Cortical lesions are common in multiple sclerosis (MS), but their visualization is challenging on conventional magnetic resonance imaging. The uniform image derived from magnetization prepared 2 rapid acquisition gradient echoes (MP2RAGE uni ) detects cortical lesions with a similar rate as the criterion standard sequence, double inversion recovery. Fluid and white matter suppression (FLAWS) provides multiple reconstructed contrasts acquired during a single acquisition. These contrasts include FLAWS minimum image (FLAWS min ), which provides an exquisite sensitivity to the gray matter signal and therefore may facilitate cortical lesion identification, as well as high contrast FLAWS (FLAWS hco ), which gives a contrast that is similar to one of MP2RAGE uni . In this study, we compared the manual detection rate of cortical lesions on MP2RAGE uni , FLAWS min , and FLAWS hco in MS patients. Furthermore, we assessed whether the combined detection rate on FLAWS min and FLAWS hco was superior to MP2RAGE uni for cortical lesions identification. Last, we compared quantitative T1 maps (qT1) provided by both MP2RAGE and FLAWS in MS lesions. We included 30 relapsing-remitting MS patients who underwent MP2RAGE and FLAWS magnetic resonance imaging with isotropic spatial resolution of 1 mm at 3 T. Cortical lesions were manually segmented by consensus of 3 trained raters and classified as intracortical or leukocortical lesions on (1) MP2RAGE uniform/flat images, (2) FLAWS min , and (3) FLAWS hco . In addition, segmented lesions on FLAWS min and FLAWS hco were merged to produce a union lesion map (FLAWS min + hco ). Number and volume of all cortical, intracortical, and leukocortical lesions were compared among MP2RAGE uni , FLAWS min , and FLAWS hco using Friedman test and between MP2RAGE uni and FLAWS min + hco using Wilcoxon signed rank test. The FLAWS T1 maps were then compared with the reference MP2RAGE T1 maps using relative differences in percentage. In an exploratory analysis, individual cortical lesion counts of the 3 raters were compared, and interrater variability was quantified using Fleiss ϰ. In total, 633 segmentations were made on the 3 contrasts, corresponding to 355 cortical lesions. The median number and volume of single cortical, intracortical, and leukocortical lesions were comparable among MP2RAGE uni , FLAWS min , and FLAWS hco . In patients with cortical lesions (22/30), median cumulative lesion volume was larger on FLAWS min (587 μL; IQR, 1405 μL) than on MP2RAGE uni (490 μL; IQR, 990 μL; P = 0.04), whereas there was no difference between FLAWS min and FLAWS hco , or FLAWS hco and MP2RAGE uni . FLAWS min + hco showed significantly greater numbers of cortical (median, 4.5; IQR, 15) and leukocortical (median, 3.5; IQR, 12) lesions than MP2RAGE uni (median, 3; IQR, 10; median, 2.5; IQR, 7; both P < 0.001). Interrater agreement was moderate on MP2RAGE uni (ϰ = 0.582) and FLAWS hco (ϰ = 0.584), but substantial on FLAWS min (ϰ = 0.614). qT1 in lesions was similar between MP2RAGE and FLAWS. Cortical lesions identification in FLAWS min and FLAWS hco was comparable to MP2RAGE uni . The combination of FLAWS min and FLAWS hco allowed to identify a higher number of cortical lesions than MP2RAGE uni , whereas qT1 maps did not differ between the 2 acquisition schemes.
Read full abstract