sensitivity, and can assess functional impairment, for both helper and killer T cell sets, even in situations in which the depletion procedure does not lead to immediate cytolysis.

An in vitro model for clonal anergy in continuously growing antigen-specific B-cell lines

Two continuously growing nonmalignant B-cell lines specific for the hapten DNP have been used to study tolerance in developing B cells. These cell lines have previously been shown to consist of small cells without sIgM but with cytoplasmic μ chains, and mature sIgM- and sIgD-bearing cells. When the sIgM-negative cells are placed in culture, mature DNP-specific B cells begin to appear. The studies reported here have shown that when these cell lines were propagated in the presence of either 200 μg/ml or 1 mg/ml of the tolerogen DNP-MGG there was no inhibition of cell line growth as measured by thymidine incorporation, and no inhibition of receptor expression by maturing B cells. The cell line lymphocytes propagated in the presence of 200 μg/ml DNP-MGG for 7, 30, 45, or 60 days became tolerant and the tolerance persisted for at least 6 days after removal of DNP-MGG. However, tolerance was lost between 6 and 10 days after removal of DNP-MGG. Propagation of the cell lines for 30 days in either DNP-KLH or DNP-Ficoll produced the same results. Limiting dilution cultures of cell line lymphocytes made tolerant by growing them for 30 days in the presence of DNP-MGG demonstrated that there was a marked decrease in precursor frequency compared to controls. However, cell line lymphocytes made tolerant by a 48-hr incubation with DNP-MGG did not have a significant decrease in precusor frequency. These data suggest that tolerance induced by growing these cell lines in the presence of DNP-MGG is a valid in vitro model of tolerance in developing antigen-specific B cells. Tolerance induced in this model is consistent with the clonal anergy hypothesis, but requires the continued presence of DNP-MGG to maintain unresponsiveness. This suggests that clonal anergy can occur in B cells but may not be the sole mechanism of self tolerance for those antigens which are sequestered from the immune system.

Double isotype production by a neoplastic B cell line. I. Cellular and biochemical characterization of a variant of BCL1 that expresses and secretes both IgM and IgG1.

We have subcloned the in vitro-adapted murine B cell leukemia, BCL1.B1, to obtain a variant that expresses both IgM and IgG1. By fluorescence analysis, radioiodination, and immunoprecipitation of cell surface Ig, and by RIA of medium from limiting dilution cultures, we have shown that: (a) all the cells express and secrete both isotypes. The heavy chains of both IgG1 and IgM have the apparent molecular weights of membrane mu and gamma 1 chains; (b) both isotypes bear the same idiotype as determined by immunoprecipitation with antiidiotypic antibody, and both use the same VDJ rearrangement as shown by Southern blotting; and (c) the cells express the membrane and secreted forms of mRNA for both mu and gamma 1 but not gamma 2b or gamma 3. Taken together, the data suggest that all the cells are synthesizing, expressing on their surface, and secreting two isotypes that use the same VDJ rearrangement in the DNA and express the same serologically-defined idiotype. The molecular basis responsible for the production of the two isotypes in a single cell is the subject of the accompanying paper.

Antigen-specific and MHC-restricted Plasmodium falciparum-induced human T lymphocyte clones.

We established and analyzed human T lymphocyte clones induced by crude Plasmodium falciparum antigens of schizont-enriched asexual blood stages. Peripheral blood mononuclear cells (PBMC) were stimulated for 6 days with antigen, and the T cell blasts were separated and were transferred to limiting dilution cultures with antigen, irradiated PBMC, and recombinant interleukin 2. The following observations were made. Malaria antigen (M.Ag) induced similar proportions of T blasts in PBMC from infected individuals and noninfected controls, and the M.Ag-dependent clone frequencies (1/79 to 1/216) obtained with the blasts were similar. The majority of established clones derived from infected and noninfected subjects specifically recognized M.Ag and would not proliferate in response to red blood cells or autologous PBMC alone. They also required HLA class II determinant-compatible antigen-presenting (E-) cells. With three clones from one malaria patient, DR 1 or DR 5 specificities correlated with antigen presentation. Although T4+ and T8+ blasts were induced by M.Ag in PBMC, only T4 (Leu-3+) clones were obtained in our culture system. These clones secreted IL 2 in response to M.Ag. 4) Differential patterns of reactivity to native M.Ag, heat-stable antigens, and heat-precipitated antigens were exhibited by T cell clones, and the tested clones did not recognize Plasmodium berghei antigen. In conclusion, it is important with regard to previous observations on apparently nonspecific, mitogen-like effects of M.Ag in bulk T cell cultures that our results demonstrate specific recognition of P. falciparum by human T cells. The T cell clones obtained will be an important tool in the quest for a better understanding of the mechanisms involved in resistance to malaria infection.

