Lightning Impulse Breakdown Voltage Research Articles

Impact of Electrode Distance in a Quasi-Uniform Model Electrode System on Lightning Impulse Breakdown Voltage in Various Insulating Liquids

This study presents findings on the influence of gap length distance on the lightning impulse breakdown voltage of three dielectric liquids of different chemical origins. The liquids were tested in a model electrode system with a quasi-uniform electric field distribution and a pressboard plate placed on the grounded electrode. The experimental studies were supported using calculations and simulations to show the individual relationships between the lightning impulse breakdown voltage and gap distance, which represent the so-called volume effect of the most stressed liquid. The results of the experiment, which involved four considered gap distances of 2, 4, 6, and 8 mm, show that a dynamic increase in lightning impulse breakdown voltage with an increase in gap distance is associated with mineral oil and bio-based hydrocarbons. However, similar trends were not observed for synthetic ester. Calculations that allowed us to assess the impact of gap length distance on lightning impulse breakdown voltage support the observations from the experimental studies. The curves obtained in this field can be considered in the process of designing insulating systems for transformers.

Lightning impulse breakdown behavior of natural ester and modified natural ester under long oil gap: An experiment and first-principles simulation analysis

The investigation of lightning impulse (LI) breakdown characteristics in long oil gaps with insulating liquids is of utmost importance for the design of high-voltage, large-capacity transformers. This study focuses on analyzing the negative LI breakdown characteristics of two types of insulating oils, namely high viscosity natural ester soybean oil (SO) and low viscosity modified natural ester palm fatty acid ester (PFAE), under long oil gap conditions. The research includes testing and analyzing the voltage and current waveforms, LI breakdown voltage, and streamer discharge development speed of these liquids across oil gaps ranging from 25 mm to 105 mm. The findings demonstrate that the breakdown voltage of both insulating oils tends to increase as the oil gap distance widens. At a 25 mm gap, the average breakdown voltage of PFAE is not significantly different from that of SO. However, at a 105 mm gap, the average breakdown voltage of PFAE surpasses that of SO by 46.29%. Weibull distribution analysis is applied to the LI breakdown voltage data of the two insulating liquids, resulting in empirical formulas for breakdown voltage as a function of oil gap width at failure probabilities of 1%, 50%, and 90%. The discharge development rate of PFAE is lower than that of SO, especially in the oil gap of 105 mm. With the increase of the oil gap, the streamer development rate of the two insulating oils showed a trend of increasing. Using density functional theory based on first principles, the study investigates changes and discrepancies in parameters such as ionization potential, electron affinity, softness, excitation energy, and molecular surface electrostatic potential of the two insulating liquids with varying electric field strengths. The atomic and molecular scale analysis reveals the primary factors contributing to the contrasting macroscopic lightning shock breakdown characteristics of SO and PFAE. The comprehensive combination of experimental and simulation results suggests that PFAE exhibits greater potential for implementation in high-voltage, large-capacity transformers compared to SO. This study aims to bridge the gap in knowledge regarding the LI breakdown characteristics of different natural esters in long oil gaps. The experimental and theoretical findings presented in this paper provide a foundation for the practical application of natural esters and modified natural esters in high-voltage and large-capacity transformers.

Atomic scale microparameter analysis of modified natural ester molecules related to impulse discharge characteristics under electric field

Modified natural ester (MNE) has significant potential for application in transformers as an environmentally friendly and renewable energy source. In comparison to natural esters, MNE offers notable advantages in terms of viscosity and power frequency breakdown voltage. However, the lightning impulse breakdown characteristics of MNE and the atomic-scale microscopic mechanisms related to its discharge characteristics remain unclear. Understanding the lightning impulse breakdown characteristics of MNE is crucial for ensuring the safe operation of transformers. In this paper, the density functional theory is used to calculate the change law of the microscopic parameters related to the discharge characteristics of MNE under the electric field under the action of electric field, so as to theoretically evaluate the lightning impulse discharge behavior of MNE. The results reveal that the electronic and geometric structures of MNE molecules are influenced by electric fields, which is the primary factor contributing to the variations in microscopic parameters under different electric field strengths. As the electric field intensity increases, the dipole moment of MNE tends to increase, while the ionization potential and excitation energy of MNE tend to decrease. The decrease of ionization potential, excitation energy and energy gap of MNE molecules is about 6.61%–68.01%, 4.34%–47.66% and 2.01%–69.23%. By comparing the calculated results of mineral oil, natural ester, and MNE microparameters, it can be inferred that the lightning impulse breakdown behavior of MNE is similar to that of natural ester and lightning impulse breakdown voltage of MNE is higher than that of natural ester but still lower than that of mineral oil. The average negative polarity lightning impulse voltages of MNE, natural ester and mineral oil in the 85 mm oil gap are about 245 kV, 199 kV and 304 kV, respectively. The test results confirmed the simulation conclusions. This study provides robust theoretical support for understanding the lightning impulse breakdown characteristics of MNE and ensuring its safe operation in transformers.

