Samples from a cored petroleum exploration well drilled in Kingfisher County, Oklahoma were studied using a combination of organic carbon stable isotopes (δ13Corg), and specific elemental geochemical proxies, to determine the effects of paleoproductivity and detrital input on organic matter enrichment in the Mississippian Limestone interval of the Anadarko Shelf. Total organic carbon (TOC) values are between 0 and 2.1 wt %, with an average of 0.4 wt % in the studied interval of the core, while δ13Corg values were between −38.6‰ and −24.7‰ (average −28.3 ± 2.9‰). Elemental proxies of detrital input and paleoproductivity are not enriched above average carbonate values, suggesting that there was low nutrient contribution to the study area, and consequent low organic matter productivity during deposition of Mississippian Limestone sediments. Together, insights from our geochemical tools indicate that the Mississippian Limestone interval of the Anadarko Shelf is unlikely to have generated liquid hydrocarbons because of lack of heightened productivity, and the largely terrestrial nature of organic matter preserved within the unit.