Abstract Background Cardiac troponin (cTn) is the preferred biomarker for the diagnosis of acute myocardial infarction due to its high sensitivity and specificity relative to other available cardiac markers. Accurate measurement is therefore paramount to proper risk stratification of patients. Analytical outliers and false positive results have been previously reported on various platforms though the exact cause remains unknown. These false positive test results may pose a risk for the misclassification of patients and lead to adverse clinical outcomes. We evaluated the performance of the Beckman Coulter Access high-sensitivity cTn I method by measuring the occurrence of analytical outliers between duplicate results and the false positivity rate (i.e., fliers). Methods We tested 2535 samples from 1879 patients in duplicate on the Beckman Coulter Access hs-cTn I assay. These specimens had initial troponin measurements above the gender-specific 99th percentile of the upper reference limit (URL) cutoff and were immediately aliquoted, re-centrifuged, and re-tested. Non-reproducible results (outliers) were defined as having a concentration difference between the replicates exceeding 10%. Critical outliers were defined as duplicate results with concentrations that differed by greater than 10% from the initial result and the second result was classified in a lower risk stratification category than the original result. Results Approximately 12% (305) of the positive samples tested in duplicate had a percent difference that was >10% and therefore did not meet the recommended precision requirements of the assay. Of these specimens, 33 (10.8%) were classified as critical outliers because the repeat test result crossed a critical decision limit threshold. For sixteen samples the risk classification for the patient was downgraded from high (>50 ng/L) to moderate risk (13–50 ng/L (F); 20–50 ng/L (M)). Seventeen false positive results were identified in which the patients were downgraded from the high to low risk category (<13 ng/L (F); <20 ng/L (M)). Nearly 85% of the samples identified as outliers were lithium heparinized plasma. Conclusion We evaluated the reproducibility of the Beckman Coulter Access hs-cTn I method across 11 hospitals in an integrated healthcare network to characterize the occurrence of analytical outliers and false positive results. Our data indicated an outlier rate of 12% (305/2535) for positive hs-cTn I results; however, the risk category only changed for 1.3% (33/2535) of positive troponin results upon repeat analysis. Overall the false positivity rate was determined to be <0.1% (n = 55 560).
Read full abstract