Statistical analysis and interpretation on lightning impulse breakdown voltages of ester liquids under varying field uniformity

AbstractEster liquids (ELs), as the alternative transformer liquids to the conventional mineral oils (MOs), have been increasingly used in power transformers with high voltage ratings. Among various properties, the lightning impulse breakdown voltages (LIBDVs) have been studied elaborately in the past two decades under different electric field uniformities. The electric field uniformities do have an effect on the breakdown characteristics, for example, breakdown mechanisms, polarity effects, and differences of LIBDV between ELs and MOs, which is quantitatively investigated based on the LIBDVs collected from the literatures. The breakdown mechanism transition phenomenon between streamer initiation dominated breakdown and streamer propagation dominated breakdown has been reviewed firstly. Then, the transition field factor boundaries to observe the polarity effect on LIBDVs are taken at around 20 for ELs and 10 for MOs. Besides, the transition field factor boundaries to observe the LIBDV distinctions between ELs and MOs are about 109 and 14 under positive and negative lightning impulse, respectively. The systematic analysis and interpretation on the transition field factor boundaries among different phenomena can provide insights on insulation design of ELs filled power transformers.

Prebreakdown and Breakdown Behavior of Low Pour Point Dielectric Liquids Under Negative Lightning Impulse Voltage

In this paper, some investigations on the prebreakdown and breakdown phenomena of low pour point insulating liquids under negative lightning impulse voltage are reported. The tested liquids include mineral oil, a typical synthetic ester, and two low pour point synthetic esters. These liquids underwent accelerated thermal aging. The non-aged and aged samples were subjected to lightning impulses using a point-plane electrode arrangement. The discussions are focused on the initiation of partial discharges, propagation of streamers, and breakdown behaviour in the non-aged and aged liquids. The investigated parameters include inception voltage, lightning impulse breakdown voltage, streamer acceleration voltage, and streamer velocity. The results are supported by the oscillographs of the light activity that is recorded during the discharge process. The prebreakdown phenomenon noticed in the typical synthetic ester vis-à-vis mineral insulating oil is in line with the existing literature. Importantly, it is noticed that the inception and breakdown voltages of the non-aged low pour point synthetic esters are similar to non-aged mineral oil. In addition, the inception and breakdown voltages of the aged low pour point synthetic esters are noticed to be higher than that of the aged mineral oil. These results add to the arguments in favor of replacing mineral oils in power transformers.

Effect of Molecular Structure on the Difference of Lightning Impulse Discharge Between Mineral Oil and Natural Ester Using DFT Calculation

The lighting impulse breakdown performance of natural ester (NE) is lower than that of the traditional mineral oil, which is a key point that needs to be considered in high-voltage level and large capacity transformers. The micromolecular structures of NE and mineral oil are quite different, which leads to significant differences in macroperformance. Therefore, molecular models of two types of oil were constructed in this article, and density functional theory (DFT) was used to calculate molecular microscopic parameters, such as ionization potential (IP) and polarization properties under the action of electric fields (EFs) with different directions. The results show that the IP of the NE is smaller than mineral oil, and the IP of the two oils continues to decrease with the increasing EFs, which is mainly because the highest occupied molecular orbital (HOMO) energy level of NE is significantly higher than that of mineral oil under EFs. Therefore, the lightning impulse breakdown voltage of NE will be lower than that of mineral oil, and the electron density difference (EDD) and atomic force of NE are greater than mineral oil under the EF; thus, the electronic structure of NE is more susceptible to EF. The differences of electronic structure between NE and mineral oil cause the discharge threshold of NE lower than that of mineral oil, which makes the discharge streamers in NE tend to develop along the axial direction of the electrode.

