Level Of State Power Research Articles

The Ordinariness of Ethics and the Extraordinariness of Revolution

In this article I present experiences of Egyptians too young to have taken part in the street protests and movement of the 2011 revolution. Today in their early twenties, they narrate their experiences during the early months of the uprising. None claimed to be revolutionaries then or now, but the revolution seems to animate them in complex and long-lasting ways. The January revolution failed to bring about change at the level of state power. Yet more is at stake than the political endgame. I turn my attention to how people narrate the revolution as a process of ethical reflection and self-formation through everyday relationships and settings that took on new meanings. These accounts challenge notions of what it means to participate in a revolution and where it is located and generate a conversation between the anthropology of ethics and the anthropology of revolutions.

MUNICIPAL PUBLIC POLICY IN THE CONTEXT OF LOCAL GOVERNMENT REFORM

The article presents an analysis of the main novelties of the reorganization of local self-government related to the proposed draft law No. 40361-8 "On the general principles of the organization of local self-government in a unified system of public power" through the prism of the phenomenon of public policy. The latter is a framework concept related to the civil competencies of state/municipal management, the quality and level of public activity of civil society, which allows influencing the adoption of socially significant decisions. Municipal public policy is more based on the use of tools of intersectoral social partnership, which contributes to building a public dialogue of all active parties of the local community and the formation of an "agenda". The reform proposed by the bill "centralizes" local self-government, significantly changing the principles of its territorial and organizational structure, enlarging municipalities by abolishing the settlement level. The multilayered concept of municipal public policy allows us to judge the optimal ratio of political and administrative properties of state and municipal authorities, combining administrative regulation and the use of forms of public participation of the population. From the point of view of the interests of the development of civil self-organization and "grassroots" public initiatives, the desire to make local self-government bodies the lower level of state power through the concept of "unity of public power" is undoubtedly alarming, which can lead to its administratization, affect the quality of the implementation of the principles of municipal public policy, reduce the opportunities for the subjective formation of an increasingly complex society.

Some Aspects of the Regulatory Environment of Local Self-Government in Federal Cities

The issues of legal regulation of the organization and functioning of all government bodi es have always been the subject of numerous studies, discussions and even disputes. The rapid new reorganization of the legal foundations of the unified system of public power that started in 2020, having passed the federal and regional level of state power, "stumbled" at the level of local self-government. The draft federal law No. 40361-8 "On General Principles of Organization of Local Self-Government in the Unified System of Public Power", which was submitted to the State Duma of the Russian Fe deration on 16 December 2021, has so far remained at the level of "proposals and comments for the second reading". This allows us to focus on the analysis of problematic issues of the current situation with the legislative basis of local self-government in Russia in order to avoid and take into account in the future existing errors and shortcomings, as well as to improve the current system of legal regulation of local self-government as soon as possible. The Authors of this study attempt to analyze and draw the attention of other researchers, representatives of federal and regional legislative authorities to the existing obvious problems in the legislative regulation of local self-government in federal cities. Specific examples of the texts of the laws of Moscow, St. Petersburg and Sevastopol, allow us to draw disappointing conclusions about the significant abuse by the legislators of these constituent entities of the Russian Federation of their rights to regulate certain issues of organization and functioning of local self-government in the territory of federal cities. Evidently, the existing conflicts should be eliminated as soon as possible and taken into account by the federal legislator in the formation of future legislative framework for determining the specifics of local self-government in federal cities. The current situation seriously affects the principle of direct and immediate effect of the Constitution of the Russian Federation, as well as the priority of federal legislation over regional legislation on issues of joint jurisdiction of the Russian Federation and its constituent entities.

Civil status of celebrations in honour of the icon of Our Lady of Saint Theodore in the 19th–20th centuries in Kostroma

The article deals with the aspect of veneration of the icon of Our Lady of Saint Theodore that did not attract the attention of researchers before – the establishment in the mid-19th century and at the early 20th century of non-attendant days (days off) in the city of Kostroma during the celebrations in honour of the Feodorovskaya Icon on March 14 and August 16 (according to the old style). Such a civil status of a church celebration was not unique to the Russian Empire of that time, but this happened only in a few regions, the list of which was published as a separate article until 1863 in the Charter on the Prevention and Suppression of Crimes, which was part of the Code of Laws of the Russian Empire (after 1863, the said list was replaced by a general indication of such celebrations). Fragments of firstly introduced into scientific discourse documents, related to the establishment of non-attendant days in Kostroma on March 14 (1852–1853) and August 16 (1899–1901) were published. It was noted that the relevant decisions were made at the highest level of state power of the Empire; however, in both cases, at the request of Kostroma residents – the proposal to establish a day off on March 14 was set forth by the performing position of Kostroma governor in the letter to the Minister of Internal Affairs, and Kostroma City Duma proposed to establish a day off in Kostroma on August 16.

