Photographs of a lichen-measurement station, established by Beschel at Str⊘mfjordshavn, West Greenland, indicate a Rhizocarpon geographicum growth rate of 17 to 18 mm 100 years-1 between 1958 and 1970. A radiocarbon date of 330 ± 75 years BP for a moraine at the head of Ørkendalen, which is 35 km farther east and 125 m higher than Str⊘mfjordshavn, indicates a Rhizocarpon geographicum growth rate of about 6 to 7 mm 100 years-1.These results support Beschel's previous estimates for lichen growth rates in the very continental inland parts of West Greenland and strongly support his conclusions that lichen growth rates are highly sensitive to local climate and inversely proportional to continentality. The results may alternatively be interpreted, with the aid of several assumptions and disregard for climatic differences, as representing a 100-year “great-period” growth rate of 17 mm 100 years-1 followed by a “long-term” growth rate of 2 mm 100 years-1. However, there are some severe inconsistencies in this interpretation, most notably that the largest lichen at Str⊘mfjordshavn should be well past its “great period,” but it is in fact still growing at a rate of 18 mm 100 years-1. Therefore, the slower rate of growth determined for the Ørkendalen site is most probably a function of the site's more continental climate.The question of whether the difference in growth rates between the two sites is climatically caused or is due to differential maturity of the two lichen populations could be resolved by the simple photogrammetric methods employed in this study. That is, by rephotographing more of the lichen stations established by Beschel in 1958, growth rates could be determined for the entire range of thalli diameters (ages) and environments spanned by his original photographs. Growth rates so determined for thalli of different diameters at the same site would provide a quantitative relation between growth rate and maturity (climate being a constant for any given site). Similarly, growth rates determined for thalli of the same diameter but at different sites would provide a quantitative relation between growth rate and climate (maturity being a constant in this case). Thereby, the necessary data could be provided for quantitative determination of the growth rate of Rhizocarpon geographicum as a dependent function of (a) thallus diameter (age) and (b) climate.
Read full abstract