Breakdown Voltage of Polymeric HVDC Insulation at DC Stress and Superimposed Lightning Impulse Voltages

Space charge formation makes it difficult to predict the resulting electric field distribution within HVDC cable insulation.The main purpose of the work presented here has been to experimentally study how the lightning impulse breakdown strength of thin (0.1 mm thick) insulation foils of polypropylene (PP) and Polyethylene Terephthalate (PET) are affected by DC prestress, polarity of the impulse voltage and the temperature.Tests were performed using parallel plate electrodes and prior to DC prestressing the lightning impulse breakdown strengths were found to be approximately 17.5 kV for samples of both PP and PET. Prior to superimposing lightning impulse breakdown voltages, a DC voltage of 8 kV was applied for 60 seconds. The effect of DC prestressing was to significantly increase the impulse breakdown strength during aiding and reduce the breakdown strength during opposing impulse polarity. This strongly support the assumption of homo-charge formation close to the metal electrodes during DC stress.The results showed higher and more temperature dependent charge accumulation in samples of PET. It is indicated that at 22 °C the homo-charge formed during DC stressing approximately reduced the electric field at the electrodes from 100 to 48 kV/mm in the PP samples and from 80 to 22 kV/mm in the PET samples, respectively

Lightning impulse breakdown performance of saturated vs unsaturated vegetable oil and their mixtures with mineral oil

This paper presents the results of the experimental studies on lightning impulse breakdown tests of two categories of vegetable oil – saturated versus unsaturated. The saturated vegetable oils comprise refined, bleached, and deodorized coconut oil and virgin coconut oil (i.e., RBDCO and VCO), while the unsaturated vegetable oil is the most commonly used soybean oil called ‘MIDEL eN1215′. The differences in the impulse breakdown performance of the two categories of vegetable oil were analyzed from the perspective of molecular ionization and ionization potential. The effect of the residual mineral oil on impulse breakdown performance was also studied and analyzed. A point-sphere electrode system was used in this study. It is observed that at a 12.5 mm gap, the lightning impulse breakdown voltage (LIBDV) of both RBDCO and VCO were nearly similar to natural ester oil (NEO) subjected to positive excitation, but with negative excitation, the latter appears to be inferior. At twice the electrode gap, LIBDV can easily differentiate between unsaturated and saturated vegetable oils, whatever be the polarity of excitation. With mineral oil, up to 20%, LIBDVs of vegetable oil tend to increase. This is mainly important with positive excitation, especially in NEO, where up to a 25% increase was observed as against pure oil.

Influence of Temperature on Lightning Performance of Mineral Oil

This article deals with the influence of temperature on the lightning impulse breakdown voltage (LI BDV) of mineral oil in a non-uniform electric field. The experiments were performed in point–plane electrode arrangements under a standard lightning impulse voltage of negative polarity. The LI BDV for the temperatures of 20, 40, 60, 80, 100 and 110 °C was measured using a step method with registration of the light signals emitted during pre-breakdown and breakdown phases. The average propagation velocity was also determined. The results confirm that the mineral oil tested under LI voltage behaves similarly to AC voltage-based stress. The LI BDV increases with temperature up to 100 °C and then tends to decrease. The results demonstrated that viscosity dependent processes are responsible for increasing the LI BDV with temperature up to the 100 °C; and liquid vapor formation processes are responsible for decreasing the LI BDV at temperatures equal to and higher than 100 °C.