Social context of establishing criminal liability for interference in the activities of a state official

The concepts of "state" and "security" are closely related. The prospects for the development of statehood will largely depend on the ability of the state and society to create a system of security measures that is adequate to the level of threats. 
 The relevance of the topic lies in the fact that the proper functioning of the state requires proper activities of persons representing the highest levels of state power. In case of encroachment or direct intervention in their activities, this can threaten national security. Therefore, this issue is relevant and requires detailed consideration.
 It is necessary to ensure effective, comprehensive interaction between state authorities. For this purpose, the effectiveness of the performance of official duties by officials of the highest state authorities to the full extent and without possible interference in their activities arises. The state is obliged to ensure proper protection of such persons, including at the regulatory and legal level.
 The purpose of the article is to investigate the grounds for establishing criminal liability for a specific criminal offense provided for in Article 344 of the Criminal Code of Ukraine and to clarify whether the existence of the aforementioned criminal prohibition is socially conditioned.
 To achieve the stated goal, this scientific work analyzes the norms of the law on the issue of criminal liability for interference in the activities of a state official.
 The author characterizes the concept of criminalization of an act and examines the grounds and principles for establishing criminal liability for this criminal offense. The issue of the social conditioning of the criminal-legal norm and the circumstances that led to its adoption is investigated. Statistical data for the period from 2015 to 2021 are considered.
 As a result, it is concluded that the criminalization of an act that involves interference in the activities of a state official is socially conditioned and necessary to ensure the proper functioning of the state and national security.

Aggravation of the Colonial Struggle in the Pacific Ocean in 1760—1770s

The article is devoted to the struggle for colonies in the North Pacific in the context of the interaction between Russia, Great Britain and Spain in the second half of the 18th century, with an emphasis on the voyage of J. Cook to the coast of Alaska. The activity of Russia and the Western European powers related to the intensification of efforts in the northern part of the Pacific Ocean is considered. The article notes that the region studied by us has long attracted the attention of European countries. The factors that contributed to the development of the North-West of America are revealed. The authors show that it was a very complex and multifaceted process, in which various levels of state power, up to the emperors, participated. The importance of the initiative of private commercial companies in the colonization of territories is noted. The authors of the article draw attention to the fact that the expansion of the Spanish Empire became possible due to Madrid’s fears about the strengthening of Russia in the North Pacific. In turn, Great Britain carried out active intelligence activities, which resulted in a phase of military conflict at the end of the 18th century. On the basis of Russian and foreign documents introduced into scientific circulation for the first time, the authors of the article try to show the validity of the fears of the Madrid court regarding Russian colonization, as well as the ambitions of London in this region. Promotion of Russia to the northwest of America was due to economic and political reasons. The access to the Pacific Ocean of Russian private structures was caused by the desire to collect yasak from the indigenous peoples, as well as to obtain furs, which were highly valued in world markets. The article notes the changes in the position of Great Britain, Spain and Russia in relation to the colonies in the 18th century. It is concluded that, in general, the policy of Spain and Great Britain was aimed at curbing the Russian advance in the Pacific Ocean. Russian-Anglo-Spanish relations in the Northwest Pacific at the end of the 17th century and the first half of the 18th century made a significant contribution to the subsequent active colonization of the North Pacific. The article was written using an interdisciplinary approach based on a wide range of sources from domestic and foreign archives.