Comparative analysis of infection and transformation of lymphocytes from African buffalo and Boran cattle with Theileria parva subsp. parva and T. parva subsp. lawrencei

This study compared infection and transformation of peripheral blood mononuclear cells (PBM) of Boran cattle and African buffalo in vitro to determine whether differences occurred which could account for the greater susceptibility of Boran cattle to infection with Theileria parva subsp. parva and T. parva subsp. lawrencei. PBM from buffalo and cattle had a similar percentage of cells which bound T. parva subsp. parva sporozoites (24 to 34%) and in which schizonts developed during the first week after infection (18 to 23%). Using a limiting dilution culture system, it was established, however, that a significantly higher proportion of cattle PBM transformed into continuously replicating cell lines after infection with T. parva subsp. parva than did buffalo PBM. The evidence suggests that the low capacity of T. parva subsp. parva to establish infections in buffalo compared with cattle is related to the lower frequency of buffalo cells which undergo transformation. With T. parva subsp. lawrencei, however, the frequency of transformation of buffalo PBM was higher than that for cattle PBM. The frequency of cells transformed by T. parva subsp. lawrencei, therefore, cannot account for the greater resistance of buffalo to infections with T. parva subsp. lawrencei. Buffalo must have other mechanisms, either innate or acquired, which control infection with T. parva subsp. lawrencei more efficiently than in cattle.

The Epstein-Barr virus-induced production of IgE by human B cells

B cells, isolated from the blood of healthy individuals and patients allergic to pollen, produced IgE when exposed to the human B-cell polyclonal activator, Epstein-Barr virus (EBV) in vitro and placed in culture. Secreted IgM and IgE were measured using immunoenzymatic assays. No difference was seen between healthy donors and allergic patients in the amount of IgE (or IgM) secreted. Cells were placed in limiting dilution cultures in order to determine the frequency of cells producing IgE or IgM (total and pollen specific) on exposure to EBV. Again, no significant differences in EBV-driven, B-cell precursor frequencies (PF) were seen between normal and allergic individuals. EBV-driven B-cell PF for total IgM and IgE, and pollen-specific IgM and IgE secretion, were 1 450 , 1 6500 , 1 83,000 , and <1 per 2,500,000, respectively, for cells from healthy donors, and 1 140 , 1 4000 , 1 56,000 and ≤1 per 2,000,000, respectively, for cells from allergic patients. We propose that the increased IgE levels seen in atopic individuals result solely from regulatory defects, rather than an increase in the frequency of B cells committed to the secretion of IgE.

Long-lasting deficit of functional T cell precursors in human bone marrow transplant recipients revealed by limiting dilution methods.

We have applied limiting dilution methods suitable for the estimation of mitogen-reactive helper (pHTL) and cytotoxic (pCTL) T cell frequencies to the analysis of immune function in patients 1 mo to 6 yr after allogeneic bone marrow transplantation (BMT). Although the majority of these patients have regained normal levels of Leu-3+ (helper) and Leu-2+ (killer/suppressor) cells by 6 to 12 mo after BMT as assessed by cytofluorimetry, the fraction of these cells that can function in limiting dilution cultures is substantially below normal levels in nearly all patients. Although some BMT patients eventually recover normal frequencies of pCTL and pHTL, values typically remain greatly depressed even in patients transplanted as many as 4 to 6 yr previously. In contrast, recovery of precursors able to proliferate (without expressing either helper or cytotoxic function) in response to phytohemagglutinin (PHA) and interleukin 2 occurs in many patients by 1 yr after transplant. In spite of the decreased frequency of functional precursor cells found after BMT, each precursor is capable of giving rise to the same amount of function at limiting dilutions as that produced by cells from normal controls. In many BMT patients, proliferation in conventional PHA-stimulated cultures returns to near-normal levels even though precursor frequencies remain low. The limiting dilution method is sensitive to residual immune dysfunction in BMT recipients not easily quantitated by other, more conventional techniques.

Regulation of cellular immune response against autologous human melanoma. II. Mechanism of induction and specificity of suppression.

The cytotoxic immune response in the peripheral blood lymphocytes (PBL) against an autologous malignant melanoma cell line, PJ-M, was found to be down-regulated in in vitro co-culture (IVC) selectively by unfractionated resident lymph node lymphocytes (derived from a lymph node infiltrated with the PJ-M melanoma cells) and T4+ as well as T8+ fractions of the resident lymph node-derived lymphocytes. In this study, the mechanism involved in, and the specificities of, cytotoxic immune response in this autologous system were examined at population and clonal levels. Resident lymph node lymphocytes were isolated from both involved and uninvolved lymph nodes from the same patient. Resident lymphocytes from both sources regulated the generation of cytotoxic immune response when both types of resident lymph node lymphocytes were further sensitized against the PJ-M cells in IVC and were expanded in interleukin 2 (IL 2). An IL 2-dependent homogeneous lymphocyte line (I-10:1) bearing the phenotype of a helper T cell (T4+) and a T4+ clone (I-10.3) of the I-10:1 line, established by limiting dilution culture, also down-regulated the generation of cytotoxic immune effector cells in the PBL in IVC against the PJ-M targets. The IL 2-dependent T4+ inducer line I-10:1 generated a functionally differentiated T8+ suppressor population(s) that, in turn, could abrogate cytotoxic response in fresh PBL in IVC against PJ-M cells. The inducer line I-10:1 and its subclone I-10.3 suppressed the generation of cytotoxic effector cells in the PBL in IVC selectively against the autologous PJ-M cells. Generation of cytotoxic allo-response in IVC was unaffected by the inducer lines. These results provide further evidence for the involvement of the regulatory network in cytotoxic immune response in an autologous human tumor system, and suggest a potential explanation for cytotoxic unresponsiveness against autologous melanoma cells.