A Review on Palm Oil-Based Nanofluids as a Future Resource for Green Transformer Insulation System

Alternative transformer oil has been investigated universally in past years. Different types of vegetable oil have been proposed and evaluated as replacements for conventional transformer oil (mineral oil) due to increasing exploitation and depleting petroleum reserves. In response to growing concern about global environmental and sustainable issues, this article discusses the suitability of palm oil (PO) and palm oil-based nanofluids (PO-N) as alternative transformer oils. A brief discussion of environmental concerns is provided in this paper, and the detailed properties of PO are thoroughly addressed. The electrical performance (alternating current breakdown voltage and lightning impulse breakdown voltage), physical behaviour (viscosity, flash point, and fire point), tan delta, and relative permittivity of PO and PO-N are also discussed in this paper. Based on reliable data and research, it has been proven that refined, bleached, deodorised palm oil (RBDPO) has been determined to be the most promising type of PO when compared to others. Furthermore, when CuO nanoparticles are added to RBDPO with the use of CTAB surfactant, the AC breakdown voltage increases by 173.42 % compared to RBDPO without CuO. However, there is still scope for further improvement in nanofluid stability. In addition to these studies, future research should focus on other aspects such as ageing studies, partial discharge breakdown voltage, etc. PO has interesting properties that make the industry and scientific community take notice.

Dielectric and Thermal Response of TiO2 and SiC Natural Ester Based Nanofluids for Use in Power Transformers

The improvement of dielectric and thermal properties of insulating oils used in High Voltage (HV) equipment has been a key part of research over the last three decades. In this study, a natural ester oil is used as matrix oil and dispersions of two semi-conducting nanoparticles (NPs), titanium oxide (TiO₂) and silicon carbide (SiC), are prepared in 0.004 weight percentage ratio (0.004% w/w). In terms of thermal features, thermal diffusivity and thermal conductivity are measured over a large temperature range between 25 and 90 °C. By means of the dielectric properties, the Lightning Impulse Breakdown Voltage (LI BDV) of nanofluids (NFs) is measured and compared to the corresponding ones of the matrix. Moreover, the dielectric constant and dielectric dissipation factor (DDF) are determined for the NF and matrix samples in the frequency range of 1 to 10⁶ Hz. The obtained results show that the NF containing SiC NPs is characterized from the greatest increase in thermal conductivity, by 58% with respect to natural ester oil’s, as well as the lowest dielectric constant in both 25 and 90 °C, most likely due to their higher permittivity and thermal conductivity. Lastly, the LI BDV of the same NF is the most enhanced, by 10% relatively to the matrix, while a numerical model in COMSOL Multiphysics is developed and is found to successfully verify the LI BDV results.

AC and Lightning Impulse Breakdown Voltages of Natural Ester Based Fullerene Nanofluids

This paper is aimed at the variation of AC and lightning impulse (LI) breakdown voltages of samples enriched with fullerene (C <inf xmlns:mml="http://www.w3.org/1998/Math/MathML" xmlns:xlink="http://www.w3.org/1999/xlink">60</inf> ) nanoparticles (NPs) of natural ester, which stand out as an alternative to mineral oils. C <inf xmlns:mml="http://www.w3.org/1998/Math/MathML" xmlns:xlink="http://www.w3.org/1999/xlink">60</inf> nanofluids with long-term stability and good dielectric properties are examined in this study on five samples for concentrations of NPs ranging 0.05 to 0.4 g/L concentrations. The AC and LI breakdown voltage measurements of each sample are repeated thirty times and the conformity of these measurements of the normal distribution is tested with the Shapiro-Wilk test. Conformity of all samples to normal distribution is accepted by this test and withstand voltages are calculated at 1%, 10% and 50% breakdown probabilities. The AC breakdown voltage performances of 0.3 and 0.4 g/L C <inf xmlns:mml="http://www.w3.org/1998/Math/MathML" xmlns:xlink="http://www.w3.org/1999/xlink">60</inf> nanofluids are increased compared to natural ester. This increase rate is 5.1% and 7.8%, respectively. The withstand voltages at 1% and 10% breakdown probabilities increase by 20.2% and 13.2% compared to natural ester at 0.4 g/L C <inf xmlns:mml="http://www.w3.org/1998/Math/MathML" xmlns:xlink="http://www.w3.org/1999/xlink">60</inf> nanofluid. 0.1 g/L C <inf xmlns:mml="http://www.w3.org/1998/Math/MathML" xmlns:xlink="http://www.w3.org/1999/xlink">60</inf> nanofluid has 8.2% better performance than natural ester at LI breakdown voltages. Withstand voltages of 1% and 10% probability of this nanofluid are 6.5% and 7.7% higher than natural ester, respectively. These measurement results show that C <inf xmlns:mml="http://www.w3.org/1998/Math/MathML" xmlns:xlink="http://www.w3.org/1999/xlink">60</inf> doped nanofluids can meet performance requirements in power system equipment with high power demands.