ОСОБЛИВОСТІ ФУНКЦІОНУВАННЯ ВЛАДИ В СУЧАСНІЙ КИТАЙСЬКІЙ НАРОДНІЙ РЕСПУБЛІЦІ

The article highlights the peculiarities of the organization and functioning of government in the modern People’s Republic of China. The formation and activity of central and local authorities, features of the electoral system and the role of the Communist Party in the administration of the PRC are considered. It was found that all local authorities (people’s assemblies and executive bodies) are part of a single vertical of power under the leadership of the National People’s Congress (parliament) and the State Council (government). In turn, both central and local authorities are under the supervision of committees of the Communist Party of China at various levels. At the same time, the party’s control is the tightest in the central authorities, the highest echelons of local authorities, and much weaker on the periphery in the lower echelons of local authorities. It was revealed that the positions of head of state, general secretary of the CPC, and chairman of the Central Military Commission are in the hands of one person (currently Xi Jinping), who actually has power over the country. At the same time, there is an agreement that at the local level party and state positions should be separated. In general, the system of managing society in the PRC is built in such a way that the party works in parallel with the state and is woven into all levels of state power. It has been established that elections in the PRC take place only at the local level, not at the national level, and their competitiveness is limited by the CCP’s monopoly on power and government interference in elections. There are no freely elected national leaders in China.

ЗАРУБІЖНИЙ ДОСВІД РОЗВИТКУ ІНФОРМАЦІЙНО-КОМУНІКАЦІЙНОГО СЕКТОРУ ЕКОНОМІКИ

In the conditions of European integration, the research of the sector of information and communication technologies through the prism of experience in European countries is relevant and perspective. It is examined the implementation of information and communication technologies in European countries and possibilities of implementing foreign experience in Ukraine in this article. Also, it is highlighted that this sector in the future variations of economic development has the largest increase and will have the largest output. This is reflected in all business models, which makes it a relevant topic for further research. In the rating positions, Ukraine has an advantage compared to other countries in terms of the use of technology by citizens, management is a strongest point in Poland and Lithuania, technology is in Germany. The areas of improvement in Ukraine and Germany remain management, it is necessary to improve technologies in Poland, while in Lithuania only impact is singled out. Based on the conducted analysis it is highlighted the experience of Poland in the field of ICT through clustering, Germany as a technological leader. It is paid the particular attention to general strategies for the development of information and communication technologies in the European dimension, and separate governmental programs of Iceland and Denmark are developed. Education, use at all levels of state power and implementation in the business sector are typical for the countries of Northern Europe in the field of implementation of information and communication technologies. It is highlighted the structural features in the public management of the ICT sector, regional autonomy is characteristic for Ukraine, regional decentralization for Poland, Germany combines administrative regionalization and regionalization through local authorities. A promising direction is the creation of clusters that will connect the entire sphere, not only information technologies, development of a plan in the short term, taking into account the current state and experience of foreign countries It is important active support from the state through updating and implementing the development strategy.

Forecasting social and economic development of Sevastopol and long-term analysis

The efficiency of state governance can be attained only on the basis of developing new systems of informational-analytical support, through which it could be possible to reach completeness and accuracy of information and to make and implement managerial decisions at all level of state power. The article studies mechanism of informational-analytical support of forecasting social and economic development of the city of Sevastopol’. On the basis of empiric research methods and approaches to forecasting social and economic development of Sevastopol’ were identified and a medium-term forecast of social parameters was made. The authors presented the forecast of the index of gross regional product on the basis of correlation – regressive analysis. To forecast social and economic development of Sevastopol’ the following factors were used: the number and structure of labour at the age of 15 +; dynamics of work volume carried out in ‘Construction’; index of investment into fixed capital. This approach can be useful for bodies of state power and introduction of the forecasting model can help settle problems dealing with optimizing state and managerial decision-making on the regional level.

ПОДАТКОВА КОНКУРЕНТОСПРОМОЖНІСТЬ КРАЇНИ ЯК ВАЖІЛЬ ДЕТІНІЗАЦІЇ ЕКОНОМІКИ

With the significant diversification of economic activities and a wide range of operations carried out in the country, the processes of making management decisions by economic entities are significantly complicated. Justification of the feasibility of a transaction should be based on objective indicators, which in addition to the characteristics of the operation should take into account the level of favorable economic environment in the country as a whole. One of the indicators that allows to make informed management decisions is the tax competitiveness of the country, the concept of which is currently poorly understood and non-uniform. The article analyzes the economic content of the tax competitiveness of the country as a driver of de-shadowing of the economy. According to the results of the analysis, it was concluded that there is no unified understanding of the nature and role of tax competitiveness in the economic development of the country. Based on the systematization of scientific approaches to understanding the essence of tax competition, the classification features of the country’s tax competitiveness are identified and systematized, the analysis of the connection between tax competitiveness and the level of shadowing of the economy is carried out. The authors propose to classify the tax competitiveness of the country by the following signs: depending on the level of state power, the duration of storage, the criterion of efficiency, the scale. The main indicators of tax competitiveness of the country, which negatively affect the level of shadowing of Ukraine include the imperfection of the tax system, its inability to compete with the tax systems of economically developed countries, high tax burden, high complexity of tax accrual and payment processes. The analysis of sub-indices of formation of tax competitiveness of Ukraine allowed us to make a conclusion about its low level in comparison with other countries of the world. According to the results of the study, it is concluded that increasing the level of tax competitiveness of the country is a necessary prerequisite for reducing the level of shadowing by increasing the attractiveness of the tax system for both international and domestic economic entities.