Specificity of human natural killer cells in limiting dilution culture for determinants of herpes simplex virus type 1 glycoproteins

The frequency and specificity of human cells with natural killer (NK) cytotoxic activity for herpes simplex virus type 1 (HSV-1)-infected targets was measured by limiting dilution culture. The frequency of NK cell precursors (NK-p) reactive with HSV-1-infected cells was 2- to 11-fold higher than that of NK-p reactive with mock-infected cells. The frequency of NK-p reactive with infected target cells lacking viral glycoprotein C or presenting an antigenically altered glycoprotein B was approximately twofold lower than that with wild-type virus-infected cells. Specificity analysis demonstrated that NK cells with a high statistical probability of being monoclonal were reactive with either glycoprotein B or C. These results provide the first evidence that cells with human NK activity possess clonal specificity for HSV-1-infected target cells.

Epstein-Barr virus-induced IgE production in limiting dilution cultures of normal human B cells.

The induction of in vitro IgE production in human B cells from normal, nonatopic donors has been difficult and somewhat controversial. We report that IgE production is consistently observed in limiting dilution cultures of in vitro Epstein-Barr virus (EBV)-infected normal human B lymphocytes. The frequency of IgE-committed, EBV-responsive cells ranged from 1/810 to 1/10 000 B lymphocytes, and it was similar in peripheral (blood, tonsil) and central (bone marrow) tissue sites. Poisson distribution analysis of these limiting dilution cultures suggested that IgE-committed B cells comprise 0.1-1% of all EBV-responsive B lymphocytes.

Heterogeneity of EBV-transformable human B lymphocyte populations.

Although most human B cells express receptors for Epstein Barr virus (EBV), few (usually less than 1%) are readily transformed into B lymphoblastoid cell lines after exposure to EBV. Transformable cells previously have been found to be mostly resting B lymphocytes. We recently developed a limiting dilution culture system which permits the growth of EBV-transformed B lymphocytes with high efficiency. Because in this system up to over 30% of peripheral blood- or tonsil-derived B cells respond to EBV, we re-examined the properties of EBV-transformable cells. Frequencies of transformable lymphocytes were determined by Poisson analysis. EBV-susceptible B cells committed to IgM, IgG, or IgA secretion were found to occur in the range of 3 to 27, 0.1 to 6, and 0.1 to 5 per 100 B cells, respectively. Under our culture conditions, a major proportion of the IgM-committed cells derived from large lymphocytes which appeared to have entered the cell cycle. This population contains most of the EBV-responsive cells detected and, therefore, most of the additional cells responding in our culture system. In contrast, precursors of IgG- or IgA-producing lymphoblast lines were small cells with DNA contents typical for the G0/G1 phases of the cell cycle. Anti-immunoglobulin antibodies were used in panning experiments to separate B cell subpopulations which expressed different immunoglobulin isotypes on their surface. In limiting dilution cultures of these purified B lymphocytes subsets, it was found that virtually all precursors of IgM-producing cell lines expressed surface IgM (sIgM) before their infection and transformation by EBV. The "cloning efficiency" of positively selected, large sIgM+ cells approached 100%. In contrast, sIgG or sIgA were found only on cells committed to the production of IgG or IgA, respectively. The expression of sIgD was examined by using sequential panning procedures. Virtually all IgM-committed lymphocytes and a subset of cells committed to IgA secretion were found among the sIgD+ cells. The majority of cells committed to IgA production and all IgG-committed cells were found in the sIgD- B cell population. Our findings indicate that the EBV-susceptible B cell subset of normal lymphocytes is heterogeneous with respect to cell size, cell cycle, sIg determinants, and efficiency of transformation. On the basis of our findings and previous reports, we propose a model in which transformability is a B cell-inherent property. Factors unrelated to the virus but present in our culture system appear responsible for the enhanced vulnerability to viral transformation in some cells which entered into the cell cycle.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 400 WORDS)

T lymphocyte control of autoreactivity: analysis with human T cell clones and limiting dilution culture.

To investigate cellular mechanisms controlling activated autoreactive T lymphocytes, a limiting dilution system was established employing cloned autoreactive major histocompatibility complex class II specific lymphocytes (a2/7) as stimulator cells for autologous peripheral blood mononuclear cells. At low responder/stimulator ratios, cytotoxic effector cells were generated capable of lysing clone a2/7. Importantly, within the population of cells mediating autocytotoxic effector function, differential specificities were found to exist. The generation of such autocytotoxic T lymphocytes appears to be inhibited by an additional population of cells circulating at lower frequency suggesting that autoreactivity is controlled at distinct levels by discrete functional cellular subsets.