Vickers hardness indentation tests were employed to investigate the near-surface changes in the hardness of a fibre laser-treated and an as-received ZrO2 engineering ceramic. Indents were created using 5, 20, and 30 kg loads to obtain the hardness. Optical microscopy, white-light interferometry, and a coordinate measuring machine were then used to observe the crack lengths and crack geometry. Palmqvist and half-penny median crack profiles were found, which dictated the selection of the group of equations used herein. Computational and analytical approaches were then adapted to determine the K1 c of ZrO2. It was found that the best applicable equation was: K1 c = 0.016 ( E/ H)1/2 ( P/ c3/2), which was confirmed to be 42 per cent accurate in producing K1 c values within the range of 8 to 12 MPa m1/2 for ZrO2. Fibre laser surface treatment reduced the surface hardness and produced smaller crack lengths in comparison with the as-received surface. The surface crack lengths, hardness, and indentation loads were found to be important, particularly the crack length, which significantly influenced the end K1 c value when K1 c = 0.016 ( E/ H)1/2 ( P/ c3/2) was used. This is because, the longer the crack lengths, the lower the ceramic's resistance to indentation. This, in turn, increased the end K1 c value. Also, the hardness influences the K1 c, and a softer surface was produced by the fibre laser treatment; this resulted in higher resistance to crack propagation and enhanced the ceramic's K1 c. Increasing the indentation load also varied the end K1 c value, as higher indentation loads resulted in a bigger diamond footprint, and the ceramic exhibited longer crack lengths.