Current Issues of Decentralization Reform and Administrative-Territorial Device

The experience of reforms in foreign countries shows that decentralization is an essential factor in democratizing and modernizing the economy, provides for concrete steps to improve the quality of life, has a clear framework and conceptual content. It is the decentralization of Public Administration that is the driving force behind the creation of a favorable regional economic space for achieving sustainable development. Reforms of the administrative-territorial structure in Ukraine have recently been fundamental, structureforming in nature, but, despite many advantages, they have revealed a large-scale complex of problems related to the relationship between new levels of state power and the distribution of budget funds. The materials of the article indicate that the current legislation has not yet been adapted to the new system of territorial structure. Issues of optimal interaction between state and local government bodies, synchronization of the development of territorial levels of the economy in the context of decentralization require regulatory changes and monitoring. For the effective completion of reforms, important steps are needed that will allow achieving the conceptual goal of the reform: the government and all authorities must serve the interests of society and ensure the sustainable development of the country. To do this, you need to form an appropriate policy and implement it systematically. It is proposed to adopt new agreements that will allow launching the work of administrations in new districts in a new format. At the same time, it is necessary to adopt a law on the administrative-territorial structure, which will establish rules by which it will be possible to further modernize districts and correct mistakes made. Finally, it is necessary to amend the Constitution in terms of local self-government and territorial organization of power. A number of provisions are proposed aimed at improving relations between the levels of subnational authorities, improving the efficiency of the Institute of prefects, distributing local finances, and legislative regulation of aspects of local self-government work.

The Two-Level System of Power of the Federal State

A contemporary theory of the state and law considers the two-level system of power as an indispensable feature of federal states. The interpretation of this organizational feature of state power depends on how the sovereignty of the federal state is interpreted, the nature of federal relations, the federal form of government itself. The purpose of the study is to identify the essential features of the two-level construction of the power system in the federation, characterize both levels of state power and their relations between each other. As a result of the study, the author highlights the concept of two-level construction of state power, describes the reasons for this structural feature of the power system, demonstrates the internal logic of relations between federal and regional levels of government in the general context of the federal model of the state structure. The study of the state power features in the federation allowed the author to look at the essence of federalism “from the inside”, from the point of view of the system-structural organization of the power apparatus. The two-level system of power appears as an internally agreed way of organizing the state mechanism, where every level has the functions and characteristics inherent only to it and that in their interaction reveal the main meaning of the federal structure— the preservation of state integrity.

The Republic of Serbia: Stuck in the grey zone of democratization?

The Republic of Serbia is a state overburdened with complex issues regarding its political transformation. These problems are a consequence of the dynamic changes which have occurred over the last 30 years. It should be remembered that Serbia underwent a transformation from an authoritarian to a democratic state in a relatively short period of time. Unfortunately, these dynamic political, economic, and social modifications coincided with serious systemic changes and this had an adverse impact on Serbian democracy. The political problems which directly influence the process of democratization are becoming more and more visible over time. One such problem is undoubtedly the fact that state power is in the hands of one political party: the Serbian Progressive Party. For states going through a transformation, such a concentration of power could have negative effects on the quality of democracy. This article evaluates the non-democratic trends in Serbia which stem from the strengthening of the Serbian Progressive Party, especially on the level of state power. The article also suggests that this development might lead to Serbia being categorized as a country which has become stuck in the so-called grey zone of democratization.