전계불평등도에 따른 대기압 공기 절연파괴특성 분석

In this study, electrical breakdown characteristics of atmospheric air under the AC and lightning Impulse(LI) voltage waveforms were investigated to settle the electrical insulation design criteria for air insulated switchgear. To investigate the electrical breakdown characteristics according to the non-uniformity of electric field, needle-plane and 4 kinds of sphere-plane electrodes were used as the tested electrode system. Through the experimental results, it was found that when positive impulse voltage is applied, it can be the weakest in terms of electrical insulation. As for the positive LI breakdown voltage, in the case of electrodes with high non-uniformity such as needle-plane electrode, it was confirmed that electrical breakdown voltage increased almost linearly with the gap length. Based on the experimental and electric field analysis results, it is found that it is desirable to establish the air insulation design/evaluation criteria as a function according to the distance in electrodes with high non-uniform electrode systems, and as a maximum electric field function in the quasi electrode systems. Moreover, maximum electric field for partial discharge (PD) inception decreased as the cross-sectional area of the electrodes facing each other increased.

Lightning Impulse Breakdown Voltage RBDPO with the Presence of Metallic Particles Under a Uniform Electric Field

The performance of liquid insulation in power transformer is vulnerable to particles, especially the metallic particles. This paper presents the experimental study on the effect of metallic particles on the palm oil (PO) as dielectric insulating fluid under lightning impulse breakdown voltage. The type of PO used in this study is refined, bleached and deodorized Palm Oil (RBDPO) Olein. Two different types of metallic particles (copper and iron) with different concentrations (clean, low, medium, and high) were studied. The lightning impulse test has been carried out according to IEC 60897 standard and under the influence of a uniform electric field. For the comparative purpose, similar test has been carried out with mineral oil (MO). The presence of metallic particles reduces the average lightning impulse breakdown voltage of MO and PO but shows less significant effect to MO. This is because the streamers in the PO propagate faster and further than in the MO at the same voltage level. Hence, causing the breakdown voltage of PO lower than MO. Under negative lightning impulse, the breakdown voltage of MO is slightly higher than RBDPO. From the study, the increment of the number of particle level contamination will reduce the lightning impulse breakdown voltages of the PO.

Lightning Impulse Breakdown Voltage of Rice Bran Oil for Transformer Application

Transformer oil does not only serve as an insulating liquid, but also in removing heat from the windings and cores. Mineral oil (MO) has been widely used in transformers for more than 150 years. Recently, researchers have attempted to search for alternative insulating oils due to the possibility that MO will run out in the future together with the concern on fire safety and environmental pollution. Among the potential oils is rice bran oil (RBO). This work presents the studies of the lightning impulse (LI) of RBO behavior under various electric fields, gap distances and testing methods. The electrical performances of LI tests show that RBO and Palm Oil (PO) have lower LI breakdown voltage than MO under both uniform and non-uniform electric fields. However, the difference in LI breakdown voltages between RBO, PO and MO are slightly small which is less than 20%. In addition, there is no significant effect in the various testing methods under both uniform field and non-uniform field where the percentages of difference are less than 12% and 8% respectively. The data of LI breakdown voltage were statistically analysed to predict the withstand voltage and 50% breakdown voltage of oil samples by using Weibull distribution. The Weibull distribution of MO, PO and RBO has well fit with the fitting line. Finally, the relationship between LI voltages under a non-uniform field with various parameters of PO and RBO was obtained and proposed. From this work, it can be concluded that RBO shows promising results to be considered as an alternative to MO in transformer applications.