Transformation of the public service of Ukraine into an institution of social interaction in the context of the global crisis

The article substantiates the conceptual foundations of the transformation of the public service of Ukraine into the institution of social interaction as one of the most important conditions for overcoming the socio-economic crisis and effective implementation of social reforms. The paper analyzes the current state of crisis in which society and the institution of public service, as the main subject of formation and implementation of public development strategy. It is emphasized that the systemic crisis may well be the factor that changes the social system in the direction of reducing entropy and contributes to the restructuring of the format of the relationship between public service and society. Favorable factors have been identified that accelerate the achievement of a new qualitative state of organization and functioning of the public service in the process of overcoming the crisis. The necessity of cardinal institutional changes at the highest levels of state power, namely in the triangle "Verkhovna Rada – President – Cabinet of Ministers" is substantiated. Based on research conducted by the Razumkov Centre's sociological service from February 13 to 17, 2020, as well as from April 24 to 29, 2020 (by telephone interview), there is a significant decrease in the professionalism and quality of government institutions, which leads to a decline in public confidence. public service. Emphasis is placed on the need to amend the relevant laws of Ukraine, which will be the first step towards the preparation of a single integrated bill "On Public Service in Ukraine", which should introduce fundamental principles for the functioning of public service as an institution of public interaction. It is proved that the process of transformation of the public service of Ukraine into an institution of social interaction should take place at all levels of public power through constructive social self-organization and broad involvement of citizens in the management process. The role of leaders of territorial communities is highlighted, who on the basis of constant social dialogue and partnership with the community should ensure constructive social self-organization and minimize the consequences of the crisis.

Political will is a required condition effective combating corruption.

Effective counteraction to corruption at all levels is not possible without the symbiosis of such components as influencing the causes and conditions of corruption, creating systemic anti-corruption legislation, its effective application to all without exception manifestations of corruption in all levels of state power. However, such a symbiosis can only produce a positive result if the political will of the state leadership is available. I would call it a "conditio sine qua non" (a condition without which there is) overcoming corruption in the country, because in Latin "conditio sine qua non" means "a necessary condition", a necessary condition for the result. Political will in combating corruption is not only the will of the political leader (head of state) as an individual, but also the will of individuals from his immediate environment. Only political will is capable of ensuring the effectiveness of all other necessary components of counteracting corruption. The political will of the leadership of the state is a conditio sine qua non of minimizing corruption in the country, that is, a condition without which effective counteraction to corruption and corruption crime in Ukraine is impossible. The presence of political will is a prerequisite in the chain of others who are not capable of effectively preventing the spread of corruption in the absence of political will of the government. No other political conditions, economic, social or legislative levers will succeed in reducing corruption. Therefore, a promising direction for further research on this issue is the development of a scientifically sound mechanism for political influence of the government on the effectiveness of anti-corruption measures in Ukraine.

The Guangdong-Hong Kong-Macau Greater Bay Area in the making: development plan and challenges

The Chinese authority intends to develop the Guangdong-Hong Kong-Macau Greater Bay Area (GBA) as a new engine to sustain Chinese development. By applying the theories of state rescaling and city-cluster formation, this paper intends to conduct a case study of the GBA to examine the state-initiated plan for city-cluster formation in China, to analyse the Chinese central and local governments’ efforts to put this plan into action and the hurdles they face in formatting this city-cluster. The formulation of the GBA development plan for integrated development reflects a dynamic process of upscaling and downscaling of various levels of state power. The state’s plan for the GBA is to create a world-class city-cluster, and to eliminate barriers that hinder the free flow of goods and resources. Nevertheless, it will be challenging for Guangdong, Hong Kong and Macau, which fall under different administrative regions and customs zones, to achieve the level of collaboration and functioning required for integrated development of the GBA. The fierce competition for dominance among these core cities could jeopardise efforts to forge closer economic integration in the region.

An improved reduced order model for nonlinear stability analysis of spatial xenon oscillations

In this paper, an improved reduced order model for studying spatial xenon oscillations has been developed which can be utilized for stability analysis (linear as well as nonlinear). The model presented in this paper has been developed to overcome situations of unphysical results which were obtained by earlier models which used quasi static assumption when the system moves away from the equilibrium point. The earlier model consisted of multipoint neutron kinetics equations including xenon and iodine feedback. In order to eliminate unphysical behaviour in the earlier model, the quasi-static approach is discarded and the total power control is represented by an ordinary differential equation. It represents the action of a reactivity device governed by the deviation of the total power from the steady state power level. In the current approach, a PHWR is modelled by dividing it into two regions. The linear and nonlinear stability analysis was carried out using the new model and compared with the older results. Linear stability maps were constructed in different parameter planes and were found to be identical. However, there was a change in the nonlinear characteristics of the system and the results are presented in this paper. Moreover, the effect of control device on the system behaviour especially on total power variation is studied through numerical simulations.