Comparison of methods applied to measuring the lightning impulse breakdown voltage of insulating pressboard impregnated with mineral oil and natural ester

Comparison of methods applied to measuring the lightning impulse breakdown voltage of insulating pressboard impregnated with mineral oil and natural ester

Latest Developments of Palm Oil as a Sustainable Transformer Fluid: A Green Alternative to Mineral Oils

Increasing awareness of safety and the environment demands the replacement of mineral oil by bio-oils in many electrical applications. Palm oil has been identified as a potential candidate for mineral oil in transformers. This study reviews the physio-chemical and electrical properties of palm oil as insulation fluid. Analysis of electrical properties has been conducted on AC and lightning impulse breakdown voltage and dielectric parameters, whereas physicochemical properties are discussed in terms of viscosity, acidity, and moisture. The performance of palm oil under aging and pressure is also presented. Several case studies of palm oil in the presence of nanoparticles have been reviewed. Concerning economic and technical perspectives, palm oil has a significantly high potential as a transformer fluid. Further studies on the suitability of palm oil as a transformer fluid is required to evaluate the long-term performance concerning partial discharge, transient energy, aging performance under various ambient conditions, and in the presence of suspended nanoparticles.

Breakdown Voltage of Transformer Oil Containing Cellulose Particle Contamination With and Without Bridge Formation Under Lightning Impulse Stress

This study investigates the effect of cellulose bridge formation on insulating oil. Such effect influences the breakdown voltage and strength of mineral oil (MO) under standard lightning impulse (LI) voltage. A cylindrical test vessel fitted with spherical–spherical electrodes with a 2 mm gap distance between them was used to generate a quasi-uniform field and observe bridge formation between the gaps. A positive LI waveform (1.2/ $50~\mu \text{s}$ ) generated by an impulse generator was applied during the breakdown tests. The rising-voltage method was used to measure the breakdown voltage in accordance with the IEC 60897 standard test method. Weibull cumulative breakdown probability was applied to present the breakdown results statistically, and the outcome was compared with clean oil (CO). Commercial cellulose microcrystalline particles were dispersed into the transformer oil to act as bridge. The concentrations of the samples were 0.004%, 0.008% and 0.012% by weight. The breakdown test results showed that the cellulosic particles reduced the LI breakdown voltage (LIBV) of MO by up to 10%. The influence of cellulose particles on LIBV was also more prominent during bridge formation, with a further reduction of 14%. Evidently, the presence of the cellulose bridge exerted a detrimental effect on the breakdown voltage of MO under LI stress, yielding a reduction of 24% and 27% at 0.004 wt% and 0.012 wt%, respectively. Finite element analysis also indicated that the electrical field strength of cellulosic particle contamination of 0.004 wt% and 0.012 wt% without a bridge skeleton exceeded the critical electric field strength of CO by 20% and 61%, respectively. The presence of cellulosic contamination at any concentration, i.e. either with or without a bridge structure, clearly decreased the breakdown strength of transformer oil. However, the breakdown is not occurred instantaneously. The LI breakdown was initiated and established only at a certain impulse stress level, when the electric field strength along the bridge lines exceeded the critical electric field strength of the oil. Thus, this finding potentially contributes to the formulation of guidelines for condition assessment and contamination monitoring to minimise common issues in power transformer failures that are attributable to the insulation system, and consequently, achieve optimum transformer insulation integrity.

The Influence of Nanoparticles’ Conductivity and Charging on Dielectric Properties of Ester Oil Based Nanofluid

This study addresses the effect of nanoparticles’ conductivity and surface charge on the dielectric performance of insulating nanofluids. Dispersions of alumina and silicon carbide nanoparticles of similar size (~50 nm) and concentration (0.004% w/w) were prepared in natural ester oil. The stability of the dispersions was explored by dynamic light scattering. AC, positive and negative lightning impulse breakdown voltage, as well as partial discharge inception voltage of the nanofluid samples were measured and compared with the respective properties of the base oil. The obtained results indicate that the addition of SiC nanoparticles can lead to an increase in AC breakdown voltage and also enhance the resistance of the liquid to the appearance of partial discharge. On the other hand, the induction of positive charge from the Al2O3 nanoparticles could be the main factor leading to an improved positive Lightning Impulse Breakdown Voltage and worse performance at negative polarity.

AC and Negative Lightning Impulse Breakdown Voltage of Mineral Oil with Different Nitrogen Addition Treatment Methods

AC and Negative Lightning Impulse Breakdown Voltage of Mineral Oil with Different Nitrogen Addition Treatment Methods