Участь громадянського суспільства у протидії корупції: досвід країн Центрально-Східної Європи.

The article is devoted to the analysis of the features of participation and the role of civil society in the context of combating corruption in a modern state. Corruption, like a web, envelops different spheres of life and different levels of state power, and thereby makes the state weak and suspends its development. It has been established that the international community, in order to prevent corruption, adopts a number of international documents that emphasize the importance of the problem and the fact that the fight against corruption is a challenge for all states of the world. The main anti-corruption treaties include the United Nations Convention against Corruption, the Council of Europe Criminal Law Convention on Corruption, the European Union Convention on the fight against corruption involving EU officials or officials of EU countries, and others. The article examines the experience of CEE countries regarding anti-corruption policy and the participation of civil society in it and it was found that state support acts as one of the necessary conditions for anti-corruption reforms and adoption of relevant regulatory acts, but their implementation is impossible if the society is not ready to adopt this participation. Today we should talk about the need for the formation and dissemination of new social values: reliability, openness, transparency, active participation and responsibility, which will form an anti-corruption worldview and consciousness. To conduct an effective anti-corruption policy, the necessary steps are: the formation of society as an equal partner in the development and implementation of a national anti-corruption strategy; involving various civil society institutions in anti-corruption counteraction.

RUSSIAN FEDERALISM: PROBLEM OF PERIODIZATION AND MODERN DEVELOPMENT TRENDS

This article analyzes the views that exist in legal and political scientific literature on the development of federal relations in Russia during drafting the Constitution 1993 and after its adoption. The main issues in the article are to determine at what stage of the development of the federalism our state is, what trends are inherent in this stage. Without solving these issues it is impossible to fully realize a number of important tasks that legislative authorities of the Federation and of its subjects face. The article concludes that modern Russian federalism is not a finally established model of political and legal relations between the center and the subjects of the Russian Federation. It is proposed to characterize the current status of federal relations as the period of ongoing reforms towards the optimization of relations between federal and regional levels of state power.

КОНЦЕПТУАЛЬНІ ПІДХОДИ ДО ОЦІНКИ ЕФЕКТИВНОСТІ ІННОВАЦІЙНИХ ПРОЕКТІВ ЗАЛІЗНИЧНОГО ТРАНСПОРТУ

Currently, the issues of innovation development are the objects of attention, both at the level of state regulation, and at the level of individual enterprises. One of the methods of increase of innovative activity is the financing of innovation. Investments in innovative projects determine the degree of development, and in consequence of the success of the structures at different levels. Naturally, it is impossible to completely commercialize all innovation projects. In this regard, increased responsibility in the adoption of competent management decisions on the effectiveness and selection of innovative projects based on the methodological principles and evaluation criteria of the projects selected subject to assessment. In contrast to investment, to innovation projects, specific risks and uncertainties due to technological backwardness and market novelty of innovation. Therefore there is a need for new approaches to the assessment of the effectiveness of any innovation project.The article is devoted to approaches to evaluation of efficiency of innovative projects. The evaluation results are the basis for making management decisions about the implementation of the project, both at the level of state power, and at the level of the entity. The article notes the relevance of innovative design, including the introduction of innovative projects at the enterprises of railway transport. The results of theoretical investigation of the essence of the innovative project. Identifies the General features and characteristics of the essence of the innovation project, such as deadlines, performers, etc. are Marked features causing the efficiency of the innovative project. Factors that determine the conditions for decision-making on project implementation. A review of approaches and methods of economic estimation of efficiency of innovative projects and compare methods such as static, dynamic and special. The comparison describes their advantages and disadvantages regarding the application of the innovative project. The advantage of application of a method of evaluation of the effectiveness of advocates simplicity and ease of calculations. When assessing the effectiveness of various methods vary depending on the indicators and criteria of effectiveness of these indicators of efficiency of the innovative project. Each indicator is given a short characteristic. Highlights specific features that contribute to the future development of the innovation project. The conclusion is formulated about the lack of research results concerning approaches to the evaluation of efficiency of the innovative project, and the need for further research.